[Basic] Reboot Mafia Game MAFIA WINS

[Andrej]

Cause you're new here mostly. I made a little jab comment in the sign-up thread about making you my lady so I was trying to engage in a little trash talk

 

Seriously though, some analysis would be appreciated.

[Kaylee]

Leelou: you say I'm being vague. I'm trying to be. I'll be on a computer later so if there's something you, or anyone else, wants me to try and further explain I will. Up to this point I've tried to be clear.

[SickPuppets]

Cause you're new here mostly. I made a little jab comment in the sign-up thread about making you my lady so I was trying to engage in a little trash talk

 

Seriously though, some analysis would be appreciated.

Give me a moment, let me catch up. 

[hazelkrs1]

Still catching up but apparently AJ bleeds burnt orange so he's obviously not scum.

 

Unvote

 

[Kaylee]

Still catching up but apparently AJ bleeds burnt orange so he's obviously not scum.

 

Unvote

 

Huh? I don't understand what you mean.

 

[Kaylee]

My response apparently got caught in the quote.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

No aj ive been considering a vote on you since des started in on you. And to be clear UNVOTE VOTE AJ

 

honestly not to fond of the casing they have on kaylee. i would have asked the same thing.

 

Peace doesnt seem to ever have any in depth reads so i really kinda just disregard what he has to say for the most part. never been a fan of town lurking.

So you know Peace is town then?

This looks like a good catch to me. Amega's use of meta to justify it after the fact doesn't satisfy me.

 

Vote Amega

 

Would also be willing to lynch Kaylee. Her flip flop on me and AJ does look pretty scummy.

[WolfbrotherKronos]

Vote Count

AJ (3) - Csarmi, Kaylee, Ame
Kaylee (3) - AJ, Leelou, Peace

Amega (1) - Despo

Not Voting: You
With 12 Alive it takes 7 to lynch

Deadline is set for Thursday, Feb. 20th at 9:00 AM CST

Deadline Link

[amegakure]

haha my use of a meta? what exactly are you trying to get at despo he lurks and i dont like it regardless of if he's town or scum. its bad play, if your not gonna contribute to the game there is little point in playing we cant use vague reads and random votes. 

 

And if your talking about my vote on X. Then im lost with your logic on that as well.

 

 

Speaking of votes. your jumping off AJ cause why? he bleeds orange that is a horrible excuse for two people who had nothing but absolute conviction the other was scum yesterday and now it's like well ig they must be town cause they defended themselves..  and it's really making me consider a gambit. My vote stays where it is.

 

And ill be clear if we get a lynch on aj and he flips scum youll probably be next.

[hazelkrs1]

haha my use of a meta? what exactly are you trying to get at despo he lurks and i dont like it regardless of if he's town or scum. its bad play, if your not gonna contribute to the game there is little point in playing we cant use vague reads and random votes.

 

And if your talking about my vote on X. Then im lost with your logic on that as well.

 

 

Speaking of votes. your jumping off AJ cause why? he bleeds orange that is a horrible excuse for two people who had nothing but absolute conviction the other was scum yesterday and now it's like well ig they must be town cause they defended themselves.. and it's really making me consider a gambit. My vote stays where it is.

 

And ill be clear if we get a lynch on aj and he flips scum youll probably be next.

Not a good response.

 

Its not that you have a problem with lurking, I'm no fan of that either. Its that you said he was town lurking... I think it was a slip. I think you know Peace is town.

[amegakure]

sure if you want to run with that go for it. You like to run will all kinds of illogical willy nilly ideas that make no sense and muck up the thread. Sorta like the gambit you and x played and respectively both jumped off for pathetic reasons.

 

And for the most part ill assume everyone is town. Logically you have more of a chance to be town then scum. Then you base your reads on what their do out of character or saying.

 

Meta may not be a sure fire way to prove innocence but it's certainly a tool to be used. I easily could have said he was scummy for the same post but he's falling into character of his last game. So i assume he's town lurking and not being beneficial. 

 

Also you have been asked to explain what you said twice and haven't done so? my scum reads are jumping up on you.

[SickPuppets]

So, anyone else feel that Despot is off? Cause...I don't think he's town

[SickPuppets]

Maybe it's just me, but the Csarmi thing was really odd. AJ...I don't know what to say really as I've never played with him, I  don't like joke votes. AT ALL. So, his joke vote on me early on, not good. 

[csarmi]

@SP

 

1) What exactly makes you feel that Despot is off?

2) Joke votes are very normal here on DM (I could say it's the standard way to check in and say hi). Does that make you change your read?

3) What Csarmi thing?

[SickPuppets]

@SP

 

1) What exactly makes you feel that Despot is off?

2) Joke votes are very normal here on DM (I could say it's the standard way to check in and say hi). Does that make you change your read?

3) What Csarmi thing?

1&3. I'm an idiot. I got another game confused with this. I apologize. That doesn't change that I think he is off, the way he's behaving and or voting is what's pining me.

2. Really...? that's odd. Not too much in all honestly. 

[csarmi]

"And for the most part ill assume everyone is town. Logically you have more of a chance to be town then scum. Then you base your reads on what their do out of character or saying."

 

@amegakure - that sounds like an anti-town way to go (starting by reading everyone as town helps scum agenda, because it is scum who know who the town are and thus the easiest way for them would be to assume everyone to be town)

[SickPuppets]

*pinging not pining =~=

[amegakure]

I guess but they dont have to think logically at all hence the fact that they already know. im relying on the laws of probability to tell me there's more of a chance; you for example are town. Then if i feel that your game play slips i will question that. Honestly i feel as if a scum player wouldnt try to break the natural ways of playing and come off different from the group in anyway. Im willing to voice that i play differently and look at things from a different perspective, but so far ive done better than how i played in 2012

[Kaylee]

Des: I wasn't flip flopping. I still think AJ is likely scum. As far as you I'm just unsure now and I've explained why.

 

You have not explained why you unvoted AJ.

[Andrej]

I guess but they dont have to think logically at all hence the fact that they already know. im relying on the laws of probability to tell me there's more of a chance; you for example are town.Then if i feel that your game play slips i will question that. Honestly i feel as if a scum player wouldnt try to break the natural ways of playing and come off different from the group in anyway. Im willing to voice that i play differently and look at things from a different perspective, but so far ive done better than how i played in 2012

Correct me if I'm wrong here but you are basically saying you are only going to end up calling out town players based on this process. You say that you look for deviations but immediately follow that up by saying scum will try hardest to blend in with the group.

[Andrej]

So, anyone else feel that Despot is off? Cause...I don't think he's town

I'd actually be more inclined to think that you are scum because of posts like this. You are very null for me atm which is troubling.

[Andrej]

Still catching up but apparently AJ bleeds burnt orange so he's obviously not scum.Unvote

\m/

[Andrej]

@CS - I would appreciate if you would address my 109.

 

I'd be willing to lynch out of Kaylee, CS and SP atm. Amega's posts read to me as reasonable enough after he explained himself a little more but I still find his POE a little odd. The town comment on Peace could've been a slip but I don't think it's lynch worthy as of yet. CS seems to sniping and only commenting on little tidbits here and there. His vote as been parked on me as well although he has been posting but not really pushing his supposed scum read.

[amegakure]

Arnt we all pretty much casing town players and hoping we get a lucky read or find a slip. scum will try to blend but it doesnt always mean they will succeed. 

 

Im starting to lean towards a vote on Des. I know he goes for an aggressive approach but his reads have no strength behind them and he seems much to sporadic. between him and aj he is pinging the most. 

[csarmi]

@CS - I would appreciate if you would address my 109.

#58 is just an example, but the tone of the post (jokey contrarian) and the timing of it (try to get back to non-serious).

 

"would like to think" <-- that it's a scum slip (you would like to "think" I'm town as that's easier for you when you know that I am town

 

also, you're dropping the weak meta read again so you can easily justify what you "thinK" about me

 

I'd be willing to lynch out of Kaylee, CS and SP atm. Amega's posts read to me as reasonable enough after he explained himself a little more but I still find his POE a little odd. The town comment on Peace could've been a slip but I don't think it's lynch worthy as of yet. CS seems to sniping and only commenting on little tidbits here and there. His vote as been parked on me as well although he has been posting but not really pushing his supposed scum read.

Which part of "took sick" is unclear to you?

 

BTW my vote is not "parked" on you, I'm voting my top scum read.