August 9, 2013: CONCLUDED

[Hallia]

You think?  So you don't know, for sure.  I agree with Len, that's pretty anti-town there.

 

Unvote

[peacesells]

You think?  So you don't know, for sure.  I agree with Len, that's pretty anti-town there.

 

Unvote

 

what are your thoughts on his reactions?

[John E. Kelley]

I smell Gambit.

Could be. And the more I think about it, now would be a helluva time to try. There are four dead Townies in this thread compared to zero scum, they're probably feeling cocky.

 

And even if not, what if the real Cop had cc'd genius? That was completely reckless and stupid.

 

Unvote. Vote Peace.

[peacesells]

You should be policy lynched for that garbage.

 

Where your vote?  Hollow words...but you need someone to run off the cliff first don't cha?

[John E. Kelley]

 

You should be policy lynched for that garbage.

 

 

Where your vote?  Hollow words...but you need someone to run off the cliff first don't cha?

Check again old man. I don't talk just to hear myself speak.

[peacesells]

 

I smell Gambit.

Could be. And the more I think about it, now would be a helluva time to try. There are four dead Townies in this thread compared to zero scum, they're probably feeling cocky.

 

And even if not, what if the real Cop had cc'd genius? That was completely reckless and stupid.

 

Unvote. Vote Peace.

 

 

Never claimed cop.  Could have been a watcher or tracker among other investigative roles.   Why would a cop CC anyway when a bad flip would expose the play?  Why would scum fake a cop claim with no pressure on day 2?  Why ask why?

[peacesells]

you ninja'd me.  Guess you realized how that looked and took the first leap.  Maybe the other lemmings will follow you..maybe not.

 

 

Anyway...putting aside what you think about my "horrible and unforgivable play" what is your opinion on his reaction?

[Tiinker]

Unvote, vote Peace

I agree with Ish. Right after that happened in the other thread? How did you NOT expect a reaction. Seems like trying to pull the cop while having plausible deniability. 
 

[Tiinker]

<- is not scum.

This reaction?

[Hallia]

He didn't seem to lose his cool, or spread wifom like fertilizer; I think he did fine?

 

Vote Peace

[peacesells]

 

<- is not scum.

This reaction?

 

 

Yes.

 

He didn't seem to lose his cool, or spread wifom like fertilizer; I think he did fine?

 

Vote Peace

 

 

I agree..which is why I stalled the lynch.  Could have let it happen. 

[Hallia]

Fair enough, or you were scared that if he flipped town, and you were wrong you'd get strung up?

[Tiinker]

Or you realized the cop didn't out themselves after your play and you would've been roasted next Day phase.

[peacesells]

Lol, I just opened a fortune cookie from Panda Express and it says:

 

YOUR IDEAS ARE CLEVER AND YOU WILL BE REWARDED.

 

Weird.

[John E. Kelley]

As I said, Town isn't in a position to pull boneheaded moves, we're getting our asses handed to us so far, but scum is in a prime position to try something off the wall. Which is what you did.

 

So you're either scum or a detriment to Town. Gotta go.

[peacesells]

Fair enough, or you were scared that if he flipped town, and you were wrong you'd get strung up?

 

What what alignment would that fear give me and why?

[Tiinker]

Lol, I just opened a fortune cookie from Panda Express and it says:

 

YOUR IDEAS ARE CLEVER AND YOU WILL BE REWARDED.

 

Weird.

LOL

[John E. Kelley]

Lol, I just opened a fortune cookie from Panda Express and it says:

 

YOUR IDEAS ARE STUPID AND YOU WILL BE KILLED AS A RESULT?

 

Weird.

/fixed

[peacesells]

As I said, Town isn't in a position to pull boneheaded moves, we're getting our asses handed to us so far, but scum is in a prime position to try something off the wall. Which is what you did.

 

So you're either scum or a detriment to Town. Gotta go.

 

Fallacy and you ignored my question.

 

If I am town..killing me is a detriment if we are in as bad of shape as you say.  Why would you advocate that?  What makes you thing I would continue with a play that turned out to be unsuccesful and further hinder town?  Even if no results have proven my play bad as of yet.  Stay in the box Ishy.

[Yates]

Alright.  Caught up in this thread.  I think Peace ran a Town gambit.  She could have let it keep going but didn't.  It was pretty obvious when she first made the claim what she was doing.  But maybe it was obvious to me b/c I just caught up in the other thread.  I think Serra reaction tested well and is Townish.

 

Going to be L/A this weekend for birthday shens.  Expect activity in spurts if/when it happens.

[peacesells]

Alright.  Caught up in this thread.  I think Peace ran a Town gambit.  HE could have let it keep going but didn't.  It was pretty obvious when HE first made the claim what HE was doing.  But maybe it was obvious to me b/c I just caught up in the other thread.  I think Serra reaction tested well and is Townish.

 

Going to be L/A this weekend for birthday shens.  Expect activity in spurts if/when it happens.

[John E. Kelley]

Which question? The one about how I think Serra defended himself?

 

He didn't really offer a defense.

[peacesells]

Which question? The one about how I think Serra defended himself?

 

He didn't really offer a defense.

 

Right...what would you do in that circumstance as town...as scum?

[John E. Kelley]

As Town? Claim my alignment and role.

 

As Scum? Lie.

 

Why even ask that?

[John E. Kelley]

Ahhh. I c wut yu did thar.