Age of Legends [standard] Mafia - Game Over

[Nynaeve]

We kinda lost an entire day because of the Calder lynch. That's annoying.

 

AJ, we'll have a drink in DT, you did well *raises glass*

 

now; Hallia/Nolder would be alright, imo. for me they seem least likely to be town here.

 

As i jokingly said before, if we lynch Hallia every game, she has to be wolf at some point, no?

Thane, there's a very compelling reason why halli is most likely scum. Look around EoD and you'll see why.

[Andrej]

 

Go town

[Zander?]

 

 

Step 1:  Unvote Calder

Step 2:  Vote Clov

Step 3:  ?????????????

Step 4:   Profit

 

 

i mean the logic's here right??

 

[v] unvote [/v]

 

[v] Clov [/v]

 

im sorry BFG.....

 

Best friend powers activate

 

 

I WILL AVENGE YOU!!!!

 

[v] Clov [/v]

 

you wolfy soab

 

i mean i love you but i should have known you'd break my heart...

[Nynaeve]

Zander.... halli is scum 99% of the times.

[Nynaeve]

I'll spell it out for you. AJ's seer cover was Thane and then you. But then just before day 2 ended (like a minute) he said to lynch Halli.

 

I think he was playing it out so scum would think he had a guilty on her. And not have peeked you N1, like he said.

 

Number 1 priority is seer hunting. If they shot AJ it means they legitimately thought he was the seer... which means halli is scum.

[Nynaeve]

Legit one of the awesomest seer cover I've seen in a while.

[Zander?]

I'll spell it out for you. AJ's seer cover was Thane and then you. But then just before day 2 ended (like a minute) he said to lynch Halli.

 

I think he was playing it out so scum would think he had a guilty on her. And not have peeked you N1, like he said.

 

Number 1 priority is seer hunting. If they shot AJ it means they legitimately thought he was the seer... which means halli is scum.

 

All valid points but its Day 3 and Clov is still alive so like.....Clov is scum like 100% of time?

[Nynaeve]

This is different because of the setup. I'm usually dead by this stage too but I'm not. Dice and AJ are seer hunting imo. I'm not concerned by Clov still being alive at this point.

 

Last two scum are in Hally and prolly Shad.

[Nolder]

Ok so it's Thane and Hallia then. Lynching wildcards is all fun and games but it should have been Hallia or Thane yesterday anyway imo.

I don't understand why Calder went off the rails like he did.

 

So, Hallia first? I agree with Nyn's assessment that wolves probably killed AJ for the Hallia comment at EOD.

 

[v]Hallia[/v]

[Nynaeve]

At this point the seer has 3 peeks... 4 if you include their own alignment. Scum can't afford to have the seer still in the game.

[Nynaeve]

Ok so it's Thane and Hallia then. Lynching wildcards is all fun and games but it should have been Hallia or Thane yesterday anyway imo.

I don't understand why Calder went off the rails like he did.

 

So, Hallia first? I agree with Nyn's assessment that wolves probably killed AJ for the Hallia comment at EOD.

 

[v]Hallia[/v]

Thane was AJ's N0 cover. They wouldn't have suspected AJ was the seer if Thane is scum....

[Zander?]

 

Go town

 

RIP AJ GOAT

 

[Nolder]

 

Ok so it's Thane and Hallia then. Lynching wildcards is all fun and games but it should have been Hallia or Thane yesterday anyway imo.

I don't understand why Calder went off the rails like he did.

 

So, Hallia first? I agree with Nyn's assessment that wolves probably killed AJ for the Hallia comment at EOD.

 

[v]Hallia[/v]

Thane was AJ's N0 cover. They wouldn't have suspected AJ was the seer if Thane is scum....

 

Really? I haven't been paying attention to who fake peeked who and whatnot. Figure I'll just wait until Seer claims or dies and look it over after.

 

What do you mean Thane was his "cover" exactly?

[Nynaeve]

Aj claimed to have peeked Thane N0. Zander N1. But then a second before D2 ended he implied that he had a guilty on Halli.

 

If you agree with me that AJ's NK was a result of seer hunting....then that means Halli is most likely scum and Thane is most likely town.

[Zander?]

This is different because of the setup. I'm usually dead by this stage too but I'm not. Dice and AJ are seer hunting imo. I'm not concerned by Clov still being alive at this point.

 

Last two scum are in Hally and prolly Shad.

 

 

 

 

@ Alanna:  Yes to your Shad and AJ question.

I don't think Shad is scum, Zander.

 

Who are you WTL today besides Shad?

 

 

We can agree to disagree on Shad

 

WTL:

 

Shad

 

Hallia

Crusher

 

 

 

Clov- Strictly for ignoring the ive sent him.....lolololoololol

 

 

WTL any of the 3 remaining players from this list.

[Nolder]

Aj claimed to have peeked Thane N0. Zander N1. But then a second before D2 ended he implied that he had a guilty on Halli.

 

If you agree with me that AJ's NK was a result of seer hunting....then that means Halli is most likely scum and Thane is most likely town.

But did he say what his result was on Thane?

[Zander?]

 

Aj claimed to have peeked Thane N0. Zander N1. But then a second before D2 ended he implied that he had a guilty on Halli.

 

If you agree with me that AJ's NK was a result of seer hunting....then that means Halli is most likely scum and Thane is most likely town.

But did he say what his result was on Thane?

 

TOWN

[Nynaeve]

Lol

[Nolder]

Ok so if scum thought AJ was Seer and AJ claimed to have a town read on Thane that means Thane can't be scum because they'd know he's lying and not kill him.

 

Got it. Sorry I'm slow sometimes.

[Nolder]

So who the bloody hell is Hallia's partner then?

Alanna?

[Nolder]

I'm going to look at the final VCs...

[Nynaeve]

Shad is

[Nynaeve]

I'll ISO him later today

[Zander?]

[v]Shad[/v]

 

I wanted to give u some benefit of the doubt for weird posts and responses, but now your coming back at me with straight up obvious misrepresentations of our discussions from two pages ago. You make no sense to me if your town.

 

 

Way hey and away we go

A long hard trek, through Dragonmount you know

When can we stop? When Shad is dead

Our victory will be his dread

A way hey and away we go!

EVERYBODY!

 

 

 

 

I will concede that I forgot about your question to him in #75.  When you said he was spinning your questions into a scum read, I assumed you meant the question about how you would act as mafia - which he answered appropriately, IMO, despite it being a pretty bad question.

 

I think it became a "bad question" when he chose to call it WIFOM and assume I had a 'correct answer' in mind instead of elaborating on his thought process.  The WIFOM is whether scum would drop early reads, but that wasn't what I was getting at at all.  He dropped the 'fluffing post count' aspect out of the question when he answered.  It enabled him to say "a good scum player would do this to look town" while simultaneously calling it out for, in his opinion, looking really scummy.

 

Basically he answered it as if I asked the question to defend myself.  What he does have going for him in the engagement is that he immediately called out WIFOM without explanation and made me prod him to elaborate.  It tells me the thought might have come honest rather than being an attempt to smear me.  He's generally been focused on interpreting what I say while blowing off most of my direct engagement.  I think it's a pretty scummy way to play and definitely doesn't help if he's town considering almost no one here knows his usual style.

Yes my main focus has been interpreting what the motivations behind your statements have been. Bc we are playing a deceitful game and to be honest you have not acted as an honest person would. You suggest over and over that i am ducking engagement while you ask no real questions of me.

 

Your contributions have been to commit the scum trifecta of non-content/shady throw-away posts, jumping right to why would scum do this statements, and then wrapping up with the inevitable attacking your attacker in an attempt to draw attention away from yourself.

 

 

So Clader thinks Shad is a wolf

 

 

Cross my fingers that Clov is town and let him weigh in on you?  Has anyone else here played with you before?  I think you are scum.  I don't see how this level of disconnect that conveniently leads to an accusation about me in every post can come from anything else, but it's also blurred my vision a good bit.  I'm going to work for a while and try to reread you with a level head tonight.

 

 

...I actually think there's a decent shot Shad is mafia.  I have some reservations because some of the argument between them depends on what people feel constitutes "engaging", but I think his point about IR ignoring his questions was blatantly false.  And he seems to be avoiding the thread (not only IR, but everyone else) after IR came back about not answering the "would mafia...." question.

 

hmmm.....

[Zander?]

 

Very roughly speaking this is where I'm at prior to any flips.  Content with the groupings, could switch the order in them a little bit, whatever:

 

Nyn

Kivam

Clov

Zander

Dice

Laine

 

Hallia

Thane

 

Nolder

Crusher

 

AJ

Calder

 

 

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

 

 

Your list kind of makes me not want to move my vote when I had been considering it previously.

 

dont hate this

 

/shrug

 

Hate this

 

 

Are you bothered that I'm scum reading you or other things?

 

 

really Shad you of all people are asking/mentioning this.....lolololololololol

 

 

/shrug

 

This may be my reaction when you flip then.