Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Turin Turambar]

Says you. All I hear right now is wolftroll.

[TheRagnarok]

Csarmi, what townie thing have you done?  You say you are obvious townie and yet I haven't seen anything townie.  Sketchy claim, no cases just calling people scum, self-voting, and FOSing everyone who disagrees with you.

 

Which of that of townie behavior?

[csarmi]

Let's look at the player list shall we.

 

DiceX. Probably town. Good instincts, good endgame analysis. Low clout anyway. Just not likely to carry the game or topic.

 

Len: comes and goes. Phones in some reads. Arrives if mentioned in negative light for some damage control. Busy voting townies from what I see. Scum. Won't carry topic either.

[Turin Turambar]

Further evidence that rags is obv town.

 

See the difference?

[csarmi]

Tina: no play whatsoever. Looks scum from last day (not gonna take Thane into acct in these) appearance. Won't carry topic either but since she's prolly scum anyway... Not likely to reread either right? Or put work in if town.

 

Turin: looks town for now but completely misguided. Worse, he has no time now. Keeps posting anyway and controls conversation but on useless topic.

[csarmi]

Despo: now him not being town (and by day three he sure isn't) hurts cause if town he might just change track.

 

Hally: pretty sure she's town and seem to be making the good decisions too. But not one to advertise now is she... Won't have time to add some serious topic stuff.

[csarmi]

Krak: now he seems to be town and I have some serious hopes he'll come and help lynch the scum. Seems to be list tho... And I didn't like his catch up overall. Don't see enough wim.

 

Rags: I'd be glad if he were town cause that'd help a lot but he just don't act like one. Keeps misrepping my actions for instance and absolutely not interested in solving the game

[csarmi]

Tsuki: he seems town though I keep second guessing myself cause how could he be so wrong and tunnel sighted. Has wim it seems and voice. Might put work too. Come and play man.

 

BFG: I think she's vanilla town and she's trying but low time. Please come add stuff and help move these guys. Too nsby vocal mafias and too few town voice and what we has spouts nonsense. Please come and help.

 

Csarmi: lock town.

 

Pray: great player looks good and good reads. But not the active kind. Come we need your help.

[Tsukibana]

Hallia, I meant your play, not you. You know I love you. We're like BFF and such, right?

 

See, don't we look great together? (admit it, I ROCK the Rinoa Cosplay...)

[csarmi]

Csarmi, what townie thing have you done? You say you are obvious townie and yet I haven't seen anything townie. Sketchy claim, no cases just calling people scum, self-voting, and FOSing everyone who disagrees with you.

 

Which of that of townie behavior?

Perfect claim with the right timing. Also claim that can only be town and wasn't CC'd. You simply lie.

 

I have been honest, transparent and acted pro town the whole game. Trying to read people you know. Be my guest anD try to be casing from phone... Not that casing is my style.

 

Fosing people who disagree is simply a lie.

 

Self voting. Yea I voted to consolidate at deadline looming. You seriously can't be that thick so yes I'm questioning your agenda... I have been clear on who I'd like to lynch most (Despo). Consolidated on Tina (who I think scum) and voted. Then I stayed up until almost three a.m. to be able to consolidate on the lynch and helped avoiding possible random when about to logout. You're trying to misrep this is just do horribly wrong I don't even know what to say really. Do you believe people don't read the exchanges of the last 24 hours or what? If I was scum all I needed to do is vote my best "read" and log out.

[csarmi]

I understand you're trying to make this misrep stick or force ME to point these out cause sure it don't sound so good from ME to point this out right?

 

Missing vocal townies... Read above.

[csarmi]

Says you. All I hear right now is wolftroll.

.... ...

[csarmi]

Further evidence that rags is obv town.

 

See the difference?

If you see that as a town post I have seriously no more to tell you.

[Lenlo]

 

Csarmi, what townie thing have you done? You say you are obvious townie and yet I haven't seen anything townie. Sketchy claim, no cases just calling people scum, self-voting, and FOSing everyone who disagrees with you.

 

Which of that of townie behavior?

Perfect claim with the right timing. Also claim that can only be town and wasn't CC'd. You simply lie.

 

Except you fail to understand that it is NOT a perfect claim and while it can be only town and wasnt CCed that doesnt mean you werent LIEING about it.

[Lenlo]

Seriously I dont understand whats with the stubborn/emo streak lately.

[Lenlo]

On DM in general, not you CS. Sorry that wasnt clear.

[TheRagnarok]

 

Csarmi, what townie thing have you done? You say you are obvious townie and yet I haven't seen anything townie. Sketchy claim, no cases just calling people scum, self-voting, and FOSing everyone who disagrees with you.

 

Which of that of townie behavior?

Perfect claim with the right timing. Also claim that can only be town and wasn't CC'd. You simply lie.

 

I have been honest, transparent and acted pro town the whole game. Trying to read people you know. Be my guest anD try to be casing from phone... Not that casing is my style.

 

Fosing people who disagree is simply a lie.

 

Self voting. Yea I voted to consolidate at deadline looming. You seriously can't be that thick so yes I'm questioning your agenda... I have been clear on who I'd like to lynch most (Despo). Consolidated on Tina (who I think scum) and voted. Then I stayed up until almost three a.m. to be able to consolidate on the lynch and helped avoiding possible random when about to logout. You're trying to misrep this is just do horribly wrong I don't even know what to say really. Do you believe people don't read the exchanges of the last 24 hours or what? If I was scum all I needed to do is vote my best "read" and log out.

 

There are a number of explanations for the claim.  Scum getting fake claims, you assuming based on scummates there wouldn't be a miller...so calling it a perfect claim is a hilarious misrepresentation.

 

Clear disagreement.

 

Clear disagreement again.  It certainly comes across that way.

 

I view all self-voting as emo/pouty which is anti-town.  Always have, always will.  You staying up late isn't indicative of anything.  You keep saying certain things like they are definitive proof of your towniness when they really aren't whatsoever.

[csarmi]

Len do you plan to comment on the game you know?

[Lenlo]

Len do you plan to comment on the game you know?

I dunno, will you cut the crap and chill out?

[csarmi]

Rags you did read the rules right?

 

No lynch agreed = random with no coroner.

 

How do you even think to have this fly?

[csarmi]

 

 

Len do you plan to comment on the game you know?

I dunno, will you cut the crap and chill out?

Me?!!!

[TheRagnarok]

Rags you did read the rules right?

 

No lynch agreed = random with no coroner.

 

How do you even think to have this fly?

Nope.  I assumed it was hammer or whoever has majority at deadline.

[csarmi]

 

 

Rags you did read the rules right?

 

No lynch agreed = random with no coroner.

 

How do you even think to have this fly?

Nope. I assumed it was hammer or whoever has majority at deadline.

It's usually (and no exception here) hammer before deadline or random no coroner (which is very anti town and also anti game).

 

That's why deadline rushes suck.

[TheRagnarok]

 

 

Rags you did read the rules right?

 

No lynch agreed = random with no coroner.

 

How do you even think to have this fly?

Nope. I assumed it was hammer or whoever has majority at deadline.

It's usually (and no exception here) hammer before deadline or random no coroner (which is very anti town and also anti game).

 

That's why deadline rushes suck.

 

Every game I can remember, it's hammer, whoever has majority at deadline, or if two players are tied then random between the two.  Also don't ever remember the no coroner thing being a part.

[csarmi]

Well the rules here are the DM std (I prefer other ways and mods are more open to other versions lately so maybe you been lucky).