Ghost Mafia - 3 out of 33 survive - Town wins!

Ithillian Turambar · May 20, 2013

@EP: yes i saw where you covered your opinion of what happened. glad to know you speak for every body in this game and are able to look over Wes,s notes to know 100% for sure what happened

I was thinking this lol. Also there's nothing wrong with the mobile version. I manage very well mostly and am skilled in manual coding and everything. It's brilliant apart from when you want to go backwards ... Or forwards ... And stuff like that.

Oh it don't multi quote either, but that's not a problem for me since I mostly forget to quote anyway :)

Gabriel Kross · May 20, 2013

The size of the game indicates to me it's likely there are third parties or multiple scum teams Red.

More the former than the later but I wont rule out multiple teams entirely just yet.

Does anyone really think that at this point we only need to lynch 2 people to win in a game of 33?

No I think we need to prevent them from getting their kills off while at the same time not lynching townies. If we don't have a damn good lead I think the no lynch may be the best solution. However this Hour we should lynch Rand

How would we prevent any kills?

And how would NOT lynching help us?

Even if you go by the logic that a townie not lynched is a townie saved...they'll likely still be recruiting at least 1 player per Hour.

That does not help us pull ahead.

#675: Scene: so EP is cleared as town for today. Wes’s scene also seems to suggest turin was killed by a ghost.

so either we’re dealing with a cultafia with a recruit and kill (most likely) or a solo SK (unlikely given the knowns in the OP)

also I've already covered the most likely situation to this.

Did you randomly make this word up? Sounds ridiculous.

Nah it's a real term. It is ridiculous though.

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Cultafia

No you didn't read my earlier theory then.

My theory is that each townie death grants one more recruited. I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure the number of deaths directly affects the recruitment

Gabriel Kross · May 20, 2013

@EP: yes i saw where you covered your opinion of what happened. glad to know you speak for every body in this game and are able to look over Wes,s notes to know 100% for sure what happened

I was thinking this lol. Also there's nothing wrong with the mobile version. I manage very well mostly and am skilled in manual coding and everything. It's brilliant apart from when you want to go backwards ... Or forwards ... And stuff like that.

Oh it don't multi quote either, but that's not a problem for me since I mostly forget to quote anyway :)

what type of phone do you use for mobile version? iPhone has a little forward and backwards button because it uses Safari

John McClane · May 20, 2013

The highlighted red names are all reputationally strong DM players, if I recall, that haven't said much, and if they have been talkative it has not been towards the effort of lynch, it's been more like fence-sitting, or statements made to look active but avoid pinging or leaving a trail of opinions about players. Tina and Talya being the best examples of that, that I can think of.

I don't agree with all of your list of strong DM players. If you think Rand is a better place to look, I can move my vote there. He has seemed to be fumbling a bit, but I have a hard time reading him since he always fumbled when I played with him. We have EP and Nol cleared for today. Ithi has claim of a prayer book with multiple prayers. Cloud has claimed the view of EP. So not going to vote for either of them today.

You'd know better than I, I've only done 5-6 games here I think. Sometimes it's tough amongst the gleep-glops and floop-dee-doos to tell if they are just popular, or reputationally strong players. ;)

I don't like you saying "If I like rand, you'll vote there". I encourage you to do what you want, don't ask for me to tell you what to do. Not sure I like that at all.

Ithillian Turambar · May 20, 2013

Mobile Version doesn't have a 'jump to page x' button - or a 'go to 1st/last post' option.

I can move about 1 page at a time of course but it's a total arse - which is why I have to try and remember everything and tend to paraphrase a lot.

Is like revising for an exam and I can hold most of it for a short while - after a fashion lol.

And it's a Blackberry 9900 Bold.

Verbal32 · May 20, 2013

DPR: can you confirm my vote on Tina, please?

John McClane · May 20, 2013

@ Ape - i generally dont get on weekands, and for sure do not get on Sundays. i've slotted time on Sat night for this game given its size.

o.0 BG is in this game, he hasn't posted that i recall. silent BG is not a town BG imo.

currently up to page 38. catching up is slow going as i'm at work.

durrent thoughts are, the Nol lynch is contrived, the wording was taken out of context by townie EP. whats more interesting is who decided to latch onto this to lead the lynch. Peace and Cloud.

given the game so far, and the interactions as well as the actions from Nols lynch my gut says Peace is cultleader and Cloud was his recruit. i dont buy his claim at all.

VOTE: PEACE

notes -

#625: LinkCloud: if everyone started out as town, then how exactly did we end up with 2 scum now?

#628: Nol: actually, how i read that is that we started with one and they recruited 1 giving us a total of 2 possessed. which means EP is right in that we’re dealing with a Cultafia.

#640: Cloud: bawks heavily at the idea of a cultafia (which now makes the most sense) and backs up his logic by accusing the mod of bastard modding.

if Wes is the original ghost then the we can never win, as the mod is unlynchable.

#644: Cloud: i dislike this post. first your advocating a rushed lynch, then the ”it isn’t important who” bit leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

ever since the reveal of 2 possessed your posts have a scrambling feel to them.

#651: Cloud: his absurd theory that Wes bastard modding us gets some critics and he begins to distance from his own theory.

#653: Nol: i agree, we need to stick to the knowns. which makes me question why you’re starting in about 3rd parties. do you know something we dont?

we know there is a town and a mafia, we now know there are 2 possessed (imo, 2 total, meaning we started with 1 mafia), we know that there is 1 kill per day aside from the lynch (which could be Vig items or could be SK or could be a cultafia kill), we know items are handed out.

where exactly do you get the conjecture of ”There very well could be and likely are more than that as well as some third parties.”

#666: Mish: tbh, Leelou gogin after Ithi and Turin were a null tell for me do to meta reasons. i would have been more curious had she not gone after them. double edge sword, but its why she’s not high on the list from Turins lynch.

#675: Scene: so EP is cleared as town for today. Wes’s scene also seems to suggest turin was killed by a ghost.

so either we’re dealing with a cultafia with a recruit and kill (most likely) or a solo SK (unlikely given the knowns in the OP)

#678: Peace: where did i say you were defending Halia? i accused you of opportunistically latching onto her lynch, same as with Turins.

#695: Cloud: this reveal pings. it was un-needed, came out of left field and feels like a reach to gain town cred.

#707: Peace: first to latch onto the supposed freudian slip.

#709: [http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2910718]Cloud[/url]: 2nd to latch onto it.

#732: [url-ttp://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2910754]Cloud[/url]: but 2 pages earlier you agreed with Womby about the No Lynch Link thats a quick latch and flip there cheerleader.

cocky because your cult leader is leading the lynch using a cleared townies bad logic?

WTF is this shit?

She flat says quiet BG is scum. Then votes Peace?

Not sure I buy the case on Peace either, she just finishes calling the Nolder thing contrived and then she makes up some narrative about Peace being the cult leader and guessing at the moves he's made? Not sure I like this mess at all.

Not even sure wtf to make of the re-read notes. All adds up to a wasted vote by someone putting a lot of effort into looking lost within the game.

Verbal32 · May 20, 2013

Also, Leelou is starting to make me feel uneasy.

John McClane · May 20, 2013

Also, Leelou is starting to make me feel uneasy.

Yeah, so you and I are seeing the same way re: Tina and Leelou.

You getting behind the Ape?

Verbal32 · May 20, 2013

Also, Leelou is starting to make me feel uneasy.

Yeah, so you and I are seeing the same way re: Tina and Leelou.

You getting behind the Ape?

I'd buy you dinner first.

John McClane · May 20, 2013

DPR: can you confirm my vote on Tina, please?

Unvote

Vote Tina

See if mine registers.

Niniel · May 20, 2013

Hm, Verbal, Leelou and Ape where some of my suspects from day one.

Leelou · May 20, 2013

Hm, Verbal, Leelou and Ape where some of my suspects from day one.

Has there been a game that we've all played in recently that you haven't suspected me or Verbal?

Nolder · May 20, 2013

The size of the game indicates to me it's likely there are third parties or multiple scum teams Red.

More the former than the later but I wont rule out multiple teams entirely just yet.

Does anyone really think that at this point we only need to lynch 2 people to win in a game of 33?

No I think we need to prevent them from getting their kills off while at the same time not lynching townies. If we don't have a damn good lead I think the no lynch may be the best solution. However this Hour we should lynch Rand

How would we prevent any kills?

And how would NOT lynching help us?

Even if you go by the logic that a townie not lynched is a townie saved...they'll likely still be recruiting at least 1 player per Hour.

That does not help us pull ahead.

#675: Scene: so EP is cleared as town for today. Wes’s scene also seems to suggest turin was killed by a ghost.

so either we’re dealing with a cultafia with a recruit and kill (most likely) or a solo SK (unlikely given the knowns in the OP)

also I've already covered the most likely situation to this.

Did you randomly make this word up? Sounds ridiculous.

Nah it's a real term. It is ridiculous though.

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Cultafia

No you didn't read my earlier theory then.

My theory is that each townie death grants one more recruited. I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure the number of deaths directly affects the recruitment

Why would you think that?

Niniel · May 20, 2013

Hm, Verbal, Leelou and Ape where some of my suspects from day one.

Has there been a game that we've all played in recently that you haven't suspected me or Verbal?

Hm... one or two maybe. :D

John McClane · May 20, 2013

Hm, Verbal, Leelou and Ape where some of my suspects from day one.

LOL, yes, we've all recruited each other and we are all 3 teaming up in thread to take you out because in the midst of saying a lot of nothing all game, you mentioned us on D1, probably when there weren't even conversions.

This might be the most irrelevant statement of the game.

Nolder · May 20, 2013

Where is Des?

John McClane · May 20, 2013

Oh, out of curiosity... Who originally suggested a NO LYNCH, and why?

Leelou · May 20, 2013

Red did Hour 1. I forget the exact why though. It was on a Saturday, under 24 hours from deadline.

Nolder · May 20, 2013

Oh, out of curiosity... Who originally suggested a NO LYNCH, and why?

Pretty sure it was Red. Don't remember why.

Niniel · May 20, 2013

Hm, Verbal, Leelou and Ape where some of my suspects from day one.

LOL, yes, we've all recruited each other and we are all 3 teaming up in thread to take you out because in the midst of saying a lot of nothing all game, you mentioned us on D1, probably when there weren't even conversions.

This might be the most irrelevant statement of the game.

Yeh, it is. I have already said that my suspicions from day 1 is useless. However, if one of you can recruit you would likely recruit one of the other.

Leelou · May 20, 2013

Hm, Verbal, Leelou and Ape where some of my suspects from day one.

LOL, yes, we've all recruited each other and we are all 3 teaming up in thread to take you out because in the midst of saying a lot of nothing all game, you mentioned us on D1, probably when there weren't even conversions.

This might be the most irrelevant statement of the game.

Yeh, it is. I have already said that my suspicions from day 1 is useless. However, if one of you can recruit you would likely recruit one of the other.

LOL I would not recruit the smelly one, he'd stink up the whole ghostly lair.

Gabriel Kross · May 20, 2013

Why would you think that?

I'm taking into account that this is a DPR game so the most outlandish ideas in normal games make the most sense here. Also it's mostly a gut feeling.

Nolder · May 20, 2013

Why would you think that?

I'm taking into account that this is a DPR game so the most outlandish ideas in normal games make the most sense here. Also it's mostly a gut feeling.

In other words you pulled it out of thin air. Got it.

Verbal32 · May 20, 2013

Hm, Verbal, Leelou and Ape where some of my suspects from day one.

LOL, yes, we've all recruited each other and we are all 3 teaming up in thread to take you out because in the midst of saying a lot of nothing all game, you mentioned us on D1, probably when there weren't even conversions.

This might be the most irrelevant statement of the game.

Yeh, it is. I have already said that my suspicions from day 1 is useless. However, if one of you can recruit you would likely recruit one of the other.

Oh! Let's WIFOM that one to hell and back! I'd recruit the person people know I'm IRL friends with (Leelou), or play mafia with all the time on another site (Ape). Yes, yes.....that would work wonderfully. Nobody would ever expect that!

Or....maybe I'd do the opposite and make you THINK I didn't. Yes....that might be better.

Oh boy, this is exciting!

/towels off the sarcasm dripping from every pore

;-)

Ghost Mafia - 3 out of 33 survive - Town wins!

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook