[Advanced]Lost mafia - Game over - Sili, SK wins!

[Thane Vakarian]

THIS IS THE NEVER ENDING CATCH UP

[Turin Turambar]

I'm presently a bit suspicious of Shad, Thane and Dice.

 

I think that you are leaning town for me. Maybe Darthe too. 

 

Pretty much everyone else sorta null.

 

 

Might need to hurry if want to talk with me as it is getting close to time to start making tea (dinner in the US). 

[seph]

 

THIS IS THE NEVER ENDING CATCH UP

 

Thane wins with that corny gif joke. I think I found it way a bit to funny lolol

[Thane Vakarian]

 

 

THIS IS THE NEVER ENDING CATCH UP

Thane wins with that corny gif joke. I think I found it way a bit to funny lolol

 

i'm the comedic relief this game, I try to jump on the right occasions (and couldn't let this one slide )

[seph]

@turin I really like the sus list there.

Sadly I can't think of many.

 

This is something I saw nyn poat about asking meaningless questions.

 

Do you think zander is actually engaging people to scumhunt, or just to engage?

I thought his catchup posts were pretty lackluster yesterday tbh.

I just don't remember him following through with any questions, or trying to garner reads from them.

 

This is one thing I'm paying attention to while reading atm, and I think he is my biggest ?? Besides dice/kiv and the non posters.

[Nynaeve]

Nyn how do you feel about eldrick and shad?

I am really lost with shad tbh, I keep going back and fourth on him. I really want to like him this game though...

 

I kinda like Eldrick so far. I don't necessarily agree with everything he's saying, but there's an air to him I really like. He seems a lot more concise and I feel like I understand what he's trying to say. Reminds me a lot of when he subbed in the Minions. 

 

Shad is living up to his name of feeling icky :P. I don't know if it means something atp because I don't read him well. Also still waiting for him to answer my question irt Besie.

[Guest]

@ darthe in regards to your besie quote. (Not trying to re quote any of that)

 

I hate when people purposely play wolfy as town to help there wolf game. If they wanna play like a wolf, I'm going to lynch them like a wolf.

I don't see this ever helping town. I also don't see any reason atm to not lynch besie. Continuing my reread

 

As you wish. If you think I'm town though, then that is the worst idea I've ever heard.

 

Green: How do you even play like a wolf without being a wolf? I can't mislead you. I know nothing. I'm definitely not going to purposefully post stuff that I don't agree with (and I don't even do that as wolf!). My WIM is way to high for that.

 

Purple. No. It won't help town. I want to hear your "definition" of "playing wolfy" before commenting further, please.

[Shad_]

I am really lost with shad tbh, I keep going back and fourth on him. I really want to like him this game though...

 

Here's to hoping my reread helps

Honestly, look at my thread presence.

 

Not so much post count as the fact that since this game has started I've managed to consistently be here if I'm not sleeping.

 

It's not something I can/choose to always do as town, but I don't think I've ever had the drive for it as a wolf.

[Shad_]

Also still waiting for him to answer my question irt Besie.

Still have a couple pages to read; if I don't see it by the end I'll check.

[Guest]

@turin I really like the sus list there.

Sadly I can't think of many.

 

This is something I saw nyn poat about asking meaningless questions.

 

Do you think zander is actually engaging people to scumhunt, or just to engage?

I thought his catchup posts were pretty lackluster yesterday tbh.

I just don't remember him following through with any questions, or trying to garner reads from them.

 

This is one thing I'm paying attention to while reading atm, and I think he is my biggest ?? Besides dice/kiv and the non posters.

 

I agree with you on Zander. He is sick; I know he's not feeling well at all. But is it enough to not follow up or anything?

[Turin Turambar]

This was Z's last post before Shad gave him his town read. There were a few game content posts but nothing that I think puts Z out of his wolf range. It really was mostly just having fun and getting into the game. 

 

 

 

Hi zander! it's page 6 and you haven't talked to me :(

 

sups brah

 

 

 

then why do it?

Because we all instinctively get a few positive and negative vibes right off the bat and have learned to disregard them, but when asked we can still state them?

 

 

Ok.  Still dont get the Penny vibe tho.

 

 

Why did you feel the need to add the bold?

To emphasize the fact that intro posts aren't worth jack for reading most people most of the time.

 

 

OK.  Same response irt Penny.

 

 

 

Zander questions Shad's read and looks for back up. 

 

I feel decent about Zander's posts so far.

 

 

Seph
Zander
the rest of you scumbags

 

What about them exactly?

 

 

Shad replies.

 

What about them exactly?

You were asking the sort of questions I expect from town!Z, basically. #113 stood out especially. Like, I get what Seph is saying but it seems like the sort of issue you would naturally raise.

 

 

This is post #113. Not sure how this is indicative of Town!Zander. Feels like this could be a buddy attempt on Shad's part. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Time to hire someone to decipher besie's hidden secrets.
Besie do you have any feels, one way or the other on anyone?

Lol. Seph.

So far I think you and Darthe are scum team together. I feel good on nyn and Shad.

any raisins?
ok let's just be honest. If you don't feel good about nyn you can gtfo

Shad cause he's playing like did last time and he was town there. Nyn because she's annoying as all hell and I love her.

You and Darthe because of how you interact - you trust darthe too easily.

 

can you explain how he played last time? Sorry for making you go into detail, but I wasn't here for it and I think it would help me tremendously to get your perspective.

I actually really like the part about me and darthe. I trust people to easily in general lol. Darthe has played more games with me on this site than anyone tbh. While I read him wrong often. He has his town game that I think is undeniable. It is extremely easy to read, as he can't fake it as a wolf. I am sure others know what I am talking about. 
The key is to see if he keeps it up, and how he is actually progressing. 

But no, I have no problem trusting that darthe. It doesn't mean I will follow him, because lol darthe

 

 

Ummmm.....explain to me how that makes any sense?

 

 

 

[Shad_]

I rarely joke vote and don't really follow it, so I will ask unless I can be CERTAIN it was a joke.

 

I asked for a sort of specific reason and I'm not sure that you know what it is but I am interested to hear your opinion on the matter.

I don't know what it is.  My guess was to see if I'd hint some sort of role-related knowledge of his slot since Advanced game.

 

I can tell you I was fully intending to joke vote him regardless of my rand.

 

Would have been amusing distancing if we were wolf bros. 

[Celeste]

[unvote] 

[seph]

 

@ darthe in regards to your besie quote. (Not trying to re quote any of that)

 

I hate when people purposely play wolfy as town to help there wolf game. If they wanna play like a wolf, I'm going to lynch them like a wolf.

I don't see this ever helping town. I also don't see any reason atm to not lynch besie. Continuing my reread

 

As you wish. If you think I'm town though, then that is the worst idea I've ever heard.

 

Green: How do you even play like a wolf without being a wolf? I can't mislead you. I know nothing. I'm definitely not going to purposefully post stuff that I don't agree with (and I don't even do that as wolf!). My WIM is way to high for that.

 

Purple. No. It won't help town. I want to hear your "definition" of "playing wolfy" before commenting further, please.

 

you basically said, you want to model your town game, after your wolfgame if I remember correctly.  So yes you can purposely play scummy.

 

Definition of playing wolfy is pretty big area. Everyone has different ways to wolf/ hunt for wolves. but I think the general consensus would be anything that isn't pro town.

[seph]

PENNEH, I don't remember much from you. Find me some wolves will ya?

Off to make the wife breakfast

[Celeste]

 

This is weird, and not a good strategy. (my new avatar is really confusing me)

What was weird about it?

 

The intro before you check your role often bites ya back in the arse at some point. It's also just personal preference. 

[Shad_]

What's the point of mentioning anything? Have you not been giving your opinion on random posts? Or are you just critisizing one of the few people that actually do? I do not think the same way you do. I look for reads in different places; in different ways.

 

And that, is what makes mafia work. We're supposed to work together and find the one person that everyone has as scum, albeit for different reasons. If you are completely against a vote because you don't like their reasoning, rather than having your own reasons for thinking them town? Then I have nothing to say to you.

Was this in reference to anything in this game? 

[Shad_]

The intro before you check your role often bites ya back in the arse at some point. It's also just personal preference.

Fair enough; I thought you were referring to me liking your opening post.

[Turin Turambar]

Statistically, Besie being wolf yet again would be insane (and one would have made a lot of money if there would have been bets on it) 

 

on the other hand, she did want to break the new player scum streak record, and can be stubborn.....

Can you explain what you were trying to say about Bessie here? I am reading it two very different ways.I think because there seems to be some inconsistency between the bold and underlined. 

 

I could just be readin it weird tho. But please clarify.

[Celeste]

Ftr I don't care about the vote. It's not doing anything and if you don't have a better use for it, you can leave it there until you do. Just wanted to be clear that's what you were saying.

What.. Can you re-word the bolded.

[Turin Turambar]

And I'm out for a bit. maybe be able to to some more later tonight before bed. 

[Guest]

 

 

@ darthe in regards to your besie quote. (Not trying to re quote any of that)

 

I hate when people purposely play wolfy as town to help there wolf game. If they wanna play like a wolf, I'm going to lynch them like a wolf.

I don't see this ever helping town. I also don't see any reason atm to not lynch besie. Continuing my reread

 

As you wish. If you think I'm town though, then that is the worst idea I've ever heard.

 

Green: How do you even play like a wolf without being a wolf? I can't mislead you. I know nothing. I'm definitely not going to purposefully post stuff that I don't agree with (and I don't even do that as wolf!). My WIM is way to high for that.

 

Purple. No. It won't help town. I want to hear your "definition" of "playing wolfy" before commenting further, please.

 

you basically said, you want to model your town game, after your wolfgame if I remember correctly.  So yes you can purposely play scummy.

 

Definition of playing wolfy is pretty big area. Everyone has different ways to wolf/ hunt for wolves. but I think the general consensus would be anything that isn't pro town.

 

 

Yes... but you don't know how I play wolf? Have we ever been scum together? 

I'll tell you anyway: When I'm wolf, I play as if I'm town. I'm very capable of closing my mind and ignoring the fact that I'm actually wolf.

The only time I become an actual proper wolf, is when I see the wolves starting to go down and then try to play mind games.

 

That's not the case this time. This is also D1. Do you think I'm town, or do you think I'm wolf? 

[Guest]

 

What's the point of mentioning anything? Have you not been giving your opinion on random posts? Or are you just critisizing one of the few people that actually do? I do not think the same way you do. I look for reads in different places; in different ways.

 

And that, is what makes mafia work. We're supposed to work together and find the one person that everyone has as scum, albeit for different reasons. If you are completely against a vote because you don't like their reasoning, rather than having your own reasons for thinking them town? Then I have nothing to say to you.

Was this in reference to anything in this game? 

 

 

Nah, was just a general thing, said to everyone.

[Thane Vakarian]

 

Statistically, Besie being wolf yet again would be insane (and one would have made a lot of money if there would have been bets on it) 

 

on the other hand, she did want to break the new player scum streak record, and can be stubborn.....

Can you explain what you were trying to say about Bessie here? I am reading it two very different ways.I think because there seems to be some inconsistency between the bold and underlined. 

 

I could just be readin it weird tho. But please clarify.

 

This was more of a joke than anything else. The underlined should have given it away. She has randed wolf in every previous game so far, and we were on the wolf team together last game. 

[Guest]

 

Statistically, Besie being wolf yet again would be insane (and one would have made a lot of money if there would have been bets on it) 

 

on the other hand, she did want to break the new player scum streak record, and can be stubborn.....

Can you explain what you were trying to say about Bessie here? I am reading it two very different ways.I think because there seems to be some inconsistency between the bold and underlined. 

 

I could just be readin it weird tho. But please clarify.

 

 

I'm going to clarify some of this, because it's me you're talking about and I'm not sure if you're up to speed.

 

This is my 4th mafia game. In all 3 the previous ones I was wolf. See my siggy.