[Basic/Standard] A Wind in the Door Mafia - GAME OVER, TOWN WINS

[monstrman]

I kind of think hallia/yates is a wolf. Like confidence level increased from > rand to >> rand

[monstrman]

I figure this should already be obvious from my vote, but I think i like where my vote is.

[monstrman]

Cory

hoya

err

tommy

 

Dicearmi

Tina

Sili

 

Lenlo

jmm

 

Pral

yates

[monstrman]

That probably took longer than it should have and I still don't think I'm 100% confident in it but that's q here I'm at for the time being.

[Yates]

Great. Now just go ahead and state why and go about convincing others of the need to dispatch of us. Just make sure we get a chance to claim before ACTUALLY dispensing of the Hally/Yates menace...

 

With Tom I'm just assuming it's because he doesn't like the fact I know his claim is BS.

 

With you boybat? Not so sure.

[Yates]

Wait. Also, why Pral?

[monstrman]

Hallia, if you had to change people around on my list, who would you move where and why?

 

Or do you like where it is.

 

You can't move yourself.

[monstrman]

Yates same question

[monstrman]

I don't remember pral.

 

I don't remember anything he's said.

 

Those with less impact go down the PoE

[monstrman]

I've got slight tone reads on jmm and lenlo that keep them just a hair closer.

 

But at the bottom of my list it's mostly just a jumbled mess of everyone being scummy in my eyes and it's hard to sort out

[Yates]

I don't remember pral.

 

I don't remember anything he's said.

 

Those with less impact go down the PoE

So? Weren't you just in a game with me and pral where he was a BG and posted just as much?

[Yates]

Sorry. He was a 1-shot RB, not BG.

[monstrman]

I don't understand why you picked pral spefically out of my list and press that I shouldn't have him there or something but both you seemingly for no reason calling me "boybat" which is at a lackluster insult at best and questioning him specifically with no other comment about everyone else I have doesn't feel like a good look to me.

[monstrman]

Like I feel like you're making this adversarial when it almost doesn't have a reason to be.

 

And it doesn't look good for you.

[monstrman]

You could fix this by... maybe not being adversarial.

 

And ansanswering my question.

[dicetosser1]

 

jmm had two things that pulled me different ways

 

A) his scum list was somewhat consensus-y of players that aren't really being townread (Sili/Sleeper where the first two IIRC) but I think he had two others that were sort of random so not sure what I'm seeing there - would love elaboration!

 

B) he said something like "scum try to act super townie to start the game!" which is the sort of ideology i try to fight since it really isn't applicably true here from experience, but he said that YET said very little about me and monstr - players who are generally absurdly villagery villagers and like rambling about how town they are. so i don't really see the logical connection if that's his mindset reading the thread.

I did not like Tina or Halli's first posts (page 1 and 2 respectively).  Nothing definite for now, but I am watching them.   

 

This could just be me never having played with them before. 

 

 

 

 

What exactly do you believe the very first post someone puts out can tell you??

 

 

 

Checking in to say I'm here... slanking unintentionally. Seems everytime I go to say something I'm distracted.

 

Yates, you're being aggressively town, so you get a carrot. Congratulations.

 

Dice, you shush. If you want my opinion of you to change you'll have to prove my opinion wrong. Simple as that.

 

Jmm, you're anti-town. Wanna make that clear.

 

Whoever it is that pointed out I treated the wagon on me like a joke... well it sort of was last time in the marlfox game.

 

Sleepah, I don't like you saying you're obviously town. I don't know your meta yet. And I'm going to have to guess it.

 

Tom could be lying I guess. Or I wouldn't be surprised if he were. Hopefully night actions can resolve his slot.

 

 

 

 

 

Ironic is ironic lmao

 

 

marker page 42

[Yates]

Cory

hoya

err

tommy

 

Dicearmi

Tina

Sili

 

Lenlo

jmm

 

Pral

yates

LOL - pretty much the only agreement we have is hoya.

 

I mean - Tommy? Dude just claimed survivor after claiming scum and what else? Day vig? 0 rationale to have him any higher than null. That's a gross read. That you have him above Dicearmi is kind of insulting to those two, tbh. I'm not going to touch your Cory-crush but even YOU have to admit he went full retard in his argument about why he found this slot scummy... Maybe full retard is part and parcel to a Cory Town read for you? No idea. I've given up on your tone read nonsense after fighting you tooth and nail to lynch confscum only to have you cock blocking the whole thing because of crap reasons.

 

Also, what has Err done to earn a Town read? I think I missed it or forgot.

 

-Lock Town-

Yates/Hally

Dicearmi

 

-Solid Green-

hoya

Sili

Tina

 

-The muddled middle-

err

Pral

Lenlo

Manbat

[really - these are any order]

 

-Just give me a reason-

Cory

jmm

 

-Scumzors-

tommy

 

 

Basically, I'm unwilling to entertain a lynch on anyone from Tina up.

[Cory Caboose]

probably the worst reads list of all time

[Cory Caboose]

yates when i said in dr. who i volunteed to mentor you i think you should have taken it up

 

for someone who said "LOL WOLVES SHOULD BE SKURRED" or whatever when have you ever been right about anything as a villager?

 

you should sheep people who know what they are doing

[Yates]

I don't understand why you picked pral spefically out of my list

You don't understand why I asked you about the OTHER person you had as a scum read that wasn't us?

 

press that I shouldn't have him there or something but both you seemingly for no reason calling me "boybat" which is at a lackluster insult at best and questioning him specifically with no other comment about everyone else I have doesn't feel like a good look to me.

Fair enough. This cold medicine still has me awake when I should have been asleep hours ago. It's for the birds. And I'm starting to see this #ALLIANCE stuff rearing it's ugly head again and it's giving me heartburn because you were already on the losing end of this stuff and an active contributor to it. So I'm going to blame cold meds and frustration with you. I guess I just wanted to see an explanation go with that post since there were pages of arguments laid out and your laziness felt kind of insulting.

[Cory Caboose]

there is no #alliance

 

stop saying that word

 

it doesn't exist

 

you just don't know how to read people

[Cory Caboose]

i'm basically 20% conscious because benadryl and just checked in to see if nayone said anything and it was already doubly obvious

 

but i mean come on

 

what are you even reading

[Yates]

have you ever been right about anything as a villager?

Fair question.

 

Let me think about it.

 

[v]HalCore[/v]

 

Huzzah!

11. Cory & Hallia, Mafia Psychoenabler

Yup. I was right about one thing once.

[csarmi]

Guys Dice will have to take over for today i caught a cold and busy at work. I shall come back with a vengeance but now i am half the pages behind :-)

[Niniel]

Take care, Csarmi. That goes for Mish too. 

 

 

I don´t know what to think about the Cory - Yates argument. I understand what Yates say about Cory not reading Hally as he usually do. But I was also wondering if Hally didn´t want to post without waiting for Yates. (To be fair, I think it´s hard to play as a hydra. When I have, I have felt that I didn´t dared to post as much until talking to my hydra buddy.) Bringing up old games doesn´t help me at all. 

 

I´m interested to hear why people want to keep Tommy alive. Cory put him in a lol category that means what? Most of you think it´s towny to claim scum or third party?