Ghostbusters Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Wins!

[alannalynn]

Alanna
Tsuki
Eldrick
Hally
Dice
Niniel
Turin
Nikon
Sooh

[alannalynn]

Lynch Sooh tomorrow and gg?

[Sooh]

Lynch Sooh tomorrow and gg?

Lynch Sooh tomorrow and you're not GG, but I guess you'll try anyway.

[alannalynn]

Yes I will!

[alannalynn]

really just depends on what tsuki brings me tonight

[Niniel]

Excellent!

 

Lynch Sooh tomorrow and gg?

 

Probably. Still have to take a look at BFG/Nikon. 

[Turin Turambar]

Lynch SoohAlanna tomorrow and gg find the third Ghostbuster?

FTFY

[Turin Turambar]

Seriously tho people, it is nearly assured that there are two left unless someone wants to claim a Ghostbuster character right now so they can be shot.

 

Alanna even thinking to sell that there's only one left is very bad.

 

Her response about Tsuki viewing her also rang of mafia miffed that all that hard work of looking town was wasted because she was getting peeked.

 

The delay on Shad is telling to me also. IIRC she never gave a real reason for either pushing/voting him or for defending him. It felt like she was just dragging her feet about voting him.

 

My 2 pence.

[Turin Turambar]

Alanna

Tsuki

Eldrick

Hally

Dice

Niniel

Turin

Nikon

Sooh

This is awful IMO. How am I barely above The two replacements? Dice doesn't belong above me IMO. Neither does Eldrick Although a case could be made about Eldrick since he was peeked. But the longer the game goes without a GF flop the more suspicious of the peeks I will become. Especially if game play doesn't match up.

[Eldrick4221]

Alanna

Tsuki

Eldrick

Hally

Dice

Niniel

Turin

Nikon

Sooh

Agree with the order of this list. Nikon would also be orange for me, though.

 

I think the last 2 are nikon and sooh. If not, I would look at turin.

[Eldrick4221]

Nini would also be above dice atp.

 

I think he's town because as has already been discussed his claim doesn't make sense from a mafia standpoint. Also I think rte spewed him town, if we are to believe he knew who the mafia were.

 

I'll take a look over shad tomorrow, now that we know he's scum, and see if I can find anything.

[Eldrick4221]

Nini is obvious town from the level of effort she has put into solving.

[Eldrick4221]

 

sooh i REALLY need to see some work from you any chance u digging in before daybreak?

It depends on when daybreak is. It's half an hour until midnight here, so if daybreak happens early during my day tomorrow then no, there's no chance of me digging in. If it takes a while longer I suppose there's a chance, however I'm not sure how much time I want to spend reading through these posts. I did put the dead peoples on ignore, and I will do the same with Shad now so there's less to read. Then perhaps I can come up with something in terms of reads. As of right now my reads are very much because of mechanics in the game.

This is something that pinged me. We get a scum flip, and Sooh's response is to ignore the scum posts instead of looking for connections to said scum.

[Eldrick4221]

Just because he likes to fabricate connections doesn't mean the real ones aren't there.

[Sooh]

 

 

sooh i REALLY need to see some work from you any chance u digging in before daybreak?

It depends on when daybreak is. It's half an hour until midnight here, so if daybreak happens early during my day tomorrow then no, there's no chance of me digging in. If it takes a while longer I suppose there's a chance, however I'm not sure how much time I want to spend reading through these posts. I did put the dead peoples on ignore, and I will do the same with Shad now so there's less to read. Then perhaps I can come up with something in terms of reads. As of right now my reads are very much because of mechanics in the game.

This is something that pinged me. We get a scum flip, and Sooh's response is to ignore the scum posts instead of looking for connections to said scum.

 

I still need to read the entire thread, and anything that I can do to cut it down helps me. If you want to go analyze scum posts, be my guest. I don't think I'll be able to find scum from it, but you might. I didn't tell everyone to stop reading the scums' posts, did I?

[Eldrick4221]

No, but how are you supposed to find scum if you ignore the biggest resource. The known scum.

[Sooh]

No, but how are you supposed to find scum if you ignore the biggest resource. The known scum.

Eldrick, I need to read this game first and form my own ideas. I need to find who I think is scummy or not, and after that I might look into the dead scums. At this point I have more than enough to read already. 

 

You can tell me over and over again that my strategy sucks, but that's not going to change it.

[Turin Turambar]

Ask the MOD: if a GF is viewed twice will the second one come back true? Or will they always view townie?

 

Eldrick, why is dice clear? His claim makes reasonable sense from a mafia PoV as it got him out of trouble and he has an excuse to not die and he doesn't have to provide any supporting information that could trip him up.

[Eldrick4221]

He's mainly clear because of how rte treated him. He's not as clear as laine or nini who have put a lot of work into solving the game. He isn't as clear as hally and Tsuki who I believe their claims.

[Eldrick4221]

 

No, but how are you supposed to find scum if you ignore the biggest resource. The known scum.

Eldrick, I need to read this game first and form my own ideas. I need to find who I think is scummy or not, and after that I might look into the dead scums. At this point I have more than enough to read already.

 

You can tell me over and over again that my strategy sucks, but that's not going to change it.

I'm not saying your strategy sucks. I'm saying your actions are scummy.

 

That you seem to be putting in minimum level effort.

[Eldrick4221]

On top of hally's claim, I also like her content. Having seen her play scum recently, she is much more involved this game.

[Sooh]

 

 

No, but how are you supposed to find scum if you ignore the biggest resource. The known scum.

Eldrick, I need to read this game first and form my own ideas. I need to find who I think is scummy or not, and after that I might look into the dead scums. At this point I have more than enough to read already.

 

You can tell me over and over again that my strategy sucks, but that's not going to change it.

I'm not saying your strategy sucks. I'm saying your actions are scummy.

 

That you seem to be putting in minimum level effort.

 

What actions would that be? The actions where I voted two scums two days in a row?

 

You're right about minimum effort. 

[Eldrick4221]

 

Alanna, I think I already showed why dice is a good lynch. tl;Dr version... Lack of town mindset regarding town/mafia interaction and motivation/willingness to sacrifice town for mafia 1 for 1. Also easy Z read. Also weird stance on Z/T d1. Also questioning GF possible for Z or T but not when he wants himself viewed.

 

Sooh, might it be better to not lynch him if he is town? Mafia are using the fact he lives yesterday to make him the inevitable lynch today Imo. I don't like doing things mafia want.

Turin, his slot is begging to be resolved at this point, and barring that he is lock clear townie to at least five of us he has to be resolved. We already know scums won't help us do that because of the lynch, so he is an inevitable lynch now, or an impossible F5/3 townie to clear.

 

I don't hate his posts, but there will always be this looming doubt over his escape from death, and short of anyone claiming responsibility for that (which I don't think you should do btw) I can't see how we can clear him at this point. Sure, lynching scum is always better, but I can't say that RTE isn't scum, and neither can anyone else at this point I would think. I would strongly advocate for his kill. If he's town.. well, sue me, but I still think we'll have cleared up an unclearable spot.

 

[v]RTE[/v]

 

Shad has defended Lenlo all game until today when he says you are an option.

So basically he's been defending a team mate until now, when he's under suspicion and then he's bussing. I can see how that's a viable way of thinking.

 

It's still wrong.

 

 

[v]Shad[/v]

 

Should be L-2

These are the votes you are trying to take towny credit for.

 

Rte you didn't even think was scum. You wanted to resolve the slot because he escaped the lynch d1.

 

Shad you agreed with nini that her reason for linking you two made sense, and then called it wrong and voted shad.

 

Rte was a symp. Doesn't count as a mafia lynch to me unless you knew he was the symp.

 

Shad could easily be a bus vote.

 

While we're on the subject, your repeatedly mentioning that you have helped catch scum and re therefore town rings hollow to me. Scum that bus do the same thing you did to look town, and you are making sure we are aware of it.

[Eldrick4221]

The minimum effort is Irt your reading the thread. As I mentioned before, a tell for me for subs is how much effort they put into finding out what happened before they joined, and you are sorely lacking in that area.

 

Nikon isn't. The reason I suspect him is his shad vote. The fact that he voted shad because everyone else was, that he felt he would look scummy if he didn't vote while not being caught up yet.

[Eldrick4221]

I need to get ready for bed now.