[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[alannalynn]

....And yet you're telling me that you haven't said that Sili doesn't know how to play as mafia and you can tell every time based on meta? uh huh, I totally see the nuance there.

[Darthe]

 

 

 

<3 Zander

Just know that the day you're scum and I'm town, I'm lynching you so damn fast

Alanna... Do you see any issue with this?

Nope.

If you were me what do you think might seem strange about it? Really try for me.

[alannalynn]

I don't think Csarmi's a problem, tbh. I'll be looking forward to his reads list

[Darthe]

....And yet you're telling me that you haven't said that Sili doesn't know how to play as mafia and you can tell every time based on meta? uh huh, I totally see the nuance there.

You really want a nuanced and in depth explanation of reasons that Sili is not a wolf here? there are a number of them. But it's not foolproof and generally it's easier to say a reason I think someone is town and move on instead of wasting time reiterating a point in multiple ways

[Darthe]

I don't think Csarmi's a problem, tbh. I'll be looking forward to his reads list

Lol maybe not for the wolf team or anyone who doesn't interact with him

[dicetosser1]

Well Dice we are 1/3 of the way to your requirements.

 

Good job Darthe. I laugh everytime I hear that ASSUMING CONTROL line. 

 

I will need to go back over all the stuffs that happened there at EoD. probably not tonight tho.

 

claps

 

Well ya'll I have a lot to say about this, not in the least relegated to pointing out that I just went full harbinger on leelou and am the clearest living player by a landslide, but I'll suffice for this

 

GET REKT SALAMI AND DICE I OWN YOU! W00T! **** YEAH

 

gives Darthe the finger

 

 

In regards to your spew paragraph, I think Wombat is a good enough player to fabricate a "Man, am I about to feel stupid post" about a teammate.  I'm not saying that necessarily IS the case, but I'm saying it's possible - even though I tend to side with the premise regarding it.  Similarly, I'm not sure mafia comes into the thread and apologizes to a teammate before the flip.  Mafia!Heart would have known that Leelou was flipping red, so why do anything but ride the spew waves to townieland?  

 

If she genuinely felt bad about lynching a friend, the apology - itself - makes sense, but she could have EASILY done that via PM or QT.  If Heart did that as mafia, kudos to her on a "so awful it's brilliant" play.

I have one of you/Heart/Wombat as a wolf.  Deciding which probably won't be as hard as I'm making it seem but I am exploring everything.

 

Seph, Zander, Eldrick, Me, Laine, Shad, Dice, Csarmi, and Talya should probably never ever ever be lynched in this game as things stand.  

 

 

here you say never lynch me

 

Sili

Alanna

Sooh

Eldrick

Clov

Csarmi

Shad

Seph

 

Zander

Yates

Wombocombo

Talya

 

Thaneballs

AH

Dice

Notbob

 

here im second last which is normally a mafia position. But i feel like im missing the setup of this list. Explain it plz?

[alannalynn]

If you were me what do you think might seem strange about it? Really try for me.

I really don't want to think like you Darthe, you're not right 100% of the time, no offense.

 

Besides the fact that I have no meta to go off of with him as scum, I have no idea what his mafia game looks like (nobody does other than a turbo?). We're trending toward being buddy-buddy a lot lately, so he can easily pocket me as scum I'm sure. But I'm also somewhat sure that I would be able to tell if he's mafia. Hell he could be mafia right now but I don't think so, and I'm not comfortable with going down that road atm

[Darthe]

List is not in order, just groups. spew from the leelou lynch dropped you back into the low group through PoE, or maybe recency bias.

 

<3 u too

[Darthe]

 

 

If you were me what do you think might seem strange about it? Really try for me.

I really don't want to think like you Darthe, you're not right 100% of the time, no offense.

 

Besides the fact that I have no meta to go off of with him as scum, I have no idea what his mafia game looks like (nobody does other than a turbo?). We're trending toward being buddy-buddy a lot lately, so he can easily pocket me as scum I'm sure. But I'm also somewhat sure that I would be able to tell if he's mafia. Hell he could be mafia right now but I don't think so, and I'm not comfortable with going down that road atm

Ohh I see, that's my bad. I was asking if you thought there might objectively be anything suspect about the post, not to change your rationale.

[alannalynn]

 

....And yet you're telling me that you haven't said that Sili doesn't know how to play as mafia and you can tell every time based on meta? uh huh, I totally see the nuance there.

You really want a nuanced and in depth explanation of reasons that Sili is not a wolf here? there are a number of them. But it's not foolproof and generally it's easier to say a reason I think someone is town and move on instead of wasting time reiterating a point in multiple ways

And I have him town read since early in the game, but I really just wanted to ask what you didn't want me to ask. I don't need a nuanced explanation at this point, and this is besides the fact that I don't see him being this self-loathing about his vote at end of day as a wolf.

[Shad_]

 

 

 

 

Different game.  But I lulz.  Pretty sure I was scum that game so yeah...hang your hat there.

 

 

...Yes....that's the point I'm making.

 

 

...and its not lost on me that now you're pushing the same tactics...you as scum using my previous tactics when I was scum...you're better than this...but lulz.

 

 

...No?  I'm pointing out that you're pointing fingers out after people who didn't contribute to the lynch immediately after you finished a game where you did EXACTLY the same thing.  

 

I don't care if you don't vote at all.  I do care that you sat by and let the events unfold as if the outcome meant nothing to you.

 

 

The outcome meant nothing to me.  If I was scum I would have put a vote on Leelou's competing train.  Good luck with this.  

 

 

Last game there were two competing trains and you bussed your scum mate over the townie.  >_>

 

[alannalynn]

 

 

If you were me what do you think might seem strange about it? Really try for me.

I really don't want to think like you Darthe, you're not right 100% of the time, no offense.

 

Besides the fact that I have no meta to go off of with him as scum, I have no idea what his mafia game looks like (nobody does other than a turbo?). We're trending toward being buddy-buddy a lot lately, so he can easily pocket me as scum I'm sure. But I'm also somewhat sure that I would be able to tell if he's mafia. Hell he could be mafia right now but I don't think so, and I'm not comfortable with going down that road atm

Ohh I see, that's my bad. I was asking if you thought there might objectively be anything suspect about the post, not to change your rationale.

I see what you mean, and no. I have faith in Zander

[alannalynn]

 

The outcome meant nothing to me.  If I was scum I would have put a vote on Leelou's competing train.  Good luck with this

 

Last game there were two competing trains and you bussed your scum mate over the townie.  >_>

+1

[dicetosser1]

Leelou spew?  what the constant "get out of the tunnel" comments? lol

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

 

Different game.  But I lulz.  Pretty sure I was scum that game so yeah...hang your hat there.

 

 

...Yes....that's the point I'm making.

 

 

...and its not lost on me that now you're pushing the same tactics...you as scum using my previous tactics when I was scum...you're better than this...but lulz.

 

 

...No?  I'm pointing out that you're pointing fingers out after people who didn't contribute to the lynch immediately after you finished a game where you did EXACTLY the same thing.  

 

I don't care if you don't vote at all.  I do care that you sat by and let the events unfold as if the outcome meant nothing to you.

 

 

The outcome meant nothing to me.  If I was scum I would have put a vote on Leelou's competing train.  Good luck with this.  

 

 

Last game there were two competing trains and you bussed your scum mate over the townie.  >_>

 

Chaotic evil?

 

 

 

 

If you were me what do you think might seem strange about it? Really try for me.

I really don't want to think like you Darthe, you're not right 100% of the time, no offense.

 

Besides the fact that I have no meta to go off of with him as scum, I have no idea what his mafia game looks like (nobody does other than a turbo?). We're trending toward being buddy-buddy a lot lately, so he can easily pocket me as scum I'm sure. But I'm also somewhat sure that I would be able to tell if he's mafia. Hell he could be mafia right now but I don't think so, and I'm not comfortable with going down that road atm

Ohh I see, that's my bad. I was asking if you thought there might objectively be anything suspect about the post, not to change your rationale.

I see what you mean, and no. I have faith in Zander

 

Cool by me

 

Leelou spew?  what the constant "get out of the tunnel" comments? lol

She did so many things

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

 

 

Different game.  But I lulz.  Pretty sure I was scum that game so yeah...hang your hat there.

 

 

...Yes....that's the point I'm making.

 

...and its not lost on me that now you're pushing the same tactics...you as scum using my previous tactics when I was scum...you're better than this...but lulz.

 

...No?  I'm pointing out that you're pointing fingers out after people who didn't contribute to the lynch immediately after you finished a game where you did EXACTLY the same thing.  

 

I don't care if you don't vote at all.  I do care that you sat by and let the events unfold as if the outcome meant nothing to you.

 

The outcome meant nothing to me.  If I was scum I would have put a vote on Leelou's competing train.  Good luck with this.

 

Last game there were two competing trains and you bussed your scum mate over the townie.  >_>

Godfathee also he knew i peeked dae

[Yates]

Sorry guys...  It was a friend's birthday dinner Friday, my anniversary today, and my first Father's Day tomorrow.

 

Good lynch.  I suspect the Town core will be set in stone once I've read through.  With the GF gone this game is pretty much in the bag.

 

Catch up with yall on Monday.

[Yates]

Can I get some Cop - Doc - Vig lists real quick?

 

Danke.

[Sili Quirrels]

doc: yourself if you're anyone important.

[Darthe]

Doc me since I am obv conf town

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

 

Verbal confirmed jealous of Sooh.

 

@Verb - got Leelou read yet?

 

heh

 

Very light village - she jumped in and her initial posts appear to show she is paying attention.  And she reached out to me with a greeting early on that didn't seem forced.  Me likey so far.

 

You going to say hi back?

 

HI

 

 

Man this is so awkward.

 

[Shad_]

Ok, I actually have time to post things now.

 

AH, are you lurking around by any chance?

[Sili Quirrels]

Doc me since I am obv conf town

=| You're probably a survivor or something.

[Sili Quirrels]

But Okay protect Darthe! :thumbs:

[Shad_]

 

 

 

 

Verbal confirmed jealous of Sooh.

 

@Verb - got Leelou read yet?

 

heh

 

Very light village - she jumped in and her initial posts appear to show she is paying attention.  And she reached out to me with a greeting early on that didn't seem forced.  Me likey so far.

 

You going to say hi back?

 

HI

 

 

Man this is so awkward.

 

 

 

Thaneballs was scummy even before Leelou went down.  If his interactions with Leelou haven't landed him rock bottom on everyone's list then it's because you all know him and I don't.

 

Consider when he's chumming it up with Leelou and giving her a solid clear without any commentary on the dirt that had already been presented about her that scum was probably not expecting her to go down yesterday.