[Advanced] Twilight Mafia Game over - Mafia win

[Tommyrod]

ISO on Pralaya:

 

I think he's town.  His reads have moved in line with the flow of the game, and his thoughts behind his reads/votes have been well-placed on thread (basically, how he viewed Lenlo).  He also was willing to put thought into how to utilize Lenlo's claimed role, and I remember agreeing with him on that topic.

 

He's also been consistent with his thoughts on Des, Darthe, and Tina.  He hasn't really focused on anybody else outside of those 4, but I can follow him pretty well.  Town lean.

Not that I disagree, but this is what you got after 2-3 hours?

[Niniel]

Unvote. Vote Verb

 

So we have seven claims on D2. This is so strange. I and Dice was forced to claim but Darthe, Des, Lenlo, Dawn and Tom weren´t. 

[Hallia]

I'm popping in on my lunch, at work on mobile lol;

 

Why would you think k Tina is lying Dice?

[Verbal32]

@Verb, this is probably going to turn on you really quickly.

 

Any reason to not lynch you?

 

I can see that coming, yes.

[Verbal32]

 

ISO on Pralaya:

 

I think he's town.  His reads have moved in line with the flow of the game, and his thoughts behind his reads/votes have been well-placed on thread (basically, how he viewed Lenlo).  He also was willing to put thought into how to utilize Lenlo's claimed role, and I remember agreeing with him on that topic.

 

He's also been consistent with his thoughts on Des, Darthe, and Tina.  He hasn't really focused on anybody else outside of those 4, but I can follow him pretty well.  Town lean.

Not that I disagree, but this is what you got after 2-3 hours?

 

 

I'm at work.  I spent half that time in a meeting.  Please don't assume the time period from 1 post to the next has me on DM staring at this mafia game.

[Niniel]

I liked Cory´s posts.

 

Also confused by Dice´s list. 

[Verbal32]

I'm waiting for an answer on my question to Dice, as it is closely related to where my vote goes today.

[dicetosser1]

i think she was hiding in that grouping of her des and cory hally

 

 

your just confused because you are on the scum end of it tina

[Tommyrod]

Dice's claim just now reminded me of Nolder's claim in the Christmas Mentors and Maffia game. Nolder was scum, claimed Doc, there was no Doc, and he coasted to endgame. I'm skeptical for two reasons: there are already a lot of claims for this early in the game, so I expect there will be more, and his play has been terrible. If Dice is town doc, then for balance reasons I'd expect scum has fakeclaims or they have quite a stacked PR deck, or both. There's also the additional problem that we're running out of scum suspects if Dice is town.

[Tommyrod]

tl;dr: I'm skeptical when the only saving grace for a player is a claim, even if not CC'd.

[Darthe]

Unvote. Vote Verb

 

So we have seven claims on D2. This is so strange. I and Dice was forced to claim but Darthe, Des, Lenlo, Dawn and Tom weren´t. 

 

I really want to lynch Tina.  

[dicetosser1]

Verb i dont know what to make of hallia. Her claim kinda came out of nowhere and convienently supports someone i find to be scummy. i am leaning mafia on her but not totally sold yet

[Tommyrod]

 

Unvote. Vote Verb

 

So we have seven claims on D2. This is so strange. I and Dice was forced to claim but Darthe, Des, Lenlo, Dawn and Tom weren´t.

 

I really want to lynch Tina.

 

For her faux pas today?

[Darthe]

TBH this really fits Dice in general Tommy.  The only difference between his town play and his scum play is that he is a lot quieter as scum.  He makes the same vague points and doesn't really think things through as either alignment but he is careful enough to not do overt scumslips that he doesn't also do as town.  I played a star wars game with him where he made it to endgame (around 150 pages) with under 15 posts I think.

[Darthe]

 

 

Unvote. Vote Verb

 

So we have seven claims on D2. This is so strange. I and Dice was forced to claim but Darthe, Des, Lenlo, Dawn and Tom weren´t.

 

I really want to lynch Tina.

 

For her faux pas today?

 

Amidst everything yes.

[Tommyrod]

TBH this really fits Dice in general Tommy.  The only difference between his town play and his scum play is that he is a lot quieter as scum.  He makes the same vague points and doesn't really think things through as either alignment but he is careful enough to not do overt scumslips that he doesn't also do as town.  I played a star wars game with him where he made it to endgame (around 150 pages) with under 15 posts I think.

Well that's disappointing. I remember him being kind of aloof, but not this much.

[Tommyrod]

##Unvote Dice

##Vote Tina

Whatchu got to say about dem apples, Hallia?
 

[dicetosser1]

aloof??  lol

 

tommy ive been quiet yes but i didnt really WANT attention. Doc getting attention usually ends up with a dead or outed doc.

[Tommyrod]

aloof??  lol

 

tommy ive been quiet yes but i didnt really WANT attention. Doc getting attention usually ends up with a dead or outed doc.

Yeah, I get it. I just hate you. No worries. 

[Tommyrod]

(I'm basically just annoyed I spent most of today talking about you when I could have been focusing on someone else.)

[dicetosser1]

i9 gotta go to work.  if you really wanna lynch tinma im down

 

##unvote vote tina

[Tommyrod]

Tina is another candidate for "if the only thing clearing is a claim..." POE. Seems like almost the entire game has found her scummy at some point, even after her claim. That's weird and suggests scum are keeping distance in case she gets lynched or vigged?

[Hallia]

There is the chance that she is.  I know her role isn't only town, it was the way in which she revealed that had me lean town.  (and why I left the 1%)

[Tommyrod]

There is the chance that she is.  I know her role isn't only town, it was the way in which she revealed that had me lean town.  (and why I left the 1%)

 

If you're not hard claiming an investigation on her, then I'm not opposed to a CFD onto someone that everyone agrees could be scum 

[Hallia]

No, I wasn't on her.