A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Gabriel Kross]

Sili even on pog I can usually keep up with mashes

 

My new job makes it impossible to read this thread, making all my reads outdated and useless.

 

I can tell you from my gigantic reread that I found sili villagery and didn't like the way the yates wagon was handled but these are all things people know already.

 

There was one post by EP I didn't like but I'm far too tired to dig it up

 

I can't even respond to people's posts because I am at work for 10 hours out of every day

Noting this will be revisting this when next you decide to show up.

 

 

Oh mod with the mostest... is Sili voting or not?

So you unvoted Yates.

Then you checked to make sure the Yates wagon had three votes with Sili.

Mod confirmed Sili is voting Yates at 5:40.

And Day end was at 5:43.

.

.

.

Coincidence?

 

I really like this post this deserves some digging, and gives a whole new insight on the "mentor speak" coming into the game. Might have been a gambit devised to give Townie cred which backfired due to rule technicalities.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

That's not good logic.

What's with the manbat quote?

 

Oh, I accidentally pushed the multi-quote button.

 

My thoughts on his post is he sometimes worries to much about being the mislynch, and I wanted to know how Cass was doing.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

That's not good logic.

What's with the manbat quote?

 

Oh, I accidentally pushed the multi-quote button.

 

My thoughts on his post is he sometimes worries to much about being the mislynch, and I wanted to know how Cass was doing.

[Gabriel Kross]

 

 

I hope that when day comes around you're contributing more rather than playing around.

Where were you all day? I've given Hally enough sass for one night. And she deserved a good 25% of it if she's Town and none of it if she's scum.

 

I posted earlier today on my thoughts, go back and read.

 

 

Aren't you replaced? O.o

No. Alanna was replaced. Pay attention, please.

 

Thank.

 

Sili and Laine:

 

Oh mod with the mostest... is Sili voting or not?

So you unvoted Yates.

Then you checked to make sure the Yates wagon had three votes with Sili.

Mod confirmed Sili is voting Yates at 5:40.

And Day end was at 5:43.

.

.

.

Coincidence?

 

Thoughts?

 

I was just reading the ISO on Sooh and saw this and thought it odd. With day ending so early (like 7 hours early), I'm assuming it was done to get Yates1.0 lynched. But why unvote first?

 

@Hallia: I think we played in Merlin together last year, so we have played together before, apparently. But you're definitely thinking of Alanna Sr.

 

because it was clear that the votes were needed to get Yates killed. All day ending abilities like that normally require a majority to still be on the target you want to die at the moment you're ending the phase.

[Sili Quirrels]

wait, are you actually saying you claimed vig in your opening posts and you were expecting 1. everyone to know that, or 2. everyone to think that was what you meant by PR when you were also claiming BP!?

 

wtf.

[Hallia]

See?  All better now.  

[Gabriel Kross]

Also can anyone go back and pull up the end of day post to see who was second in line for lynch and quote it? I want to see who was in danger if Silli hadn't been voting Yates.

[Hallia]

I think I posted the last vote count before the lynch.

[Gabriel Kross]

I think I posted the last vote count before the lynch.

but I want it here and readily accessible I don't want to dig through the last few pages of posts because I'm also playing Echo of Soul while reading.

[Hallia]

 

 

Official Vote Count Ten:

 

 

Pizza (1/13): Eldrick

Yates (3/13): AJ, Leelou, Sili

Eldrick (1/13): Pizza

Alot (1/13): Yates

Hally (1/13): Talya

Seph (2/13): Sooh, EP

 

Not Voting (15/24):

Alot, Alanna, John Snow, Thane, Krak, Taborline, Tress, Batassery, Laine, Tina, Seph, Dice, Zander, Verb, Hally

 

 

With 24 alive, it's 13 to lynch!  Deadline is 12:15 AM EST on Wednesday, the 13th.  

 

 

[alannalynn]

because it was clear that the votes were needed to get Yates killed. All day ending abilities like that normally require a majority to still be on the target you want to die at the moment you're ending the phase.

 

Obviously. I'm not stupid, no matter what you may think, EP. The point is that A. It was odd for Sooh to check the vote count to make sure Yates still had majority votes, and B. For her to unvote in the first place. Then day ended early.

 

If she had just unvoted, it would be less odd, but verifying the votes?

[Gabriel Kross]

 

because it was clear that the votes were needed to get Yates killed. All day ending abilities like that normally require a majority to still be on the target you want to die at the moment you're ending the phase.

 

Obviously. I'm not stupid, no matter what you may think, EP. The point is that A. It was odd for Sooh to check the vote count to make sure Yates still had majority votes, and B. For her to unvote in the first place. Then day ended early.

 

If she had just unvoted, it would be less odd, but verifying the votes?

 

oh wait I missread your question I was thinking you were asking why she didn't? I thought Sooh was still voting Yates.

 

However, it was Seph who was in danger along with Yates if Silli hadn't been voting Yates. Keep that in mind when you're sifting through all of this. (to everyone)

[Andrej]

However, it was Seph who was in danger along with Yates if Silli hadn't been voting Yates. Keep that in mind when you're sifting through all of this. (to everyone)

That's not a bad thought actually. Conversely, Yates.1 had claimed a PR by this point and I think any scum that had seen it would've jumped at the chance there.

[Andrej]

What really bugs me is that over half the roster isn't voting in the final tally.

 

Lots of question marks to be resolved there.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

However, it was Seph who was in danger along with Yates if Silli hadn't been voting Yates. Keep that in mind when you're sifting through all of this. (to everyone)

That's not a bad thought actually. Conversely, Yates.1 had claimed a PR by this point and I think any scum that had seen it would've jumped at the chance there.

 

Sorry, you lost me.

[Andrej]

What're you confused about?

[Sili Quirrels]

are you insinuating i'm scum because i 'jumped' on yates when i got back?

[Sooh]

Sooh,

 

what's your opinion of me?

 

I want an alignment, a role, and a reason from you.

 

And I want a very specific reason, and I'm telling you that in advance, because this isn't me asking you to town read me. This is me asking you to prove to me cory is town.

You want my opinion on you? And you want me to tell you your alignment AND role?

 

I have stated before that I believe you're town. You seem to be in town mode and trying to solve this game, and so far it's looking really good. I have no weird vibes about you.I have no clue what sort of role you would have, but you're putting yourself out there, so that makes me think you're a plain vanilla, but that's nothing but a guess on my part. 

 

Also what's this about proving that Cory is town? Cory isn't playing. He is mentoring me. He offers me his opinions and I try to see if I agree on them or not. We came off to a rocky start because some things were uncleared with the mods, but that's it. 

 

 

Oh mod with the mostest... is Sili voting or not?

So you unvoted Yates.

Then you checked to make sure the Yates wagon had three votes with Sili.

Mod confirmed Sili is voting Yates at 5:40.

And Day end was at 5:43.

.

.

.

Coincidence?

 

Yes, smart plan! I would check IN THREAD to see if you had the majority of votes before phase changing, instead of just doing the whole phase changing thing earlier when a lot more people were voting for you. This is ALL LOGICAL.... except it isn't.

If I was a wolf with a phase changer I would probably have A been paying much more attention to the votes and B asked my team in the QT or even the mods in the QT for confirmation. What I saw was a vote count that had Sili in two places and I wanted to draw the mods' attention to that. 

 

Like I said when asked about my unvote, I saw no reason to lynch a claimed PR. 

[Sooh]

 

However, it was Seph who was in danger along with Yates if Silli hadn't been voting Yates. Keep that in mind when you're sifting through all of this. (to everyone)

 

Yes, Seph was in danger, and Hallia was getting heat in the thread for her quick vote on Yates. 

 

I still think Seph might be scum.

[Andrej]

No, not in the least. I actually wouldn't be surprised if the wagon is all villagers in the final tally.

 

EP is saying that we should consider other players who were on the block around the time Day was ended because scum could've done this to save their teammate. It's not a bad theory but I was adding that the fact Yates had claimed a PR by then and had the necessary votes to be in the lead that I think scum would've done that regardless just to kill him and be done.

[Sili Quirrels]

You want my opinion on you? And you want me to tell you your alignment AND role?

 

I have stated before that I believe you're town. You seem to be in town mode and trying to solve this game, and so far it's looking really good. I have no weird vibes about you.I have no clue what sort of role you would have, but you're putting yourself out there, so that makes me think you're a plain vanilla, but that's nothing but a guess on my part. 

 

Also what's this about proving that Cory is town? Cory isn't playing. He is mentoring me. He offers me his opinions and I try to see if I agree on them or not. We came off to a rocky start because some things were uncleared with the mods, but that's it.

 

Nevermind. Maybe it was a dumb idea.

 Thanks for responding.

[Andrej]

That was to Sili.

 

Sooh ninja'd me

[Sooh]

No, not in the least. I actually wouldn't be surprised if the wagon is all villagers in the final tally.

 

EP is saying that we should consider other players who were on the block around the time Day was ended because scum could've done this to save their teammate. It's not a bad theory but I was adding that the fact Yates had claimed a PR by then and had the necessary votes to be in the lead that I think scum would've done that regardless just to kill him and be done.

Yes, this is also a good point. 

 

Btw Verb? You said you had changed your mind and wanted Seph to be the lynch. Why didn't you vote him?

[seph]

 

 

because it was clear that the votes were needed to get Yates killed. All day ending abilities like that normally require a majority to still be on the target you want to die at the moment you're ending the phase.

 

Obviously. I'm not stupid, no matter what you may think, EP. The point is that A. It was odd for Sooh to check the vote count to make sure Yates still had majority votes, and B. For her to unvote in the first place. Then day ended early.

If she had just unvoted, it would be less odd, but verifying the votes?

oh wait I missread your question I was thinking you were asking why she didn't? I thought Sooh was still voting Yates.

 

However, it was Seph who was in danger along with Yates if Silli hadn't been voting Yates. Keep that in mind when you're sifting through all of this. (to everyone)

How is 2 and 3 votes in danger when 3/4 of the game was not voting.

Ep weren't you one of the first to follow aj and help run up the train, then unvote once it got going?

[seph]

 

However, it was Seph who was in danger along with Yates if Silli hadn't been voting Yates. Keep that in mind when you're sifting through all of this. (to everyone)

 

Yes, Seph was in danger, and Hallia was getting heat in the thread for her quick vote on Yates. 

 

I still think Seph might be scum.

Why do you think I am scum?