[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

seph · June 28, 2015

Also I doubt wombat is scum.

Rereading day 3 with sooh. But I doubt it.

Sili Quirrels · June 28, 2015

I skim big posts, not ganna lie.

For shame!

Sili Quirrels · June 28, 2015

:rolleyes:

Sili Quirrels · June 28, 2015

I get the sense yates brought a lot of drama. fun fun. going back to pg 50 to start from where i left.

i think this is my only honest post wrt yates besides when i comment on his wagon day 2. I don't tear him apart. I'm ambivalent to the yates drama.

Eldrick, i think you vote and unvote a lot of ppl, and it looks jumpy. I can see some merit in what Yates says. On a level it reminds me of your wolf game when you said one thing, only backtracking when reproached. On another level it feels like you're more engaged because of it.

day 3. continuation.

just now strikes me how out of order this all is. hopefully it adds to how genuine i'm being. XD

We're not lynching Eldrick tomorrow.

The lunch menu shall need approval via WomboCombo before proceeding and currently the main course is Heart or Yates depending on how NAs go.

Any further questions refer to this post.

Your Villa Captain,

Combo

Not yates.

ref.

My win condition is to be killed at night.

=3

I doubt that. Please don't leave us

Not bob wants to kill me. My wish will be granted. =D

Not bob killed clov. Not bob does what he does.

Hero Shots. as in shots that shoot heroes. -__-

This is when I talk about being nk'd. After things between nb and i calm down. I don't believe nb will kill me at this point, but I want to maximize value by making scum think he might.

Just remember that u r horrible, and I h8 u.

hate is mean word

http://www.mothering.com/forum/35-parenting/850836-hate-inappropriate-bad-word.html

u r going to shoot me and I will cry

I don't want you to cry...I will shoot Dice.

I will hope for the best.

ref.

doin'rounds

Salami is incredible in the traditional sense of the word.

You have my permission to lynch.

<3

leaning town on Durin and slight town on Thaneballs

null read on Wombocombo- but i didnt like the early agression and aj carrying over stuff from last game and the fact hes been pretty inactive. im not just relying on darthes math i think there a likely chance theres scum on the hydra list.

i think someone is more likely to say this as a villager, in this context, but not sure . just kind of interesting. also, the angle that's being taken could have lead to verbal, so it seems like it'd be risky for scum to pursue.

anyway, noted.

Salami he dropped the peek in his OP. So Day action? Not likely.

Masons? Maybe. Still not the best way to go about breadcrumbing imo.

You're more advanced than to come to these conclusions imo.

didn't think about this.

@Leelou- ive been leaning you towards slightly wolfy. am i wrong and if so why?

zander town

Sili I could use some help lynching Darthe. Or do you think I'm wrong there?

i think this is a a super genuine post for salami. probably doesn't ask a villager to vote another villager as scum.

Yes it was my joke that you decided MIGHT POSSIBLY IN 1 of 100,000( or maybe a few more percentage points, IDK you didn't really say definitively) times be serious that led you to drop a vote an hold onto it all day.
Dude. Are you serious right now? WHY DO YOU KEEP IGNORING MY SIMPLE QUESTION?

WHY do you keep demanding that Dice QUANTIFIES his read on this? This is complete garbage to me. And it's seriously ticking me off that you won't answer.

This line of discussion goes on for a long while, and I'm not sure what the point is. I think Yates started pressing Turin page 20 or something.

I haven't been following the dice & darthe interaction at all. Someone care to explain concisely?

Peeked Darthe N0.

Result:

Dice didn't like this post.

Right. Let me break it down.

It's basically a self-vote - since Turin claimed to peek his hydra buddy a wolf.

The REASON Dice is ascribing so much scum value to a self-vote [which is usually dumb but not really alignment indicative] is because he thinks this looks like a staged interaction orchestrated by Darthe for lulz.

I won't say I'm the GOAT Turin reader but I don't recall his game being self-vote lulzy. I *DO* know Darthe's meta and can absolutely see Dice being 100% on the money with this.

Turin has been hard defending this play by trying to force Dice into ascribing a numerical value to the odds of him doing this as Town vs Scum. And that's complete horse pucky. If that was just a joke, why not say "lulz jkjk?" This defense is really pinging hard because it's way off point and the play itself seems out of character for Turin.

So there you go. Now you know why I've been riding Turin to answer me for two days and why I'm annoyed that he's been ignoring my question. I think he's ignoring the question because he doesn't have a good answer.

I'm going to finish my reread but I'm probably voting Durin.

Summary: yates' insistence is kind of weird and one dimensional, but I agree with the bold at least.

I didn't get the impression it was unreasonable for turin to pin Dice down. I am... pretty sure that's what he was trying to do? (haven't read turin's posts in a while)

day 3 post. probably doesn't count for a lot but i'm trying to naturally build in my changing stance on yates.

My best guess is that you were trying to make me look bad because I asked him to quantify his level of belief (or his thought of likelihood).

Bottom line is I asked in order to gauge whether he had sufficient believe to justify his actions of voting and making a big stink and posturing in an OTT manner that parodies his town meta. The same meta he claims to not be able to properly emulate as mafia.

Ok. You saw my post above about why it was bothering me. Wish you had just said this the first time...

Okay, resolved on 71.

ref.

here you are.

Sili Quirrels · June 28, 2015

This is when I talk about being nk'd. After things between nb and i calm down. I don't believe nb will kill me at this point, but I want to maximize value by making scum think he might.

seph · June 28, 2015

Will read it in a min... holy jesus

WWWwombat · June 29, 2015

Then lets go for the SK...because that is one things that could still muck us up...if there is a sk, then that clears AJ/Womb and means there would be just one more to get. If you clear Heart it narrows it down to Eld.

We don't even know there is an SK and SK is one of the hardest roles to find.

Yates · June 29, 2015

Uwnsbsndhsysj

Still angry at you both!!

I haven't decided what I want to do yet, I feel.. I'm not sure what I feel anymore, Mafia had made me numb.

I blame Zander. His stupid tunnel forced our hand and has lead to this mass claim.

Would you agree, at least, that Sili had been Town prior to not handling the claim situation well? Like, he was at least in a good enough position not to stick his neck out if we were scum buddies, right?

WWWwombat · June 29, 2015

Right now I want to vote Wombocombo. Like REALLY want to.

Im gonna try and read D3 at lunch and see if that really does clear them

Tearing my hair out IRL.

Yates · June 29, 2015

Then lets go for the SK...because that is one things that could still muck us up...if there is a sk, then that clears AJ/Womb and means there would be just one more to get. If you clear Heart it narrows it down to Eld.

We don't even know there is an SK and SK is one of the hardest roles to find.

Yeah. SK hunting is hard because they also need to lynch wolves. If there are two kills tonight and one of them doesn't make sense? THEN you can start thinking about SK's.

Yates · June 29, 2015

I was more worried you'd shoot dice or salami.

FTR - I *told him* Dice was VT.

Zander? · June 29, 2015

Uwnsbsndhsysj

Still angry at you both!!

I haven't decided what I want to do yet, I feel.. I'm not sure what I feel anymore, Mafia had made me numb.

I blame Zander. His stupid tunnel forced our hand and has lead to this mass claim.

Would you agree, at least, that Sili had been Town prior to not handling the claim situation well? Like, he was at least in a good enough position not to stick his neck out if we were scum buddies, right?

lol blame yourself and your teammate imo.

WWWwombat · June 29, 2015

Heart basically hasn't done anything meaningful since D1 but she claimed doc so she's unlynchable I guess.

WWWwombat · June 29, 2015

Afk a bit. Should be back at least one more time before EOD.

Yates · June 29, 2015

Right now I want to vote Wombocombo. Like REALLY want to.

Im gonna try and read D3 at lunch and see if that really does clear them

Tearing my hair out IRL.

Here's where I swallow some pride and admit I was probably wrong...

@Dice - The Sooh lynch was 100% driven by Wombo and Sili. EVEN IF I thought there were two scum remaining. And EVEN IF I thought that team was EXACTLY Wombo and Eldrick based on Wombo putting the brakes on the Eldrick lynch, I don't see Wombo putting the brakes on an easy Sili or Yates mislynch if scum. At worst, they are SK trying to buy time and extra Town credit. But honestly, NB has more SK equity and - again - we don't know that there is even an SK in the game.

WWWwombat · June 29, 2015

Wait nvm, EOD is tomorrow.

鲍勃不是我的名字 · June 29, 2015

Heart basically hasn't done anything meaningful since D1 but she claimed doc so she's unlynchable I guess.

I've liked her detailed analysis. Why not Sili?

Why are you so hung up on letting a uncountered Doc live for another day? At least Zander has rationale. You sound like scum having to eliminate the one potential roadblock to a scum win.

WWWwombat · June 29, 2015

Heart basically hasn't done anything meaningful since D1 but she claimed doc so she's unlynchable I guess.

I've liked her detailed analysis. Why not Sili?

Why are you so hung up on letting a uncountered Doc live for another day? At least Zander has rationale. You sound like scum having to eliminate the one potential roadblock to a scum win.

Her analysis isn't analysis, it's just a summary. She does that every game. It means almost nothing. I will lynch Sili if I have to, but I don't think there are 5 mafia, and I don't think Yates claims masons with Sili as scum here.

Andrej · June 29, 2015

If by "detailed analysis" you mean recapping everything on everyone, sure.

Andrej · June 29, 2015

Ninja'd.

Wombat and I agree.

Yates · June 29, 2015

I realize I was threatening to vig you n2 and yet you left zero clues for you fellow masonite...yes, you looked really good...hmmn

If he flipped R2D2 - Mason and I was forced to claim "C-3PO - Sili's mason partner," would you have believed me? There obviously would not have been a counter claim.

Yates · June 29, 2015

You sound like scum having to eliminate the one potential roadblock to a scum win.

In this scenario there would be 3 scum remaining. Now it's just getting out of hand...

Zander? · June 29, 2015

Heart basically hasn't done anything meaningful since D1 but she claimed doc so she's unlynchable I guess.

I've liked her detailed analysis. Why not Sili?

Why are you so hung up on letting a uncountered Doc live for another day? At least Zander has rationale. You sound like scum having to eliminate the one potential roadblock to a scum win.

Her analysis isn't analysis, it's just a summary. She does that every game. It means almost nothing. I will lynch Sili if I have to, but I don't think there are 5 mafia, and I don't think Yates claims masons with Sili as scum here.

sounds good lets go!

seph · June 29, 2015

the problem here.
day 1-3 went so smoothly thanks to darthe and his cfd.
its down to 1-2 scum possibly a sk

sili basicly threw me though a loop

I just iso'd all the scum, and about to iso heart now.
through thane's iso I felt like he avoided talking about his scum mates as much as possible.

seph · June 29, 2015

Heart basically hasn't done anything meaningful since D1 but she claimed doc so she's unlynchable I guess.

I've liked her detailed analysis. Why not Sili?

Why are you so hung up on letting a uncountered Doc live for another day? At least Zander has rationale. You sound like scum having to eliminate the one potential roadblock to a scum win.

Her analysis isn't analysis, it's just a summary. She does that every game. It means almost nothing. I will lynch Sili if I have to, but I don't think there are 5 mafia, and I don't think Yates claims masons with Sili as scum here.

sounds good lets go!

zander I am starting to come around on them tbh.

tbh the last wolf has to be in heart, tayla, eld

and I feel good about tayla

alright on eld

and at the start of this day my plan was to vote heart.

will iso heart again and see how I feel.

I know the sili was, is safe. but if I can feel confident about them being mason's then I don't want to go that route...

[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook