[Basic] Supernatural Mafia ~ Game Over ~ Town Wins!!!

[Eldrick4221]

It's one thing to have the right idea from the get go. It's another thing entirely to second guess yourself over and over, and STILL be right.

[Nynaeve]

Lily's gonna blond.  *grins*   Her response was just on edge. Like she was caught off guard that two people were "guessing" she was the cop. Of course that was just a misunderstanding but the point still applies.

[Pralaya]

like feel free to disagree and say that Nolder and Sooh looked townie to YOU. But seeing as you guys had the setup.... that read is biased. I thought they had scummy content and reactions. And that was my opinion .... without knowing the setup. So get off your high horse. Want to give constructive criticism? I'll only accept that if you did NOT have access to the setup all along?  Okay? Great!  Glad we cleared that up.

 

Nyn, to be fair, even I was annoyed at some things that were happening D2. I had read Sooh scum but I eased up on my read after certain stuff that I saw and I tried convincing you and Zander about it. It is not about the reasoning or being stubborn but more about the mocking tone that annoyed me. I eventually voted Turin because I did not see the lynch going anywhere else and I just wanted to end the day as soon as possible. In that respect, as someone playing the game and not sitting on the DT, I kind of agree that there was a bit of disrespectful tone towards Turin that day. Nothing personal, just what I noticed this game. 

[Pralaya]

 

This is prolly the most insulting DT I've ever seen. And that's saying something.

 

Star Wars was pretty bad, and I actively participated in that one so yeah.

 

I remember the things you said about me in Buffy FWIW, lol.

 

And I remember all the things Verbal and Leelou said about me in the ABBA Mafia QT. 

 

 

And, I remember all the things you said about me in that 1000-page game that I never bothered to remember what the name was.

 

LOL

[Pralaya]

 

 

This is prolly the most insulting DT I've ever seen. And that's saying something.

 

Star Wars was pretty bad, and I actively participated in that one so yeah.

 

I remember the things you said about me in Buffy FWIW, lol.

 

And I remember all the things Verbal and Leelou said about me in the ABBA Mafia QT.  

 

 

And, I remember all the things you said about me in that 1000-page game that I never bothered to remember what the name was.

 

LOL

[Nynaeve]

 

like feel free to disagree and say that Nolder and Sooh looked townie to YOU. But seeing as you guys had the setup.... that read is biased. I thought they had scummy content and reactions. And that was my opinion .... without knowing the setup. So get off your high horse. Want to give constructive criticism? I'll only accept that if you did NOT have access to the setup all along?  Okay? Great!  Glad we cleared that up.

 

Nyn, to be fair, even I was annoyed at some things that were happening D2. I had read Sooh scum but I eased up on my read after certain stuff that I saw and I tried convincing you and Zander about it. It is not about the reasoning or being stubborn but more about the mocking tone that annoyed me. I eventually voted Turin because I did not see the lynch going anywhere else and I just wanted to end the day as soon as possible. In that respect, as someone playing the game and not sitting on the DT, I kind of agree that there was a bit of disrespectful tone towards Turin that day. Nothing personal, just what I noticed this game. 

 

 

There was nothing disrespectful coming from me. I thought I had nailed scum and I was happy about it. If other people want to associate lies and false assumptions for the intention behind it? Then they don't know me at all and aren't my friends.

[Nynaeve]

Let me make this abundantly clear. People can criticize game related stuff all they want and I take it with a grain of salt. And at the end of the day I walked away from a lot of these discussions just agreeing to disagreeing, and that's fine. No hard feelings. But you're NEVER gonna assert that I made a game choice based on out of the game reasons and not look the fool. That much I can promise pretty much anyone.

[Nynaeve]

Like seriously. People act as if this is something new. I always get sassy when I think I put a scummy between a rock and a hard place and I always talk smack. Now SUDDENLY it's a problem?  Spare me.

[Pralaya]

Like seriously. People act as if this is something new. I always get sassy when I think I put a scummy between a rock and a hard place and I always talk smack. Now SUDDENLY it's a problem?  Spare me.

 

To be fair, I had you as town because you were stubborn, lol. If you were scum, you would have pocketed me !

[Nynaeve]

My warm recommendation for most of the spectators is to grow a pair and get over themselves. And to watch what they say if they don't even know what they're talking about. Which, apparently most of them didn't.

 

Don't make assumptions. You wanna know? Ask me. You can bet I'm gonna tell you. No assumptions necessary. Honest.

[Nynaeve]

I'm kinda straightforward that way.

[Nynaeve]

 

Like seriously. People act as if this is something new. I always get sassy when I think I put a scummy between a rock and a hard place and I always talk smack. Now SUDDENLY it's a problem?  Spare me.

 

To be fair, I had you as town because you were stubborn, lol. If you were scum, you would have pocketed me !

 

 

I am definitely stubborn. And while I make a point of displaying confidence in my reads on thread, I'm often not. But I learned pretty quickly that I have to at least appear sure if  expect to push my suspicions.

[Nynaeve]

Like I said, you did an excellent job at removing yourself from the PoE. I felt like your read list was consensusy and not as in depth as I've grown to expect from you but your involvement later on was never happening from scumPral. It's why I never really pushed you, even after mentioning that I suspected you. And yeah, we disagreed on some things but you were so engaged that it was pretty apparent that you were a townie, imo. 

 

FTR, I disagree with Nolder. I think you have a lot to offer as a townie.

[BFG]

 

Nyn <3

<3

 

Like I said, it was really nice to be able to just automatically clear you. One slot I never had to worry about. And the research you did, specifically on thane irt dead payers subbing in was pretty amazing. I commend you for the patience.

Lol, as far as I know Spaceballs is Thanes best game as mafia. Not sure why I remember it, I know Tommy was really paranoid of him in the next game they played lol. Course Tommy was probably mafia and overplaying it... AG was my game so I remember it, I haven't modded that many yet.

 

I wasnt researching games people had subbed into, was trying to check I understood Thanes game because he does switch styles every few games and I wanted to check what I was seeing was more than just surface level /shrug

 

I've now given away ~80% of the meta I have on him, so he's going to be a tough read again for a while :(

 

 

And I probably won't ever do that type of analysis for most other players, it's just cos he has a lower PC than most :p

[Pralaya]

Yeah, talking about that, this was a great game based on content. Last few games I had been so jaded with the amount of posts, that I was losing interest in mafia. But, this game got me back to the excitement. This was perfect - with only 130 pages it had everything - drama, fun, solving etc. It doesn't have to be a 130 page D1 to be able to read people better.

[Pralaya]

Lol, as far as I know Spaceballs is Thanes best game as mafia. Not sure why I remember it, I know Tommy was really paranoid of him in the next game they played lol. Course Tommy was probably mafia and overplaying it... AG was my game so I remember it, I haven't modded that many yet.

I wasnt researching games people had subbed into, was trying to check I understood Thanes game because he does switch styles every few games and I wanted to check what I was seeing was more than just surface level /shrug

 

I've now given away ~80% of the meta I have on him, so he's going to be a tough read again for a while :(

 

 

And I probably won't ever do that type of analysis for most other players, it's just cos he has a lower PC than most :p

 

 

BTW, sorry for doubting you, lol. I couldn't believe that you didn't see Lily's breadcrumbing the whole game and that's why I thought you were trying to distract. Kind of a confirmation bias !

[Nynaeve]

I prolly could have toned down the amount of posting lol  But then I had quite a few posts that weren't game related.

[BFG]

Lol np Pral :)

 

I saw it, I just have a weird brain sometimes.

 

I don't really know how to explain, I saw it,noted it and since it wasn't a hard claim and I was VT sort of shelved it.

 

When reading you, you'd never mentioned BG and weren't voting him so wondered if I was wrong on the hints

 

 

I mean for comparison when Cory claimed Survivor in HHGG, I had the original role list and knew Survivor wasn't on it, but had shelved it and never made the connection

[Nynaeve]

where did eldrick breadcrumb?  lol 

[BFG]

I was also trying not to draw attention to it and at one stage thought about trying to provide cover... My posting was kind of all over the place when I came in Day 2.

[Eldrick4221]

How did I do postwise? I know I had some fluff, but I also tried to have game content too. It's hard when you're mafia and your content has to be intended to mislead, but I still feel I did...adequately.

[Eldrick4221]

where did eldrick breadcrumb?  lol 

 

My unexplained town read D2 on Zander was supposed to do that >.>

[Eldrick4221]

Installed new software. Its alignment was:

 

 

 

 

 

Lynched it off my computer :)

[Cory Caboose]

 

 

This is prolly the most insulting DT I've ever seen. And that's saying something.

Star Wars was pretty bad, and I actively participated in that one so yeah.

 

I remember the things you said about me in Buffy FWIW, lol.

 

And I remember all the things Verbal and Leelou said about me in the ABBA Mafia QT.

And, I remember all the things you said about me in that 1000-page game that I never bothered to remember what the name was.

 

LOL

If I didn't gripe about Pral it wouldn't be a game!!!

 

Though to be fair this game was like the first ever I had you as a villager

 

Gg bud :P

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

This is prolly the most insulting DT I've ever seen. And that's saying something.

Star Wars was pretty bad, and I actively participated in that one so yeah.

 

I remember the things you said about me in Buffy FWIW, lol.

 

And I remember all the things Verbal and Leelou said about me in the ABBA Mafia QT.

And, I remember all the things you said about me in that 1000-page game that I never bothered to remember what the name was.

 

LOL

If I didn't gripe about Pral it wouldn't be a game!!!

 

Though to be fair this game was like the first ever I had you as a villager

 

Gg bud :P

 

I always do, but then change my mind and mislynch him for crappy reasons.

 

Working on that...