[Advanced/Experimental] No Roles Disney Game - Game Over - Town Wins!

[Leelou]

Are we sure that Leelou was vetted multiple times?  She said she's been suspicious of Pralaya for a while....but in her ISO, before today she posted a grand total of ONE time about him in the 90574903579234750934 posts in this game.

 

Just sayin'.

 

Got distracted by Darthe before I could pull the posts, but twice before this day phase: 

 

 

I keep forgetting Pral is playing. A couple of his posts were shady. 

 

 

Okay I got similar amount of points from the day before. Since I don't know what will happen overnight here is a summary of what I did during the day: 

 

Voted: 

 

Krak

Darthe

 

Mentioned not liking posts by Krak and Pral, posted my pixie dust result, hit a trigger for Wombat and was involved with the Darthe train.

 

We need to kill Darthe. 

 

 

Hated this post by him, hence my response (which he never touched upon again): 

 

 

 

 

Then you need to earn points during the night phase.

Yeah, well, it isn't that easy when all I have to do are catch-up posts. I mean, how many can I post when everything's already been discussed?

 

 

Seriously? Everything has been discussed? 

 

[Alanna]

Wow, that was quick. I missed a whole day. I hadn't even decided what I was going to buy Night 2 lol.

[Verbal32]

You said "a couple of his posts have been shady".  You quoted one, and really only mentioned it once.  I don't count the 2 times where you say "mentioned not liking posts by Krak and Pral".  That is barely anything.

[Verbal32]

^ the above is obv to Leelou

[Leelou]

You said "a couple of his posts have been shady".  You quoted one, and really only mentioned it once.  I don't count the 2 times where you say "mentioned not liking posts by Krak and Pral".  That is barely anything.

 

Yeah I know. I got distracted by Darthe and the Bruins game to go dig for shady posts. I had full intentions to. 

[Leelou]

^ the above is obv to Leelou

 

And I only mentioned it like I did during the night phase because I ended up getting about the same amount of points I did the day before that and wasn't sure if I was going to die. 

[Verbal32]

Ok.  It just raises my suspicions considering a smart scum play would be to carpet 2 members away together to avoid detection.

[Tyler Glembo]

@Verb - I called it about Pral independently of you calling it.  And I didn't defend Pral, but if you wanna read it that way then feel free to read it wrong.

 

Oh, and yes I have been vetted by Kaylee.  Feel free to vet me in whatever other ways you'd like. 

[Leelou]

Ok.  It just raises my suspicions considering a smart scum play would be to carpet 2 members away together to avoid detection.

 

That would have been dumb considering Darthe was trying to buy townie points by "cop" clearing me as town. 

[Tyler Glembo]

GUYS!  New plan!

 

We can no longer trust views because mafia has had enough time to get themselves all godfathery.  From here on out I'll be vetting people by using Abu to steal their items.  If they have mafia scummy items then we poison apple them.  BOOM BABY! 

[Kaylee]

@Verb - I called it about Pral independently of you calling it. And I didn't defend Pral, but if you wanna read it that way then feel free to read it wrong.

 

Oh, and yes I have been vetted by Kaylee. Feel free to vet me in whatever other ways you'd like.

I never vetted you. I cop viewed Darthe, wrongly but he slipped up. Also Pral guessed my trigger and came back as mafia.

[Leelou]

Verb, I'm not scum. I fairy dusted you and got town. Don't over think this. 

[WWWwombat]

GUYS!  New plan!

 

We can no longer trust views because mafia has had enough time to get themselves all godfathery.  From here on out I'll be vetting people by using Abu to steal their items.  If they have mafia scummy items then we poison apple them.  BOOM BABY! 

 

I've been considering this.

[WWWwombat]

Also, Kaylee is townspewed by Darthe believing her cop view imo.  Felt much more like he was happy his Godfather worked than a gambit.

[WWWwombat]

And there are the viewings too, but Godfathers and all.

[Tyler Glembo]

Then who was it who town viewed me?  I need to go back and look I guess.

[Alanna]

GUYS! New plan!

 

 

 

We can no longer trust views because mafia has had enough time to get themselves all godfathery. From here on out I'll be vetting people by using Abu to steal their items. If they have mafia scummy items then we poison apple them. BOOM BABY!

Views were never very trustworthy because the mafia can vet each other, as far as I'm concerned. The Abu thing is a good idea, but also not foolproof.

 

The items are all well and good, but we really should focus on gameplay more, like Leelou and Verb are doing. It's near impossible to completely vet someone using any of the items.

[Lenlo]

 

@Verb - I called it about Pral independently of you calling it. And I didn't defend Pral, but if you wanna read it that way then feel free to read it wrong.

 

Oh, and yes I have been vetted by Kaylee. Feel free to vet me in whatever other ways you'd like.

I never vetted you. I cop viewed Darthe, wrongly but he slipped up. Also Pral guessed my trigger and came back as mafia.

 

He didnt slip up I tracked him >.>

 

 

GUYS!  New plan!

 

We can no longer trust views because mafia has had enough time to get themselves all godfathery.  From here on out I'll be vetting people by using Abu to steal their items.  If they have mafia scummy items then we poison apple them.  BOOM BABY! 

 

I've been considering this.

 

How do you define which is a town and which is a scum item though? I mean some are obviously scum but others not so much.

[Alanna]

Yeah, and see, Kaylee's scum result on Pral - was he millered, given all the attention on him? Why would he have intentionally guessed Kaylee's trigger word if he was scum and had no godfather protection? But maybe that was the point, and he will claim he was millered. This is why I think the views/pixie dust aren't worth much. Getting double or triple confirmed helps, but the mafia can still work together to get multiple vets.

[WWWwombat]

Then who was it who town viewed me?  I need to go back and look I guess.

 

Kayolee I think although I don't think she's actually said that yet.  You and I have hit her triggers and she hasn't said we're scum like she did Pralaya.  So yeah.

[WWWwombat]

 

GUYS! New plan!

 

 

 

We can no longer trust views because mafia has had enough time to get themselves all godfathery. From here on out I'll be vetting people by using Abu to steal their items. If they have mafia scummy items then we poison apple them. BOOM BABY!

Views were never very trustworthy because the mafia can vet each other, as far as I'm concerned. The Abu thing is a good idea, but also not foolproof.

 

The items are all well and good, but we really should focus on gameplay more, like Leelou and Verb are doing. It's near impossible to completely vet someone using any of the items.

 

 

Well I figured buying a ton of them on Night 1 might be able to outpace the scum ability to get millers and godfathers, so I'm treating my town reads as somewhat townish, but not 100%.  And I'm probably not going to be buying any more views.

[Leelou]

Yeah, and see, Kaylee's scum result on Pral - was he millered, given all the attention on him? Why would he have intentionally guessed Kaylee's trigger word if he was scum and had no godfather protection? But maybe that was the point, and he will claim he was millered. This is why I think the views/pixie dust aren't worth much. Getting double or triple confirmed helps, but the mafia can still work together to get multiple vets.

 

Did we ever get confirmation from Lily if Pixie Dust is godfather/miller proof or if they are fooled? 

[WWWwombat]

 

How do you define which is a town and which is a scum item though? I mean some are obviously scum but others not so much.

 

 

Well the obvious ones are obvious.  For the others, further probing is needed.  It's still info though and you get to use the item, right?

[WWWwombat]

 

Yeah, and see, Kaylee's scum result on Pral - was he millered, given all the attention on him? Why would he have intentionally guessed Kaylee's trigger word if he was scum and had no godfather protection? But maybe that was the point, and he will claim he was millered. This is why I think the views/pixie dust aren't worth much. Getting double or triple confirmed helps, but the mafia can still work together to get multiple vets.

 

Did we ever get confirmation from Lily if Pixie Dust is godfather/miller proof or if they are fooled? 

 

 

It's fooled.  I asked her in my PM.

[Leelou]

 

 

Yeah, and see, Kaylee's scum result on Pral - was he millered, given all the attention on him? Why would he have intentionally guessed Kaylee's trigger word if he was scum and had no godfather protection? But maybe that was the point, and he will claim he was millered. This is why I think the views/pixie dust aren't worth much. Getting double or triple confirmed helps, but the mafia can still work together to get multiple vets.

 

Did we ever get confirmation from Lily if Pixie Dust is godfather/miller proof or if they are fooled? 

 

 

It's fooled.  I asked her in my PM.

 

 

Okay.