[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[ed2funy]

You don't know how to play if you think just saying someone's case is wrong and therefore they are scum. You have been playing scummy and most of your remarks and posts have been interpreted so. Either case her back and point out how she is wrong or just take it like a man.

 

Because Red's a bigger woman. A very harsh, cruel woman.

[ed2funy]

I'm not annoying. I'm Frank and Ernest.

 

Hi, I'm Ed. Just Ed.

 

in other news, i said it before, i'll say it again. yours and Rands discussion mid Day 1 about what role Eddard Stark might have was ultra pingy. more so on Rand as he was driving the convo, but you were egging him on by entering the convo with him.

Uhhhh, quote me where I was trying to figure out his role, please.

I don't remember being in the convo that way.

You cooty queen.

[Nightstrike]

I did, but she keept repeating the same stuff over and over. That's my case made already.

[Sakaea]

Points to Eds for making me laugh

[Red2111]

Ed i've quoted it for you before. it was soon after Johns reveal.

 

 

also (non game related) check the Blues public board *pokes Ed*

[ed2funy]

I did, but she keept repeating the same stuff over and over. That's my case made already.

Most of your defense was, "you're wrong," and "you're just not reading that right," and "you're probably misinterpreting that on purpose."

And thus, you haven't been really defending yourself. So your OMGUSCYCC (Oh My God You Suck Cause You Can't Case) is ridiculous.

 

 

Points to Eds for making me laugh

>.>

Points?

[ed2funy]

Like I remember when he revealed. I will go look for it, but since you're making the argument, I think you should.

[Nightstrike]

Yeah, I still think there must be scum on my list. Flawed reasoning is flawed. I said more than "wrong". I'm just waiting for day break. If I'm not dead, then I'll vote off the list.

[RandA lThor]

Red, never once did I ask for him to reveal his role, all I said was that if there was a real Ned Stark, that he might not claim because he would then become a target and he had an important role.

[Red2111]

n/m i got mixed up. i retract my FoS at Ed, wash it many times in bleach and then direct said FoS squarely at Ishy.

 

this is the exchange i'm referencing.

 

Ed did pop up in it, but more as to quesitonoing why Rand was talking about roles on revelaed characters.

 

my apologies bro

 

 

 

 

Think about it, a confirmed townie has who's best interest in mind? Town's duh.

Yeah, Nol, but some people believe that if someone claims doc, then you shouldn't claim. What if Jon Snow was a really important role like the cop?

We're not talking about roles. This is a discussion about characters so far, two different things.

Right, but obviously, if Jon Snow reveals, he will be one of the mafia's top targets, and if he is the doc, I don't think he would want to reveal. I'm not saying I think EP is mafia, I think he's town, but I don't think its as proven as Nol thinks it is.

Counterclaiming a character is much less risky than CCing a role. Who the hell knows what Ed Starks role is? Could be anything.

Counterclaiming a character is much less risky than CCing a role. Who the hell knows what Ed Starks role is? Could be anything.

 

Still risky, and if he is an important character, then perhaps too risky.

[Red2111]

Yeah, I still think there must be scum on my list. Flawed reasoning is flawed. I said more than "wrong". I'm just waiting for day break. If I'm not dead, then I'll vote off the list.

 

just saying, if you vote without a case on someone pressuring you like i have been, its an OMGUS. back your thinking i'm scum up with proof of your own rather than trying to leech off a case i bring agaisnt you cause your lazy.

[Red2111]

also

 

Red, never once did I ask for him to reveal his role, all I said was that if there was a real Ned Stark, that he might not claim because he would then become a target and he had an important role.

 

never said you asked for a role reveal. i said talking about and tryign to figure out what role he might or might not have is scummy.

[RandA lThor]

also

 

Red, never once did I ask for him to reveal his role, all I said was that if there was a real Ned Stark, that he might not claim because he would then become a target and he had an important role.

 

never said you asked for a role reveal. i said talking about and tryign to figure out what role he might or might not have is scummy.

 

I wasn't trying to figure it out either, I was giving reasons for why he wouldn't want to CC, just saying that since Jon Snow is important apparently, he might have an important role which is why he isn't CCing.

[ed2funy]

Starting at his reveal, only possible relevant posts will be quoted, and leading to the final post.

 

Reveal:

I'm Ned Stark.

 

My post following reveal:

I was going to o back and reread more on John Snow because of the train, but apparently, it would be useless now.

 

So,

Unvote for now.

 

 

Far as I am tracking, the reveals thus far are:

 

Noldy - Innocent Child - Riccon Stark (da fug is that?)

EP - Probably lying about his role - Jon Snow

John Snow - No Role Claim - Ned Stark

 

Not related to role, just reveal and part of my response:

I was going to o back and reread more on John Snow because of the train, but apparently, it would be useless now.

 

just cause john revealed doesn't mean going back and gettign a read on him and stuff surroundign him is pointless. i dislike how your using this as an excuse.

 

Where I questioned why Rand was bringing up Roles, and Rand's reply:

Not sure why Rand is tying in the Role at the moment. I kinda understand, but since that isn't what this is about, pinging.

 

And I tied in the role because it might matter if that character has a strong role and mafia decide to kill him, he is done for

 

 

And your FOS. Not on me. The only part with my name in that post immediately follows, but not related:

Rand & ishy, why are ya;ll so concerned with what their roles might be? isn't it bad enough that they've outted their characters, if their telling the truth. imo only scum would be concerned about their roles now.

 

Ed - you know better than this on the vetted town thing. his words hold more weight because we know he's not WIFOMing anything and we can take them at face value. also, whats up with that complete 180 on EP. up until a few posts ago you were saying you still didn't trust any of what he was saying.

 

 

 

[Red2111]

i still dislike all the WIFOM around it and it seems more aimed at tryign to dig out or entice convo surrounding it that lay cover for them.

[Red2111]

yo, ed *clears throat*

 

ninja'd you again bro

 

 

n/m i got mixed up. i retract my FoS at Ed, wash it many times in bleach and then direct said FoS squarely at Ishy.

 

this is the exchange i'm referencing.

 

Ed did pop up in it, but more as to quesitonoing why Rand was talking about roles on revelaed characters.

 

my apologies bro

[ed2funy]

n/m i got mixed up. i retract my FoS at Ed, wash it many times in bleach and then direct said FoS squarely at Ishy.

 

this is the exchange i'm referencing.

 

Ed did pop up in it, but more as to quesitonoing why Rand was talking about roles on revelaed characters.

 

my apologies bro

 

 

Ah. Ninja.

My bad.

[ed2funy]

 

Stop ninja-ing me!

[Kaylee]

This is the most game related posting I've seen in a night phase.

[John E. Kelley]

FoS at me Red? Read the quote again.

 

I said I didn't care what Ned's role was, only that he claimed Ned. I never speculated, asked, inquired, anything. I was specific in trying to move the conversation away from speculating over his role.

[Red2111]

yet you continued to engage him in the dialouge Ishy. it was manipulative imo.

[John E. Kelley]

If you say so. I disagree, but okay.

[Sakaea]

Red, Brienne of Tarth, role cop, town, has died.

 

It is now Day 2.

 

With 22 alive, it takes 12 to lynch.

 

"I'm no lady." - Brienne.

 

[Sakaea]

Red, are you interested in replacing back in? Let me know ASAP please.

[JenLenaMom]

There's a shocker. Red got NK'd.