[Role Madness] Overwatch Mafia - Game Over

[Zander?]

 

Cory your level of flip flopping, indecisiveness irt to Hallia is off putting

 

IIRC you claim you can read Hallia quite well.

You were in Spirited Away.

 

 

Yes I was.

[Zander?]

Cory if you were me what would you do tonight?

[Hallia]

As much as I hate to say it, I don't know that Cory/Zander is v/v :(

[Zander?]

As much as I hate to say it, I don't know that Cory/Zander is v/v :(

 

Which one of us would be the Wolf in your scenario?

[Zander?]

Hallia i asked more then once now.

 

I had questions/concerns about your EoD that you still arent addressing.

 

sadface.gif

[The Crusher]

 

Cory if you were me what would you do tonight?

What our your choices!

[Zander?]

 

Cory if you were me what would you do tonight?

What our your choices!

 

 

Is this a serious question?

 

And no its not a i think your role fishing thing

[Zander?]

Dont be scared Wolves....

 

[Hallia]

I'm unsure yet;

 

What are you talking about Zander??

[Zander?]

Dont be scared Wolves....

 

 

 

I'm unsure yet;

 

What are you talking about Zander??

 

Sick xpost Hallia

 

Then whats giving you that feeling?

 

What are your reads on me and Cory?

 

About your EoD.

 

You answered parts of it so you obv read through it.

 

Your sheeping, your nonchalant attitude to mislynching a Towny, especially Kat who has helped us form the Tri-Force of Lunching Wolves.

[Shad_]

Pral's pop-in over night could be villa. It reads honest enough, especially
 

Hindsight is awesome.

But I really can't not lynch there. It takes two seconds to say "hey guys I have this weird PR that forces me to only vote via PM, and it's not going to register as Pralaya, but it's me and I'm doing this to avoid a no lynch." I think that's the natural inclination for the vast majority of villagers, because villagers don't want other villagers to chase phantoms.  Vs a wolf just goofing up. He could have thought that it wouldn't display as literally "Anonymous" and people would think I was a double voter. He could have thought "hey I have this cool PR that lets me hammer villagers without revealing myself" and not really thought through the consequences--I mean yes his character is a ninja, but in a normal game where theme is not so relevant literally anyone in the game could have submitted an anonymous second vote to seal the deal, and Pral isn't familiar with Overwatch.

 

No one's going to believe you if you straight deny the vote was yours.  As a wolf moving forward your options from there are to either give up and never check back into the thread or else admit the evidence against you is strong but you're a villager and play on making reads in the hopes people will start to have doubts.

 

In other words Pral's tone was pretty pure and I do have doubts now, but the improbability of the action stemming from a villager outweighs my confidence in being able to read Pral correctly on his words.

 

And if he is a villager well, lol role madness.  I'm not going to beat myself up over it.

[Shad_]

Pral - why not just vote the wagon?

 

I have infinite trouble believing that if you had the time to submit the ninja vote that you couldn't make ONE post in the thread, especially since you'd read enough to know the wagon situation.

 

How difficult is it to say "I am going to vote Kat."

 

basically this

[Tiinker]

Pral's pop-in over night could be villa. It reads honest enough, especially

 

Hindsight is awesome.

But I really can't not lynch there. It takes two seconds to say "hey guys I have this weird PR that forces me to only vote via PM, and it's not going to register as Pralaya, but it's me and I'm doing this to avoid a no lynch." I think that's the natural inclination for the vast majority of villagers, because villagers don't want other villagers to chase phantoms.  Vs a wolf just goofing up. He could have thought that it wouldn't display as literally "Anonymous" and people would think I was a double voter. He could have thought "hey I have this cool PR that lets me hammer villagers without revealing myself" and not really thought through the consequences--I mean yes his character is a ninja, but in a normal game where theme is not so relevant literally anyone in the game could have submitted an anonymous second vote to seal the deal, and Pral isn't familiar with Overwatch.

 

No one's going to believe you if you straight deny the vote was yours.  As a wolf moving forward your options from there are to either give up and never check back into the thread or else admit the evidence against you is strong but you're a villager and play on making reads in the hopes people will start to have doubts.

 

In other words Pral's tone was pretty pure and I do have doubts now, but the improbability of the action stemming from a villager outweighs my confidence in being able to read Pral correctly on his words.

 

And if he is a villager well, lol role madness.  I'm not going to beat myself up over it.

 

Massively that. 

[Zander?]

Pral's pop-in over night could be villa. It reads honest enough, especially

 

Hindsight is awesome.

But I really can't not lynch there. It takes two seconds to say "hey guys I have this weird PR that forces me to only vote via PM, and it's not going to register as Pralaya, but it's me and I'm doing this to avoid a no lynch." I think that's the natural inclination for the vast majority of villagers, because villagers don't want other villagers to chase phantoms.  Vs a wolf just goofing up. He could have thought that it wouldn't display as literally "Anonymous" and people would think I was a double voter. He could have thought "hey I have this cool PR that lets me hammer villagers without revealing myself" and not really thought through the consequences--I mean yes his character is a ninja, but in a normal game where theme is not so relevant literally anyone in the game could have submitted an anonymous second vote to seal the deal, and Pral isn't familiar with Overwatch.

 

No one's going to believe you if you straight deny the vote was yours.  As a wolf moving forward your options from there are to either give up and never check back into the thread or else admit the evidence against you is strong but you're a villager and play on making reads in the hopes people will start to have doubts.

 

In other words Pral's tone was pretty pure and I do have doubts now, but the improbability of the action stemming from a villager outweighs my confidence in being able to read Pral correctly on his words.

 

And if he is a villager well, lol role madness.  I'm not going to beat myself up over it.

 

If Prals a villager that would rank in like the top 3 worst plays/moves Ive ever seen a Villa make.

 

I like to think Pral is much better that.

[Shad_]

In a vacuum I'd say Zander might actually look better if Pral's a villager than if Pral's a wolf, because he demonstrated the same immediate "lol Pral just outed himself" reaction that I had and a wolf who knows Pral is a villager is probably going to be staring at the screen dumbfounded wondering wtf just happened and worrying that some sort of gambit is going on.  A more measured reaction.  In a vacuum.  Zander is Zander so he might just immediately bark at weirdness as either alignment.

[Shad_]

If Prals a villager that would rank in like the top 3 worst plays/moves Ive ever seen a Villa make.

 

I like to think Pral is much better that.

Meh, if Pral's a villager he made a mistake. I'd chuck it in the same bin as 100 others I've seen and made myself.

 

If you want to see some truly god awful village plays, ask me for archive stories one of these days. ;)

[Shad_]

I'd probably start with the 40 or so uncountered doc claims that have gotten lynched over the years. 

[Tiinker]

In a vacuum I'd say Zander might actually look better if Pral's a villager than if Pral's a wolf, because he demonstrated the same immediate "lol Pral just outed himself" reaction that I had and a wolf who knows Pral is a villager is probably going to be staring at the screen dumbfounded wondering wtf just happened and worrying that some sort of gambit is going on.  A more measured reaction.  In a vacuum.  Zander is Zander so he might just immediately bark at weirdness as either alignment.

 

This is super reachy imo.

 

Zander campaigning to lynch Pral while the rest of vote Kat (confirmed town) up until 5 minutes to the deadline where Pral outs himself? If Pral/Zander are scum then this has gotta be a play to vet Zander which seems like a massive gamble in role-madness.

[Zander?]

In a vacuum I'd say Zander might actually look better if Pral's a villager than if Pral's a wolf, because he demonstrated the same immediate "lol Pral just outed himself" reaction that I had and a wolf who knows Pral is a villager is probably going to be staring at the screen dumbfounded wondering wtf just happened and worrying that some sort of gambit is going on.  A more measured reaction.  In a vacuum.  Zander is Zander so he might just immediately bark at weirdness as either alignment.

 

This garbage just helped me make a much easier decision.

[Zander?]

Hey Pral, gonna say something this time or just keep lurking?

[Shad_]

 

In a vacuum I'd say Zander might actually look better if Pral's a villager than if Pral's a wolf, because he demonstrated the same immediate "lol Pral just outed himself" reaction that I had and a wolf who knows Pral is a villager is probably going to be staring at the screen dumbfounded wondering wtf just happened and worrying that some sort of gambit is going on.  A more measured reaction.  In a vacuum.  Zander is Zander so he might just immediately bark at weirdness as either alignment.

 

This garbage just helped me make a much easier decision.

 

 

You and Cory are wolves and that's why nothing is coming together in this game, aren't you?

[Shad_]

You've been soft threatening to vig me all night phase while calling me your second or third highest town read.

 

:???:

[Zander?]

 

If Prals a villager that would rank in like the top 3 worst plays/moves Ive ever seen a Villa make.

 

I like to think Pral is much better that.

Meh, if Pral's a villager he made a mistake. I'd chuck it in the same bin as 100 others I've seen and made myself.

 

If you want to see some truly god awful village plays, ask me for archive stories one of these days. ;)

 

 

 

I'd probably start with the 40 or so uncountered doc claims that have gotten lynched over the years. 

 

OK I legit lolololol'd at the second.

 

But its not a mistake if thats the case it was a decision.  He CHOOSE to vote and not say anything.

 

And that decision is BAD one if thats the case.

[Zander?]

 

 

In a vacuum I'd say Zander might actually look better if Pral's a villager than if Pral's a wolf, because he demonstrated the same immediate "lol Pral just outed himself" reaction that I had and a wolf who knows Pral is a villager is probably going to be staring at the screen dumbfounded wondering wtf just happened and worrying that some sort of gambit is going on.  A more measured reaction.  In a vacuum.  Zander is Zander so he might just immediately bark at weirdness as either alignment.

 

This garbage just helped me make a much easier decision.

 

 

You and Cory are wolves and that's why nothing is coming together in this game, aren't you?

 

 

im never a Wolf this game and you know it.

[Shad_]

I'm just saying we're lynching him regardless so if he's a villager there's no reason to beat him up over it.  We've all made bad plays as villagers at one point or another.