Greek Mythology: Man Vs. Gods [Advanced] - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS!

[Darthe]

I don't see the logic there Mish. Its based on a previous event and the assumption of that events reoccurance. Not likely or deoendable enough to warrant pause really. Hell, I forgot they were on a team together already.

[WWWwombat]

Not sure I believe Des. His claim sounds like a very handy fake claim for a SK. But Dice said there's a vig.

 

If Des isn't the vig, I would advise the real vig to kill him.

 

unvote

Vote: Ithi

 

Noticed something she said that seems inconsistent with her earlier play. Brb with it.

[csarmi]

Morning.

[WWWwombat]

 

mega ninja

 

 

Maybe he is fibbing about being human.

 

Maybe he is a God. A MAFIA GOD!!!!

then why would he tell us all mafia are gods?

Because then he looks really good when the first Mafia God gets Lynched of course.

 

It's almost too easy.

This doesn't quite fit with Ithi's earlier suggestion that maybe the humans are the mafia (which was a pretty absurd suggestion in the first place btw).

 

Also, her nudging the Des train while seeming very reluctant to vote Des is sketchy.

 

Starting to think Ithi is a Godfather trying to draw a cop viewing.

[WWWwombat]

Morning.

Goodnight.

[csarmi]

 

 

mega ninja

Maybe he is fibbing about being human.

 

Maybe he is a God. A MAFIA GOD!!!!

then why would he tell us all mafia are gods?

 

Because then he looks really good when the first Mafia God gets Lynched of course.

 

It's almost too easy.

 

This doesn't quite fit with Ithi's earlier suggestion that maybe the humans are the mafia (which was a pretty absurd suggestion in the first place btw).

 

Also, her nudging the Des train while seeming very reluctant to vote Des is sketchy.

 

Starting to think Ithi is a Godfather trying to draw a cop viewing.

 

The statement in bold doesn't make sense, by the way.

1) Dice claims that all maffia are gods. This cannot be verified save for lynching all the maffia (before the end of the game).

2) Dice claims that all titans are town. This cannot be verified save for lynchign all Titans (which would be absurd and stupid).

 

Dice has a load of positive statements. By their nature, they cannot be tested true without going through all the cases.

They can be tested false (less helpful) by counter-example. [finding a titan who isn't town, finding a maffia who isn't god]

[csarmi]

UnOfficial Vote Count

 

Despo (5/9): Basel, Berf, Darthe, Cloud, Csarmi

 

Ithi (1/9): Wombat

 

Basel (1/9): Song

 

Thorum (1/9): Dice

 

Berf (2/9): Krak, Thorum

 

Cloud (3/?): Ithi, Despo, Mish

 

Not Voting: Praya, Hallia, Tina

[Darthe]

 

 

 

mega ninja

Maybe he is fibbing about being human.

 

Maybe he is a God. A MAFIA GOD!!!!

then why would he tell us all mafia are gods?

 

Because then he looks really good when the first Mafia God gets Lynched of course.

 

It's almost too easy.

 

This doesn't quite fit with Ithi's earlier suggestion that maybe the humans are the mafia (which was a pretty absurd suggestion in the first place btw).

 

Also, her nudging the Des train while seeming very reluctant to vote Des is sketchy.

 

Starting to think Ithi is a Godfather trying to draw a cop viewing.

 

The statement in bold doesn't make sense, by the way.

1) Dice claims that all maffia are gods. This cannot be verified save for lynching all the maffia (before the end of the game).

2) Dice claims that all titans are town. This cannot be verified save for lynchign all Titans (which would be absurd and stupid).

 

Dice has a load of positive statements. By their nature, they cannot be tested true without going through all the cases.

They can be tested false (less helpful) by counter-example. [finding a titan who isn't town, finding a maffia who isn't god]

 

 

You forgot to mention that killing Dice would solve the issue.

[hazelkrs1]

Not sure I believe Des. His claim sounds like a very handy fake claim for a SK. But Dice said there's a vig.

 

If Des isn't the vig, I would advise the real vig to kill him.

 

unvote

Vote: Ithi

 

Noticed something she said that seems inconsistent with her earlier play. Brb with it.

 

 

You really think I'd be that daft to fake claim a role that Dice has told us there's only one of?

 

 

 

mega ninja

Maybe he is fibbing about being human.

 

Maybe he is a God. A MAFIA GOD!!!!

then why would he tell us all mafia are gods?

Because then he looks really good when the first Mafia God gets Lynched of course.

 

It's almost too easy.

This doesn't quite fit with Ithi's earlier suggestion that maybe the humans are the mafia (which was a pretty absurd suggestion in the first place btw).

 

Also, her nudging the Des train while seeming very reluctant to vote Des is sketchy.

 

Starting to think Ithi is a Godfather trying to draw a cop viewing.

 

 

Hmmm. This actually might explain why Ithi revealed as a God like she did, knowing that she might catch some attention but that if she got out of it could end up drawing a cop viewing as well. I've def seen some questionable moves on her part this game, but I dunno. I'm still thinking lynching Dice's Lover might be the best bet.

 

 

 

Because then he looks really good when the first Mafia God gets Lynched of course.

 

 

It's almost too easy.

 

This doesn't quite fit with Ithi's earlier suggestion that maybe the humans are the mafia (which was a pretty absurd suggestion in the first place btw).

 

Also, her nudging the Des train while seeming very reluctant to vote Des is sketchy.

 

Starting to think Ithi is a Godfather trying to draw a cop viewing.

 

The statement in bold doesn't make sense, by the way.

1) Dice claims that all maffia are gods. This cannot be verified save for lynching all the maffia (before the end of the game).

2) Dice claims that all titans are town. This cannot be verified save for lynchign all Titans (which would be absurd and stupid).

 

Dice has a load of positive statements. By their nature, they cannot be tested true without going through all the cases.

They can be tested false (less helpful) by counter-example. [finding a titan who isn't town, finding a maffia who isn't god]

 

 

That's why the best way to verify all of Dice's info at once is to lynch his Lover. We'll have a plethora of info to use for the rest of the game, and will have a good chance at taking out mafia.

 

I still don't get why so many aren't seeing the value of this play. In the meantime, if I get a chance tonight I might go through and do a reread, or at the very least build a case on Cloud (biggest pinger of the day imo). Isn't deadline coming up quick, like later today or something?

[csarmi]

Because killing Dice makes no sense. Let the maffia worry about that.

 

Lynching his lover makes even less sense. How is it better than lynching Dice himself?

[csarmi]

Deadline is in 7 hours or so, I believe.

[csarmi]

Because killing Dice makes no sense. Let the maffia worry about that.

 

Lynching his lover makes even less sense. How is it better than lynching Dice himself?

I'm sure it's been spelled out before, but:

 

If Dice's lover is town, the maffia should kill Dice for us.

If Dice's lover is scum, the maffia can't kill him without removing his lover (a scum) so it's good to wait.

[hazelkrs1]

 

Because killing Dice makes no sense. Let the maffia worry about that.

 

Lynching his lover makes even less sense. How is it better than lynching Dice himself?

I'm sure it's been spelled out before, but:

 

If Dice's lover is town, the maffia should kill Dice for us.

If Dice's lover is scum, the maffia can't kill him without removing his lover (a scum) so it's good to wait.

 

 

If Dice's lover is town, then the mafia wouldn't know who it is. You think they'd try NK'ing Dice, knowing there's a good chance Doc would protect him tonight?

If Dice's lover is scum, I think there's a good chance it would be a powerful scum role. All the more reason to off them quick.

 

Additionally, Dice's claim will still represent a small amount of wifom till he is vetted in some way. I'd rather not use the cop to do so, I think it would be better to lynch his lover (or him, they essentially amount to the same thing). That way town would have FIVE confirmed townies day 1, and for mafia to try and work against that they'd have to shoot at confirmed townies, which would keep our PR's safe and keep them from silencing people who are getting hot on their trail. If they don't go for the confirmed townies, then the cop can townhunt and town will have so many confirmed townies, that essentially the only real challenge of the game would be finding the GF, which could possibly be done by sorting through the human/titan/god claims.

 

Dice do not skim this:

 

Please, when you get a chance, ask the mod these questions:

 

1. How many humans, how many titans, and how many gods there are in the game

2. Besides Persephone, how many town aligned gods are in the game.

[Niniel]

 

 

mega ninja

Maybe he is fibbing about being human.

 

Maybe he is a God. A MAFIA GOD!!!!

then why would he tell us all mafia are gods?

Because then he looks really good when the first Mafia God gets Lynched of course.

 

It's almost too easy.

This doesn't quite fit with Ithi's earlier suggestion that maybe the humans are the mafia (which was a pretty absurd suggestion in the first place btw).

 

Also, her nudging the Des train while seeming very reluctant to vote Des is sketchy.

 

Starting to think Ithi is a Godfather trying to draw a cop viewing.

 

 

Godfather - lol

 

I like this post. I hadn´t thought about the possibility of Ithi being a godfather. 

 

Vote Ithi

[csarmi]

Despo, make up your mind and tell us which of these actions make sense.
 

• Lynhing Dice
• The doc protecting Dice

[Niniel]

Deadline is in 7 hours or so, I believe.

 

Oh. Are you sure? I haven´t seen a deadline. It hasn´t been one on the vote counts. 

[csarmi]

DEADLINE: Friday at 2 PM BST or 9 AM Eastern Time (arriving back in the UK Friday morning bear that in mind in regards to deadlines and when I'll be awake).

 

Will post countdown link when I can!

 

there you go

[Niniel]

Thanks, Csarmi. I did see that but I guess I forgot it since it´s no in the vc. 

[csarmi]

Well there hasn't been an official VC since Page 14 (2 pages before this post), so probably that's why.

[hazelkrs1]

<p>

 

Despo, make up your mind and tell us which of these actions make sense.

 

• Lynhing Dice
• The doc protecting Dice

Lynching Dice makes sense (to vet his claim and potentially bag a mafia).

 

If dice isn't lynched, I think there's a good chance hell be doc-protected tonight.

 

And what do you mean "make up your mind"? I haven't changed at all in my stance that lynching Dice's lover would be he best move.

[hazelkrs1]

If the deadline really is that close-

 

Unvote, Vote Ithi

[hazelkrs1]

Tina, you might have to bold your vote

[hazelkrs1]

Rather, color it. Blech.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Back in England. Will post official things when at computer. From today on things like VCs will be more regular. Sorry! And thanks CS.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Deadline in 6 hours and 9 minutes.