Jump to content

DRAGONMOUNT

A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY

[Advanced] The Dresden Files Mafia - Game Over - Ed loses, Verbal wins


John Snow

Recommended Posts

Posted

People stalling and not voting Tina: Hybrid, Lenlo

Yup.  I want to know whether he targeted you or Verbal before the end of day.

 

Did you view Tina?  Spell it out for me.

  • Replies 1.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted

Tina

 

 

Leelou, love how you don't even have a reason.

 

 

Lenlo, that was seriously a stupid question. Sounded more like you were hoping for a response to help validate a vote.

Posted

I wasn't wrong on D1. Csarmi was not town, that was scum hunting logic.

 

I was digging into JIF on D2 because he was going after AVM, and I knew AVM was town. I went after Ishy because he was insinuating Tina was cop. That's why I pressed on that. 

 

Sure, Ishy was town and got lynched, but I wasn't wrong in how I played it. Not by a long shot. My night talk was also devised to keep me alive and untargeted.

Posted

 

People stalling and not voting Tina: Hybrid, Lenlo

People who arnt sure how to think of you since youve been wrong every time so far: Lenlo.

 

Unless of course your saying outright that she is scum? Cause that from a cop I can get behind. But if this is off a hunch, well, im not so sure of that yet.

 

Stalling. I haven't been wrong either, as explained.

 

 

People stalling and not voting Tina: Hybrid, Lenlo

Yup.  I want to know whether he targeted you or Verbal before the end of day.

 

Did you view Tina?  Spell it out for me.

 

I want to know the answer from booboo too.

 

I think I've spelled out plenty.

Posted

Booboo, Ape, Noldy.

 

Or Ape, Booboo, Noldy. 

 

Was too damn busy today to properly read this thread, but I am leaning scum on those. 

 

 

Going to try and actually read the last two pages and post some more thoughts, but I might not be coherent for very much longer. 

 

 

Can you explain why you list myself and booboo on your list? 2 of the 3 of your FOS are investigative town roles.

Posted

 

So, we are lynching AVM tomorrow right?

 

No, you.  I re-read every post of yours this game.  Yes, it was painful.  You're totally scum.  You're latching onto anything "scummy" said by players (town say scummy stuff all the time - you've even pointed this out many times), but you aren't giving them that benefit of the doubt.  Scum play the clean games, remember?  You are hunting the people not playing clean.

 

I'm sold on you as scum - you should be run up first thing tomorrow.

 

 

What's up Sally, you want to revisit this?

 

I've got a bone to pick with you, Rand and Ed for all that jibba jabba during night phase.

Posted

Tina

 

 

Leelou, love how you don't even have a reason.

 

 

Lenlo, that was seriously a stupid question. Sounded more like you were hoping for a response to help validate a vote.

Stupid question or not, it was asked so an answer should be expected.

 

 

 

People stalling and not voting Tina: Hybrid, Lenlo

People who arnt sure how to think of you since youve been wrong every time so far: Lenlo.

 

Unless of course your saying outright that she is scum? Cause that from a cop I can get behind. But if this is off a hunch, well, im not so sure of that yet.

 

Stalling. I haven't been wrong either, as explained.

 

People stalling and not voting Tina: Hybrid, Lenlo

Yup.  I want to know whether he targeted you or Verbal before the end of day.

 

Did you view Tina?  Spell it out for me.

 

I want to know the answer from booboo too.

 

I think I've spelled out plenty.

 

Alright well spell it out some more, this time in detail and using specifics instead of just saying "I think ive spelled it out.". A nice yes or no on the thing would actually be perfect.

 

And what purpose would stalling serve? It is literally the first couple of hours after night ended. Theres so much time that stalling would be stupid and pointless.

Posted

Look at Lenlo, trying to find out if she needs to bus or not.

 

Did you guys know that Lenlo wasn't on the csarmi train on D1, he was on Ishy... but he wasn't on the Ishy train on D2, and now he's talking about how "I was wrong" for going after Ishy!

Posted

Look at Lenlo, trying to find out if she needs to bus or not.

 

Did you guys know that Lenlo wasn't on the csarmi train on D1, he was on Ishy... but he wasn't on the Ishy train on D2, and now he's talking about how "I was wrong" for going after Ishy!

Did you know im not a female and that my vote on Ishy was a joke vote all the way back from page 2 or 3?

Posted

 

Booboo, Ape, Noldy.

 

Or Ape, Booboo, Noldy. 

 

Was too damn busy today to properly read this thread, but I am leaning scum on those. 

 

 

Going to try and actually read the last two pages and post some more thoughts, but I might not be coherent for very much longer. 

 

 

Can you explain why you list myself and booboo on your list? 2 of the 3 of your FOS are investigative town roles.

 

Reread and notes coming up. 

 

Quick answer: 

I already told you that your back and forth with Noldy felt contrived, and the way you advocated for Ishy's lynch when there were two possibly confirmed townies. We should have taken another angle with that, imo.

And I already said that Boo viewed AVM. Ishy was town. IF there is a mafia Reporter, it's him. Combined with his play, well, yea, you can see why I am sus of him. 

Posted

Here was the vote count yesterday, tied up between Boo and Ishy. Hard to get anything to budge really. A sign that Boo and Ishy are both town, and scum doesn't want to do their own dirty work, since none of their peeps are getting heat.

Official Vote Count:

 

Boo(5): Peace, AVM, Verb, Kat, Vam

Ishy(4): Leelou, Nol, Ape, Hybrid

Kat(1): Ishy

 

Not voting:

TGlems, Song, Lenlo, Tina, Rand, boo, Ed

 

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch

 

Deadline: http://www.timeandda...=Day 2 Deadline

 

This is noon on the 4th in Mountain Timezone. I also believe that's DM time.

 

I make a case on Tina. Things start shifting... 

 

 

 

Leelou is pinging me too right now, she's in lock-step with me. I always get most paranoid about those too willing to be closely aligned with the alpha scum hunter.


Leroy has been playing the Follow the Ape game now that you mention it....

 

 

CHOMP!!!!!!! Can't be this easy, can it?

 

^^^ Ishy bit on this trap pretty hard. If his logic was that there's no way there's a game mechanic that would out two townies at once (his words) then why at no point has he voted AVM? Instead he's hanging around and nudging every bit of FOS I throw out there. He didn't really take a position on JIF though, he avoided that. 

 

Ah, a reply box... Nice. 

 

Lets see. AVM and Ishy might be vanilla, or maybe not. 

 

Ishy offers to get lynched and Booboo selfvotes. 

 

TGlems has different suggestions on different roles. Katiora has as well. 

 

I don´t like when people suggests jester every game.

 

 

 

But half of my post got eaten. Arrrrgh... *daily kill Cloudflare scream*

 

I´m vary about Verbal at this point. Also think Leelou is on a team with someone. 

 

 

lol @ Booboo

 

 

 

 

>style="margin-top: 0px; margin-right: 0px; margin-bottom: 0px; margin-left: 0px; "> 

Vote AVM  

 

Second time you've done the whole vote with no explanation and move on thing.

 

This is a strange comment from someone who plays on a site where noone ever explains their votes.

 

 

Also, Vote: BooBoo

 

Verbal surfing. 

 

 

 

 

I agree that Booboo´s reactions looks scummy. But he immedeately asked what a Chicago Citizen is after the coroner´s report. That would be kind of clumsy  to ask if scum.

 

Ishy don´t add anything except for letting us know he is willing to get lynched. Any thoughts, Ishy? 

 

Vote Katiora.

 

 

 

 

I agree that Booboo´s reactions looks scummy. But he immedeately asked what a Chicago Citizen is after the coroner´s report. That would be kind of clumsy  to ask if scum.

 

Ishy don´t add anything except for letting us know he is willing to get lynched. Any thoughts, Ishy? 

 

Vote Katiora.

 

 

Talk about a hedging statement. "I agree JIF looks scummy, but here's a reason why he's probably not scummy, and here's some redirected pressure at Ishy (possible distancing) and a random vote on Katiora"

 

You are on my short list for good reason. Now, I really want to know JIFs alignment. You should have put him at L1.

 

I would if I thought he was mafia. 

 

 

 

 

I agree that Booboo´s reactions looks scummy. But he immedeately asked what a Chicago Citizen is after the coroner´s report. That would be kind of clumsy  to ask if scum.

 

Ishy don´t add anything except for letting us know he is willing to get lynched. Any thoughts, Ishy? 

 

Vote Katiora.

 

Why Katiora? 

 

To me it looks like she is trying to look town rather than being town. I can find some quotes if you want. 

 

 

 

I agree that Booboo´s reactions looks scummy. But he immedeately asked what a Chicago Citizen is after the coroner´s report. That would be kind of clumsy  to ask if scum.
 
Ishy don´t add anything except for letting us know he is willing to get lynched. Any thoughts, Ishy? 
 
Vote Katiora.


*squints thoughtfully at Tina's vote*

Okay, I get it. Vote Kat.

 

^^^ These are all Tina's posts BEFORE she finally votes Kat. So she's building towards suspicion on Verbal, and gives Leelou a push too, then somehow finds herself on Kat, with Ishy quickly putting the soft-sell on there being some sort of "informed" vote hint in her post.

 

I don't anything in her vote. I see him calling attention to it though. Doesn't add up. So it's worthy of being questioned, imo.

 

Now he's playing "super townie" trying to villainize me for asking what they are being cryptic about, when he was the one that spotlighted her vote and insinuated there was more to it than just a guess.

 

 

One of the first things we saw happen with the case on Tina, and some chatter about Vambram starting up. Lenlo gives the Ishy train a good PUSH.

Alright Ishy I personally want to take the word of the big, mod provided scene reveal thing, but hes right. That comment was scummy as hell.

 

Then Tina echoes the chatter on Vambram, telling us all it's his scum tell. Doesn't vote him though... 

 

I VOTE BOOBOO

 

 

His posts are mostly either attacks against the most active scum hunter in this game, or BooBoo posts lots of random stuff that, to me, almost sounds like his game style is very erratic or even kind of schizophrenic in nature. If we on the Town team are going to defeat the Mafia, then I don't understand how BooBoo is being helpful, even if he is Town. Throughout Day 1 and Night 1, most of Booboo's votes have come without any explanation. That is rarely a  good thing to do. But,  I think that he is Mafia attempting to masquerade as Town. 

 

This is typical Vambram. "We on the town team." I have seen him use it as scum before. His post is not logical at all. He says that Booboo isn´t being helpful and that it´s not good to vote without an explanation but still he think Booboo is attempting to look town. Basically that means Booboo is playing scummy but trying to look town. Where is the logic? This sounds like a made up reason for his vote. 

 

 

Votes Ishy instead. 

 

Yes, I agree. His last comment shows that he is not interested in helping town. Unvote. Vote Ishy.

 

Rand drops by, this I've already picked apart, but he basically builds a case for why I am scum - then votes Ishy - essentially setting up a circumstance to lynch a townie, and use it to frame me. I quoted the version with my response with it.

 

Holy crap its hard to catch up on this game.  First thing I want to point out.  Everyone went of JiF/Boo when he claimed town reporter but not a single one of you mentioned that he might in fact be a mafia reporter.  We thought of this scenario before, but now it doesn't get a single mention.  I thought JiF was town before Ape started casing him on pretty much meta alone (which is really weak, especially when playing on another site), but none of you looked at anything else other than what Ape was saying.  This game it seems like most people are playing get behind the Ape, notice how where he votes, others do as well.  Two things here, either we can find scum their trying to hide between everyone else, or Ape himself is scum, and he's just capitalizing on how much scum hunting he can do, instead of how well.  I know I said before that he caught a town threat, but to him if he was mafia, that would have seemed like town before a reveal, and after he had gotten that far, he couldn't have backed off anyways.  Second of all, Ishy has been very scummy, first of all in his initial reaction to anyone who questioned him.  Usually I would think that this would be too clear for anyone to do and would be a town tell, but I think Ishy was trying to overplay his town meta of being too nonchalant and kind of free with what he says.  Not only that, but once Tina said that she was fine with him revealing what he thought, not only did he insult Tina as well, he didn't give the reason he had.  So now that there is nothing to lose, please go ahead and tell us Ishy, what you thought.

 

vote Ishy

 

You build a case where I could likely be scum, talk about how everyone is following me, and then vote Ishy. LMFAO This stinks like you are pushing the Ishy train, and trying to set up a lynch on me for if/when Ishy flips town. Universal scum tell: I call it "getting greedy" when scum is trying to set up the next lynch before today's even finishes.

 

For the record on Booboo... My case on Booboo was sincere and NOT just based on meta, he piggy-backed my csarmi case on D1 (game play related), he had a town result on AVM but chose to vote him anyway?

 

The meta part of my case doesn't really take playing at JN to understand. He said I lied about how he hates when I play "connect the dots", which when you decouple the statement I actually made is an easy thing for him to sell. I never lied about that, I freely admit he HATES when I do it. That said, that wasn't the focus... the focus was that he KNOWS it is a big-time town tell of mine, and he ignored that it's a town tell and sold that town tell to you all as a scum tell. That IS something he often does as scum, selling my town tells as my scum tells. So, if you are in my shoes it becomes quite easy to convince yourself he's dirty.

 

Also, him selling you all my town tell as a scum tell, is also meta-casing, why aren't you scolding him over that?

 

Anyway, it's a moot point, unless he gets counter-claimed he is Bob.

 

I voted Vambram, because I saw Tina vote him after distancing from Vambram, I saw Rand vote Ishy while framing me. I knew Vambram was scum, he had to be. My plan was to connect him to Tina, but a SK or Vig did one better. 

 

Agreed with TGlems, ftr.

 

Unvote

Vote Vambram (edited to make red)

 

I'm not sure what to make of Ishy's behavior right now, but I don't the nature of the votes coming on him right now. Leelou's vote pinged, so did Rand's, I'm a little suspicious when I see people putting effort into establishing an undertone that I might be scum, but then they vote who I'm voting. It feels like they are pushing a town lynch, and trying to indict other townies leading the train.

 

Vambram's vote on Booboo now looks super scummy. 

 

AVM backed me up.

 

unvote

 

While I agree Ishys play sticks the most out, keeping him around for at least another game day could allow us to start vetting people.  If scum ignore the situation (including JiF -- booboo), I'd assume we get more information and start having a big pool of players in that semi-confirmed pool.  If scum kill, then they're going to have a tough time not essentially confirming someone at town (too many people involved).  I'd assume that's the route they'll take as they won't want that group to get too big, but then at least we're forcing their hands in the direction of us.  If we get to deadline without a clear option, he or I are obviously there as fallback plans.

 

Got a good chuckle out of Tina.  I guess you don't read along much at JN, as people explain their votes all the time through case building...but it's a regular occurrence.  D1 joke votes are one thing, D2 coming out is usually down to business.  JiF(booboo) claims to have been playing possum, so as I said...something was off about the post (though I was completely wrong on what exactly, lol)

 

Now for Vam -- I concur he tried to reignite the JiF (booboo) train, sort of...but the bigger deal, to me, is that he seemingly copied my case against JiF (booboo) with the "he's just voting without explaining."  Which, by how Tina is acting, shouldn't be all that odd around here I guess?

 

vote: Vambram

Posted

Look at the vote count now...

 

Boo(3): Peace, Verb, Vam

Ishy(5): Leelou, Nol, Hybrid, Tina, Rand

Vam(2): Ape, AVM

Ed(1): Boo

Kat(1): Ishy

 

Not voting:

TGlems, Song, Lenlo, Ed, Kat

 

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch

 

Deadline: http://www.timeandda...=Day 2 Deadline

 

This is noon on the 4th in Mountain Timezone. I also believe that's DM time.

 

 

BOOM!

 

It appears that everyone is believing Booboo's role and character claim as Bob, the Town Reporter. Obviously, if he is telling the truth, then he is not someone that we ought to take a chance with on the lynch. Half of those who were on the BooBoo lynch vote have unvoted him and cast their vote elsewhere. For now, I will believe his character and role claim.

 

UNVOTE BOOBOO

 

Therefore, who will I cast my lynch vote on now? A re-read of the last few pages of this thread provided me a few posts by Ishy that I thought are very scummy. My previous reasons for voting on BooBoo now apply even more strongly upon Ishy. He has been very erratic and extremely defensive, in my opinion. I think that Ishy's behavior is scummy and that the part in the Rumors section of the paper was meant to try to throw suspicion off of Ishy. However, I am placing a major FOS on Ishy because I now believe that he is scum.

 

VOTE  ISHY 

 

BOOM!

 

 

Unvote. Vote Ishy.

I deserve it after the personal attack. Sorry.

 

What is this crapola, and what personal attack?

 

 

I think this is the "go screw yourself" etc etc type stuff he posted... one thing, that kind of behavior might be common at JN but it is not very common and frowned upon here where we are PG-13 and are told to play nice together or get your spankings (and not in a good way lol)... "Personal attacks" here are frowned upon greatly by staff.. DM prides itself on at least TRYING to have a friendly and welcoming attitude. *takes off staff hat*

 

 

Though i have to say voting yourself in this situation is pointless... seems like he's trying to pull a 360 like boo did yesterday when he was almost lynched and everyone was voting him. I find this scummy enough to vote. Unless he can pull a role reveal out of his butt and make us believe it.. and that's not gonna happen

 

I vote Ishy

 

 

 

Official Vote Count:

 

Boo(2): Peace, Verb

Ishy(8): Leelou, Nol, Hybrid, Tina, Rand, Vam, Ishy, Kat

Vam(2): Ape, AVM

Ed(1): Boo

 

Not voting:

TGlems, Song, Lenlo, Ed

 

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch

 

Deadline: http://www.timeandda...=Day 2 Deadline

 

This is noon on the 4th in Mountain Timezone. I also believe that's DM time.

 

 

At this point, as cop, I decided go with the lynch on Ishy. Make sure he flips town, and gain the context I needed to inform my reads on Tina, Vambram, Rand and Kat.

 

If you look at the trains, you see that theres 4 townies not on Ishy at the time before hammer. IF we believe the rumors on AVM and Verbal. I don't doubt JIF, he hasn't been countered. I'm also uncountered. 

 

I think the Tina, Rand votes to push Ishy over the top reeked. Lenlo pushed the Ishy train, and Peace hid out.

 

I'd make them my top 4: Tina, Rand, Lenlo, Peace.

Posted

I'm making my notes. Shush. 

But like I said, Noldy's scum vibe came from his interactions with you feeling contrived. Soooo, I'm looking back and not really seeing it the same way. 

Will still post my thoughts on him. 

Posted

Page 26.

Not staying focused enough on the page. These are my unpolished thoughts of Day 1. Obviously foresight is a bitch, and looking back, you know certain people flipped certain ways, it makes you rethink. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Boo
 
#40 Boo switches to Nol
 
 
#464 - Posts that he believes Czar's claim but wants him dead. But he also would rather leave him alive to find scum. 
 
Comes back two posts later aftering having pooped and had his coffee. Advocates lynching Czar. 
 
Noldy
 
 
#44 More emo crap about people not wanting to play mafia on DM 
 
#63 (http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/80818-advanced-the-dresden-files-mafia-day-3/?p=2852601) - Makes an argument that Ape didn't call him on his meta. Ape counters that that is his meta when he has a town power role and he wouldn't do that. Some back and forth on if Ape was scum and how things owuld play out between them. Not a whole lot in this interaction that matters now.
 
This whole thing between them was rather annoying and their first back and forth. It is why I felt things were contrived between them.  
 
#185 (http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/80818-advanced-the-dresden-files-mafia-day-3/?p=2853112) - Noldy gets on his high horse about joke votes again, trying to spin them as "Lazy votes."
He also says that Boo's vote change is something he likes. There is nothing but an unvote and new vote on Noldy. No explanantion or reason. And Noldy thinks it's a good vote because it looks like Boo is looking for info. 
 
AVM
#245 (http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/80818-advanced-the-dresden-files-mafia-day-3/?p=2853790) - Comments on the Cstarmie stuff. Says he thinks he believes him. 
 
#266 (http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/80818-advanced-the-dresden-files-mafia-day-3/?p=2853910) - I don't know how AVM plays, but I feel his defense of Czar was scum latching onto an assumed townie
 
#397 (http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/80818-advanced-the-dresden-files-mafia-day-3/?p=2855644) - BIG FLIP. Sure, Csarmie was scummy as hell, but at least give reasons when the last time you came in was saying you thought he was town. 
 
He finally comes in with reasons once Peace asks him for it.
 
 
Lenlo
 
Lenlo later comes and apologizes for being wrong. 
 
 
VAM = MAFIA
TINA =? MAFIA
 
APE = COP
ISHY = Town Vanilla
DAP = Town Doc
DARTHE = Town Watcher
 
BOO = Reporter (scum?)

 

 
Posted

And caveat to that is that now you're off my list. Kind of obvious. 

*looks at Lenlo*

 

Would you like to ask a question? 

I did and you called it stupid. Meanie head.

Posted

Hello everyone. I have been away the past two days so need to see what all I missed. That will most likely be tomorrow during the day as I have to sort my household after my absence.

Posted

I like Ape's cases on Tina, Lenlo.  To a lesser extent on Rand.  Disagree on Peace, though.

 

I still want to have BooBoo's response before moving, but I re-read (most of) the thread in the meantime.  Summary of my thoughts:

 

10. Ape, Reported Day 2 as Cop
15. Verbal, Reported Day 2 as Roleless Innocent
16. AVM, Reported Day 1 as Roleless Innocent (by BooBoo)

 

18. BooBoo, Claimed Day 2 as Reporter

 

3. Song Turin, AFK


7. Peace, Town read
8. Leelou, Town read

14. Nolder, very slight town read

20. Katioria, very slight town read

 

19. Crusher Rand, Slight scum read

1. TGlems, Scum read
4. Lenlo, Scum read
5. Ed, Scum read
13. Tina, Scum read

 

I'm fine with any of the above 5 for today.

Posted

A few highlights from my re-read.  I'm getting tired, though, so I cut if off early.

 

Tglems

Posts 574, 575, 641.  Setup speculation, setup speculation, and more setup speculation.  Pretty much everything he posted D2 was setup speculation.  There were a couple more posts later on as well, IIRC.

 

Lenlo

Post 295.  Fencesitting.  Reads both csarmi and Ape as town, calls out Darthe but otherwise does nothing.  Reads like mafia trying to stay clean in a townie flare-up.

Post 496.  FOSes everyone who wanted to lynch csarmi before his reveal as mafia trying to do away with a potential townie.

 

ed

Post 298.  Says he thinks csarmi is town, then puts a little something about how Ape left himself a way out if csarmi flipped town.  Which is interesting because . . .

Post 517.  Calls out Lenlo's post 496.

Post 565.  Comments on piano's death.  Posts like this always read to me like crocodile tears.

 

Tina

Post 342.  Setup speculation, asking about whether or not two scum teams are realistic for the theme.

Post 357.  Defends csarmi and "unvotes" -- her vote was the first on csarmi (Post 106) and occurred well before that csarmi started acting like an ass -- but her unvote is neither bold or red.

Posted

Also in my wall of text posts, in the middle of me switching from Ishy/booboisie casing to vambram Nolder surfaced and started trying to derail me. As soon as I went back to Ishy, he shut up.

 

Similar thing happened on d2 when I went from Ishy to boohoo nolder got up my ass for switching votes. He goaded me back onto Ishy. If Nolder were to flip scum, it would make sense that he tried keeping me from pursuing vambram, and how about boohoo?

 

Still can't decide about Nolderp. Sigh.

Posted

Well, it´s clear that Ape didn´t view me. So who did he caught in his "trap"? I need to re-read some before adding more but Leelou still looks scummy. 

Posted

I'm concerned about booboo, because he suggested leaving the roleblocker alive and voted for AVM who is the person he reported as town, but since nobody countered bob i have no reason to doubt him. I'm surprised he was left alive last night though.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...