[Basic] Supernatural Mafia ~ Game Over ~ Town Wins!!!

[BFG]

ftr: i won't be on much during the weekend (family stuff)

Have a great time :)

[BFG]

Cop: Lily

vig: Thane

lynch: Zander

Doc: Turin

 

Go!

Ftfy :)

 

I hate the vig question :(

[BFG]

There should be question marks with those

[Zander?]

 

You were mafia with him in which he was cleared because 'tone' by most players in a game until he got 'outed', either because he played dumb over SHC or POEd.

 

 

Ya i was once in DIablo. Ok so I should never use Tone as a part of my read of someone?  Yes tone can be faked but it doesnt mean it always is.

 

 

 

What does it matter if he's a 'deep wolf' candidate if he's a wolf? why on earth would I look for a 'deep wolf' before looking for the obvious wolves?

 

 

I dont care what your process for hunting people is.  You were asking me what I thought of Thane and Ive been explaining it.  There are others players that are/were scummier to me then Thane,

 

Sooh, Nol, Eld to name a few.

[Zander?]

 

Cop: Lily

vig: Thane

lynch: Zander

Doc: Turin

 

Go!

Ftfy :)

 

I hate the vig question :(

 

 

 

So now you wanna lynch me?  Why?

[BFG]

/shrug

 

Ok

 

I'm ISOing Sooh, you, Laine tonight

[Sooh]

 

Cop: Lily

vig: Thane

lynch: Zander

Doc: Turin

 

Go!

Ftfy :)

 

I hate the vig question :(

 

I am confused. Is this how you feel, BFG, or how you think he feels?

[Nynaeve]

How many times has Nolder?

 

Nolder has also been caught as scum many atime. What's your point?

[BFG]

 

 

Cop: Lily

vig: Thane

lynch: Zander

Doc: Turin

 

Go!

Ftfy :)

 

I hate the vig question :(

 

 

 

So now you wanna lynch me?  Why?

 

I put lynch as someone questionable, I want to be able to argue it and change my mind if I'm wrong.

 

I've been unable to completely shake the feeling I got from your reads list, I know you've tried to explain, it just sits badly still. I need to look back at the things I thought could make you town as well and reread the past 20 pages. I'll admit some could be annoyance at how hard it's felt getting you to consider Thane, or the fact you won't show what your issue is with Eldrick (or I've missed it )

[BFG]

 

 

Cop: Lily

vig: Thane

lynch: Zander

Doc: Turin

 

Go!

Ftfy :)

 

I hate the vig question :(

 

I am confused. Is this how you feel, BFG, or how you think he feels?

 

Me, at least sometimes, other than Thane and Turin most reads change pretty rapidly.

[BFG]

Turin how much time do you have tonight?

[Zander?]

I put lynch as someone questionable, I want to be able to argue it and change my mind if I'm wrong.

 

I've been unable to completely shake the feeling I got from your reads list, I know you've tried to explain, it just sits badly still. I need to look back at the things I thought could make you town as well and reread the past 20 pages. I'll admit some could be annoyance at how hard it's felt getting you to consider Thane, or the fact you won't show what your issue is with Eldrick (or I've missed it )

 

 

Ive tried to explain.  Ive explained Eld.  And as far as frustration getting me look at Thane its the same way with me irt Sooh.

 

I try to find some Townies and clear them if I can but everyone knows my primary goal is to find wolves.  And when I do thats where my focus goes.

[BFG]

And Zander, no. Of course you can use tone however you want. It seems 'strange' to me that you would clear somebody based on something you know they can fake

 

[BFG]

 

I put lynch as someone questionable, I want to be able to argue it and change my mind if I'm wrong.

 

I've been unable to completely shake the feeling I got from your reads list, I know you've tried to explain, it just sits badly still. I need to look back at the things I thought could make you town as well and reread the past 20 pages. I'll admit some could be annoyance at how hard it's felt getting you to consider Thane, or the fact you won't show what your issue is with Eldrick (or I've missed it )

 

Ive tried to explain.  Ive explained Eld.  And as far as frustration getting me look at Thane its the same way with me irt Sooh.

 

I try to find some Townies and clear them if I can but everyone knows my primary goal is to find wolves.  And when I do thats where my focus goes.

 

Ok thanks

[Zander?]

And Zander, no. Of course you can use tone however you want. It seems 'strange' to me that you would clear somebody based on something you know they can fake

 

 

 

When did I clear Thane???  He was my top Town read and only in light green.  Not Dark Green nor Blue.

[BFG]

 

And Zander, no. Of course you can use tone however you want. It seems 'strange' to me that you would clear somebody based on something you know they can fake

 

 

 

When did I clear Thane???  He was my top Town read and only in light green.  Not Dark Green nor Blue.

 

Fine. You haven't cleared him, he was your top town read, you don't understand why I've been suspicious and only just looked at him seriously and are (presumably) still calling him town, but he isn't clear :)

 

Got it

[Zander?]

BFG feel free to ask me as many questions as you want so you can get your read on me right.

 

What are your thoughts on BG?

[bgrishinko]

Hey Zan, did you read my ISO results of Thane earlier?

[BFG]

BFG feel free to ask me as many questions as you want so you can get your read on me right.

 

What are your thoughts on BG?

BG's kind of under my radar at the moment.

 

I didn't like the extended meta discussion earlier today (including Lily and Laine in that). The reaction test thing between him and Sooh read weirdly to me at the time, and still does

 

Obviously I like his vote, but a lot of his real content is from the past day or so and is in my list of things to read.

 

 

I need to ISO you before I ask questions, are you around for a while?

[Zander?]

Hey Zan, did you read my ISO results of Thane earlier?

 

I did.  Im having trouble reading you and Lily as you guys are "old school" type players and have different things you look at and ways of doing things.  I also have no Meta on you to work with.  Im a Meta/Gut Read player primarily so its making me take what you say with a grain of salt.

 

Please dont take offense to that.  I'll dig in to you more as well as listen to others take on you and proceed accordingly.

 

I have a slight inkling concerning you but like I said I want to look into it further.

[BFG]

Ugh quote limits

[Zander?]

 

BFG feel free to ask me as many questions as you want so you can get your read on me right.

 

What are your thoughts on BG?

BG's kind of under my radar at the moment.

 

I didn't like the extended meta discussion earlier today (including Lily and Laine in that). The reaction test thing between him and Sooh read weirdly to me at the time, and still does

 

Obviously I like his vote, but a lot of his real content is from the past day or so and is in my list of things to read.

 

 

I need to ISO you before I ask questions, are you around for a while?

 

 

 

Fair enough.

 

I should be my dear.

 

Also I wanna ask the players that IF I become Post Count leader but keep myself in check with mostly content posts and not going overboard, will that be a problem?

[Nynaeve]

Not a problem for me.

[BFG]

 

 

BFG feel free to ask me as many questions as you want so you can get your read on me right.

 

What are your thoughts on BG?

BG's kind of under my radar at the moment.

 

I didn't like the extended meta discussion earlier today (including Lily and Laine in that). The reaction test thing between him and Sooh read weirdly to me at the time, and still does

 

Obviously I like his vote, but a lot of his real content is from the past day or so and is in my list of things to read.

 

 

I need to ISO you before I ask questions, are you around for a while?

 

 

 

Fair enough.

 

I should be my dear.

 

Also I wanna ask the players that IF I become Post Count leader but keep myself in check with mostly content posts and not going overboard, will that be a problem?

 

Not for me :)

[bgrishinko]

@BFG, Not gonna lie. I didn't like the extended meta discussion earlier either. I had to force myself take a step back from it and just let it go.

 

@Zan, no offense taken. I'm an unknown quantity to you so it makes sense.