A Basic Game: Mafia Wins!

[SBoydW]

BTW I totally think that Cosmic and Key are scum buddies. That whole argument seemed staged. Both kept claiming they weren't going to agree and would stop arguing, but both kept arguing. Then magically close to the deadline cosmic came around and saw the wisdom of key's ways. Classic distancing imo.

[a pale tanned lover]

My vote stays where it is.

[keyholder21]

ALright by my count Arez only needs one more.... with only 4 hours left.... I guess I'll hammer....

 

Unvote. Vote Arez

 

I think that only puts him at L-1. I'm considering how scummy it would look if I unvoted myself and hammered him here. I'm sure I'm damned if he's town anyway.

 

Unvote, Vote Arez.

 

BTW I totally think that Cosmic and Key are scum buddies. That whole argument seemed staged. Both kept claiming they weren't going to agree and would stop arguing, but both kept arguing. Then magically close to the deadline cosmic came around and saw the wisdom of key's ways. Classic distancing imo.

 

It is weird to me too, actually.

 

And it seems like no matter what I do, the lot of you are going to think I'm scum *laughs*. A girl can't catch a break. Just go ahead and think that Soy. It's really difficult to stop arguing once you start. Especially after you leave for awhile and then come back. You're like, oh I've stopped arguing for five hours I can get back into it now - even though on thread your posts follow one another and it looks like it's all at once. Know what I mean?

[SBoydW]

My vote stays where it is.

 

Still waiting for your "reason" btw.

[Arez Al'Loke]

I guess I'm going to die now =P So better write while I can xP

 

You see, when a new player starts mafia, he wants to learn how to play right? That means his first playstyle might not be the optimal one. Hence different reasonings and different style's emerge.

Most people read that as mafia, because , I don't know why yett tbh. Anyway, time to defend certain posts written as to why I'm mafia, just for the heck of it xP

 

Key wrote - "Reread his previous vote for Razen. Yes he states that a random lynch would be boring (which is totally not the point of the game but I digress), but then he also states that he voted for Razen who he THOUGHT WAS A TOWNIE, in order to avoid a random. Then he asks if what he did was right or not."

 

First off I thought as most of you do, random is bad, I migth die or a townie might, better hammer someone even if he's town. But as I stated, I only THOUGHT he was a townie, but I wasn't very convinced. Therefor I could feel a certain degree of satisfaction from voting him.

 

But when he finally got lynched and it turned out he was townie, I kinda felt bad, so I decided not to do that again. So this time when AH felt like a townie, I didn't vote for her.

 

I can't keep track of all the blaming and flaming xP So I'll just sit here patiantly and wait for DOOM!!

[Nolder]

Votecount

Arez - Ishy, Sakaea, Levity, Cosmic, Soy 2.0, Key (6)

Ishy - Arez (1)

Key - Red, Aemon (2)

Soy 2.0 - Pale (1)

 

Not Voting: N/A

 

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch

 

Deadline

 

Sorry there were no further votecounts last night

I had a little too much to drink and went to bed early

[Nolder]

Arez Al'Loke, Backup Doctor, has been lynched

 

It is now Night 4

[keyholder21]

Fan-fricking-tastic.

 

No worries ya'll. I'll vote for myself in the morning too.

[Nolder]

Pale has informed me he'll need to be replaced so uhh I'm gonna work on finding a replacement for him ASAP

[Red2111]

Nol can you work on finding a replacement for me as well. i'm gonna try to finish getting caught up, but i don't think ill be able to :( sorry

[Nolder]

Sure thing

[aemonkristen]

Sorry I disappeared. I'm swamped at work. Literally doing 15 hour days and then studying at night. I'm trying to keep up as best I can. I'll be back later tonight with my thoughts on everything.

[cosmicpanda]

Fan-fricking-tastic.

 

No worries ya'll. I'll vote for myself in the morning too.

 

Please don't do that. We might be near lylo - I haven't checked the details of the setup, yet. If you're town, you don't want to let the mafia lynch you tomorrow.

[Arez Al'Loke]

NOoooooooooooooooooooo 3rd time I get lynched as one of the good guys

 

[aemonkristen]

I know it's a moot point, but I am curious why Arez didn't reveal. It would have instantly removed him from the voting pool. My thoughts up to this point: I have no idea why Key wants to vote herself. It doesn't prove any point and, if she is town, only helps the scum. At this point I am most suspicious of Red and Key both for trying to lead us by the nose. Red is doing it by trying to case everyone on the assumption that Mynd was scum, which we have absolutely no way of knowing, and Key is trying to make us think of the scum team as inexperienced players. It's not that the rationals are bad in themselves, but that both of them push their theories so hard when there is little to support them.

 

@Key- I did FoS Red for doing exactly what you are doing and I even did it in the quote you used. I'll go back and quote it again so you can see. I don't know why you would say I didn't call Red out on it.

[aemonkristen]

I bolded the bit where I showed how Red was doing the same thing. And then you say I didn't call her out on it. What's up with that?

 

Here it seems she is trying to lead the town into looking at the more inexperienced players because Mynd got killed. By building up Mynd as a source of conflict that an experienced scum team would like to have around, she effectively disregards a lot of very dangerous players in this game. Such as Red, who is basing many of her theories on Mynd flipping scum, which can be neither proved nor disproved. Key is a good choice for today.

You’re calling me out for that Aemon, yet you completely ignored/disregarded Red doing virtually the same thing. Noted.

[keyholder21]

No. There you are calling her out for basing theories on Mynd being scum NOT for stating that she thinks we are dealing with experienced scum which is what I was referring to.

[keyholder21]

that both of them push their theories so hard when there is little to support them.

 

How am I pushing my theory hard? It was a one time suggestion. The Arez vote has little to do with that. I actually thought he was scum so I voted for him. Panda was fighting me on it, so I tried to explain my side.

[Nolder]

Razen is returning to replace Pale (who replaced Amega)

[Nolder]

Red, Powerless Townie, has been killed

 

It is now Day 4

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

[Sakaea]

Welcome back, Razen

[Sakaea]

1. Ishmael Forsaken

2. Bgrishinko, vanilla town, NK’d Night 2

3. Red, vanilla town, NK’d Night 3

4. Razen 2.0[replaced Pale Merlot (replaced Amega)]

5. aemonkristen

6. Arez Al'Loke, Backup Doctor, Lynched Day 3

7. Razen, vanilla town, Lynched Day 1

8. Mr. Soy Boyo, vanilla town, NK’d Night 0

9. cosmicpanda

10. Soy Boyo 2.0 (replaced Perf)

11. Aiel Heart, Lyncher, Lynched Day 2

12. Myndrunner, Killed Night 1

13. Sakaea

14. keyholder21

15. Levity

 

This should be accurate. I copy/pasted from Word to here, it kept the formatting. Awesome.

[aemonkristen]

I have good news and bad news. The good news is I can narrow down the field for us quite a bit because I'm the cop. The bad news is that we are at LyLo. Here are my findings:

 

Night 0: Cosmicpanda = "town" This is why I never chased after him when he made his "100%" comment. I knew he was a townie who felt sure of himself.

Night 1: AH = "not town" This is why my first post that day was to throw an FoS on AH. I wanted to see if there was support for the lynch without having to reveal so early.

Night 2: Kaea = "town" I decided on her that night because there was a lot of conflict that day phase and she was at the center of it.

Night 3: Ishy = "town" I chose Ishy because he had been looking scummy ever since he cased Arez and then voted for Mynd. I wanted to finally clear him and move on.

Night 4 Red = "town" Unfortunately, I chose the wrong person to check last night. I went for Red because she is an extremely experienced player and I didn't like the way she was trying to steer us to see Mynd as scum. Now I may have to revise my opinion of her theory.

 

Any way we look at this, there are only 4 people left and at least 2 of those are scum.

 

I'l go whichever way you all decide, but I am leaning heavily towards Key at the moment. Amega was replaced by Pale was replaced by Razen. Most scum do their best not to get replaced, so I'm leaning town on Razen 2.0 for the moment.

[Sakaea]

1. Ishmael Forsaken, Town

2. Bgrishinko, vanilla town, NK’d Night 2

3. Red, vanilla town, NK’d Night 3

4. Razen 2.0[replaced Pale Merlot (replaced Amega)], possible town

5. aemonkristen, cop

6. Arez Al'Loke, Backup Doctor, Lynched Day 3

7. Razen, vanilla town, Lynched Day 1

8. Mr. Soy Boyo, vanilla town, NK’d Night 0

9. cosmicpanda

10. Soy Boyo 2.0 (replaced Perf)

11. Aiel Heart, Lyncher, Lynched Day 2

12. Myndrunner, Killed Night 1

13. Sakaea, town

14. keyholder21

15. Levity

 

So our candidates are Key, Levity, Soy 2.0, and cosmic. I'd be ok with Key also, but because of being at LyLo, I'm hesitant to vote. What do the rest of you think?

[Sakaea]

Forgot to color Aemon blue. Grrr