Alien mafia [BASIC] - Game Over - Town won

[Shad_]

^ Nullifies my reason for not voting Dae yet and drops my strongest scum read off his train.  [v]Daetirion[/v]

 

Should have quoted, responding to Darthe not Talya

[Darthe]

^ Nullifies my reason for not voting Dae yet and drops my strongest scum read off his train.  [v]Daetirion[/v]

[v] shad [/v]

 

this time dumb is scum

[Talya]

Hallia, I have been through before briefly. I know she doesn't post much, I just don't like that she says hardly anything here. She said a little more in the Middle Earth game and was more snarky and spoke out more, this feels like shying away from the limelight and not tackling anything. This is why I have a wolf lean on her.

 

Shad

• Where to start - He seemed so certain from the start that Eld was town. Something about his posts seem odd for a newbie. Didn't like Alanna and Darthe on Eld
• Again doesn't like the Eld train, getting good vibes on Dae and Notbob. I question the Notbob bit because he hasn't done much especially at this point on day 1 so how can he get a good vibe from him. Again thinks Alanna is agressive.
• doesn't like Darthe and that darthe, Sili and me are at bottom for him. (Interesting use of words - only because if you were saying about who you thought was most wolfie you would put at the top of your list...)
• Still bothered about Darthe
• He said something odd about toning down his game so that the two (town and wolf) are less distinct - that implies he has played before.
• Day 2 would gladly vote Darthe
• He mentions Darthe in the American Gods game...hence his suspicions

Nor sure what to make of him yet, but I think there is an experienced player in there and he is Lying his guts off Trouble is that doesn't automatically make him wolf, but to pretend to have not played before could make him be wolf.

•  

[Talya]

Is that the Hammer?

[Leelou]

@Mod don't be high on some unvote rule, they're unneccesary

 

Actually, they are not. And don't tell me what is necessary or not. 

[Daetirion]

Back from interview and already dead. Would have been nice to have a chance to defend myself but so be it. 

[Shad_]

Back from interview and already dead. Would have been nice to have a chance to defend myself but so be it. 

 

You have four votes.  You need six.

[Leelou]

Vote Count
 
Dae (5) - Verbs, Notbob, Darthe, Sili, Shad
Talya (3) - Dae, Heart, Hallia
Darthe (1) - Sooh
 
With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch
 
Deadline - Friday noon EDT

[Talya]

Darthe is all over the place...as usual, he was in the other game and he was town, although before the end of Day 1 (or night 1) he did step up to the mark there. Yet to see that here, so would like to see more of his reasoning.

 

AH

• I have a hard time reading her posts, they all jumble together and it's a hard read for me. To start with she found Alanna over bearing, she was Happy with Sooh, Shad's posts stick out but it was Alanna who pinged her.
• Eld was flipping all over the place
• Says what is happening in her posts, but doesn't put what she thinks of it, after putting the event down. I get the feeling she copies and pastes her notes and not much else.
• She said that Dae was looking to go on the Eld post before he did, so his was a good vote. I'm sure I got the impression that he thought Eld was town and he then suddenly voted him.
• She voted me. I suppose the result of Dae may make her look wolfie or not so wolfie.

I'm not liking the way she doesn't put too much thought into the posts and just copies her notes, I would rather see the interpretation of those notes than a wall of notes, which makes my eyes go funny.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Back from interview and already dead. Would have been nice to have a chance to defend myself but so be it. 

 

 

Vote Count

 

Dae (5) - Verbs, Notbob, Darthe, Sili, Shad

Talya (3) - Dae, Heart, Hallia

Darthe (1) - Sooh

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

 

Deadline - Friday noon EDT

 

LulZ.

 

I think he just took his ball and went home.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

BTW Hammer was prob just dumb, not alignment indicative.

 

Why do either of these people have trains?  They're bad, not scummy.

 

[v] Sili [/v] is scummy

 

scummy 

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Is that the Hammer?

 

a couple of nice townie posts...thanks

[Talya]

Oh not a lynch...I had the wrong figures in my head. ok

 

Dae

• Dae saw Eld as misplay on his behalf because of what had happened to him in another game. Thinks that Darthes vote is a joke..why?? He guarantees that there are one or two wolves in Alanna, Darthe, Sili, Hallia and Poss Notbob. Interesting that he put Hallia here when she had hardly said anything to Eld except about the N0 peek. 
• Gets asked by Yates how confident he is on Eld being Town. He explains it's to do with how he felt it was.
• He said that Me and Alanna gave somegood evidence on Eld, but his gut was telling him town. Will hold off on his vote. Darthe doesn't gel well for him, sili concerns him, Shad deserves "something", gut on eld being town.
• Then he leans mafia on sili
• then votes Eld. Who Yates had said he would happily Hammer. But it was me that did it and he comes in and votes me day for the hammer and disappearing off. Funny he should say that, because it was an evening vote for me, so what with night and then work day he would know, being the same timeline as me.

This is where I saw the discepency in AH's post when she said Dae was looking to vote Eld, where he wasn't sili was his lean, and yet still voted Eld.

 

Going to have to go, otherwise I will be late. Be back soon for the next installment

[Daetirion]

Ok thought that was the hammer. I'll give it a shot, for what it's worth. 

 

As far as i can tell, there are 3 reasons people are voting for me:

 

1) Trusting my initial read on Eldrick. Its not suspicious to ANY of you that in the space of 24 hours he gets the kitchen sink thrown at him? 

 

2) Explaining my actions. Apparently in this meta i need to throw out random accusations and be 100% behind each one (per Sili's reading). At the end of the day, there is one person whose alignment i am sure of and that is mine (Town for those wondering). I am not someone who posts meaningless one sentence posts, and will normally explain my thought process. It should be clear from my posts on day 1 that my initial read on Eldrick was strong town (~80%) which progressed as more evidence came up and eventually I reached a decision that he was probably Mafia (60%), and i then voted accordingly. On Talya I was probably 55% Town until the hammer was dropped suspiciously, and she went to at least 70% Mafia. Sili seems to be conflating putting a lynch at l-1 with being as bad as a hammer (something i disagree with).

 

3) Yates being NK'd as someone who "caught my slip". Yes he questioned my post, but if you think my Mafia game is bad enough to immediately kill a primary accuser you underestimate my Mafia game! 

 

The thing that is getting me is Talya makes a mistake and gets a pass from large numbers of players, Eldrick slips up and is railroaded and the same happens with me in American Gods, and arguably here. 

 

And as Talya posted whilst i was typing this, what's surprising about having multiple Mafia suspects? We can expect two, probably three Mafia. At the end of the day I was persuaded by the arguments and evidence presented - which is what we are supposed to do, isn't it? 

 

At the end of the day, i am l-1. I can't role claim anything as i'm vanilla so there is little else to say. I expect the hammer to drop soon, possibly from a Mafia. I'm unlikely to get back on too soon as i put my life on hold for my interview today and there is a hell of a lot of things i need to catch up on, and i'm running a training weekend this weekend. If i'm alive on Monday, i'll see you all then. 

[Darthe]

[unvote]

[Darthe]

Vote Count

 

Dae (5) - Verbs, Notbob, Darthe, Sili, Shad

Talya (3) - Dae, Heart, Hallia

Darthe (1) - Sooh

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

 

Deadline - Friday noon EDT

But then you didn't count my vote

[Darthe]

Sooh prob wolf. Parked her vote and ditched.

 

I officially dislike both trains

[Verbal32]

Sooh prob wolf. Parked her vote and ditched.

 

I officially dislike both trains

 

Dae is probably a wolf.

[Darthe]

I wouldn't know, I don't get dae in general

[Verbal32]

YOLO

[Darthe]

TBf I don't much care yet. 20 page game with snap reads and people degenerating into chaos with things like "my wolf read says this person is town so ima vote that person instead of the wolf read"

 

I'm prob not really gonna step up and batman this thing before tomorrow

[Shad_]

Ok thought that was the hammer. I'll give it a shot, for what it's worth. 

 

As far as i can tell, there are 3 reasons people are voting for me:

 

1) Trusting my initial read on Eldrick. Its not suspicious to ANY of you that in the space of 24 hours he gets the kitchen sink thrown at him? 

 

2) Explaining my actions. Apparently in this meta i need to throw out random accusations and be 100% behind each one (per Sili's reading). At the end of the day, there is one person whose alignment i am sure of and that is mine (Town for those wondering). I am not someone who posts meaningless one sentence posts, and will normally explain my thought process. It should be clear from my posts on day 1 that my initial read on Eldrick was strong town (~80%) which progressed as more evidence came up and eventually I reached a decision that he was probably Mafia (60%), and i then voted accordingly. On Talya I was probably 55% Town until the hammer was dropped suspiciously, and she went to at least 70% Mafia. Sili seems to be conflating putting a lynch at l-1 with being as bad as a hammer (something i disagree with).

 

3) Yates being NK'd as someone who "caught my slip". Yes he questioned my post, but if you think my Mafia game is bad enough to immediately kill a primary accuser you underestimate my Mafia game! 

 

The thing that is getting me is Talya makes a mistake and gets a pass from large numbers of players, Eldrick slips up and is railroaded and the same happens with me in American Gods, and arguably here. 

 

And as Talya posted whilst i was typing this, what's surprising about having multiple Mafia suspects? We can expect two, probably three Mafia. At the end of the day I was persuaded by the arguments and evidence presented - which is what we are supposed to do, isn't it? 

 

At the end of the day, i am l-1. I can't role claim anything as i'm vanilla so there is little else to say. I expect the hammer to drop soon, possibly from a Mafia. I'm unlikely to get back on too soon as i put my life on hold for my interview today and there is a hell of a lot of things i need to catch up on, and i'm running a training weekend this weekend. If i'm alive on Monday, i'll see you all then. 

 

I didn't like Eldrick getting the kitchen sink thrown at him at all.  But given that, why do you place a fairly critical vote on him at 60%?  You're a little bit suspicious of him but also of some of the people who initially voted for him, there's plenty of time left, lots of other people hadn't voted yet.  I'm not saying this makes you mafia, but I want to hear a good reason for it.

[Shad_]

• He mentions Darthe in the American Gods game...hence his suspicions

 

I did?

 

 

Nor sure what to make of him yet, but I think there is an experienced player in there and he is Lying his guts off Trouble is that doesn't automatically make him wolf, but to pretend to have not played before could make him be wolf.

 

 

I claimed noob in the sign-up thread.

[Talya]

I concede that point, doesn't mean you haven't played before though. lol

[Darthe]

[v] talya [/v]