BASE MAFIA - Mafia Wins!

[John E. Kelley]

Look back man, never did I say "Snow is the cop" or any variant of that.

 

Well that's completely contradicted by what you yourself just said. I'm just taking what you said at face value. I'd scroll back through pages to see what the truth actually is, but meh, too lazy.

[Andrej]

Well, the proof is there.

 

True, I probably tipped them off but I'm not the only one who came to that conclusion. Lesson learned, old school. I'm hitting the ground running with this DM Mafia biz.

[John E. Kelley]

Hey smartass!! Yeah, you Mr. Mod. I just noticed that you named one of your characters in your BT game Ishmael Forsaken. And made him the Mafia GF??

 

Hardee har har......

[Darthe]

I got you in the black tower Suck it.

[michellem]

I see you have just quietly dropped your case on me now AJ, hoping nobody will remember it, since all your reasons for it has fallen through...

 

 

Time, I see you had enough time to stop by, but again not giving any thoughts...

 

Chuckles, TG, Dap... Where are you guys today?

[dapianoplay3r]

I was planning to go after TG guns blazing but I'm changing my mind and saying lets lynch AJ or Ishy

 

Well, interesting. I had a thought that Snow was the cop... I don't think I was the only one in that logic. Funny Turin, I think you sort of directed a NK from the mafia team. Desperation at it's finest.i wasn't feeling the cop vibe like you were but this is where AJ starts to set up using the NK to his advantage

 

Anyway, in light of what happened yesterday I must say that I think I have likely been completely wrong on just about everything this game. I don't know why, but I just didn't recognize the things some of you were seeing in Peace. He almost had me at DL too with his mention that the Vig was a NA only role, seeing as how it wasn't specified until after.

 i feel the paragraph before just hinting at his newbieness and trying to do damage control on his play with regards to Peace yesterday

For now, I think my vote will go to one of the lurkers. Someone who hasn't contributed much in this game and I think was forced to vote yesterday since he showed up at DL. Even then, he seemed noncommittal until after the reveal.

 wants to lynch an inactive. The other reason was valid but the fact he said that just sends my mafia senses tingling

Also, with Peace's flip... I'd like to bring up this beauty.

 

 

Yo

 

wazz up peace ;)

  rebuttal http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/79409-base-mafia-day-3/?p=2787411 or http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/79409-base-mafia-day-3/?p=2788105

You get the same buddying from chuckles and peace gives you a link on thread to cover any coaching happening on the QT

Turin already pointed this out when he did all his casing back in D1, but I didn't think much of it back then. Could still be nothing, but I know he was around when Turin mentioned Snow being the cop yesterday to RTE when he swapped his vote back. The fact that Snow is now dead seemed like the scum team got hopeful, not surprised.

 

vote chuckles

  

Yeah, I think the mafia goofed on that one. Instead of killing the only confirmed townie they went after Snow.

AJ starts playing up that the mafia made a mistake with the NK. It feels calculated to me, especially the way people are ting to spin it as the opposite

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

That is a good case; especially since it seems like he's protecting Peace while trying to push the heat onto Turin. I think he and AJ might be the last two mafia members. It makes even more sense with how AJ tried to descredit my ponderings about him and TG.

 

 

As to the bolded, I can't decide whether AJ is scum, or just really, really excited to be playing in his first game. I'm leaning more towards Time for her refusal to vote Peace and stay on Turin. Add that to her lurky play and she doesn't really pass the smell test, at least to me.

 defends AJ

Also, look back at the night kill. The fact that scum wouldn't NK a vetted Townie, and instead kill someone who was already catching a lot of heat and was already a prime lynch candidate seems to point to a newbie Mafia team.

or a mafia trying to spin the team as so which would make them more likely not soI don't know whether or not Darthe or Len would allow Peace to continue posting in the QT probably, especially if its a new team. But I don't remember the last game I played that they left the QT when killedor not, but no way would a veteran scum member choose Snow as the NK. Were I scum, he would definitely not have been my choice, better to let Town lynch him and keep my hands clean. So that being said, look to some of the newer players for the remaining Mafia. I like TG and Time right now as the last two.the if I were scum part really annoys me. I could see you doing it. If for no other reason than to confuse people, especially new players

I agree with this. Like I stated earlier, they goofed by targeting Snow instead of the only vetted town member i disagree. I'm thinking it's TG with either Chucky or Time as the other member, both have been lurky. Not to mention it was commented that Snow was the cop before the RTE lynching. I think they got hopeful when they went for him that they'd knock off another PR since the vig had already been revealed.

 

Now see, that right there is the kind of thing that keeps me from completely discrediting the whole "AJ as scum" idea. Was this a Freudian slip, letting us know what you were thinking last night as you sent in your NA? Because your knowledge of the only credible reason that a scum team might want to NK Snow is telling. Keeping my eye on you sir.

Ishy and AJ distance from each other but are leading people the me direction. I don't like it at all

[dapianoplay3r]

That god that worked. I meant to press preview not post. I hadn't checked any of that code

 

And sorry for the delay I only just woke up

[John E. Kelley]

 

I was planning to go after TG guns blazing but I'm changing my mind and saying lets lynch AJ or Ishy

 

Well, interesting. I had a thought that Snow was the cop... I don't think I was the only one in that logic. Funny Turin, I think you sort of directed a NK from the mafia team. Desperation at it's finest.i wasn't feeling the cop vibe like you were but this is where AJ starts to set up using the NK to his advantage

 

Anyway, in light of what happened yesterday I must say that I think I have likely been completely wrong on just about everything this game. I don't know why, but I just didn't recognize the things some of you were seeing in Peace. He almost had me at DL too with his mention that the Vig was a NA only role, seeing as how it wasn't specified until after.

 i feel the paragraph before just hinting at his newbieness and trying to do damage control on his play with regards to Peace yesterday

For now, I think my vote will go to one of the lurkers. Someone who hasn't contributed much in this game and I think was forced to vote yesterday since he showed up at DL. Even then, he seemed noncommittal until after the reveal.

 wants to lynch an inactive. The other reason was valid but the fact he said that just sends my mafia senses tingling

Also, with Peace's flip... I'd like to bring up this beauty.

 

Yo

 

 

wazz up peace ;)

ockquote>  rebuttal http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/79409-base-mafia-day-3/?p=2787411 or http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/79409-base-mafia-day-3/?p=2788105

You get the same buddying from chuckles and peace gives you a link on thread to cover any coaching happening on the QT

Turin already pointed this out when he did all his casing back in D1, but I didn't think much of it back then. Could still be nothing, but I know he was around when Turin mentioned Snow being the cop yesterday to RTE when he swapped his vote back. The fact that Snow is now dead seemed like the scum team got hopeful, not surprised.

 

vote chuckles

  

Yeah, I think the mafia goofed on that one. Instead of killing the only confirmed townie they went after Snow.

AJ starts playing up that the mafia made a mistake with the NK. It feels calculated to me, especially the way people are ting to spin it as the opposite

  

 

 

 

 

 

That is a good case; especially since it seems like he's protecting Peace while trying to push the heat onto Turin. I think he and AJ might be the last two mafia members. It makes even more sense with how AJ tried to descredit my ponderings about him and TG.

 

As to the bolded, I can't decide whether AJ is scum, or just really, really excited to be playing in his first game. I'm leaning more towards Time for her refusal to vote Peace and stay on Turin. Add that to her lurky play and she doesn't really pass the smell test, at least to me.

 defends AJ

Also, look back at the night kill. The fact that scum wouldn't NK a vetted Townie, and instead kill someone who was already catching a lot of heat and was already a prime lynch candidate seems to point to a newbie Mafia team.

or a mafia trying to spin the team as so which would make them more likely not soI don't know whether or not Darthe or Len would allow Peace to continue posting in the QT probably, especially if its a new team. But I don't remember the last game I played that they left the QT when killedor not, but no way would a veteran scum member choose Snow as the NK. Were I scum, he would definitely not have been my choice, better to let Town lynch him and keep my hands clean. So that being said, look to some of the newer players for the remaining Mafia. I like TG and Time right now as the last two.the if I were scum part really annoys me. I could see you doing it. If for no other reason than to confuse people, especially new players

I agree with this. Like I stated earlier, they goofed by targeting Snow instead of the only vetted town member i disagree. I'm thinking it's TG with either Chucky or Time as the other member, both have been lurky. Not to mention it was commented that Snow was the cop before the RTE lynching. I think they got hopeful when they went for him that they'd knock off another PR since the vig had already been revealed.

 

Now see, that right there is the kind of thing that keeps me from completely discrediting the whole "AJ as scum" idea. Was this a Freudian slip, letting us know what you were thinking last night as you sent in your NA? Because your knowledge of the only credible reason that a scum team might want to NK Snow is telling. Keeping my eye on you sir.

Ishy and AJ distance from each other but are leading people the me direction. I don't like it at all

 

 

This entire post is gibberish. Translation please?

[John E. Kelley]

Code fail, blah.

[dapianoplay3r]

Read all of it. My thoughts in blue

 

I think you and AJ are mafia. Both of you are distancing but at the same time you are trying to lead the town to think that snow was a mistake and that mafia must be noobs

[John E. Kelley]

Read all of it. My thoughts in blue

 

I think you and AJ are mafia. Both of you are distancing but at the same time you are trying to lead the town to think that snow was a mistake and that mafia must be noobs

 

But I do think that. And if you think I'm Mafia, make the case, simply saying it doesn't make it true.

[Andrej]

I see you have just quietly dropped your case on me now AJ, hoping nobody will remember it, since all your reasons for it has fallen through...

 

 

Time, I see you had enough time to stop by, but again not giving any thoughts...

 

Chuckles, TG, Dap... Where are you guys today?

Hardly Mish. I haven't backed down from anything I've said or done all game. Frankly, I'm content to let it lie now in the events that I was very wrong about Peace. At the time it looked to me that you were hopping on another train.

 

Anyway, quite the turn from you Dap. What did you mean by the "me" direction?

[dapianoplay3r]

I will. And one on AJ. I was just posting my thoughts from my read of what happened last night as I was sleeping

[dapianoplay3r]

Sorry I didn't even see that. It should say "same"

[Andrej]

Also Dap, you're being rather short sighted. How is that you think I'm suddenly teammates with Ishy when before he replaced Rand I was going hard at Rand for his lack of play? Open your eyes man. That, or are you just offended that some people think your NK was a bad one?

[michellem]

Gambit, dude. It's already been explained. Teammates go at each other all the time.

[dapianoplay3r]

It is a turn around. I have you pinned but that recent stuff overshadows the distancing on day one in my eyes

 

and if i was mafia i wouldnt of picked Snow. I do see the merit of picking someone like him though. Mafia dont generally make mistakes like typing tge wrong name to nk. It was planned. It may not of been the best move but it was planned

[John E. Kelley]

So that was your "case" against me Dap?

 

Not very impressed. Lame case is lame.

[dapianoplay3r]

On my.phone. Ill do it later when i can actually multi quote

havent voted yet have i.

[John E. Kelley]

Don't have to vote to case someone sir.

[dapianoplay3r]

You need to be able to go back and read. Its almost impossible on my phonne. You will wait and deal with it when im able to do it

 

atleast im active and stay posting rather than dissappearing

[Turin Turambar]

AJ, can you show me where I stated I thought Snow was the cop? I just looked back at the last 15 pages and I don't see it. Also on the Rand thing, Peace was after him and Rand did come back slightly with a defense stting it was deflection on Peace's part. also Ishy had claimed Peace as the scummiest player in the game. If my thought was correct and Peace picking Rand was a try for a bus then it would be even more beneficial if BOTH the remaining mafiosos were pushing that lynch cause they would NEVER do that

[John E. Kelley]

AJ, can you show me where I stated I thought Snow was the cop? I just looked back at the last 15 pages and I don't see it. Also on the Rand thing, Peace was after him and Rand did come back slightly with a defense stting it was deflection on Peace's part. also Ishy had claimed Peace as the scummiest player in the game. If my thought was correct and Peace picking Rand was a try for a bus then it would be even more beneficial if BOTH the remaining mafiosos were pushing that lynch cause they would NEVER do that

 

Was this stating that you think that Peace and I were Mafia attempting to distance/bus each other? Just wanting to make sure where everyones thoughts are right now.

[dapianoplay3r]

See im not crazy. Others can concieve it too

[John E. Kelley]

And the prevailing thought is that this was originally conceived by Peace and........Rand?