Escape From The Carnival Of Horrors! Game Thread [Mafia Win]

[Leelou]

@Mods - will we be getting a deadline?  or at least have a RL day between when you issue a deadline and when the deadline is?

 

 

 

It is now Day 3!

 

With 9 alive, it's 5 for majority!

 

Deadline is 9:00 PM E/ST on 2/25.

 

[Red2111]

ah thanks Leelou!!   all i kept seeing was the [insert deadline clock here] thingy

[Thane Vakarian]

@Red: honestly, you're tunneling on a townie? what will you do wheni flip town? who'll be next?

[Verbal32]

@Red: honestly, you're tunneling on a townie? what will you do wheni flip town? who'll be next?

 

Now you're just echoing Leelou.

[Leelou]

@Red: honestly, you're tunneling on a townie? what will you do wheni flip town? who'll be next?

Get your own material.

[Thane Vakarian]

don't care, i want to know what she'll do next.

[Leelou]

Meant willing to vote Thane.

Kaylee still just going with the flow.

[Verbal32]

i think it's a solid reason.

 

possibility 1) She's town and thinks i'm wolf : she'll be lynched next because nobody will buy she's town when i flip town

possibility 2) She's a wolf and wants to kill a townie. Would be suicide; and i don't think Leelou is suicidal as wolf

 

possibility 3) you're both "wolves"

[Kaylee]

 

Meant willing to vote Thane.

Kaylee still just going with the flow.

No I've had him as possible scum.

[Thane Vakarian]

Verb, i know i'm not, that's why i didn't include that one

[Andrej]

Kaylee is scummy in a faux way. I would still lynch Leelou before her if Thane is the direction we go in today.

 

At this point it seems he's throwing in the towel though, so I'll probably swap as the DL approaches if people are too scared to string up Leelou.

 

I'd like to hear from Tina on the matter.

[Leelou]

 

 

Meant willing to vote Thane.

Kaylee still just going with the flow.

No I've had him as possible scum.

Do you have complete conviction on someone that you can follow through on and not follow the flow of the game?

[Leelou]

When I get back to my computer after lunch, I'm pulling up all of your votes.

[Verbal32]

 

 

Meant willing to vote Thane.

Kaylee still just going with the flow.

No I've had him as possible scum.

 

 

How?  Your first few lists had him as "I need to look into him", and you didn't waver on that until people started pushing on him a little.  Then he went into the "null to scum" pile for you, and that's basically the last I can see about him from you.

 

Can you see how this looks weird?  You're not offering a single case on your own, even though you've been active in the thread.  That tells me you're afraid to stick your neck out.

[Niniel]

I´m here. I have only skimmed the thread - will get back when my daughter has gone to bed. I´m not lurking. I´ve started working again so there is much to do. 

 

Can someone help me with a question: when did Nolder vote Hallia? Was it before or after AJ´s reveal? 

[Thane Vakarian]

i'm still convinced Hallia is the way to go today, but, seeing nobody believes i'm town, it's hard to convince any of you to vote her. That's the feeling i have for the moment.

[Verbal32]

Kaylee is scummy in a faux way. I would still lynch Leelou before her if Thane is the direction we go in today.

 

At this point it seems he's throwing in the towel though, so I'll probably swap as the DL approaches if people are too scared to string up Leelou.

 

I'd like to hear from Tina on the matter.

 

I disagree with this - she's scummy, period.  Leelou has been as well (at times), and so has Thane (all the time).

 

Agree on Tina, though.  She dropped off the radar - hope she's ok.

[Verbal32]

^ nvm that, lol

[Thane Vakarian]

i got home 4.5 hours ago, but i've been busy with so many things, i'm still in work clothing. RL has me annoyed, and mafia has me frustrated..... i think i need some more beer today

[Verbal32]

i'm still convinced Hallia is the way to go today, but, seeing nobody believes i'm town, it's hard to convince any of you to vote her. That's the feeling i have for the moment.

 

Explain why Hallia is scum to me.  Explain like I have just subbed into this game.

[Verbal32]

I´m here. I have only skimmed the thread - will get back when my daughter has gone to bed. I´m not lurking. I´ve started working again so there is much to do. 

 

Can someone help me with a question: when did Nolder vote Hallia? Was it before or after AJ´s reveal? 

 

I don't know if he put a vote on her D1 or not, but D1 ended with him on Sili.  He did vote Hallia D2, and was lynched that day after AJ's reveal with his vote on Hallia.

[Andrej]

 

 

I´m here. I have only skimmed the thread - will get back when my daughter has gone to bed. I´m not lurking. I´ve started working again so there is much to do.

 

Can someone help me with a question: when did Nolder vote Hallia? Was it before or after AJ´s reveal?

I don't know if he put a vote on her D1 or not, but D1 ended with him on Sili. He did vote Hallia D2, and was lynched that day after AJ's reveal with his vote on Hallia.

I made a post about this early. Let me try to find it since no one really responded but SQ at the time

[Red2111]

@ Tina - i cant recall when Nol placed the vote on Hallia, i'd have to go back and look

 

 

@Red: honestly, you're tunneling on a townie? what will you do wheni flip town? who'll be next?

 

1st - i doubt you'll flip town, i've doubted it since D1.

 

2nd - if you read my posts then you know full well whose in my scum salad and who'll i'll be going at next

 

3rd - this feels like you've seen people jump off Leelous train after she asked that, so you went "hmmm wonder if it'll work for me"   the bad thing is with that, you've got too many independently scummy things against you for that ploy to work.  hence why

 

Thane > Leelou when it comes to Red's preferred lynch today

 

 

i'm still convinced Hallia is the way to go today, but, seeing nobody believes i'm town, it's hard to convince any of you to vote her. That's the feeling i have for the moment.

 

its not that we dont believe your town, its that you have yet to make a compelling enough case as to why we should vote Hallia after what Nol (a confirmed scum) did.

 

 

 

i'm still convinced Hallia is the way to go today, but, seeing nobody believes i'm town, it's hard to convince any of you to vote her. That's the feeling i have for the moment.

 

Explain why Hallia is scum to me.  Explain like I have just subbed into this game.

 

 

see, this is another thing thats not setting well with me on Thane.  he's not readily offering up info on why he has those reads; he has to have it dragged out of him.  like with his reads list on D1 and me asking him repeatedly about why he had those people as scum.

[Andrej]

Nolder voted Thane early on in D1 then moved to Sili for EOD. D2 he only voted Hallia.

 

Leelou voted Red and Kaylee I believe thru EOD and then only Hallia D2.

 

Thane was only on Red D1 and no one on D2.

[Thane Vakarian]

Hi Verbal, welcome to the game.

 

Now, with everything going on, what i'll try to tell you might sound odd, but i'm convinced i'm right. I hope you will be too.

 

This entire post here just reeks of wolf. Would she have hammered instead of vote me, then she'd be top suspect. Now, if Leelou still would be voted,she could have stated that she 'knew Leelou was town' and hope to stay off people's radar for some time to come. Ofcourse she knows Leelou is town, she's wolf. Her entire vote on me is to gain towncred.

 

Now, perhaps she thought that someone would hammer Leelou and get away with it. She is, still, one of the top suspects in the game. Unfortunately, that didn't happen, so here's the dilemma: two townies with trains on them, so it was difficult to choose who to go for. 

 

Throughout the gamephases that i haveread today, i never really was convinced that Hallia was town. Just doesn't feel like it... gut says, Leelou town, Hallia wolf.

 

So, Verbal, feel free to read the rest ofthe game, but you have my opinion on her