[Basic]TRON Mafia Game-Day 4

[Xthrax]

 

I'm glad people liked it and thought it was a challenge to figure out. The activity you guys showed was awesome. I hope you all will play again if I mod.

ABSOLUTELY!!!

 

Thanks

 

The next one is going to be Tron:Legacy!

[Nynaeve]

GG US

 

Great game Xthrax. Thanks :D

[Xthrax]

God dang it, got Clov down, wrong about Tommy. Lol Mynd, definitely thought you were trolling near the end.

 

Good game X!

Thanks Rand

[Xthrax]

GG US

 

Great game Xthrax. Thanks :D

Thanks Nyn

[Myndrunner]

 

Ok so splain the hammering of DT please?

 

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Quickhammer

 

Yes, sometimes good players do obvious scum things simply because they can say "lol, why would we do that? it's such an obvious scum move"

 

 

yup

 

my gut was saying Tommy/Cov but logic was saying UNPOSSIBLE!

[Nynaeve]

DT please

[RandA lThor]

Btw that was balanced, our fault for not finding the mafia correctly this last day.  Or should I say Darthe's...    lol jk.

[RandA lThor]

I thank everyone who played and made my game a success. 

 

 

To Darthe and anyone else who thinks my game was unbalanced, you are welcome to your opinion.

 

I chose the set-up because I have played with it before-was my first game as Mafia.

 

But Primarily because, since it was my first game I asked Verb to look over it and he had okay'ed it. 

 

Once again, Thank you for playing.

 

Deadthread-http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/hE8cBEAB7Jd

 

If Mafia agree, I can release their QT.

[Xthrax]

DT please

Nyn, it's in my second post 

[Xthrax]

Mafia-you guys agree to release the qt?

[Nynaeve]

OK ty

[Tommyrod]

Let it loose

[Cory Caboose]

Btw that was balanced, our fault for not finding the mafia correctly this last day.  Or should I say Darthe's...    lol jk.

 

For more on Darthe, read the DT

 

[Nynaeve]

Mafia-you guys agree to release the qt?

 

Niet  *evil grin*

[Xthrax]

Mafia qt-http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/h74ZDgFbR2pR

[Nynaeve]

LOL

[Myndrunner]

Wow, you DID fall for my fake Doc claim and foolishly killed the actual Doc instead......wait........dang.

[Darthe]

Two things.  

 

1) Damn, I really should have went with what I was thinking initially.  I got myself messed up bad in that final day and totally threw this game for town.

2) X, you took it really personally in the DT when I spoke about your game balance.  I apologize for that.  Ultimately yes, there is some skew towards the scum team since the traditional (often considered "perfect") mafia game is 3 goons, 1 cop, 1 doc, 7 vt.  You adding a scum PR to that mix who could permanently and immediately end the ability for town to gain any night information affects the game in wolves favor because you didn't give town a third PR.  A godfather has been more traditionally given to scum teams because it is passive where this had the ability to make a direct affect in the game.  That said I think this was an excellent first game and hope to see you continue moderating.  I don't remotely blame the loss on anything other than myself (since I was essentially making the choices for the team) and if you would like to discuss some of the finer points of game development etc I would be happy to do that.  

[Myndrunner]

The mafia QT is as enlightening as it is frustrating.  Also very entertaining, you ratscums!

[Darthe]

I ain't even mad about Clov =p

[Myndrunner]

Well played. 

 

[Xthrax]

Two things.  

 

1) Damn, I really should have went with what I was thinking initially.  I got myself messed up bad in that final day and totally threw this game for town.

2) X, you took it really personally in the DT when I spoke about your game balance.  I apologize for that.  Ultimately yes, there is some skew towards the scum team since the traditional (often considered "perfect") mafia game is 3 goons, 1 cop, 1 doc, 7 vt.  You adding a scum PR to that mix who could permanently and immediately end the ability for town to gain any night information affects the game in wolves favor because you didn't give town a third PR.  A godfather has been more traditionally given to scum teams because it is passive where this had the ability to make a direct affect in the game.  That said I think this was an excellent first game and hope to see you continue moderating.  I don't remotely blame the loss on anything other than myself (since I was essentially making the choices for the team) and if you would like to discuss some of the finer points of game development etc I would be happy to do that.  

Not very personally, Darthe.

 

Just that since it's my first game, I was hoping that everyone liked it. But I'm glad since that is the end result. 

[Nynaeve]

Wow, you DID fall for my fake Doc claim and foolishly killed the actual Doc instead......wait........dang.

 

*laughs*

[Nynaeve]

The mafia QT is as enlightening as it is frustrating.  Also very entertaining, you ratscums!

 

For your viewing pleasure :P

[Darthe]

I did very much like it =) It made for a suspenseful game.  I suppose more than anything I am dejected that I had a perfect game as cop (technically I viewed Mynd D3 but I tried to switch it to Tommy that night and viewed Tommy N4) and it got messed up by a role that by most standards shouldn't have been there.  My feelings about it aren't your job man, you just make and run the games.  If it doesn't meet to my anticipations well, it wasn't an open setup anyhow.