A Basic Game: Mafia Wins!

[Myndrunner]

Reason #1564 why MyndJack Mafia Boards is waaaay better than DM:

 

Unread Replies Warnings before you post!

 

[Aiel Heart]

There are some interesting points in the speculation above. Maybe Cosmik is the lyncher, but if he is he's being rather... Outright about it. Seems to me like he's not afraid of being caught pushing for a vote. The points brought up on Arez and Ishy are also interesting. I'd like to wait for the information that day will bring before I make any firm decisions.

[Sakaea]

I think I've only been in one other game where a lyncher was in play. I don't remember who it was, but they were very forward about it also. It didn't work very well.

[Levity]

sdkjshdada'; I hate OMGUS arguments so much

 

Anyway, I actually forgot to mention the possibility of Cosmic being the lyncher, though I don't really think Cosmic would be that obvious about it. Don't treat that as valid though, I'm always wrong about blatant obviousness lately >:

 

Fex is suspicious in my eyes for the silent vote. Aemon is teetering in the middle, as well as Sakaea.

[aemonkristen]

The idea of the Lyncher never even occurred to me. What I come back to is "I'm 100% sure" followed by "I'm not the cop". Doubtful that Panda is scum because it would just lead to his own lynch the next day when I flipped town. Doubtful that he is the Lyncher because he didn't press a claim of cop to push through a lynch on me. If he were the lyncher it wouldn't really have mattered as long as there was no counterclaim the same day and he could get me lynched. I'll be back later with more thoughts

[Myndrunner]

The idea of the Lyncher never even occurred to me. What I come back to is "I'm 100% sure" followed by "I'm not the cop". Doubtful that Panda is scum because it would just lead to his own lynch the next day when I flipped town. Doubtful that he is the Lyncher because he didn't press a claim of cop to push through a lynch on me. If he were the lyncher it wouldn't really have mattered as long as there was no counterclaim the same day and he could get me lynched. I'll be back later with more thoughts

 

So if its doubtful that he's scum and doubtful he's the lyncher, and he's 100% sure you are scum.......

[Levity]

I feel like we're putting too much weight on something that Cosmic meant to say casually.

"100% certain" was supposed to mean more along the lines of "this post makes me pretty sure Aemon is scum," and worded it to augment that sense of confidence in the idea.

[Nolder]

Myndrunner has been killed

 

It is now Day 2

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch

[aemonkristen]

Mod, do we get a coroner report for Mynd?

 

Like I said, I don't think Panda would be so obvious coming after me he was the lyncher. However, his "100% sure" sets my teeth on edge. I am more likely to vote for AH today, however, because of her erratic behavior Night 0 and Day 1.

[Levity]

What erratic behavior in particular do you speak of?

 

Also, I still don't think Cosmic's statement should be scrutinized so heavily, but eh.

[Myndrunner]

 

*dies*

[Nolder]

Mod, do we get a coroner report for Mynd?

Nope

only the Janitor will know Mynds role and alignment

[Nolder]

might be MIA for a few days

charger isn't working

I ordered a new one though so I should be good to go in a week at the latest

 

edit: I might be able to get on using my itouch

I dunno yet though since I haven't tested it

also it's lost in my room atm so I have to find it first

[keyholder21]

Mod, do we get a coroner report for Mynd?

Nope

only the Janitor will know Mynds role and alignment

 

Interesting considering we've had coroner reports for the other two that have died.

[bgrishinko]

I'm more than willing to pursue this idea

 

Vote CosmicPanda

 

 

[Arez Al'Loke]

Sorry for my inactivity recently! I've been studying for my physics exam =P!

I like how I phrase things that people can missinterpret them, I need to start paying more attention to what I'm writing.

 

Anyway, I didn't want anyone random to die as that kinda makes the game boring.. So I did the only thing possible to stop a random lynch, and that was voting on someone to get lynched. I was pretty sure Razen was a Townie, but as I said, I had no other choice to prevent a random lynch, unless I've got something wrong?

 

I don't like that Cosmic is doing so little to clarify the suspicion about him.. Unless I've missed something again. I'm going to wait with my vote a bit, does anyone remember seeing Cosmic defending himself about the 100% sure thing? The only thing I can remember about that is him saying, "I'm not a cop" Or something like that?

[Aiel Heart]

Well that's annoying. What if he was the lyncher or an important town and we don’t know?

 

I don't like this you drunken shiny Spinda!!!!

 

 

Ok, anyway, it's obvious that someone didn't like Forrest. Janitor is a mafia role so we should probably assume the worst and think that it's a townie (possibly power role) that died. Still, I won't take all that Forrest said at face value either. Then again, you'd think the mafia would have wanted to leave him alive--a lot of us were doubting him. So I'm not sure...

 

Is it just me or is Float doing a lot of odd? She considered all of the trains yesterday to be “sudden” or “erratic.” Then she is kinda protecting Cosmik and that “100%” comment. Then she doesn’t see how I was acting strangely?

 

I will look at everyone else during lunch.

[Sakaea]

Float?

[keyholder21]

Mynd was an interesting choice to kill. You'd think you would want to keep around someone who was creating so much tension/so many arguments. Maybe we're dealing with inexperienced scum?

 

I feel like we're putting too much weight on something that Cosmic meant to say casually.

"100% certain" was supposed to mean more along the lines of "this post makes me pretty sure Aemon is scum," and worded it to augment that sense of confidence in the idea.

 

 

Cosmic is not new to mafia. He should know how we would take a remark like that. He hasn't exactly lifted any suspicion by not offering any explanation other than that he's not cop. Instead, others are doing it for him.

 

I'm game for a little bit of pressure. Vote Cosmic.

[keyholder21]

Float?

 

I'm guessing Levity by what Heart said.

[Red2111]

Mynd was an interesting choice to kill. You'd think you would want to keep around someone who was creating so much tension/so many arguments. Maybe we're dealing with inexperienced scum?

 

though it's intersting that the Janitor didn't cover Night 0's corner report as well. reflex reaction to Mynd's kill is the same as you Key, but my gut is screaming no and tellign me that maybe the scum sacrificed one of their own, and covered up his corner report to mislead and confuse us.

 

 

 

VOTE: AH

[Aiel Heart]

Float = Levity. I thought I'd stated that at some other point already.

 

Yes Float = Levity and Forrest=Mynd and I think that's everyone that I have obscure nicknames for in this game....

 

I assume both of these votes are based on my strangeness at the beginning of the game? Or am I continuing to seem scummy

[keyholder21]

I assume both of these votes are based on my strangeness at the beginning of the game? Or am I continuing to seem scummy

 

Both?

[Sakaea]

I only see one vote on AH....

[Aiel Heart]

I could have sworn that Aemon had voted me at some point yesterday. I guess he was just looking suspiciously, which I don't blame him for.

 

Ha what I get for trying to play between classes when I can't sit and double check.

 

Speaking of which, time to go!