[BASIC] Discworld Mafia - MAFIA win

[Krakalakachkn]

Damn that was probably the perfect choice for NK.

[Yates]

Damn that was probably the perfect choice for NK.

What?

[Krakalakachkn]

 

Damn that was probably the perfect choice for NK.

What?

What?

[Yates]

Why did you say Barm is the perfect choice for NK? I don't disagree but it seemed odd to comment on.

[Krakalakachkn]

 

@Krak - give me your 2 best for scum, then.  You have been hinting that you now think I'm town.....so I'm not expecting to be on your lynch list anymore.  So then, who is on it?

 

(let's assume Tina flips town, which I think is likely especially given her good luck post)

You/Yates atm. I'm starting rethink Barm.

 

Because I was hoping they would choose someone else.

[Yates]

Dice and Barm were probably the two darkest blues. So it makes sense just from that perspective. Neither of them were/are ever getting mislynched.

[Yates]

I don't know that you have to read much deeper that that.

[Krakalakachkn]

I should have made a half-assed attempt at "casing him."

[Yates]

I should have made a half-assed attempt at "casing him."

Oh. I see what you are saying now.

[Krakalakachkn]

Dice and Barm were probably the two darkest blues. So it makes sense just from that perspective. Neither of them were/are ever getting mislynched.

That's pretty much what I'm saying.

[Verbal32]

 

You keep avoiding answering my question.

 

You implied you have solid town on Mish, Yates, and Dice.  Don't give me the crap about "if I was scum" - that is not how you're phrasing those posts, so that excuse is out the window.

 

You started with the hint that you'd push for Yates, and now you're opening up Mish to that.  As I said before, you are willing to lynch ANYBODY that isn't you.

 

 

What's your question?

 

 

LOL

 

That's probably 4 times you've dodged my question, but ok.  I'm not repeating it.

[Verbal32]

 

I should have made a half-assed attempt at "casing him."

Oh. I see what you are saying now.

 

 

So, do you think Krak is being as transparent scum as I do?

 

My guess is no.

[Yates]

No.

[Verbal32]

So what are you thinking then for today?

[Krakalakachkn]

 

 

You keep avoiding answering my question.

 

You implied you have solid town on Mish, Yates, and Dice.  Don't give me the crap about "if I was scum" - that is not how you're phrasing those posts, so that excuse is out the window.

 

You started with the hint that you'd push for Yates, and now you're opening up Mish to that.  As I said before, you are willing to lynch ANYBODY that isn't you.

 

What's your question?

 

LOL

 

That's probably 4 times you've dodged my question, but ok.  I'm not repeating it.

 

Are you still talking about the Yates thing I said?

[Verbal32]

What?

[Krakalakachkn]

Lol really?

[Krakalakachkn]

 

 

@Verb

Yeah, if I were scum then that would mean Yates is town...

@Yates

I'm still wary of a ruse, but I don't see Verb going so hard after this plan as scum.

 

 

No no no, you aren't sneaking away from that one.  You said you would kill Mish, Yates, or Dice.....and not Nolder.  But now you're asking me why I have Yates blue, with the obvious implication that you do not.

 

So then how can you tie that back to your implicit statement that Mish, Yates, and Dice are the townies you'd gun for as scum?

Is this the question I've been dodging?

[Verbal32]

What?

[dicetosser1]

im thinking that was a numbers game kill. mafia absolutely dont want me AND barm alive come lylo. they cant win that way.

 

so peoples thoughts on verbs proposed plan. Should we do it? Should we do it in that order?

[Krakalakachkn]

I don't think we should.  I'm not scum and I'm not trying to get to LyLo knowing that town!Verb is dead and town!Krak is about to be lynched for the loss.  And the problem with Vice-Versa is Verb might be town too.

 

 

We have plenty of time to think about this, although this:

 

 

 

 

 

You keep avoiding answering my question.
 
You implied you have solid town on Mish, Yates, and Dice.  Don't give me the crap about "if I was scum" - that is not how you're phrasing those posts, so that excuse is out the window.
 
You started with the hint that you'd push for Yates, and now you're opening up Mish to that.  As I said before, you are willing to lynch ANYBODY that isn't you.

What's your question?

 
LOL
 
That's probably 4 times you've dodged my question, but ok.  I'm not repeating it.

Are you still talking about the Yates thing I said?

 

 

 

What?

 

 

 

 

@Verb
Yeah, if I were scum then that would mean Yates is town...
@Yates
I'm still wary of a ruse, but I don't see Verb going so hard after this plan as scum.

 
No no no, you aren't sneaking away from that one.  You said you would kill Mish, Yates, or Dice.....and not Nolder.  But now you're asking me why I have Yates blue, with the obvious implication that you do not.
 
So then how can you tie that back to your implicit statement that Mish, Yates, and Dice are the townies you'd gun for as scum?

Is this the question I've been dodging?

 

 

 

What?

 

 

 

is literally the opposite of how town should be acting right now.  I don't care how convinced you are that I'm scum, Verb, if that is the question you're referring to then I'm not going to apologize for asking you to repeat yourself because I'VE ALREADY ANSWERED IT.

 

 

HOW MUCH CLEARER CAN I BE, THERE'S ALWAYS MONEY IN THE BANANA STAND! IF I WERE SCUM THEN YATES WOULD HAVE TO BE TOWN AND THEREFORE IT LOGICALLY MAKES SENSE IN IN THIS THEORETICAL SCENARIO YOU CONSTRUCTED THAT YATES WOULD BE ON MY TOP THREE HIT LIST.  YOU'RE MAKING ME GO #FULLTOM AND I HATE YOUI love youFOR IT!!!  I DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW YOU DON'T UNDERSTAND THIS BECAUSE LOOK:

 

 

 

 

I don't know that I'd agree with Yates being a blue.


What's your reasoning on him again?

Hmmm.....

 

 

 

 

Actually, I take that back.  If I'm right and Krak is scum, killing Nolder is PERFECT to provide cover for why it wouldn't be him.
 
His easy defense is that he'd kill a blue....so going for some reverse psychology here.  Won't work.
 
[v]Krak[/v]

Lol no

I could have gone for anyone else. Killing Dice, for example, would be a way better play for scum!Krak.

If you're scum then this would be the perfect gambit to pull and then pull this wifom on me .

I like how you ask the question and then answer it.

See how this works?

 

 
Yes, which is why I said it was reverse psychology to kill Nolder....the next guy on your list to lynch.  It makes you look better.
 
ScumKrak's best kill thinking only logic and no evolving strategy:  Dice
 
ScumKrak's best kill including the evolving strategy of Verbal going hard at him and Yates defending him:  Nolder
 
 
^ the best move for you was to kill Nolder.  I would have relaxed on you if it was Dice, actually.

 

I would have killed either Mish or Yates or Dice, I would not have killed Nolder as scum.  Nolder doesn't even make sense to me.  Can you explain this any more because I obviously cannot make an argument against your points here…which I think you're very well aware of.

 
Seems that you (as of yesterday) think Yates is town, as you included him on the list of people you would kill if scum.  To me, that sure sounds like you calling him town. 

 

 

How can you say that I had a town read on Yates when I called him town during a hypothetical situation where I am scum and he couldn't possibly be because, spoilers, THERE'S ONLY ONE SCUM LEFT!

 

 

So, laid out plain as day, I said that if I were scum (therefore Yates couldn't be) Dice, Yates, or Mish would have been my kills instead of Nolder.

 

Gah, I feel like I'm taking stupid pills.

 

 

 

 

Apparently, Jeffrey Tambor, apparently.

[Krakalakachkn]

[color:red]Vote Verb[/color]

 

 

Verb's misreps, blind pushes, and general lack of town play is getting out of hand.  I'm over giving him the benefit of the doubt.  He's been the scummiest player the past couple days and I'm saying **** all, I'm lynching this ewok.

[Yates]

I'm going to do some hard core rereading tomorrow if possible. This other 30 pages per 24 hours game is a bear to keep up with.

[WolfbrotherKronos]

My gut still says Krak or Verb.

[michellem]

I'm sorry for going AWOL; RL has kicked my butt hard the last few days and I'm utterly exhausted.

 

As Kronos said, we're thinking Krak or Verb.

 

Yates, I'm gonna put my trust in you now, since you're the most active person around that I have the strongest townie read on. I wish I could say I could help out with a reread, but my brain is mush and I know I won't be able. I know it's unfair and I'm sorry.