[ADVANCED/KITCHEN SINK] The Axe or the Hammer - GAME OVER

[Nolder]

Well in a deadline game that would make sense, but seeing as how there aren't set day deadlines in this game, might as cast one out there and hope.

 

Vote: amegakure

my thoughts on this post

you make a fair point about there being no deadlines

however that list bit strikes me as off

"cast one out there and hope" implies two things to me

1. that you know that this is fairly weak reasoning

2. despite the weakness of your case you would actually want Amega lynched over it

 

those two things lead me to think that you therefore know Amega is not on your team because why else would you want to lynch someone over such weak reasoning?

based on what you said it looks like you're going for an "easy lynch"

 

perhaps I'm going overboard though

I've been known to do such things in the past

I get caught up in my own little theories of what's going on

would anyone else like to weigh in on this?

[SBoydW]

Well in a deadline game that would make sense, but seeing as how there aren't set day deadlines in this game, might as cast one out there and hope.

 

Vote: amegakure

my thoughts on this post

you make a fair point about there being no deadlines

however that list bit strikes me as off

"cast one out there and hope" implies two things to me

1. that you know that this is fairly weak reasoning

2. despite the weakness of your case you would actually want Amega lynched over it

 

those two things lead me to think that you therefore know Amega is not on your team because why else would you want to lynch someone over such weak reasoning?

based on what you said it looks like you're going for an "easy lynch"

 

perhaps I'm going overboard though

I've been known to do such things in the past

I get caught up in my own little theories of what's going on

would anyone else like to weigh in on this?

 

It isn't really even a case, just doing as I said and "casting one out there". I may have a different hankering later but for now it's as good a vote as any.

[Amadine]

Vote Count:

Ed (1) - Arlow

 

Leelou (2) - Des, Nolder

Des (1) - Leelou

 

Maw (1) - Ley

 

Ley (1) - Maw

 

Nyn (2) - Meesh, Levity

 

Verb (1) - Kae

Song (1) - Nyn

Levity (1) - Corrosive

Arlow (1) - Key

Amega (2) - Pandy, Soyo

 

Only Red & Verb are yet to check in - it's no problem - i am just adding here for my own reference.

[Nolder]

Well in a deadline game that would make sense, but seeing as how there aren't set day deadlines in this game, might as cast one out there and hope.

 

Vote: amegakure

my thoughts on this post

you make a fair point about there being no deadlines

however that list bit strikes me as off

"cast one out there and hope" implies two things to me

1. that you know that this is fairly weak reasoning

2. despite the weakness of your case you would actually want Amega lynched over it

 

those two things lead me to think that you therefore know Amega is not on your team because why else would you want to lynch someone over such weak reasoning?

based on what you said it looks like you're going for an "easy lynch"

 

perhaps I'm going overboard though

I've been known to do such things in the past

I get caught up in my own little theories of what's going on

would anyone else like to weigh in on this?

 

It isn't really even a case, just doing as I said and "casting one out there". I may have a different hankering later but for now it's as good a vote as any.

to clarify are you in fact willing to lynch Amega?

[ed2funy]

This point in the game, are we not willing to lynch anyone?

o_O

 

I agree Amega's reason is odd in the light of the fact that the deadlines are set by activity.

 

MEESH

[Blackhoof]

Nolder hit the nail on the head methinks.

vote soy

[SBoydW]

Well in a deadline game that would make sense, but seeing as how there aren't set day deadlines in this game, might as cast one out there and hope.

 

Vote: amegakure

my thoughts on this post

you make a fair point about there being no deadlines

however that list bit strikes me as off

"cast one out there and hope" implies two things to me

1. that you know that this is fairly weak reasoning

2. despite the weakness of your case you would actually want Amega lynched over it

 

those two things lead me to think that you therefore know Amega is not on your team because why else would you want to lynch someone over such weak reasoning?

based on what you said it looks like you're going for an "easy lynch"

 

perhaps I'm going overboard though

I've been known to do such things in the past

I get caught up in my own little theories of what's going on

would anyone else like to weigh in on this?

 

It isn't really even a case, just doing as I said and "casting one out there". I may have a different hankering later but for now it's as good a vote as any.

to clarify are you in fact willing to lynch Amega?

 

I'm willing to lynch anyone. Would you like if I put my vote on someone else... it seems like you may be back dooring a defense of amega here. You don't seem to have a a problem with only 1 person voting him (pandy) but when a second person jumps on you all the sudden are suspicious...

 

Nolder hit the nail on the head methinks.

vote soy

 

And this reeks of fishyness. Nol makes an extraordinarily thin case against me (not even voting for me himself) and you're all the sudden like Oh yeah Nol is a mafia god and nailed a scum the first day on the first try, after only analyzing the second post that person made. Seriously?

 

Note: Possible Amega/Nol/Hoof connection (it's only day one though so probably not much to that.)

[Nolder]

to clarify are you in fact willing to lynch Amega?

 

I'm willing to lynch anyone. Would you like if I put my vote on someone else... it seems like you may be back dooring a defense of amega here. You don't seem to have a a problem with only 1 person voting him (pandy) but when a second person jumps on you all the sudden are suspicious...

it was what you said that roused my suspicion

however you've eased it by saying (even in a roundabout way) that you'd still be willing to lynch Amega

I'd have been more worried if you backed off because at this point in the game pretty much everyone should be a target

it was a test and you passed, grats

 

Nolder hit the nail on the head methinks.

vote soy

 

And this reeks of fishyness. Nol makes an extraordinarily thin case against me (not even voting for me himself) and you're all the sudden like Oh yeah Nol is a mafia god and nailed a scum the first day on the first try, after only analyzing the second post that person made. Seriously?

 

Note: Possible Amega/Nol/Hoof connection (it's only day one though so probably not much to that.)

I was waiting to see how you'd react to my test before voting you

as it happens I'm fine with where my votes at right now

I agree about Hoof, I think the vote was very premature

[Leelou]

*pokes Nol* Why are you voting for me?

[SBoydW]

Well in a deadline game that would make sense, but seeing as how there aren't set day deadlines in this game, might as cast one out there and hope.

 

Vote: amegakure

my thoughts on this post

you make a fair point about there being no deadlines

however that list bit strikes me as off

"cast one out there and hope" implies two things to me

1. that you know that this is fairly weak reasoning

2. despite the weakness of your case you would actually want Amega lynched over it

 

those two things lead me to think that you therefore know Amega is not on your team because why else would you want to lynch someone over such weak reasoning?

based on what you said it looks like you're going for an "easy lynch"

 

perhaps I'm going overboard though

I've been known to do such things in the past

I get caught up in my own little theories of what's going on

would anyone else like to weigh in on this?

 

Also to in reference to the bold. What would make me want to lynch someone so badly in the VERY beginning of the game. Not even scum would be pressing hard for a lynch on anyone right now unless someone just came and said Hey guys I'm the cop... and the doctor... and the vig, please lynch me.

 

And I never said I WANT to lynch amega. Placing a vote on someone is not necessarily a declaration of your desire to lynch said person. Votes are vanilla town's way of gathering info. Apply pressure see what happens.

 

BTW, didn't we already argue about the whole D1 vote thing a few games ago?

 

Any who. I applaud you for getting the game going, you do seem to have a knack for that.

[SBoydW]

ninja'ed X2

[Nolder]

Well in a deadline game that would make sense, but seeing as how there aren't set day deadlines in this game, might as cast one out there and hope.

 

Vote: amegakure

my thoughts on this post

you make a fair point about there being no deadlines

however that list bit strikes me as off

"cast one out there and hope" implies two things to me

1. that you know that this is fairly weak reasoning

2. despite the weakness of your case you would actually want Amega lynched over it

 

those two things lead me to think that you therefore know Amega is not on your team because why else would you want to lynch someone over such weak reasoning?

based on what you said it looks like you're going for an "easy lynch"

 

perhaps I'm going overboard though

I've been known to do such things in the past

I get caught up in my own little theories of what's going on

would anyone else like to weigh in on this?

 

Also to in reference to the bold. What would make me want to lynch someone so badly in the VERY beginning of the game. Not even scum would be pressing hard for a lynch on anyone right now unless someone just came and said Hey guys I'm the cop... and the doctor... and the vig, please lynch me.

a decent point

I definitely think you're smarter than that

 

And I never said I WANT to lynch amega.

no you didn't

however what you said did imply to me

however I know better than to just take action off assumptions like that which is why I asked you for clarification

 

Placing a vote on someone is not necessarily a declaration of your desire to lynch said person. Votes are vanilla town's way of gathering info. Apply pressure see what happens.

1. I definitely disagree with that

2. this seems like a soft claim...I don't like it

 

BTW, didn't we already argue about the whole D1 vote thing a few games ago?

 

Any who. I applaud you for getting the game going, you do seem to have a knack for that.

possibly

I often comment on D1 stuff

also thanks

 

*pokes Nol* Why are you voting for me?

putting my vote on a train

[SBoydW]

 

Placing a vote on someone is not necessarily a declaration of your desire to lynch said person. Votes are vanilla town's way of gathering info. Apply pressure see what happens.

1. I definitely disagree with that

2. this seems like a soft claim...I don't like it

 

Could you clarify the soft claim statement. I'm not sure what you mean.

[Leyrann]

uh....meta here....but i have recently thought joke votes irrelevant and a great tactic for scum to delay the beginning of day one. I just felt the need to say these thoughts again. I dont want anyone to think im trying to fly under the radar.

I assume he means that the longer people joke around and not do anything the more rushed people get to lynch someone, someone who is usually town.

 

I think you are right, and because of that - UNVOTE.

[John E. Kelley]

 

Placing a vote on someone is not necessarily a declaration of your desire to lynch said person. Votes are vanilla town's way of gathering info. Apply pressure see what happens.

1. I definitely disagree with that

2. this seems like a soft claim...I don't like it

 

Could you clarify the soft claim statement. I'm not sure what you mean.

 

Bolded could be interpreted as a Vanilla claim methinks.

[Leyrann]

Forget to bold again...

 

UNVOTE.

[Leyrann]

 

Placing a vote on someone is not necessarily a declaration of your desire to lynch said person. Votes are vanilla town's way of gathering info. Apply pressure see what happens.

1. I definitely disagree with that

2. this seems like a soft claim...I don't like it

 

Could you clarify the soft claim statement. I'm not sure what you mean.

 

Bolded could be interpreted as a Vanilla claim methinks.

 

I'd say it's the only way to gather information at D1.

[SBoydW]

 

Placing a vote on someone is not necessarily a declaration of your desire to lynch said person. Votes are vanilla town's way of gathering info. Apply pressure see what happens.

1. I definitely disagree with that

2. this seems like a soft claim...I don't like it

 

Could you clarify the soft claim statement. I'm not sure what you mean.

 

Bolded could be interpreted as a Vanilla claim methinks.

 

Ahh...

[Amadine]

Bolding is preferred but not required. As long as it is RED it will count.

[ed2funy]

Yea, Nolder has a point on soft claim.

[Leyrann]

Bolding is preferred but not required. As long as it is RED it will count.

 

You can easily miss it in my green posts... Or maybe that's just because I'm a bit colourblind...

[SBoydW]

Stupid... I was going to continue on and say, that wasn't a claim of any kind. Just stating a fact.

[Amadine]

Bolding is preferred but not required. As long as it is RED it will count.

 

You can easily miss it in my green posts... Or maybe that's just because I'm a bit colourblind...

 

Yeah... RED and GREEN are very different to me, i am sure i will be able to find your votes Ley, bolded or unbolded

[Leelou]

*pokes Nol* Why are you voting for me?

putting my vote on a train

 

Correction: You are starting a train.

 

And I don't mind joke votes for a bit. Gets conversation started. Especially while waiting for all of the players to show up. Once everyone is here is when I really like to get going with the game.

[Nolder]

*pokes Nol* Why are you voting for me?

putting my vote on a train

 

Correction: You are starting a train.

 

And I don't mind joke votes for a bit. Gets conversation started. Especially while waiting for all of the players to show up. Once everyone is here is when I really like to get going with the game.

fair enough

it's not a joke vote though

if it was I'd make that obvious

I am completely willing to lynch you at this point

as much as anyone else anyway

 

@Soy: what Ishy said, seems like you're trying to hint that you're vanilla without saying it outright

dunno why a vanilla would softclaim vanilla personally but then I don't know why scum would softclaim vanilla either

I think I'm going to conclude that you weren't softclaiming at all since it doesn't make sense from any perspective I can think of