American Gods Mafia [Advanced] - mafia win

[dicetosser1]

but not before the actual lynch?  

[Sili Quirrels]

Sili can we get a reads list from you

Ya sure.

 

Town wombat

Null to town dice notbob

Null thane sooh

Null to scum aj darthe

[Andrej]

Ur reaching aj... But good wim all the same. Do me next

Sili knew I was wrong on Hallia?

it seemed to me you were casing her on things related to her low post count, even though every game it's like this, which is why i said you were reaching because you and i both know your arguments were immaterial. now you're reaching again by turning it back onto me.

 

Yeah, I never pointed to her post count and said it was wolfy. I did acknowledge her small number of posts and that it made it hard to really dissect because she was never around to progress but of the 3 that did offer insight I didn't like. The way she was giving reads felt like buddying and I disagreed with her scum leans.

[Andrej]

Wow that got messed up.

[Andrej]

 

Sili can we get a reads list from you

Ya sure.

 

Town wombat

Null to town dice notbob

Null thane sooh

Null to scum aj darthe

Try harder not to try hard.

 

I really can't imagine you playing this lackadaisical as a villager. If you are I'm disappointed in you

[Andrej]

Care to explain why you guys don't like my case? Looks pretty suggestive to me.

I get where you're coming from and I think you put a fair amount of thought into it but I don't think things he's said, as contradictory as them may seem, make him a wolf. You acknowledged yourself that he says/does scummy and weird things and they don't always mean he's scum.

 

If you think Thane hasn't done anything for the game where are you regarding Sili? Give me your opinion on him.

[seph]

I agree, I actually said wtf when i read that list. It's 46 pages and you have 1 villager?

 

Sili is here, but won't even try.

 

[v]sili [/v]

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

Sili can we get a reads list from you

Ya sure.

 

Town wombat

Null to town dice notbob

Null thane sooh

Null to scum aj darthe

Try harder not to try hard.

 

I really can't imagine you playing this lackadaisical as a villager. If you are I'm disappointed in you

 

 

Sorry if I disappoint you, but I'm in a bit of a slump. I thought that was obvious

[Andrej]

What's obvious is that you're mailing it in.

[Sili Quirrels]

I agree, I actually said wtf when i read that list. It's 46 pages and you have 1 villager?

 

I have a few days to solve the game. There are likely 3 wolves in 8 players, and not everyone can be a villager.

 

 

Besides, every time I tried to put an mq together something took me away so now I'm just doing it in the background.

[Sili Quirrels]

What's obvious is that you're mailing it in.

whut -_-

[Andrej]

also on a side note, I was thinking about the reporter thing earlier and when comparing it with the theme I think that's almost ALWAYS a scum role here. The whole premise of the game is the Old Gods warring with the newer powers and the media is considered a bad guy. The reporter thing comes across as a way to spew mod confirmed wifom.

[Darthe]

[v] sili [/v] pitiful reads list.  

[Andrej]

also on a side note, I was thinking about the reporter thing earlier and when comparing it with the theme I think that's almost ALWAYS a scum role here. The whole premise of the game is the Old Gods warring with the newer powers and the media is considered a bad guy. The reporter thing comes across as a way to spew mod confirmed wifom.

In other words the 3rd party thing is probably a false trail for town to chase. Just focus on the scummy players

[Darthe]

 

 

We didn't experience three kills.  It's possible that Snow didn't shoot last night.

 

I took it as snow killed hally. or are you claiming the kill?

 

 

Lol no

 

 

I'd most like to see seph or Sili on the coping block but think Sooh is a good candidate.

 

Thane I don't want to lynch, don't see a reason to and I think wombat analysis of him is decent but not enough to compare to the others

 

 

Like I said yesterday, Not Bob takes that stance on Dae as either alignment imo.

 

Ftr I pushed Dae quite a bit before moving to Sili and eventually Hallia before I fell asleep that night.

 

I'm not sure the stuff Wombat points at makes Thane scum tbh.

 

Care to explain why you guys don't like my case?  Looks pretty suggestive to me.

 

Suggestive sure but you're comparing someone who looks kinda odd to the S group.  

 

 

Wombat why even say the first part if your going to add the second?

 

This looks like the type of post you were battering sooh for.

 

What do you mean?

 

 

 

 

What do you think is causing people to misclear Thane if he is a wolf

 

People are clearing Thane?  Why?  What has he done to make anyone think he is town?  I can understand not having a read on him yet, but what has he done that screams town?

 

Thane is bad as a wolf.  I liked his thoughts a few times though he had a post with two lists that was off.  I think mostly it's that others who looked better have made themselves look worse since so he appears to have trended up by proxy?  At least that's why he is higher on my list.  I'd also say that of the low content people his tone and posts have been the best.  

 

 

Don't start that lynch me because of who I am crap. I don't know where it came fromor why you started it but I'll absolutely go to war over it and you lose every time because it's not based in the game.

 

This is fake.  Why are you being fake?

 

It isn't fake it's by rote.  For the past ~10 games we have had together somewhere notbob will push to lynch me though I have no clue why.  He just randomly picks me out and pushes to lynch me because I'm Darthe.  I think it's gotten him killed all but one time and I don't think I've ever been lynched due to it.  

 

I just don't get it.  It's not upsetting so much as it is plain confusing but idk what else to do besides attack it.  At this point it's basically outside the game.

 

 

 

I don't really trust other peoples' tone reads unless it's fairly obvious stuff.  Also, by D2, people should be going on more than tone.  What has Thane done gameplay-wise that is good?

 

Earlier this game you basically FoSed NotBob for not coming at you with the lynch Darthe stuff and then when he makes a throwaway comment about doing so, you flip out?  I don't get that.

 

I clearly think it odd for him to not do it until someone else starts.  This wasn't a policy thing it was held back until someone else had interest.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Sili is active regardless of alignment.  I've seen him high content as both alignments.

 

 

-_-

 

How do you know that?

 

Though, yes, I like to think my scum game is improving steadily.

 

I think Aj asked me if posting less was to my scum meta earlier.

 

My opinion is it doesn't mean anything.

 

 

You claimed BP PR, not BP and something else. You tried to be too clever with your wording  for someone who is skimming the thread. -_-

 

 

THis is on DM. AJ knows I slank from time to time.

Such is the caliber of monster cass hydra...

 

Sorry I dropped out for a day. I was following up on some obligations.

 

 

 

 

Were town.

 

Let's just be clear on that. Okay?

 

 

You tunnel when you're a wolf, like you're doing now.

[Sili Quirrels]

Should I also pull up some pog and tmf games to emphasize the point I'm making about me?

[Sili Quirrels]

[v] sili [/v] pitiful reads list.  

whut -_-

[Sili Quirrels]

 

also on a side note, I was thinking about the reporter thing earlier and when comparing it with the theme I think that's almost ALWAYS a scum role here. The whole premise of the game is the Old Gods warring with the newer powers and the media is considered a bad guy. The reporter thing comes across as a way to spew mod confirmed wifom.

In other words the 3rd party thing is probably a false trail for town to chase. Just focus on the scummy players

 

Isn't that what everyone does anyway?

[Andrej]

How is that singular post indicative that I tunnel?

 

But sure spend more time pulling quotes from other games to somehow prove you only slank as a villager instead of actually playing this one.

 

Also a notable difference here between this game and that one is even if you were absent at times you always came back with drive. You were still a top poster up to the point you were modkilled. You're nowhere near that this game.

[Andrej]

Isn't that what everyone does anyway?

Typically yes. That sort of info coming from the mod could likely skew some people's perspective though. Eventually people will start to hunt the supposed Indy player specifically.

[Sili Quirrels]

How is that singular post indicative that I tunnel?

 

But sure spend more time pulling quotes from other games to somehow prove you only slank as a villager instead of actually playing this one.

 

Also a notable difference here between this game and that one is even if you were absent at times you always came back with drive. You were still a top poster up to the point you were modkilled. You're nowhere near that this game.

 

I slank, drop out, or screw around based on my mood and energy level. That is the only point I'm making.

 

The bold isn't true. I got by, by skimming and acting tough.

 

That single post serves to highlight a trend. Do you disagree with the assertion you tunneled Yates last game?

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Isn't that what everyone does anyway?

Typically yes. That sort of info coming from the mod could likely skew some people's perspective though. Eventually people will start to hunt the supposed Indy player specifically.

 

On pog they always laugh at ppl who hunt for the hardest to hunt anti-town.

[Sili Quirrels]

hm.

[Sili Quirrels]

ya I can see the angle either way.

 

will note that aj tried to discuss an early day 1 lynch last time, to distract the town i think. i don't know if seph was on his team though.