[BASIC] A Long Walk - Game over. Town Wins!

[bgrishinko]

Well hrm. I just ninja'd Rand with like the exact same post.

[bgrishinko]

Super ninja skills back and forth.

[hazelkrs1]

JLM could be a good direction to go in to apply pressure, but for now I wanna follow a hunch

 

Vote Kae

 

Yes yes, I always seem to find her scummy, but replacing in and then immediately going for the NK frame job angle still bothers me

 

Was surprised to see TG flip town, and it's also kind of strange that the lynch took so long to secure being that he was town.

[hazelkrs1]

Also, who was it again that came in asking about the number of mafia or w/e? Was that Snow? Can anyone help refresh my memory?

 

And I should also mention that I'm off for my 5 days, so I will not be quite as active as usual.

[JenLenaMom]

Okay well, I'm going to have to agree with Darthe here. Mafia is looking to jump on a bandwagon but seem afraid to start it. Therefore

 

Vote JLM

 

Care to elaborate on "not the only one its worth looking at?"

 

I mean, if someone else finds Darthe scummy maybe there's something to look at, beyond my feeling that he is always scummy. Does that make any more sense?

 

And yes I disappeared for a while I know, See KaeKey's game for why, I needed a mafia break before i broke something.

[Sakaea]

Ok Kaylee I read what you said but what's your point? I mean I can get what you're driving at but it always bugs me when people post a bunch of quotes and then just leave it up to the reader to decide what it all means

Ok, for Darthe: He pulls up his case on GF but only votes Ishy with a "you beat me to it". Was there another reason besides that he jumped in with a vote? Also he then asks Despo to case TG. Was that because Despo found him scummy? Or Darthe does? If Darthe does, why ask someone else to case? Snow: He originally votes Nol. He later agrees about the slip up from GF but, as the final vote count shows, never switched his vote. He finds someone else scummy but doesn't change his vote off a joke vote? That really pings to me. Then his last post is about how many scum there are. Why? Wondering if we have them all pegged already?

Here it is Kae

 

 

I can agree with this casing on Snow.

 

My interview went well, I think.

[Darthe]

No roles. VT or Goon. Here we are so far

 

1. John Snow

2. Rand

3. Darthe

4. Kaylee

5. GF - Water Thief lynched day 1. http://www.dragonmou...80#entry2631205

6. Despo

7. TGlems Thirsty plane crash victim lynched day 2. http://www.dragonmou...2/#entry2638907

8. JLM

9. Red/Ishy

10. Mish/Sakaea 2.0

11. BG

12. Nolder - Thirsty plane crash victim Night killed night 2. http://www.dragonmou...2/#entry2639706

13. Sakaea - Thirsty plane crash victim Night killed night 1. http://www.dragonmou...1/#entry2632299

[peacesells]

Vote Count:

 

JLM (1): Ishy, BG, Rand

 

Sakaea (1): Despo

 

John Snow (1): Sakaea

 

 

Not Voting: John Snow, Darthe, Kaylee, JLM, Sakaea

 

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch. Deadline is Thursday 5 PM MDT.

[peacesells]

RAND!

 

yes?

 

RAND!

 

yes?

 

You have been chosen. You shall decide.

 

me?

 

PICK ONE. KAYLEE OR JOHN SNOW. YOU HAVE UNTIL 11 AM MDT TOMORROW TO DECIDE.

 

DO NOT FAIL ME.

[peacesells]

I'm off for halloweenie stuffage. So no updates probably till the morning.

[Darthe]

And now to update with reads (based on a reread I just completed):

 

1. John Snow

2. Rand

3. Darthe

4. Kaylee

5. GF - Water Thief lynched day 1. http://www.dragonmou...80#entry2631205

6. Despo (on his meta but low post counts lately. this has happened everywhere or it would ping)

7. TGlems Thirsty plane crash victim lynched day 2. http://www.dragonmou...2/#entry2638907

8. JLM

9. Red/Ishy (though I disagree with some of how ishy has played this game, he was the first vote on GF and I have to assume this is a small mafia team so when his second post is a vote for the first mafia flip we have and he continues to push the vote I assume he is town)

10. Mish/Sakaea 2.0

11. BG

12. Nolder - Thirsty plane crash victim Night killed night 2. http://www.dragonmou...2/#entry2639706

13. Sakaea - Thirsty plane crash victim Night killed night 1. http://www.dragonmou...1/#entry2632299

 

Green is confirmed town (including myself because i know my alignment), Red is confirmed not town (trying not to say mafia because of the listing "water thief") blue are my town reads, orange are my mafia leads, black are my null reads.

 

Vote JLM, I will quote soon

[Darthe]

Rand, it is your call but I think Snow is the better choice.

 

Does anyone else think we should all weigh in on who Rand chooses?

[RandA lThor]

yes, I definitely want input on who I choose

[Sakaea]

Well, since I'm voting for John Snow, maybe you could kill him and we can lynch Kaylee? Or we could do it the other way around. Mafia could be hiding by being inactive, and trying to "ride the edge" of rule 15. If that's the case, they sure didn't realize how close to the edge they were

[Sakaea]

I meant that since I'm voting for him, I think he's possible scum, and therefore a good choice to kill. What I just posted doesn't make sense upon re-read, my bad.

[Darthe]

Unvote

Vote GF

for bandwagoning on my joke vote and general scummy behavior. Although if he flips town I'm going to start believing Darthe really is mafia all the time. :p

 

Well, he flipped mafia and you still seem to think me mafia.

 

Okay, I've got a year on you since I started Feb. last year and I've only been mafia around 9 times. You've been mafia quite a bit.

 

I just figured this out! I play around 3-5 games at a time. do you play that much?

 

You can't give the reasoning requested and I have given you opportunities to the point that I stuck my neck out. IMO you can die now. Would have done this yesterday if I had known.

 

Just gonna leave this here.

 

Since deadline is close & I may not be on later, Vote GF

 

Not much to this and it was the hammer. However, I really liked the giant WoT's placed in late game. Could possibly be mafia saving her own ass by attempting to look over-townie but the casework didn't read as forced to me.

 

I still get a scummy vibe from Darthe but I really think it's just Darthe being Darthe and that's how I read him so I'm willing to ignore it for now.

 

 

TG however I don't like this at all.

Out of curiousity Ishy, what was your reasoning on the GF vote?

 

Defending GF.

Someone hammer this turkey please

 

Why are you pushing to have this vote happen quickly when there is still time before the deadline?

 

Trying to derail the lynch.

 

Vote Tglems

 

And this happened. First vote on TG

 

Vote Ishy

 

I think he jumped into the game and threw a vote on a teammate

Notice how afterwards he really tries to trump up his involvement and take credit for the lynch but right after his vote he does everything under the sun to distract the town from paying attention to it

This guy is scum

Book it

 

*sigh*

 

Thought you were smarter than this Nol. If I were scum, and I'm not, I would feel absolutely no reason to need to buss a teammate in my very first act as a replacement. And if I were scum, and saw one or two votes build on my teammate, I would have jumped off and played it off as my proverbial joke vote.

 

Plus, isn't it a little early for voting based on a gut feeling? Because you damn sure don't have anything else backing it up.

 

But by all means, come at me bro. Kae's dead, I don't mind an early exit in the slightest.

 

Sad ishy was sad, cannot decide how to feel about this post.

 

Post reread thoughts: Ishy's vote didn't really look like a bus vote, atm I don't find him scummy. TGlems is still uberscummy, and stopped posting. Kaylee, Rand, or Mish might be the last scum (assuming 3 mafia based on Peace saying he'd keep it closer to 20% mafia ratio).

 

Nol, do you seriously not see TG's scumminess?

I"m trying! Although I should now be able to keep up and post more. She's been a few days without getting sick.

 

I like your case on Snow Kaylee. I wasn't really paying him all that much attention, but you raised some pretty good points, and that quote where he's asking everyone if Peace said 2-3 scum total or w/e is actually kind of a giant ping, it really seems like he was trying to play the clueless townie angle there. After reading your stuff on him, I actually got a pretty strong antitown read on him now

 

As for Darthe, I just don't think he's mafia. I think his abrasive playstyle has pinged more to people than anything, which has gotten him the attention he has. But he has raised some very good points throughout the game, and pointing out that thing from the OP just a bit ago is pretty big.

 

@Darthe: You really want me to make a case on TGlems? Blech. He... defended GF. Hardcore. Do I really have to case him?

 

I do wonder what has Despo so busy, he usually loves to case the hell out of everyone. Either way, he did case earlier in the game and sort of fell off activity wise around here. Still have a pretty strong town read.

 

Back after my 20 year class reunion this weekend, I cannot stay out as late as I used to and still function. OY!

 

I agree Rand needs pressure as well, but all these leads you keep bringing up still seem secondary to me Nol.

 

TGlems still has the most obvious stuff against him. He gots to go.

 

Don't really agree with the bolded. But the underlined I do. Rand is definitely a good target for tomorrow, especially if TG turns out to be mafia.

 

In day 2 I haven't been because i haven't found anything to contribute to.

 

The lynch of a water thief and you haven't found something to contribute to? That's almost enough to make me change my mind and vote to lynch you today.

 

I think we have short enough time to deadline at this point that trying to get everyone here to jump to a new train is going to be really difficult.But if it does happen I could be ok swinging over to Rand.

 

Again setting up lynches and also confirms that JLM knows their is more than one Water thief. Based on the flip, I had initially assumed this was like an SK though I think it has since become clear that it is the mafia thematically speaking. Nonetheless, JLM seems to know and has once more set up a contingent lynch.

[Darthe]

I messed this up by not highlighting des in blue. fixed here, please disregard the first.

 

And now to update with reads (based on a reread I just completed):

 

1. John Snow

2. Rand

3. Darthe

4. Kaylee

5. GF - Water Thief lynched day 1. http://www.dragonmou...80#entry2631205

6. Despo (on his meta but low post counts lately. this has happened everywhere or it would ping, )

7. TGlems Thirsty plane crash victim lynched day 2. http://www.dragonmou...2/#entry2638907

8. JLM

9. Red/Ishy (though I disagree with some of how ishy has played this game, he was the first vote on GF and I have to assume this is a small mafia team so when his second post is a vote for the first mafia flip we have and he continues to push the vote I assume he is town)

10. Mish/Sakaea 2.0

11. BG

12. Nolder - Thirsty plane crash victim Night killed night 2. http://www.dragonmou...2/#entry2639706

13. Sakaea - Thirsty plane crash victim Night killed night 1. http://www.dragonmou...1/#entry2632299

 

Green is confirmed town (including myself because i know my alignment), Red is confirmed not town (trying not to say mafia because of the listing "water thief") blue are my town reads, orange are my mafia leads, black are my null reads.

 

Vote JLM

[JenLenaMom]

I'm assuming that Water Thief is the name of the mafia players.

[RandA lThor]

guys who should I get?

 

So far I have 2 for Snow.

[bgrishinko]

I'm pretty much in most every game vi remember to sign up for sometimes I miss one here or there, or else if I'm Modding sometimes I skip some sign ups.

[Darthe]

guys who should I get?

 

So far I have 2 for Snow.

 

Don't get me wrong, I think both should die I just happen to think that considering how the day has went Snow will give us more current info.

[RandA lThor]

I would like some more input before I modkill, but I am leaning towards Snow right now.

[John E. Kelley]

To be completely fair, I'm not very happy with either options.

 

But I'll trust Kae. I'll go with her and say Snow.

[Darthe]

I'm sort of annoyed that the effort I put into my casework and presenting my reads on people is going unnoticed because of this.

[John E. Kelley]

I'm sort of annoyed that the effort I put into my casework and presenting my reads on people is going unnoticed because of this.

 

It hasn't. It's just that I already reached the same conclusion as you did earlier.