Ghostbusters Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Wins!

[Eldrick4221]

Him not knowing rte was the symptoms isn't the issue. It's him saving the person he was voting, which doesn't make sense.

 

I'll chew over the "Zander was scummier" for a bit.

[Eldrick4221]

Ok. The line itself sounds like a towny response. Scum!Rey wouldn't care who got lynched if mafia doesn't know who the symptoms is (which I don't think they would)

 

I'll have to check and see if his play matches the response.

[Eldrick4221]

Oh. Shad also took a big drop for me at eod. 10 pages behind, and only have 1 person on your wtl?

[Shad_]

I'd be a little suss of anyone with a large pool to be honest.  The scummy people are all dropping claims.  Could be as simple as BFG and Sooh at this point.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Oh. We need another replacement btw. If anyone can help find me one I'd really appreciate it. Thanks.

[Eldrick4221]

Actually, the only scenarios I see that make sense for scum!rey to governor Zander instead of rte are

 

1. Turin is mafia. Making Zander flips confirms turin's role.

 

2. Mafia know rte is the symptoms.

 

I don't believe either of those, so I'm leaning Rey is telling the truth.

[Shad_]

I wonder if RTE's flip would read different depending on whether or not mafia recruited him?

[Shad_]

Day 2 Result

 

RTE has been Lynched. He was ...

 

 

Winston Zeddemore - Mafia Symp

www.youtube.com/watch?v=NFX4fmldZFs"]

 

 

I suppose not. It's pretty non-descript. Unless it would have just shown Mafia Goon after recruit and we'd never know he was a symp in that case.

[Sooh]

Actually, the only scenarios I see that make sense for scum!rey to governor Zander instead of rte are

 

1. Turin is mafia. Making Zander flips confirms turin's role.

 

2. Mafia know rte is the symptoms.

 

I don't believe either of those, so I'm leaning Rey is telling the truth.

lol

 

Sympathizer, not symptom. Perhaps that makes the role more clear?

 

Turin could be mafia, because neighbors aren't always town/town, however I have nothing to build that on.

 

I replaced in in the middle of a very busy week for me. You should all know that I'm going to be camping with 150 wild teenagers from morning Thursday to afternoon Friday and won't be able to be here at all. 

 

As for Rey's claim, he could actually be derp clear from how that claim and lynch went down. I would need to look further at it, but both his role and his actions from what I've seen would match that of a Governor.

[Eldrick4221]

What I don't get is why Rey waited til right before eod to claim.

[Sooh]

What I don't get is why Rey waited til right before eod to claim.

Well, according to his own posts he wasn't around.

[Sooh]

 

What I don't get is why Rey waited til right before eod to claim.

Well, according to his own posts he wasn't around.

 

Basing this on what I've read other people say about him btw.

[Eldrick4221]

Ok. Back on the laptop. Time to go read up on what I missed.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

What I don't get is why Rey waited til right before eod to claim.

Well, according to his own posts he wasn't around.

 

Basing this on what I've read other people say about him btw.

 

He was earlier in the phase, though. Why didn't he explain what happened about the lynch earlier, instead of having us sit here confused?

[Eldrick4221]

Oh. We need another replacement btw. If anyone can help find me one I'd really appreciate it. Thanks.

Asked my mom. She said no.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Thanks for trying :)

[Eldrick4221]

I haven't ISO'd RTE myself yet. This is going off of what BFG posted, and the assumption that RTE knew who the mafia were.

 

RTE was consistently pushing for dice. IMO this spews dice not mafia.

 

RTE's read on Shad goes from town to null for no explainable reason. Looks to me like trying to get town credit for a kill if he flips scum.

[Eldrick4221]

 

Actually, the only scenarios I see that make sense for scum!rey to governor Zander instead of rte are

 

1. Turin is mafia. Making Zander flips confirms turin's role.

 

2. Mafia know rte is the symptoms.

 

I don't believe either of those, so I'm leaning Rey is telling the truth.

lol

 

Sympathizer, not symptom. Perhaps that makes the role more clear?

 

Turin could be mafia, because neighbors aren't always town/town, however I have nothing to build that on.

 

I replaced in in the middle of a very busy week for me. You should all know that I'm going to be camping with 150 wild teenagers from morning Thursday to afternoon Friday and won't be able to be here at all. 

 

As for Rey's claim, he could actually be derp clear from how that claim and lynch went down. I would need to look further at it, but both his role and his actions from what I've seen would match that of a Governor.

 

:P

 

I don't proofread my posts when I'm sneaking them in at my other job. I typed "symp".

[Eldrick4221]

Also, I'm not denying the possibility of Turin being mafia. I said it's not believable.

 

Those are the 2 reasons I could see scum governor rigging the D1 lynch. Ok, 3rd option. For the lols.

 

All are unlikely to me, which makes me think Rey is town from this.

[Eldrick4221]

Also, being the lynch is easily town's greatest asset, can I get you to explain your future actions should you choose to use it again, Rey?

[Turin Turambar]

Claims to date. I didn't bother looking up names as I am not putting much into that.

 

 

1. Turin: Dana Barrett- Town Neighbor
2. Eldrick:
3. Niniel:
4. Tsuki: ??? - Town Cop
5. BFG: 
6. Zander - Louis Tully - Town Neighbour- Lynched Day 1
7. Dice: Slimer? - Town Treestump
8. Lenlo Sooh replaced Day 2: 
9. Shad: 

10. Rey: ??? - Town Governor

11. John McClane Hallia replaced Day 1: ??? - Town Doc
12. RTE - Winston Zeddemore - Mafia Symp - Lynched Day 2
13. Alanna: 

[Eldrick4221]

And which of claims do you believe?

 

Of the ones you don't, why?

[Eldrick4221]

If Sooh is scum, then scum almost assuredly didn't know RTE was the symp. RTE is the only person she voted, without even being fully caught up,

[Turin Turambar]

And which of claims do you believe?

 

Of the ones you don't, why?

All??? maybe not Dice? Bad juju.

 

How about you?? I get the impression that some people are trying to create doubt in the claims. I think that mafia might be feeling the PoE heat. 

[Reyoru]

He was earlier in the phase, though. Why didn't he explain what happened about the lynch earlier, instead of having us sit here confused?

So that you and your mafia pal Shad didn't know what town was working with quite obviously.