[Basic] Shifters vs Hunters - Game Over! Congrats Mafia!

[Ironeyes]

And by the way, Razen, I apologize for being so hard on you. I was sure you were scum.

[John E. Kelley]

That's why I unvoted. I apologize too, but in my (our) defense, some of your play was suss.

[Ironeyes]

Seems to me that we now have three mostly confirmed townies: Razen, Ishy, and Ironeyes (me). That's excellent!

[Nolder]

or you're all mafia together

 

any particular reason I shouldn't think that?

[Razen]

So Ishy's a wolf too then? Unvote. Hmm...

[Ironeyes]

or you're all mafia together

 

any particular reason I shouldn't think that?

 

Yeah, I knew that would be a concern. Either we're going to need a lot more people to chime in, or one of us could die, confirming the other two. Lynch me if you must.

[Nolder]

And I expect you all claim vanilla town?

[Nolder]

mind you before you do, if you're telling the truth we've narrowed down our power roles quite a bit

perhaps to the point where we might as well all claim and get it out in the open

 

as I asked it should be obvious that is something I would prefer but I can see an argument against it as well

[Ironeyes]

And I expect you all claim vanilla town?

 

I do believe that's the definition of wolf shifter. Don't know. Razen claimed it, I do too. Haven't heard from Ishy.

[Ironeyes]

mind you before you do, if you're telling the truth we've narrowed down our power roles quite a bit

perhaps to the point where we might as well all claim and get it out in the open

 

as I asked it should be obvious that is something I would prefer but I can see an argument against it as well

 

I expect that there are few power roles in this game. Basic ones don't have many. So therefore a mass reveal would narrow down the targets for NK's a lot. I don't think it's a good idea.

[Nolder]

a little too late to disagree now don't ya think?

[Lenlo]

Im assuming reporter was our cop equivalent, so that means we only have the doctor left I would think.

 

Now heres a question. Wheres Sakaea been the past few days? Been rather quiet. Also I forgot Key was on LOLA until this Saturday so was about to ask about her to.

[Ironeyes]

a little too late to disagree now don't ya think?

 

Not really. Only three of us revealed. And on the plus side, the Mafia probably won't kill any of us now because that would a) get them very little and b) confirm the other two.

[John E. Kelley]

I'm in constant contact with Miss Key, I can get her to pop in and see what she has to say.

 

And I also concur that wolf shifter apparently = vanilla town, at least it does for me.

[Ironeyes]

Im assuming reporter was our cop equivalent, so that means we only have the doctor left I would think.

 

Now heres a question. Wheres Sakaea been the past few days? Been rather quiet. Also I forgot Key was on LOLA until this Saturday so was about to ask about her to.

 

I hope the Reporter wasn't a substitute for cop. According to the link Alanna provided, a reporter can only tell when somebody uses any night action. We probably still have a cop and a doc left.

[Ironeyes]

I'm in constant contact with Miss Key, I can get her to pop in and see what she has to say.

 

And I also concur that wolf shifter apparently = vanilla town, at least it does for me.

 

1- good idea

2- do you think that the other roles are linked to their animals?

[John E. Kelley]

Well, as Nol can attest, cop isn't necessarily a given in a Basic game, just likely. We shouldn't assume anything.

[Lenlo]

Huh, I dont remember seeing that. Ok then.

[Nolder]

I'm in constant contact with Miss Key, I can get her to pop in and see what she has to say.

Personally I don't think it's right to poke another player about a game as they may be lurking as a strategy

but I'm not the mod so I'm not going to tell you not to do it

[Nolder]

also re: animal=role

 

are you guys forgetting there was a vanilla rat shifter and a reporter rat shifter?

[Nolder]

Players:

1. Ironeyes - Wolf Shifter, Vanilla Townie

2. Nolder

3. Key

4. Blackhoof Rat Shifter, Reporter, Lynched Day 3

5. Arez

6. Ishy - Wolf Shifter, Vanilla Townie

7. Sakaea

8. Kaylee Hawk Shifter, Vanilla Townie, Killed Night 1

9. Lenlo

10. Razen - Wolf Shifter, Vanilla Townie

11. EP Rat Shifter, Vanilla Townie, Lynched Day 1

12. Darthe

[Nolder]

so who, according to you guys is the mafia team?

there isn't much choice left is there?

[Nolder]

also I've sort of forgot Sakaea was in this game

it'd be nice to hear from her again

[John E. Kelley]

I'm in constant contact with Miss Key, I can get her to pop in and see what she has to say.

Personally I don't think it's right to poke another player about a game as they may be lurking as a strategy

but I'm not the mod so I'm not going to tell you not to do it

 

Well she did post she was going on a LoA, she's in Seattle.

[Nolder]

oh yeah I remember that

 

when did she say she'd be back again?