[Advanced] The Dresden Files Mafia - Game Over - Ed loses, Verbal wins

[Tyler Glembo]

 

Also, Dap, if you actually believe your own case then why not vote?  Why just nudge in the direction of CS?

You do know I think he is town and want him alive?

I have a personal issue with him and his play more than a game issue. I'm not one to lynch for that

 

Okay, reread and I missed the last sentence of your #348. 

[peacesells]

Hey Tglems...Darthe is a top 4 poster in the Girls gone wild game.  What does that say about your meta on him?

[csarmi]

John I withdrew my vote from you because apparently I cannot vote everyone who misspelled my name.

It was a bluff anyway. I do feel hurt by it, but everything I ever do in a maffia game is a play. Even when my real "me" would mostly agree.

 

Again, I'd like to ask everyone to use my name correctly. It's really an important point to me.

 

Thank you.

[ed2funy]

You realize that probably isn't going to happen, right? 

 

Also, sounds like major back peddling. 

"It was a bluff anyway." 

 

Really? 

*snort* 

[ed2funy]

Also, unvote, vote Starmie

 

 

[csarmi]

Well, a smi-bluff.

 

Anyway, I'm Demonreach, Roleblocker. I win if I'm alive at the end of the game :)

[csarmi]

Which makes me a safe lynch and you also get an annoying player gone. Two in one eh :)

[ed2funy]

Annnnd, you realize no one will really care about a Solo Win, right? 

[csarmi]

Yep, that's right.

[John E. Kelley]

Well, a smi-bluff.

 

Anyway, I'm Demonreach, Roleblocker. I win if I'm alive at the end of the game :)

 

So you don't win with Town, you're a third party then?

[peacesells]

Roleblocker with a solo victory condition?  I don't buy it.  He's gotta be scum.

 

UNVOTE

 

VOTE CHARMIE

[John E. Kelley]

Roleblocker with a solo victory condition?  I don't buy it.  He's gotta be scum.

 

UNVOTE

 

VOTE CHARMIE

 

You're awfully quick to leap on an easy lynch.

[csarmi]

Actually, I win with Town (if there is any such thing) or with any other party.

[csarmi]

 

Roleblocker with a solo victory condition?  I don't buy it.  He's gotta be scum.

 

UNVOTE

 

VOTE CHARMIE

 

You're awfully quick to leap on an easy lynch.

 

I've been an easy lynch for days now :)

But I'm really hoping that some people would gain something from my coroner's report. I'm trying to help town here you know.

I also realize that as solo & power role you should play low, it's just not my style. It'd never work. Not like this one does.

[dapianoplay3r]

Ok so explain how that role makes sense?

[csarmi]

The Roleblocker, or the solo win?

[csarmi]

I'm a survivor, I win if I'm alive when another party wins.

I'm given the ability to roleblock a player every night. I supposed that would mean that I select a player and his role won't work for that night. 

 

I suppose my superpowers should allow me to stop some maffia kills, detective work, whatever. 

No idea how I should actually use it however.

[ed2funy]

I think Dap means it is an odd combo. 

I thought that at first, because I've never seen it, but it makes sense, imo. 

 

I'm still fine with getting rid of a Solo Roleblocker. 

If the mafia are doing well, you just look for the Cop or Doc to block. 

You could go either way. 

 

So meh. 

[csarmi]

Well, I don't suppose it's going to be that easy to figure out who to roleblock in any case.

 

I think I can do more good alive than dead (especially as my coroner's report won't be very informative now), but it's your call.

 

I'm just trying to help, I don't have much to lose you see.

[Hybrid]

But I'm really hoping that some people would gain something from my coroner's report. I'm trying to help town here you know.

 

We gain just as much from your coroner's report as we would from an innocent one.

 

I'm not entirely sold on the reveal -- though I guess it would be an absolutely horrible fake reveal for a scum player -- but I absolutely do not want a solo-win roleblocker around if the game gets tight.  Vote stands.

[dapianoplay3r]

I had an issue with the combo

Gaming the mod more than anything else, it is just one of those things that doesn't sit we'll with me

Well, I don't suppose it's going to be that easy to figure out who to roleblock in any case.

 

I think I can do more good alive than dead (especially as my coroner's report won't be very informative now), but it's your call.

 

I'm just trying to help, I don't have much to lose you see.

Last line, you have everything to lose. If you are telling the truth you have no alliance to anyone and so the only thing you have is winning the game, which killing you will prevent

You have everything to lose. You also can chose to help or hinder the town, plus you don't chose which side you get counted to, just the faster win. So you are a threat to the town in many ways

 

vote Csarmi

[Nolder]

3rd party roleblocker? You'd have been better off claiming to be town aligned.

Unvote Vote: Csarmi

[Nolder]

Tglems: RVS?

[Leelou]

 

I think he was referring to me...

 

Lets be clear. I think Csarmi is town cos I don't think any mafia team would let this happen how it did

I kept going cos he called me a liar.

 

Depends on who is on the team with him. If there are JN players on the team with him, they might have advised him to keep at it with me until I make so much of a commotion I end up drowning out my own case, and the town moves on because it becomes exhausted with the situation.

 

This is scum's go-to method of dealing with me when I latch on with a solid case. I've seen Booboo do it, Verbal do it, and just about everyone tries. Sometimes I outlast it, usually I find a shiny object or drown myself out.

 

So, while I value your point of view, there's some major meta that makes me doubt your reasoning, at no fault of your own. You could not have know this, but it is very much a reality on JN. I'm reading Leelou as town, she can probably vouch for what I'm saying. Booboo's favorite way of dodging me when he's scum is to arguing peripheral crap with me, and complete avoid addressing the case, which is almost exactly what csack was doing.

 

Leelou is awesome, btw.

 

Ape is telling the truth as far as meta goes, but it's still to early in the game for me to say if he is definitely town or scum. Right now, I'm leaning town. 

 

;-)  I am. 

 

 

Leelou is awesome, btw.

 

Or it's a PR.  Hm.

 

Ape has been known to fake PRs, I'm not reading too much into it. I also wouldn't be surprised if he was asked to be nicer for a bit. 

 

Actually, I win with Town (if there is any such thing) or with any other party.

 

About that.... unvote, vote csarmi

 

3rd party role blockers have way too much power to have the game go which ever way they want it. 

[csarmi]

Yea and they way I want this to go is for town to win. You're doing scums a favour now.