Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

[WWWwombat]

Oops. With 12 voting players, it takes 7 to lynch.

[Paperblade]

Aight.

 

vote meesh

[Christine]

I wish I could vote...

[hotpocket2006]

Wanted to make a reveal before the day starts.

 

I'm the tracker.

 

On night 4 I tracked mmeshal and she visited Leelou. At the time I could not determine her intentions. Since Leelou flipped Healer I can only assume she attempted a NK but was successfully blocked. Further, we only had one NK so maybe we actually had two killers target her. Anyways, my tracker results as follows:

 

N1: Thorum visited no one.

N2: Trench visted no one.

N3: Perfexionist visted the Ape.

N4: mmeshal visted Leelou.

N5: JF80 visted no one.

 

I can get down with the get down. VOTE MEESH let's see what she has to say about that.

[John E. Kelley]

Anything you'd like to say at this point Meesh?

 

Vote Meesh

[Amadine]

I am prepared to vote Meesh based on Not-Bob's reveal, but i want to hear what she has to say first.

[trench]

Not Bob's info not withstanding, I would like to see why Leelou and Christine wanted to lynch Vic so bad yesterday. I could get on Mmeesh's train but I would rather give her sometime to explain herself and would also like to slow down the speed at which we have been lynching people the last few days.

[trench]

err... Vote Vic yhea that works better

[The Crusher]

Crusher, hun, I'm a tree stump. I can't vote. I would love to, but I can't. Well, I can, but it isn't counted.

 

 

Thats my point sweety. Make a vote and show me it doesn;t count. You may have already but I missed it.

 

 

 

By the way whoever tried to kill me last night, "You R Teh suk"

 

I'm goignt to reveal thinking not making it thru another night. Im the faction leader of the Hightower gang that pretty much is all dead. I killed my sweet leelou who was protecting me I think. Waiting for Wombutt to hit me back to see if he will let me know if she knew who I was. If she did Not Bot may be lying about that night if the person was visiting her to kill her. I would guess with my backup dead Leelou would have started protecting me. Not sure if the nights line up and not willing to go back and look.

 

Anyhow I promised so vote Vic

[keyholder21]

Not Bob's info not withstanding, I would like to see why Leelou and Christine wanted to lynch Vic so bad yesterday. I could get on Mmeesh's train but I would rather give her sometime to explain herself and would also like to slow down the speed at which we have been lynching people the last few days.

 

While I admit that I'm curious too, I'd rather go with a more "known" quality. Not that his views necessarily mean she was up to no good, but it's a safer bet I think.

 

Vote Meesh.

 

bolded - Although yesterday didn't have the same result, the first "fast" day lynched a cultist. I don't see the harm in doing that and doing it fast.

[JF80]

Vote Meesh.

[trench]

Well were just shy of 12 hours into this day and we have Meesh at L-1, im sure there is no harm in going this fast at all Key

[Vicious89x]

Not Bob's info not withstanding, I would like to see why Leelou and Christine wanted to lynch Vic so bad yesterday. I could get on Mmeesh's train but I would rather give her sometime to explain herself and would also like to slow down the speed at which we have been lynching people the last few days.

 

I'm pretty much awaiting this myself. I want to hear what outside of rubbing her wrong I'm guilty of.

 

I'm not voting Meesh yet as I'd like to hear her defense.

[keyholder21]

Well, if you'll notice - JF hadn't voted yet when I said that trench.

 

Additionally, it might actually be a good thing to lynch her - we don't know that it wouldn't, unless you know something we don't about her?

 

And finally, I don't think going fast is a good OR bad thing. It can be good if it's not a team member, bad if it is. It's just a part of the game. What matters more is why people are voting so fast and where they are in the process, wouldn't you agree?

[Paperblade]

unvote

 

let's let him claim

[trench]

Well I would say most people's thought process is, "hey as long as the group doesn't want to speed lynch one of my teammates, I'm good with it". But personally I think we have to drop this idea of multiple factions, and start finding solid reasons why they may be cult or Greyjoy/Lannister, because its those groups that are the enemy of all. I dont doubt Not Bob's reveal or his results, but they dont tell us for sure that Meesh is cult or Greyjoy/Lannister, and I just want to be the voice of reason here. We should give Meesh a chance to reveal or refute before we put her at L-2, let alone L-1.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Well I would say most people's thought process is, "hey as long as the group doesn't want to speed lynch one of my teammates, I'm good with it". But personally I think we have to drop this idea of multiple factions, and start finding solid reasons why they may be cult or Greyjoy/Lannister, because its those groups that are the enemy of all. I dont doubt Not Bob's reveal or his results, but they dont tell us for sure that Meesh is cult or Greyjoy/Lannister, and I just want to be the voice of reason here. We should give Meesh a chance to reveal or refute before we put her at L-2, let alone L-1.

 

The main reason I hesitated to reveal in the first place was I didn't know Leelou's alignment. I'm guessing Meesh thought she was Cult after she ackowleded getting a gun from the Ape. I know I was convinced she was Cult. We only had one NK on night 4. When Leelou flipped healer I have to assume Meesh as either a night killer or the SK. I'm assuming a SK is in the game because Pac was an FBI Agent. Its best to let her try to explain it.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Crusher, hun, I'm a tree stump. I can't vote. I would love to, but I can't. Well, I can, but it isn't counted.

 

 

Thats my point sweety. Make a vote and show me it doesn;t count. You may have already but I missed it.

 

 

 

By the way whoever tried to kill me last night, "You R Teh suk"

 

I'm goignt to reveal thinking not making it thru another night. Im the faction leader of the Hightower gang that pretty much is all dead. I killed my sweet leelou who was protecting me I think. Waiting for Wombutt to hit me back to see if he will let me know if she knew who I was. If she did Not Bot may be lying about that night if the person was visiting her to kill her. I would guess with my backup dead Leelou would have started protecting me. Not sure if the nights line up and not willing to go back and look.

 

Anyhow I promised so vote Vic

 

 

lazy

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Not Bob's info not withstanding, I would like to see why Leelou and Christine wanted to lynch Vic so bad yesterday. I could get on Mmeesh's train but I would rather give her sometime to explain herself and would also like to slow down the speed at which we have been lynching people the last few days.

 

I agree with this as well. Christine, would you like to offer a reason? Especially, when Vic was trying to clear Leelou ealier on Day 5.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Can vote Leelou or Pats. Leelou admitted she was offered the gun. Hard to believe she could turn down a recruitment.

Pats denies shooting Fex and now claims he's barely paying attention. Would have thought he would have denied killing Fex when he voted Ape yesterday.

We need to eliminate one of the wifoms.

 

Vote Leelou

 

LOL Why do you think I voted him?

 

You voted the Ape but you did not deny taking the gun or shooting Fex until today.

 

I'd be more keen to kill PatsFan personally. I think it's convenient he's denying today that he didn't take the gun. If he's cult, we know he took and use the gun and it might clear Leelou based on my theory.

Vote: PatsFan

 

Vic, could you explain your theory in a little more detail?

[Vicious89x]

I thought perhaps that taking and using the gun meant "I accept your offer and am going to use it and understand that using this means I'm going to become cult". If you discarded it, it mean not thanks. It would make sense in game of thrones you'd have to be bribed in a way to join a faction, rather than a typical conversion game where a target gets converted due to choice of that converter. Apes roles was recruiter, so I think you can turn away his offers.

 

I didn't get time to log on and check the game before Leelou was dead, but I wouldve brought this up had I been available.

[Christine]

I get the air that Vic is Cult. But, don't believe me, I'm just the tree stump.

 

 

I shall once again prove to you, Crusher, but Wombat already CONFIRMED that I am a stump.

 

 

Vote Vic

 

 

Just to prove it doesnt count.

 

 

 

It is now Day 7. With 11 voting players, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

also

 

It is now Day 7. With 11 voting players, it takes 6 to lynch.

there are 13 living players and a stump

 

Is this an error?

 

Oops. With 12 voting players, it takes 7 to lynch.

[trench]

Well I would say most people's thought process is, "hey as long as the group doesn't want to speed lynch one of my teammates, I'm good with it". But personally I think we have to drop this idea of multiple factions, and start finding solid reasons why they may be cult or Greyjoy/Lannister, because its those groups that are the enemy of all. I dont doubt Not Bob's reveal or his results, but they dont tell us for sure that Meesh is cult or Greyjoy/Lannister, and I just want to be the voice of reason here. We should give Meesh a chance to reveal or refute before we put her at L-2, let alone L-1.

 

The main reason I hesitated to reveal in the first place was I didn't know Leelou's alignment. I'm guessing Meesh thought she was Cult after she ackowleded getting a gun from the Ape. I know I was convinced she was Cult. We only had one NK on night 4. When Leelou flipped healer I have to assume Meesh as either a night killer or the SK. I'm assuming a SK is in the game because Pac was an FBI Agent. Its best to let her try to explain it.

 

green and Bold is mine

 

That makes a lot of sense to me, when you put like that. Definitely something to consider. My vote stands for now until Meesh replies.

[dapianoplay3r]

Im pretty sure Meesh isnt cult, so even with a NK she isnt too much of a threat as a whole

 

VOTE VIC

[Paperblade]

the cult recruiter is dead, someone with a night kill is a much bigger threat atm