[ADVANCED/KITCHEN SINK] The Axe or the Hammer - GAME OVER

[Cuathon]

Ishmael onto Ed2.

[ed2funy]

....

>.>

 

What?

 

 

 

All of them.

But I shall take another look.

[bgrishinko]

Vote Cuathon

 

I don't believe you. Or Red is lying through her teeth. But since that avenue is closed today... I don't believe you.

[dapianoplay3r]

Neither do I but it looks like BG stole my thunder

 

BG did you find scum last night? Im guessing not since you haven't revealed

[Cuathon]

Vote Cuathon

 

I don't believe you. Or Red is lying through her teeth. But since that avenue is closed today... I don't believe you.

 

Don't believe me about what?

[bgrishinko]

Either you are lying about who you targeted or Red is hiding something particularly dangerous to town.

[dapianoplay3r]

Im inclined to believe Red more at this point

[Cuathon]

Im inclined to believe Red more at this point

 

I don't understand. What does my redirect have to do with red? Did red claim something about one of those players?

[dapianoplay3r]

nope but it just doesn't feel right at the moment. Red's does. I just believe her and you im having a hard time believing

[Cuathon]

I made a wrong quote. I was talking to brshrinko.

[bgrishinko]

I'm leaving it at that for now until Red responds as well.

[hazelkrs1]

(sigh) Still mucking through my reread... it really is quite a chore.

 

With limited information though, it kinda doesn't make sense to me, Red's pursuit of Cauthon as scum. The main reason is that he thought her and Kae's roles were a bit overpowered, which actually seems like a legit reaction to me (even tho I think they might be a bit OP, I can see how it wouldn't be that easy to automatically glean that much information from the lists in a game this big). Then the other thing was that he was skimming a bit, but I don't see how that's that damning when he just came into the game and is trying to jump right into the scumhunt, instead of poring over every post in the thread first.

 

And it REALLY doesn't sit well with me, the whole RBing/silencing Kae thing. It pretty much makes no sense to do both to her as the mafia team. I don't know why this hasn't been thrown out there but has anyone considered this: the person who RB'ed her might not be mafia. It could have been a town RB'er (many games will have both a mafia AND town RB'er to help balance things a bit) who was trying to vet Kae's role claim (and Red's too as well).

 

I also had an idea to possibly vet someone as town. We can prob only use it one day effectively but here it is: get EVERYONE to vote for someone different, then wait for an official VC from Ama. The person whose vote isn't being counted is most assuredly town, since I don't see mafia being clever enough to nullify one of their own votes for this purpose. This maneuver can also help us because by keeping track of who everyone votes for we can have more information for later days.

 

What yall think?

[dapianoplay3r]

A whole game co-operating? A whole game of this size??

 

That sounds like communism. A good idea on paper but it never seems to work in practice

[Turin Turambar]

There are some issues to clear:(if I am understanding this correctly)

The vote still counts, the affected person just has to vote for a specific person.

all the effected person would have to do is vote early in the day while the person they are supposed to vote is available.

I don't think we've had everyone post in a day let alone vote.

The votes would have to be somewhat random in nature to allow everyone to vote for a different person.

The entire thing could be setup by the mafia to vet one of their own.

 

All in all it sounds like the overly complicated plans that bond villains come up with that never seem to quite work out properly.

[SBoydW]

Why do I have this sickening feeling that Red, Kae, and BG are scamming us all... I really don't like that people who have already claimed roles won't reveal any information... I'm still catching up but as far as I've seen Red has only revealed N1 actions and and neither red nor BG have revealed N2 actions. Reasons: Red supposedly wanting to protect which of the two roles she and kae has, and bg for some odd reason won't reveal until red does... it's all to twisted to me...

 

I also find it interesting that the mafia didn't simply whack one of those three. I mean that's three reveals and the mafia hasn't even taken a shot at one of them? I don't like any of their reveals and frankly am starting tho think they're all full of it.

[SBoydW]

BTw as not to ignore meesh *gives meesh funny look*

[Amadine]

Vote Count:

Verb (1) - Meesh

Cuathon (2) - Red, BG

Not Voting: Nolder, Corrosive, Verb, Ishy, Turin, Nyn, Ed, Kae, Loki, Maw, Cuathon, Player, Womby, Des, Ledinna 2.0, Tina, Soyo

20 players = 11 to lynch

[dapianoplay3r]

Is Meesh the Silencer?

[Amadine]

 

 

5. No personal insults... play nice my pets - or I maycompulse you with a PR

 

 

 

Fair Warning

[Turin Turambar]

I don't think you can draw that conclusion from the currently available evidence. The only way I could see that would be if she was also given a PR that stated she had to draw attention to whoever she silenced and it could be shown that verb was visited N2. Why would she silence and then call out Verb for inactivity after she got blasted for her comments on Nolder yesterday? I just don't think that would make any sense.

[dapianoplay3r]

Sorry that wasnt a suggestion it was just a question. It was in my notes and I couldnt remember if it was verified or just an idea that needed looking into

 

Thank you though

[ed2funy]

So, at this point, I am gonna say that Cauthon is WAY more scummy then Red.

I wonder though....Now, I could be way wrong, because, well, my mind isn't what it used to be, but I would rather lynch Cauthon.

 

 

Red

[SBoydW]

So, at this point, I am gonna say that Cauthon is WAY more scummy then Red.

I wonder though....Now, I could be way wrong, because, well, my mind isn't what it used to be, but I would rather lynch Cauthon.

 

 

Red

 

huh?

[ed2funy]

What?

 

I already told you I think we should lynch Cauthon.

[SBoydW]

Then you voted red...