[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[RandA lThor]

ninjad, but most of my points still stand.

[keyholder21]

Official Vote Count:

 

BG (4) – Cyan, Rand, Red, darthe

 

Darthe (4) – NS, BG, EP, Mish

 

 

Not voting (12) - Kaylee, Songs, Snow, Verb, JLM, Des, peace, Ishy, Eddie, Razen, Basel, dice

 

With 20 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

 

A Gladiator Challenge has been issued! You must now vote for either BG or Darthe. 2 contestants in the Game of Thrones one-on-one; who will live?

[Gabriel Kross]

Lynch this scummy ^

 

You didn't even respond to his claim first of all.

 

Second of all, that was not a scummy bandwagon vote, I have stated my reasons before. Something tells me that you would not have said that if my vote was for Darthe, hmm?

 

Third of all, he was right about what he did as gladiator.

 

Fourth of all, I can't check mafiascum or epicmafia at school, but I have never heard of a mafia gladiator. Doesn't seem beneficial to mafia either as it highers the chance of them getting lynched.

 

It states on Mafia scum that it has both a town and a mafia variant. I only know this because I was one of the Javier Gladiators in the Spider Country game. I did respond to his claim btw when he claimed his ability. I don't believe him anymore now than I did then, also I already have you labled as scum by circumstance for replacing WoT13.

[bgrishinko]

Right. So I was doubled exactly like I said.. Would be a pretty stupid fake claim since if I live through today I would have to use that ability again at some point... So just no to basically everything EP says.. Honestly, listening to the guy at this point should be considered anti-town play. And I do not know where the whole Khal Drogo thing came from but I never claimed that because I am not he. BG has a scummy fake claim though. Gentry. Good enough to get a name in the show but not very important otherwise, it is a good claim. However, it is not so good as mine. I am Jon Umber, the Greatjon himself. Bannerman to Robb Stark, the King in the North.

 

Cannot wait to see what you have to say to that BGscumco

 

Um, sounds like you are describing your own fake claim to me.

[Darthe]

Still dumb. I have two uses, end of story. Ill prove it if I live and if not then you'll see it in the flip. Either way do me a favor and make sure that EP is lower on the totem pole than the film that builds at the corner of your mouth after bad sleep when I prove him wrong... Again.

[Darthe]

Right. So I was doubled exactly like I said.. Would be a pretty stupid fake claim since if I live through today I would have to use that ability again at some point... So just no to basically everything EP says.. Honestly, listening to the guy at this point should be considered anti-town play. And I do not know where the whole Khal Drogo thing came from but I never claimed that because I am not he. BG has a scummy fake claim though. Gentry. Good enough to get a name in the show but not very important otherwise, it is a good claim. However, it is not so good as mine. I am Jon Umber, the Greatjon himself. Bannerman to Robb Stark, the King in the North.

 

Cannot wait to see what you have to say to that BGscumco

 

Um, sounds like you are describing your own fake claim to me.

 

Correct me if I am wrong here but their are no mod given fake claims this game according to the OP, right? So claiming the Greatjon would be pretty dumb if I wasn't him. Intelligent reply though, you definitely turned it around on me with that one! (Sarcasm btw)

[Gabriel Kross]

Blah blah blah^

[ed2funy]

The only issue with the whole Darthe being doubled thing is it could be possible, but using doesn't mean you are Town. And who would you use it on?

[RandA lThor]

Blah blah blah^

 

Thank you EP for these intelligent replies that did not respond to my questions before this at all. /sarcasm

[bgrishinko]

All right... let's see what we have here. I've left out quotes that didn't seem relevant to gameplay (stuff about book cannon and spam) and a few other inbetween quotes I didn't really feel were consequential one way or another.

 

This post will take us through N1.

 

 

no BG i'm supportive of geting rid of a person that thinks they know a series well enough to argue it when they clearly dont and on top of that is being a jerk about it.

 

espeically since i think he's doign it on purpose, i dont believe his claim, i think he's tryign to cause a distraction and cause chaos to limit the amoutn of D1 info we can gain and becuase he's not reacting well to pressure and his play is very sloppy.

Just checkin for slip-ups and how you'd react. No backtracking so you check out so far.

You expected Red to backtrack? And they say I'm still new ).)

This is the entirety of what Darthe has hung his arguement about me being scummy is hooked on, but he doesn't really get around to clarifying that for a really long time. Doesn't seem to find it too terribly scummy yet.

 

Well, I have reread and have to say I think my vote goes best here: Unvote Vote BG

Also, I didn't see a reason why from either of you but I believe both Ishy and Despo think me scummy now?

Well, I have reread and have to say I think my vote goes best here: Unvote Vote BG

Also, I didn't see a reason why from either of you but I believe both Ishy and Despo think me scummy now?

Ironic post is ironic

And this post from Nolder is as relevant today as it was on Day 1. Darthe voted for me without giving a reason.

 

Well since Red is going talking about this in the mafia grievences thread. (which btw is bad juju) let me give a bit of incite that I have gleaned from this whole thing.

 

Darthe- loves to come at me call my actions illogical. Was also the one that gave me this idea due to a similar scenario by him. No comment from him about the whole thing. Very fishy.

Verb- Unknown entity as of yet gut still telling me not to trust him.

Red- Loves to bulldog possible jesters. Red introduced I may be a jester and backed down. Way off from her style. Defended Verb early on, pressed hard against me even after I revealed my character. Is now ignoring me, when I could say something very useful at any time.

Desp- Suspect, I'm getting a repeat gut feeling from the last GoT game based on his actions, and how he is handleing my actions.

Leelou- getting a town read on, she likes to throw jibes at me when she is town, especially when I pull my stunts.

LZM- already stated in response to BG c/p so you don't have to find it I want to know why LZM hasn't flipped his lid about a claim and a modconfirm yet. It's against his meta to take it this well in stride. Earlier I was just poking fun at him, now I'm genuinely curious.

Ed-unknown but I want to lean town on him. Will be watching closely

BG- a bit worried, he called out 2 bigginers for something that would be what I feel to be an experienced play.

John Snow- He is scum, it is known.

 

This is all just from purposefully pissing people off to get reads. Valid style, not recomended for every game but valid nonetheless.

Strangely enough I somewhat agree with this. Obviously John Snow and EP are pretty safe for the day, claiming Ed and Rickon (I think someone claimed Jon as well?)

BG still sticks out like a sore thumb to me here. I disagree with the statements in red atm. We have the claim from John I believe, and I do not see what Verb or Despo have done that is pingy. As for the last sentence of Red's that is... red.. well, that is perception I suppose.

EP already hit on this, but I'm in a bit of a disagreement with him about it. I don't think this was a scum slip, just Darthe wasn't highlighting his disagreement about himself, I'd assume that was implied.

I also found it funny that Red asked me why I voted BG then voted BG next post :p

And yet he still never gave a reason to vote for me, at least Red gave a reason, she wanted to know yours, which you never really provided.

 

Why should I own up to how bad it looks, when I made the mistake as a townie? I made a mistake, then the question remains whether it means I'm scum. And it doesn't, so I still think I've struck a nerve. Feeling pretty good about where I placed my vote.

This all looked like townie flail to me until here. If you make the mistake as a member of the town, then why wouldn't you own up to it? It isn't a big deal to make an error and not admitting that is both scummy and misleading which can create WIFOM or, at least, confusion.

Seems fairly certain NS is town at this point. Not a problem, I think I was too.

 

R&U Mod lady. Nightstrike, you can't expect her to not see you as scummy.. you offended her and it has created a bias regardless of your alignment. /Psych Truth

Also, my apologies for being gone the past two days. Hellova weekend with some sickness thrown it. It is getting cold around here.

Still fighting for Nightstrike.

His alignment. Jesus, pay attention. I have a good feeling Red is town atm. Too much posting for me in this game (I'm in too much lately and have the flu) but am trying to catch up so my apologies there. She is at least on her meta. Nol is obvious town but I think that being confirmed is messing with his scumhunting ability some because others are still questioning it. That is truly pingy to me. Ishy is probably townie as well. Nightstrike and BG both interest me highly and EP is null tell as ever because he is anti-town regardless of alignment. There are some of my thoughts, more to come later.

I forgot to quote who he was responding to, I think it was something about Nolder. Casting doubt on EP and Snow. Starts to feel NS is scummy. Tries to get people to discount EP again.

[Gabriel Kross]

Blah blah blah^

 

Thank you EP for these intelligent replies that did not respond to my questions before this at all. /sarcasm

 

Go back I actually did respond to you. Better yet I'll even quote it for you. Hello scum I'm EP.

Lynch this scummy ^

 

You didn't even respond to his claim first of all.

 

Second of all, that was not a scummy bandwagon vote, I have stated my reasons before. Something tells me that you would not have said that if my vote was for Darthe, hmm?

 

Third of all, he was right about what he did as gladiator.

 

Fourth of all, I can't check mafiascum or epicmafia at school, but I have never heard of a mafia gladiator. Doesn't seem beneficial to mafia either as it highers the chance of them getting lynched.

 

It states on Mafia scum that it has both a town and a mafia variant. I only know this because I was one of the Javier Gladiators in the Spider Country game. I did respond to his claim btw when he claimed his ability. I don't believe him anymore now than I did then, also I already have you labled as scum by circumstance for replacing WoT13.

[RandA lThor]

Blah blah blah^

 

Thank you EP for these intelligent replies that did not respond to my questions before this at all. /sarcasm

 

Go back I actually did respond to you. Better yet I'll even quote it for you. Hello scum I'm EP.

Lynch this scummy ^

 

You didn't even respond to his claim first of all.

 

Second of all, that was not a scummy bandwagon vote, I have stated my reasons before. Something tells me that you would not have said that if my vote was for Darthe, hmm?

 

Third of all, he was right about what he did as gladiator.

 

Fourth of all, I can't check mafiascum or epicmafia at school, but I have never heard of a mafia gladiator. Doesn't seem beneficial to mafia either as it highers the chance of them getting lynched.

 

It states on Mafia scum that it has both a town and a mafia variant. I only know this because I was one of the Javier Gladiators in the Spider Country game. I did respond to his claim btw when he claimed his ability. I don't believe him anymore now than I did then, also I already have you labled as scum by circumstance for replacing WoT13.

 

Oh thanks, I didn't see that.

 

First of all, if I remember correctly, you were town Javier then. I was mafia Javier.

 

Second of all, I was ninjad on the claim thing, but there are no fake claims first of all, so I don't know how you would think someone who seems important you would just pass up on

 

Third of all, WoT mainly was fairly inactive, which is why I replaced her. Thats the main reason she looked scummy.

 

But thanks for the mafiascum clarification. However, first of all, I don't know why he would do that right now if he already looked scummy, it would just increase his chances of getting lynched.

[John E. Kelley]

So BG, what role do you enable?

[bgrishinko]

Day 2:

 

Well that is difficult. The mafia has semi-WIFOMed this. Big FoS to those of you who quickly jumped onto the nightstrike wagon, ya'll are far to experienced to make such a rookie move. And look who it was, I am content to move my vote back to where it was yesterday. Vote BGscummerson

Says this is difficult, then immediately says jumping on Strike is a rookie move. If it is a rookie move, then why is it difficult.

guys theres no need for us to be moving this fast. we gain info from Nights lynch yes, but theres plenty of time and it would be better to pressure another person and get more info. about all the info that can be gained from Night at this point can be gained.

i'm not saying Night shouldn't be lynched, i agree with my previous pressure on him and my thoughts haven't changed abotu him. but i dislike basiclaly wasting this day by only focusing on him. this lynch feels scum driven tbh, in more ways than one.

^ for emphasis

He actually got ninja'd by Rand inbetween these two posts, but this is what he was referring to. He agrees whole heartedly with Red's notion to turn away from the NS lynch and focus on other things.

Vote NS. I've been away all day long, so a good deal of this is stuff that I have been beaten to the argument. But his supplying an entire list without any reason was something I've never seen in any game before that I can recall. Voting or FoSing one person with no case, yes I've seen that, but a full scum list? The comment that he hopes town loses pings hard. Who wants town to lose? That's right: scum! And let's not forget the blatant and unrepentant OMGUS on Red, backed up by the logic of "she's wrong and must therefore be scum". Riiiight. I think that if Basel 1.0 were still around, that he might have NKed NS just on policy for all the trolling.

So if NS is scum, and is lynched... win. If NS is town and is lynched... well, he has not been a team player and has not really made an attempt to be helpful toward town. So not as big a win, but I'd still call it a small win.

I can't tell if that push was complete sarcasm or if you really are that bad as mafia..

Tada. We really didn't need the impressionism.. Its only point is to try and buff your own image in the game and it reads as very.. theatrical. AKA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNtrJc03Beo

Gee, here's a radical thought for you... I might honestly believe that NS is scum? You present the only options here as me being sarcastic, or that I'm just really bad as scum, as if these are the only two possibilities there are. You respond with a confusing post that doesn't even quote who you're replying to. And then you go on to say you don't need the impressionism. Where do you get impressionism? If I see someone as scum, do you seriously expect me to not call them out?

I fully expect you to play to your beliefs in game, however the bolded is clear Impressionism and a quite blatant push on someone who is already almost certain to die. Not to mention that nobody needed this case rehashed, it's only purpose, again, is to make it appear as if you're scum hunting. Good job on the far overly defensive reply though, kudos. Again, if you wanted to help the town at least give something more than what everyone else already knows thrown about in a different manner.

 

I'm baffled by Darthe's responses. Basel's thoughts seemed quite organized and normal to me.

 

Nice way of twisting things.

I only cast doubt on his verifying you.

Because let's face it, if he knew from the Mods you and John were Town, he would have said so off the bat. And he only said that after constant badgering.

 

Or maybe he didn't want multiple outed mod confirmed town targets? We saw that the mafia decided not to go after either of the claimed characters, why? It's because we still had reasonable doubt pointed at us, now that Nolder has outed that we are modconfirmed to him, then we are the prime night targets.

Casting doubt on something that an in thread mod-confirmed town says is 100% modconfirmed to him is casting doubt onto a modconfirmed town.

Just a quick aside; I hate mechanics like this. It's proxy bullshanks and even if it doesn't cast doubt on Nol it does on you. At worst it will eventually be an almost mod-pushed waste of a day to test how reliable Nol's info is.

Still hints that EP might be scum and that it will need to be tested at some point.

 

 

Hmm. You know Red, you have been calling me scum for a long time now and I haven't seen my name or a reason in any WoT in a long while. Even when you tried to bait me with the "lurking" thing because I was busy for a day that was at least some reason.

And yet, still never presented a case for his vote on me. Ironic post is still Ironic.

 

Wait, when did Red stop being for NS's lynch? I thought we were all pretty much agreed on that and simply stalling to keep this from being a waste day.

My thoughts exactly. Thanks for supporting my argument Darthe.

 

Lolz @ Ishy

Also, I think today has been eventful enough. I have gained enough info that I don't consider it a waste and so now I am finally going to Unvote Vote NS

Maybe once we get this goose out of the way we can move back to BG. Blegh

Fair Enough. Though why you want to move back to me still hasn't been properly explained.

[... back to Basel and Darthe arguement from earlier...]

First off, thank you for clarifying impressionism. I was really confused as to where you were going with it till now.

Secondly... this is one of my biggest mafia grievances. By definition, not everyone can be the first to notice something. Who the first person to catch a ping is depends heavily on who is around during that general time. So if anyone isn't physically present till later, sometimes several hours later, they are screwed because they notice the same thing and for some idiotic reason aren't supposed to point it out. If they call it out, they get called scum for sheeping a ping. A ping which should be just as valid at 6 PM as it is at noon. I've lost count of the number of times in assorted games that I have caught a ping while reading all that's happened while I've been out of the house, and people have already called it out before I even log back on. While I can't expect other players to conform to my personal schedule, I don't appreciate taking heat for being pinged by something that I wasn't physically around to catch when it originally happened. You mentioned how I've rehashed a case that was already out there. So if it pings one person, it can't ping other people? Aren't we supposed to be presenting cases to persuade each other, thus requiring other people to agree with us? These are the reasons that NS pings me; this is why I voted him. I wasn't the first person to take notice of these things. Big fat hairy deal. A ping is a ping either way. So why don't you get off your damn high horse with this rehashing bullshit? I wasn't around to be the first one to call attention to something. Deal with it, cause this really pisses me off.

Wow you seem angry. Deal bro, and chill while you're at it. I haven't even FoS'd you, but it wouldn't be worth much to not test waters when I see something suspect. And you again have missed the point. It isn't simply that you said the same things about NS that others did. It is how you did it and the responses you have given me are quite.. poor tbh. How BG can think you townie is incredible. I bet if one of you is scum the other is as well.

I'm still confused by Darthe's orginal response or how this implies that he is scum because I think he is town.

 

Well okay then, back to unvote vote BG!

Aaand, back to me when NS is proclaimed Town. Big surprise.

 

Rand, at this rate you're going to be a consolidation if you don't speak. Do you have anything to say?

Not to push here or anything but it takes 12 to lynch and there are 21 hours left.

Rand is at L-8 with 4 votes on him.

Tress is suddenly at L-9 with 3 votes on her.

BG is at L-10 with 2 votes on him.

These are our leading people... I do not like the tress lynch because of its' speed. BG is obv scum. Still, we need some consolidation and if you are a power role and one of these three people we are boned if we do not know by early tomorrow.

Gets involved with trying to push people to claim their roles. Despo calls him out on this later incidentally.

 

Guys I have been pushing BG since D1 and nothing he has done this game has been town play. If anyone deserves your votes it is him today, Syrio is a somewhat strange claim but still acceptable. We can use the night to test Rand if he gets 2 of his 4 abilities. This train doesn't make much sense at all and reeks of opportunistic... Hence exactly what I said yesterday.

BTW, loving that you completely disagree with me Despo and say it was pingy of me to tell him he was going to be consolidated etc so he should reveal and then you vote him. I realize that you decided against that but you both argued with me and then helped prove me right.

Darthe still hasn't given a reason for why he has been pushing me since Day 1, but somehow uses that to justify his actions.

 

 

 

It don't look like we're getting anyone but Rand today, I can't wait to say I told you so on Darthe and Verb though. The JoaT claim is convenient since it was discussed in thread though...

unvote vote rand

Remind me what part of me not wanting to lynch Rand is going to look bad on me when he probably flips town JOAT? This was contradictory as * censored*

Darthe seemed fairly certain Rand was town here before the flip.

 

 

Three hours left.

Rand= L-2

BG= L-6

I will be here for consolidation if needed but please dear god vote BG, he is positive scum with the awful plays at emotion and sneakery. And yes, I am damn well tunnel visioned but he is scum so BG I will tunnel your ass into a fine red mist!

Ewww....

+1

When he flips mafiaz you're next.

 

Randomly decides to push the EP could be scum thing again.

 

 

 

That whole thing is still confusing =/ IMO better to leave it alone. Mod confirmed confirms others somehow? It is a good position for town and so long as we find mafiaz then it can wait to be tested.

 

This is confusing to me still.

[Gabriel Kross]

Blah blah blah^

 

Thank you EP for these intelligent replies that did not respond to my questions before this at all. /sarcasm

 

Go back I actually did respond to you. Better yet I'll even quote it for you. Hello scum I'm EP.

Lynch this scummy ^

 

You didn't even respond to his claim first of all.

 

Second of all, that was not a scummy bandwagon vote, I have stated my reasons before. Something tells me that you would not have said that if my vote was for Darthe, hmm?

 

Third of all, he was right about what he did as gladiator.

 

Fourth of all, I can't check mafiascum or epicmafia at school, but I have never heard of a mafia gladiator. Doesn't seem beneficial to mafia either as it highers the chance of them getting lynched.

 

It states on Mafia scum that it has both a town and a mafia variant. I only know this because I was one of the Javier Gladiators in the Spider Country game. I did respond to his claim btw when he claimed his ability. I don't believe him anymore now than I did then, also I already have you labled as scum by circumstance for replacing WoT13.

 

Oh thanks, I didn't see that.

 

First of all, if I remember correctly, you were town Javier then. I was mafia Javier.

 

Second of all, I was ninjad on the claim thing, but there are no fake claims first of all, so I don't know how you would think someone who seems important you would just pass up on

 

Third of all, WoT mainly was fairly inactive, which is why I replaced her. Thats the main reason she looked scummy.

 

But thanks for the mafiascum clarification. However, first of all, I don't know why he would do that right now if he already looked scummy, it would just increase his chances of getting lynched.

 

I had diferent reasons for suspecting WoT13, one of which being Desp commenting on that edited post she made at the very beginning of the game stating what her post was actually about. (Why we let her live at that point is beyond me)

[RandA lThor]

Blah blah blah^

 

Thank you EP for these intelligent replies that did not respond to my questions before this at all. /sarcasm

 

Go back I actually did respond to you. Better yet I'll even quote it for you. Hello scum I'm EP.

Lynch this scummy ^

 

You didn't even respond to his claim first of all.

 

Second of all, that was not a scummy bandwagon vote, I have stated my reasons before. Something tells me that you would not have said that if my vote was for Darthe, hmm?

 

Third of all, he was right about what he did as gladiator.

 

Fourth of all, I can't check mafiascum or epicmafia at school, but I have never heard of a mafia gladiator. Doesn't seem beneficial to mafia either as it highers the chance of them getting lynched.

 

It states on Mafia scum that it has both a town and a mafia variant. I only know this because I was one of the Javier Gladiators in the Spider Country game. I did respond to his claim btw when he claimed his ability. I don't believe him anymore now than I did then, also I already have you labled as scum by circumstance for replacing WoT13.

 

Oh thanks, I didn't see that.

 

First of all, if I remember correctly, you were town Javier then. I was mafia Javier.

 

Second of all, I was ninjad on the claim thing, but there are no fake claims first of all, so I don't know how you would think someone who seems important you would just pass up on

 

Third of all, WoT mainly was fairly inactive, which is why I replaced her. Thats the main reason she looked scummy.

 

But thanks for the mafiascum clarification. However, first of all, I don't know why he would do that right now if he already looked scummy, it would just increase his chances of getting lynched.

 

I had diferent reasons for suspecting WoT13, one of which being Desp commenting on that edited post she made at the very beginning of the game stating what her post was actually about. (Why we let her live at that point is beyond me)

 

Her reason for edited post is because she realized that she was not supposed to post before Kae said it was OK. If you remember, I did the same thing in the Operation Domination game, except I edited when I realized I posted with my alt. Breaking two rules at the same time, thats what Kae was talking about. Posting before and editing.

[Gabriel Kross]

Her reason for editing was that, but her reason for posting was apparently questioning the validity of the mafia win condition.

[RandA lThor]

She was? I did not know that, how do you know? Well, I don't know why she would do that, maybe she was trying to figure out how the game worked.

[Gabriel Kross]

As I said Desp commented on it, he probably recieves full post notifications. I am actually leaning town on Desp at present so I will trust his comment about that.

[RandA lThor]

No he doesn't I just checked.

[michellem]

I couldn't see any refrence to it in the first pages either, so I don't know where you get that info from EP.

[Gabriel Kross]

No he doesn't I just checked.

 

it was somewhere around day 2 there is no way you checked all those posts that fast.

[bgrishinko]

So, back to Darthe. I meant to ask this earlier, but this post sounded odd.

That whole thing is still confusing =/ IMO better to leave it alone. Mod confirmed confirms others somehow? It is a good position for town and so long as we find mafiaz then it can wait to be tested.

You say leave it alone, then leave a question right after.

This was pretty obvious rhetoric.

Glad you can rest in peace now Nol! had to.

Also, we need to lynch BG me says. He is totally scummy.

Had to.......Kill Nolder perhaps? Was that an admission of guilt.?

That just... wow. I can't tell if that's a serious FOS or a bad joke.

Poking back at Darthe.

Poking for what? Only scummy mcscummerson would want to poke someone without reasoning. So mafioso.

 

Accuses me of misinterpreting it on purpose, which I was to get a rise out of him, but interestingly enough is he doesn't deny what I said. Also, to the bolded.... Ironic post is still Ironic.

 

At this rate, we will just be able to lynch everyone who isn't confirmed town and eventually win.

Was just reading through and am amazed I didn't pick this up before. BG, you know how many people are on the mafia team?

 

I can take a guess and be fairly close based upon typical mafia setups. But no I do not how many mafia there are, because I am not mafia. In any case, it was kinda a joke about Nolder being confirmed, then him confirming EP and Snow. Then, in my opinion, Basel is basically confirmed. Then Peace confirms NS, which kinda confirms himself. All assuming nobody is lying of course.

 

So yea, I have to agree BG is coming off as slightly scummy. Mainly because I get a sense of defensiveness and aggresiveness behind his posts.

But then again, so are Basel and yourself, Darthe.

Acceptable, but Hell dude that is just D1. Wait til I post day 2 and do a little analysis.

 

Okay then.... analyze me! Come on now.

 

Speaking of which before I mentioned I had jailed Verb both nights, He never once complained about being blocked, do to evidence of flips and effects, I am of the belief all players are rolled. So him being blocked 2 nights in a row and not saying anything raises suspicion.

The biggest problem here is you're already assuming that Verb is scum, has an ability that works at night every night, and would mention issues with it if both of those things were true. If you have something that makes sense we can all listen and talk about it but this is complete logical fallacy.

 

Hasn't had time to case me, but seemingly has plenty of time to continue to tell people to ignore what EP has to say.

 

 

Hey BG, wanna know why your case on red didn't matter?

 

Because you're scum, that's why.

 

 

I just... I mean... no words for how dumb this post is.... AT LEAST I AM MAKING CASES! And it matters, because I'm town.

 

*ugh*

 

 

Lol now you're baiting a reaction. Is that town play people?

 

I mocked him with basically the same words, and this is his response. *headdesk*

 

I would love something more fleshed out than "you should vote verb because...stuff."

And yes I know, pot meet kettle. I plan to get on the BG case tonight.

Except you are scum yourself, if not you would have vocalised something important come day.

First: you double quoted.

Second: you would literally be more valuable to the town if you voted and didn't speak otherwise

Third: this, once more, makes absolutely no sense. I don't know, use more nouns or something? It's not even that what you're trying to say makes no sense, it's more like you forgot to add certain words or English is a third language or something?

I'm sure everyone other than you picked up that hint.

Nobody has seemed to. You and Ishy had that odd ass interplay and talked. Ed voted with you two because he thought it was odd, not because he picked up something fantastic. Hinting=anti-town play. Say what you mean or stop wasting time.

 

His first post.... Ironic post is still Ironic. At least he recognizes it this time. And EP's response post made sense to me. The second half though I'll admit EP, it took me a while to understand what happened between you and Ishy. I was confused for a bit too.

 

 

Yeah, sorry EP, but I didn't get it either...

Me either.

I have to admit it was more because it was odd than me picking up on what exactly happened. But it more or less sounded like Ishy performed an action and EP was effected, but it gave them both some insight on Verb, somehow.

I'm pretty calm. With your history this would likely be dismissed as another of your "plans" if it weren't for Ishy so be thankful for him. However, as was just stated by three or four others, nobody has a clue what this is about. In short, either contribute or stop wasting time, all that you're going to gain like that is a bad reputation.

The people that said they didn't get it are all pretty new to the game and count again buddy only 2 people said they didnt get it Mish and Rand not 3-4 people.

I Went back quickly here. Include me and that is four so... no.

Razen, I get the point of voting Verb, it makes sense in a way but parts are missing. For verb to speak up on being RB'd at night he would have to have a night action and would have to use it during one of the nights he was blocked. Possible reasons he didn't do those things according to EP are: He is scum or... scum. However, for those of us in the real world, reasons may include X shot abilities, passive abilities, day abilities, vanilla, or a role important enough to not bring up that you have been roleblocked.

Voting based on this is scummy, those of you who are doing so either are catching something that I am not or are voting without knowing (or seemingly caring to know) why. AKA, scummy bandwagon.

 

Fair enough.

 

Other than saying I'm scummy repeatedly without reasoning and trying to make EP seem like a baffoon that doesn't understand what he is talking about, there are very few posts by Darthe that contribute except in defending Red 2.0's slow down of NS's lynch, which you all know how I feel about that so it is interesting they seemed to work off each other but rarely talked about each other, well I guess Red did a little bit. Distancing? Also more recently defending Verbal. Well, I suppose he has been pretty effective in that since now people CAN'T vote Verbal, even if just to get more info. It is effectively like saying, "Stop looking at Verbal! Look at BG!" and grabbing the town by the head and forcibly turning it away.

 

Uh... I'm spent.

[bgrishinko]

So BG, what role do you enable?

 

Blocking roles. I assumed for a while that was just EP, but according to Snow there is a mafia RB so I guess that makes sense for balance.

[Sakaea]

Official Vote Count:

 

BG (4) – Cyan, Rand, Red, Darthe

 

Darthe (4) – NS, BG, EP, Mish

 

 

Not voting (12) - Kaylee, Songs, Snow, Verb, JLM, Des, peace, Ishy, Eddie, Razen, Basel, dice

 

With 20 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

 

 

A Gladiator Challenge has been issued! You must now vote for either BG or Darthe. 2 contestants in the Game of Thrones one-on-one; who will live?