[Pick Your Poison] Pulp Fiction Mafia - Game Over

[alannalynn]

Leelou your classes i that new pic are adorbs

[Leelou]

 

 

I'm just wondering if y'all were to guess town or mafia on Shad right now, which would you pick, based on on what you've read so far on the game and without spending an hour in his ISO. lol

I think he's scummy.

Why? In your list you had him as null, then moved him to your bottom 2, before voting, without really addressing him in the interim

Yeah, been busy and haven't been at a computer most of the day yesterday. After I posted my reads, I noticed his posts were starting to have a general slimy feel from them. I almost forgot about deadline and voted quickly while driving into Boston. If you notice from my reads I also said that I didn't see anything wrong with Tina. There was no way I was going to vote her. That lynch yesterday was crap.

[alannalynn]

im saying my gut is right more often then my head is. i tend to overthink things

I can't very well trust your gut to be right, I need support to back it up. I'm a factual person: gut feels are okay and all, but you gotta be able to back them up with evidence.

[Leelou]

Bah! DM just ate my post.

[Leelou]

Also I hope the unicorn thing is sowing well :)

Yes, I believe it did! I was doing an Internet scavenger hunt and submission deadline was 3 am. So my team and I were frantically trying to complete our tasks.

[BFG]

 

 

 

I'm just wondering if y'all were to guess town or mafia on Shad right now, which would you pick, based on on what you've read so far on the game and without spending an hour in his ISO. lol

I think he's scummy.

 

Why? In your list you had him as null, then moved him to your bottom 2, before voting, without really addressing him in the interim

 

Yeah, been busy and haven't been at a computer most of the day yesterday. After I posted my reads, I noticed his posts were starting to have a general slimy feel from them. I almost forgot about deadline and voted quickly while driving into Boston. If you notice from my reads I also said that I didn't see anything wrong with Tina. There was no way I was going to vote her. That lynch yesterday was crap.

 

Ok, I'll buy that. Why was Dice your other bottom 2 pick?

[Leelou]

Leelou your classes i that new pic are adorbs

Thanks! Funny thing is I only wear contacts. I bought these from the dollar store for a prop for the scavenger hunt video I was making yesterday. XD

[Leelou]

 

 

 

 

I'm just wondering if y'all were to guess town or mafia on Shad right now, which would you pick, based on on what you've read so far on the game and without spending an hour in his ISO. lol

I think he's scummy.

Why? In your list you had him as null, then moved him to your bottom 2, before voting, without really addressing him in the interim

Yeah, been busy and haven't been at a computer most of the day yesterday. After I posted my reads, I noticed his posts were starting to have a general slimy feel from them. I almost forgot about deadline and voted quickly while driving into Boston. If you notice from my reads I also said that I didn't see anything wrong with Tina. There was no way I was going to vote her. That lynch yesterday was crap.

Ok, I'll buy that. Why was Dice your other bottom 2 pick?

I haven't seen any of his town game yet. He seemed a bit cautious.

[dicetosser1]

 

im saying my gut is right more often then my head is. i tend to overthink things

I can't very well trust your gut to be right, I need support to back it up. I'm a factual person: gut feels are okay and all, but you gotta be able to back them up with evidence.

 

 

yeah i know. problem is i suck at casing.  Just go this way  if i suddenly do what i did to you?? take a good look at my target and make up ure own mind

[alannalynn]

 

Leelou your glasses in that new pic are adorbs

Thanks! Funny thing is I only wear contacts. I bought these from the dollar store for a prop for the scavenger hunt video I was making yesterday. XD

Awesome! I can never do contacts... my face looks weird without glasses. Been wearing them since 8th grade.... so... like 10 years maybe? lol

[alannalynn]

 

 

im saying my gut is right more often then my head is. i tend to overthink things

I can't very well trust your gut to be right, I need support to back it up. I'm a factual person: gut feels are okay and all, but you gotta be able to back them up with evidence.

 

yeah i know. problem is i suck at casing.  Just go this way  if i suddenly do what i did to you?? take a good look at my target and make up ure own mind

Well there's a problem because there is a disconnect between what my read of Shad is telling me, what your head is saying, and what your gut is saying. So I guess I don't trust your gut.

[dicetosser1]

ive worn glasses since i was 5. im now 40. had contacts for a few mths at 16. two problems  1 i have no feeling in my hands so i cant put the damned things in 2 the lining of them came off onto my eyes. that REALLY hurt. now im not game enuff to get them for my daughters

[dicetosser1]

my guts not really saying anything. thats the problerm lol

[alannalynn]

ive worn glasses since i was 5. im now 40. had contacts for a few mths at 16. two problems  1 i have no feeling in my hands so i cant put the damned things in 2 the lining of them came off onto my eyes. that REALLY hurt. now im not game enuff to get them for my daughters

OMG that's terrifying. WHY? HOW does that happen? I'm basically never wearing contacts. Though I REALLY wish I would go and get some tinted prescription glasses because driving is really hard with the sun in my eyes and unable to wear sunglasses. Also, I hate 3D movies because glasses on top of glasses.... Life is hard.

 

my guts not really saying anything. thats the problerm lol

[alannalynn]

Okay going to bed now. I'll be awake for a bit later but then I'll have to work tonight, so... yeah

[dicetosser1]

i dont see 3D real well. and i have no idea how it happened

[Shad_]

Aroundish, 5am, irritated by the flip and irl things.  Quick skim I would lynch Laine in a heartbeat and it's going to look omgus as hell, I have to completely reevaluate Kivam but I have a bad feeling about him, I was initially bothered that Leelou quit explaining her reads after a few of us commented on them positively but why would scum stop doing the main thing they're being town read for?  Sudden lack of interest in building town cred is not inherently scummy but it's not exactly helpful.  Will comment on Laine at least and maybe some other things if I haven't fallen asleep yet.

[BFG]

Ok, I've just ISO'd Shad, and as far as I can tell, his focus was pretty much on Seph and then Tina in terms of 'hunting' yesterday.

 

He responds to Kivam about the emo tell thing

Agrees with Darthe about his vote being presumptive

Responds to Talia about his Seph vote

Responds to me about Kivam

 

Then gives out his reads list (general stances do look reasonable on the whole)

Backs off Seph and cases and votes Tina having spent time looking at the 'inactives'

 

 

 

 

There's a lot of follow through with his case on Seph and I don't have much of a feeling on the vote itself. He's been building up to it but the explanation with the vote was because of the 'game' Seph was playing, not because of finding him scummy.

 

I kind of expect Town!Shad to be more proactive than this. He doesn't have multiple suspects, he addresses Seph, backs off goes for Tina.

 

I want to check votes properly to see how Shad's train stacked numbers wise against Tina's at different points. But I think Shad just dropped in my list.

 

I also buy Leelous reasons above for the vote and build up, at least for now, so Leelou's heading up.

 

 

As an immediate difference with the games of his that I remember (SW, Belichick) there's been little to no interest in finding Town (until his reads list). Not sure how much emphasis I put into words but looking again at his reads list, although he's reading (e.g.) Sooh, Leelou as town, he says 'feeling pretty positive', 'like what I'm seeing so far', etc...

[BFG]

Aroundish, 5am, irritated by the flip and irl things.  Quick skim I would lynch Laine in a heartbeat and it's going to look omgus as hell, I have to completely reevaluate Kivam but I have a bad feeling about him, I was initially bothered that Leelou quit explaining her reads after a few of us commented on them positively but why would scum stop doing the main thing they're being town read for?  Sudden lack of interest in building town cred is not inherently scummy but it's not exactly helpful.  Will comment on Laine at least and maybe some other things if I haven't fallen asleep yet.

Looking forward to it :)

[BFG]

I'm out for a few hours, see you later!

[Shad_]

 

Let's do specifics...

 

Dice what are your thoughts on Sooh and Hallia?

 

Laine what are your thoughts on Shad and Talya?

Ninja'd lol

 

Shad I'm very wary of. His reaction post to Seph asking for a vote was very OOC and then playing it off like a reaction test felt like backtracking. That coupled with him calling the trap from Kivam just feels so weird. He's coming off as very wary this game but still has those really townie moments interspersed. I've never really had to question my read of Shad before, and that has me thinking that he's mafia.

 

As for Talya, I need a lot more time for her. I like her reads list, I need to go back to it and look it over though because I mostly skimmed it. But I have a hard time reading Talya to being with.

 

 

Basically this is total garbage.  In Belichick Laine comes in dead set on buddying me and trying to look as engaged as she can fake it.  When I dabble in tests and post OOC her reaction is consistently "that's weird but I'm ok with it/will trust you".  The buddying fails to swoon me, AJ and I dissect her activity and lead a lunch on her.  Here she sits out most of D1 and I comment that I hope she's not keeping quiet because she's afraid I'm high-tuned to her scum game.  I vocally lunch Tina D1 and she flips town, and now suddenly Laine's out of the cave and gunning for me, calling me out for the dirty side of my town game that she's seen four times now.  Calling my Seph test "backtracking" is opportunistic AF coming from her and I'm not going to give it a pass.

[BFG]

To add to the Dice is pinging thing... More active at Night then in the run up to EOD

[dicetosser1]

Ok, I've just ISO'd Shad, and as far as I can tell, his focus was pretty much on Seph and then Tina in terms of 'hunting' yesterday.

 

He responds to Kivam about the emo tell thing

Agrees with Darthe about his vote being presumptive

Responds to Talia about his Seph vote

Responds to me about Kivam

 

Then gives out his reads list (general stances do look reasonable on the whole)

Backs off Seph and cases and votes Tina having spent time looking at the 'inactives'

 

 

 

 

There's a lot of follow through with his case on Seph and I don't have much of a feeling on the vote itself. He's been building up to it but the explanation with the vote was because of the 'game' Seph was playing, not because of finding him scummy.

 

I kind of expect Town!Shad to be more proactive than this. He doesn't have multiple suspects, he addresses Seph, backs off goes for Tina.

 

I want to check votes properly to see how Shad's train stacked numbers wise against Tina's at different points. But I think Shad just dropped in my list.

 

I also buy Leelous reasons above for the vote and build up, at least for now, so Leelou's heading up.

 

 

As an immediate difference with the games of his that I remember (SW, Belichick) there's been little to no interest in finding Town (until his reads list). Not sure how much emphasis I put into words but looking again at his reads list, although he's reading (e.g.) Sooh, Leelou as town, he says 'feeling pretty positive', 'like what I'm seeing so far', etc...

 

just pointing out thats what you lynched me for last game.

 

 

and im here now and not busy hence activity

[Sooh]

To add to the Dice is pinging thing... More active at Night then in the run up to EOD

Well.. to be fair... EOD was at 5am I believe his time... 

[BFG]

 

Ok, I've just ISO'd Shad, and as far as I can tell, his focus was pretty much on Seph and then Tina in terms of 'hunting' yesterday.

 

He responds to Kivam about the emo tell thing

Agrees with Darthe about his vote being presumptive

Responds to Talia about his Seph vote

Responds to me about Kivam

 

Then gives out his reads list (general stances do look reasonable on the whole)

Backs off Seph and cases and votes Tina having spent time looking at the 'inactives'

 

 

 

 

There's a lot of follow through with his case on Seph and I don't have much of a feeling on the vote itself. He's been building up to it but the explanation with the vote was because of the 'game' Seph was playing, not because of finding him scummy.

 

I kind of expect Town!Shad to be more proactive than this. He doesn't have multiple suspects, he addresses Seph, backs off goes for Tina.

 

I want to check votes properly to see how Shad's train stacked numbers wise against Tina's at different points. But I think Shad just dropped in my list.

 

I also buy Leelous reasons above for the vote and build up, at least for now, so Leelou's heading up.

 

 

As an immediate difference with the games of his that I remember (SW, Belichick) there's been little to no interest in finding Town (until his reads list). Not sure how much emphasis I put into words but looking again at his reads list, although he's reading (e.g.) Sooh, Leelou as town, he says 'feeling pretty positive', 'like what I'm seeing so far', etc...

 

just pointing out thats what you lynched me for last game.

 

 

and im here now and not busy hence activity

 

 

That's a specific Dice tell

 

 

To add to the Dice is pinging thing... More active at Night then in the run up to EOD

Well.. to be fair... EOD was at 5am I believe his time...

 

Fair enough, I don't recall anything from Dice during 'my' Saturday (roughly 16 hours before deadline) and I was on and off most of the day.