Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Tsukibana]

@Turin - Hallia's activity level, oh YEAH. She is off the chart. Want me to pull the analysis of her activity level I did for the Real Genius game?? Summary: As town, she regularly posts less than 60 posts A GAME. When she is scum, her activity rises. There was ONE town exception, and 1 scum exception (but she replaced in that game, IIRC).

[csarmi]

Maybe just maybe I could buy Hally being governor there as third party if we're shooting wild theories lol.

[csarmi]

Tsuki I'm pretty sure you're wrong there. Ie if there is s correlation its a false one.

 

Also Hally became note outspoken lately. Making her mentors and ex-mentors proud.

[csarmi]

More.

[Hallia]

You gains and your wild theories. If you're going off on a long and looking at other games, look at how often I claim early with a PR. I'm town, not mafia and not third party

[Hallia]

<3 I owe it to you guys, you, and Leelou especially!

[Hallia]

Gains? Stupid autocorrect - guys

[Tsukibana]

Tsuki I'm pretty sure you're wrong there. Ie if there is s correlation its a false one.

 

Also Hally became note outspoken lately. Making her mentors and ex-mentors proud.

 

Perhaps - in that game I used the correlation to case her, and then she went and turned out to be GOAT Doc (again!!) despite the high level. I was simply pointing out facts: FACT - she is more (greater than 75% of the time) active as scum. Whether there is a link that is valid, remains to be seen.

[csarmi]

I'd totally pardon Thane there if I was a scum governor. You don't let a Symp go down there if you can help it.

 

That's even without Turin's wild pardon sump stuff.

 

She even got cue for it.

[Tsukibana]

You gains and your wild theories. If you're going off on a long and looking at other games, look at how often I claim early with a PR. I'm town, not mafia and not third party

 You usually claim AFTER the PR has been used to devastating effect. I would see Town!Hallia claiming Governor after saving a Cop or Doc or something, not claiming to stop a juvenile thunderdome.

[Tsukibana]

I'd totally pardon Thane there if I was a scum governor. You don't let a Symp go down there if you can help it.

 

That's even without Turin's wild pardon sump stuff.

 

She even got cue for it.

Unless you had already outed as governor for town, and knew the symp was as obvious as a barking cat. Save it for your GF or the Lurker that is the ace in the hole.

[Turin Turambar]

Turin I find Hally somewhat off and it works me a little that she keeps me-too'ing me.

 

But my gut says she's town.

 

Aren't you biased from your Mynd/Hally gambit idea? You know they been in no communication.

Make up your mind here Csarmi...

 

Distancing in the first sentence, then coming back with "gut" defense

 

Ending with trying to discredit the accuser that you have recently called town. Hallia and Thane don't need to communicate in this case. Mynd was a dupe that She was using entirely to get herself "conftown" status.

 

My point about activity is that I have found that one role above all others is likely to be more active talkative as mafia than others. You know which one? Hint: it is in the list of roles that Thane gave out.

[csarmi]

Nah.

 

Forcing town to relynch the sump is worth a member.

 

Almost always worth for Mafia to trade a lynch 1 for 1.

 

But we're getting nowhere I guess. All wifom.

[csarmi]

I'm discrediting no one Turin.

 

I'm thinking you're town and Rags scum at this point. I know how good a town!Turin is if on the right track so I'm trying to get you see things the right way there.

[Tsukibana]

Forcing town to relynch the sump is worth a member.

 

 

Not when it outs you as Scum as well, putting a fat Vig target on your back, Cop target, etc.

 

Wonder who in the Holmes world would be a Granny? Mrs. Hudson, perhaps?

[Turin Turambar]

Nah.

 

Forcing town to relynch the sump is worth a member.

 

Almost always worth for Mafia to trade a lynch 1 for 1.

 

But we're getting nowhere I guess. All wifom.

BS. and it would end up being 2 for 1. All they buy there is a bit of time. but it makes them almost certain to lose barring a deep wolf

[csarmi]

 

 

Forcing town to relynch the sump is worth a member.

 

 

Not when it outs you as Scum as well, putting a fat Vig target on your back, Cop target, etc.

 

Wonder who in the Holmes world would be a Granny? Mrs. Hudson, perhaps?

Or she could have sheeped Turin there and/or say she'd follow her gut there or smth. That self vote could be justified to be deep town (I think he actually played well there for once) sooo the pardon wouldn't have been too off.

 

Now Tsuki if you do have the time, the win and you're town (which I find likely here). What about reading through.

[csarmi]

Derptown.

[Tsukibana]

Derptown.

???

 

@CS - plan on reading, when I get home, and in a comfortable chair.

[csarmi]

I men Thane's self vote looked too deep to be scum... Read what Turin said after his hammer.

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

Forcing town to relynch the sump is worth a member.

 

Not when it outs you as Scum as well, putting a fat Vig target on your back, Cop target, etc.

 

Wonder who in the Holmes world would be a Granny? Mrs. Hudson, perhaps?

Or she could have sheeped Turin there and/or say she'd follow her gut there or smth. That self vote could be justified to be deep town (I think he actually played well there for once) sooo the pardon wouldn't have been too off.

 

Now Tsuki if you do have the time, the win and you're town (which I find likely here). What about reading through.

 

So you were arguing on your QT for her to save/recruit him? And now that she can no longer recruit she is the least useful teammate? serious spinning there Csarmi. 

 

You trying to push everyone to read through to see if they will start to doubt themselves? one more day...

[csarmi]

Fitting the events and thread play to your theories rather than the other way around, Turin... Scummy, or lazy.

 

On a related note. Someone please analyse the switch away from Thane day one. Pretty likely to be a Mafia in there if not guaranteed. Now I know its not me.

[csarmi]

Yea reading the thread and specifically doing a thorough reread after a symp flip is unhealthy and anti town.

 

Seriously Turin?

[Hallia]

He just keeps digging o.o

[csarmi]

Yea I think Turin's town there and Rags/Ithi the scum.