MAFIA KART WII [BASIC] - Mafia Sweep

[Zander?]

I really dislike it when someone reads my post finds all the flaws that aren't there. IT's probably a me problem though, but it still rubs me the wrong way lol.

 

 

Derp

 

 

sick xpost???

[Clovdyx]

 

Don't have time to edit the quotes properly, but in response to the first part, I would rephrase it. The two outcomes of lynching Zev today woudl be:

 

1) yay! wolf is dead

or

2) townie is dead, but at least we don't have to worry about an unknown quantity on D2 and we can narrow our POE.

 

Mislynching active town might give us more information, but it also deprives us of an active townie that could be helping us on D2.

 

As for the part about Calder, I have yet to see anyone offer any reason for NOT lynching him. Why keep him if you don't have a better lynch prospect? Or do you have a better lynch prospect?

 

If the choice were between him or Zev, who would you choose?

 

 

This is untrue. I think multiple people have given stronger candidates - your case on him is that you've heard he's a strong player and he hasn't lived up to your expectations.  He's basically an inactivity lynch that's playing for you.  I don't really fault you for taking that stance, because like I said...you don't know him.  But you can't possibly expect those of us who are familiar with him to be gung ho about lynching him just off that when we have people that we actually think ARE mafia, over a lack of town read.

 

Beyond that, I think some of the things he's brought up are decent points.  Not saying he can't make them as mafia, as well, but his point about Penny's irritation very easily comes from a townie mindset.  I would expect you, of all people, to give him some credit for that one.  He explained why he was voting Seph with no major issues.  The only real knock I have against Calder is that he's pretty much where he started the game at - Seph - without significant progress made there.  

 

It probably doesn't help your case for me that an inactive player and my top candidate are voting him.

 

And I see I'm talking to myself

 

anyway, I have to go back to work but I would looooove for people to answer my questions.

 

Oh, and Clov - how are you feeling about Seph now? Is your vote still on him? are you comfortable with that?

 

Celeste - where are you? What are your thoughts?

 

Calder, how do you feel about my answers to you and with continuing to leave my vote lying there on ya? And are you still okay with lynching Seph?

 

And I've asked this before but it hasn't been answered: Hallia, Sili, and Thane (and anyone else who cares to answer) - if it comes down to Calder vs. zev who would you rather lynch? And if neither, who would you lynch in their place?

 

Okay...Liz out!

 

Yeah.  He's done nothing to alleviate my concerns, and I can't shake the feeling he was trying to find posts to twist into explanations, rather than sincerely clarifying what he meant.  Failing him, my list would probably be Celeste -> Inactive, third from left.  

 

I have one potential deepwolf candidate (not really that deep, tbh), and I can't for the life of me figure out why I have concerns.

 

What's really bugging me right now is that a bunch of circular talks are happening with nothing being gained in my opinion. 

 

.....I realize that some players haven't been particularly loud this game, in terms of impact, but I have a hard time thinking you mean this.

[Hallia]

 

Just pedicures with my sis, it was divine!

 

For Sili I'm on the fence, leaning towards town. I very much disliked the way he went after me this morning. I nearly subbed out, but I don't want anyone to make me not play. His 180 on me is what gives me pause. But I don't know that he Would have gone after me the way he did as scum.

I probably wouldn't have regardless of your alignment.

 

I did not do anything untoward however.

I disagree of course, but you apologized for what upset me

[Sili Quirrels]

I wish instead of spreading this stigma that I do not know what I am talking about we could instead discuss whether I am right or wrong.

[Darthe]

 

And yes. All great enemies deserve shrines to commemorate their presence. I myself have posed naked for many such shrines.

 

I mean they asked me to put my clothes back on, but hell its my shrine.

ah yes, the statue of david. I think I hve seen this shrine.

Screw it ill talk about the elephant in the room. The joke is that statue has a small penis

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

Just pedicures with my sis, it was divine!

 

For Sili I'm on the fence, leaning towards town. I very much disliked the way he went after me this morning. I nearly subbed out, but I don't want anyone to make me not play. His 180 on me is what gives me pause. But I don't know that he Would have gone after me the way he did as scum.

I probably wouldn't have regardless of your alignment.

 

I did not do anything untoward however.

I disagree of course, but you apologized for what upset me

 

Sorry again if it helps.

[Calder]

 

And yes. All great enemies deserve shrines to commemorate their presence. I myself have posed naked for many such shrines.

I mean they asked me to put my clothes back on, but hell its my shrine.

 

ah yes, the statue of david. I think I hve seen this shrine.

Haha. This was pretty great.

[Darthe]

I wish instead of spreading this stigma that I do not know what I am talking about we could instead discuss whether I am right or wrong.

No, the discussion is about you and not your read. Many pf us consider it particularly thick and so are attempting to decide of it is genuine or an attempt at blending.

 

We can discuss the statements merits after we decide their intent.

[Calder]

 

 

@ calder.

you want to build a shrine for me? I would be honored.

 

Want to explain your shift from serious early D1 to these past few posts?

Bc from my end it feels like I reiterated my suspicion about you seeming to overreact and now it feels like forced nonchalance

suspicion? I thought you where trying to pull a rabit out of a hat.

I am not sure why you want anything from me, I am actually pretty terrible at this game.

I am kind of confused with where your trying to go here. Not critiquing you. Just think your mafia.

[seph]

 

 

And yes. All great enemies deserve shrines to commemorate their presence. I myself have posed naked for many such shrines.

 

I mean they asked me to put my clothes back on, but hell its my shrine.

ah yes, the statue of david. I think I hve seen this shrine.

Screw it ill talk about the elephant in the room. The joke is that statue has a small penis

 

lol, that was not the case. but I fell outa my fraking chair laughing.

[Darthe]

 

 

@ calder.

you want to build a shrine for me? I would be honored.

Want to explain your shift from serious early D1 to these past few posts?

 

Bc from my end it feels like I reiterated my suspicion about you seeming to overreact and now it feels like forced nonchalance

suspicion? I thought you where trying to pull a rabit out of a hat.

I am not sure why you want anything from me, I am actually pretty terrible at this game.

Totally missed this post til just now. It is not good.

[Calder]

@Clov

 

Curious to your significant progress line. I understand no more votes have come in, but I think the argument has progressed and I think there is an odd lack of defense that is strange.

 

Interesting that outsiders are not weighing in.

[Zander?]

Great now youre getting derp cleared.

 

Are you happy now?

 

I'm assuming this is irt Sili?

 

Yeah, you missed the omgus.

 

I don't think you can rationalize Hallia's post for her. Fact is her focus was not on finding out whether liz was town on her own merit.

 

Can you quote me the OMGUS post from her and your comment on it.  I wanna try and see what youre seeing and Im trying to get caught up and post a reads list.

 

I think that assuming someone is a certain alignment based on someone's else reads/reactions/rush is not an invalid thing.  It's not the best or guranteed to be right without flips or views and the such but I mentioned I dont think Liz and Celeste are w/w and I think Clov (?) did as well.

 

Did you mention either od us coming to that conclusion?

[Sili Quirrels]

Ah whatever. Think ill just ccept that im right.

 

Ill be busy for rest of day sp glgl.

[Calder]

 

 

 

@ calder.

you want to build a shrine for me? I would be honored.

Want to explain your shift from serious early D1 to these past few posts?

Bc from my end it feels like I reiterated my suspicion about you seeming to overreact and now it feels like forced nonchalance

suspicion? I thought you where trying to pull a rabit out of a hat.

I am not sure why you want anything from me, I am actually pretty terrible at this game.

Totally missed this post til just now. It is not good.

Take these responses back to our original exchanges and see how different they are. It makes no sense for a townie to have changed up his angle of attack like this against me.

[Zander?]

how much you play with someone doesn't really matter.

 

also already commented on how well i thought i read hallia.

 

Disagree

 

And I dont remember you saying how well you did only that you said you played with her a fair bit.

[Calder]

Sili has almost worked to avoid commenting around me and Seph's posts.

[Zander?]

 

 

@ calder.

you want to build a shrine for me? I would be honored.

Want to explain your shift from serious early D1 to these past few posts?

 

Bc from my end it feels like I reiterated my suspicion about you seeming to overreact and now it feels like forced nonchalance

suspicion? I thought you where trying to pull a rabit out of a hat.

I am not sure why you want anything from me, I am actually pretty terrible at this game.

 

 

Dude, really?

 

Come on man are you lolcatting here?

 

Give us something to work with.

 

How about a reads list?

[Sili Quirrels]

Imo villagers try not to rely on spew preflip unless they dont have anytging else to work with.

[seph]

@ clov. I am twisting narrative? you are literally picking apart everything I say to fit your narrative, your only viewing it from your perspective. and I just don't really care anymore.

also this is the last thing I am going to say involving calder. 
1. I like the guy, he seems pretty cool.
2. I absolutely Hate his mafia play style. It is honestly gotten better this game, but he seems like a anti town player from what clov and others have said. So basically he plays like this, claims mafia as town to benefit himself when he is mafia. All it does is hurt the town.

two was a bit of speculation, because I obviously don't know the guy and his play this game has gotten better since I dropped off.
His last few game related posts have felt more town orientated, though the ones about the scum leader, or being one of the main voices is null.
[unvote]

[Sili Quirrels]

 

how much you play with someone doesn't really matter.

 

also already commented on how well i thought i read hallia.

 

 

Disagree

 d

And I dont remember you saying how well you did only that you said you played with her a fair bit.

fact is you can play with someone a hundred times and still know nothing about them. Its not what youre looking for.

[seph]

 

 

 

@ calder.

you want to build a shrine for me? I would be honored.

Want to explain your shift from serious early D1 to these past few posts?

 

Bc from my end it feels like I reiterated my suspicion about you seeming to overreact and now it feels like forced nonchalance

suspicion? I thought you where trying to pull a rabit out of a hat.

I am not sure why you want anything from me, I am actually pretty terrible at this game.

 

 

Dude, really?

 

Come on man are you lolcatting here?

 

Give us something to work with.

 

How about a reads list?

 

I gave a reads list, not much has changed, except I would move calder up a bit. I had a good feeling about you at one point, but would need to reread if I ever got around to it.

 

[Sili Quirrels]

Sili has almost worked to avoid commenting around me and Seph's posts.

I wouldnt know what i was talking about though.

[Calder]

My job is to help my alignment which I always attempt to do in my own way. I respect others opinions of me and they dont have to approve.

[Calder]

 

Sili has almost worked to avoid commenting around me and Seph's posts.

I wouldnt know what i was talking about though.

What do you mean? We are actively posting all around you. Our early altercation happened when you were active as well. Maybe you dont have an opinion, I guess thats possible. But, you seriously straight never addressed us. It makes me feel like your connected to Seph.