[BASIC] Lord of the Rings Mafia GAME OVER!!!

[Sakaea]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Tiinker (1) -- Ape

 

 

Not voting: Maw, Ithi, Ledinna, Verbal, Ishy, Tiinker, Min, WWWomby

[Minuet]

Ledinna you are correct that the mafia would not know who the SK is. Unless the Mod decided to put a twist to it, which seeing as they killed the SK I would have to say "no" they didn't know who the SK was.

 

 

After reviewing the vote count and the claims that are out there, I would say that Verbal and Ledinna are probably our mafia team. One of them would be the godfather and one a goon probably. At least that is what I think so far. Going on hunch and deductive reasoning here of what I know. No I am not the finder. This is not a ploy to have them reveal either. Knowing that Sam is a mason means Merry and Pippin are our cop and healer. Goodness help us if Pippin Took is our cop. *giggles* Just a book reference, no way does that mean the person who got the role is a fool. With a SK in the game I think we only have 2 remaining mafia members.

 

So, with that vote Verbal

 

I think Ledinna is being coached, but that is still just a hunch and to be honest we can lynch her tomorrow if Verbal is mafia. This of course is if John is not mafia. Which I will be honest, I don't think he is at this point.

 

[John E. Kelley]

At this point, I'd like to hear from Wom as well, he's been awol for awhile now. Loa or lurking? I'll do a reread and see if I notice anything on Verb too Min.

[John E. Kelley]

And if Verb and Led are our last two, her getting coached makes that much more sense, Verb would have been perfect for the mod to pair up with a first time player.

[Minuet]

What I was thinking to be honest. Not to mention he jumped on the lynch wagon at the end. It is the weekend and I know some people don't get on then.

[WWWwombat]

Ishy comments about everything and seems incapable of making a post where he doesn't state he is Town.

 

I'm incapable of making a post where I don't state I'm town? Do you maybe have an example you'd care to share with us? But we all already know the answer to that, there isn't one. There isn't one single post in this game where I say a word about roles / alignments anything like that where it concerns me. Not one. FoS at you for trying to paint me in a negative light. If you want to make accusations about me, at least try to use something based on facts and not made up, non-existant gibberish.

 

I'm Ishy and I approve of this message.

 

I'd like to hear from Ithy on this.

[John E. Kelley]

Ledinna is playing opportunistically and could be getting some coaching.

 

And it seems that others have already thought about that too.

[WWWwombat]

Maw is mason. Leyrann was Gollum. She voted Maw first, dumb of me not to catch this the first time through.... Scum needed a competing train with Leyrann and that Maw train was rapid. Ledinna also needed a competing train... Ledinna, Tink, Minuet.

 

At least one of those 3 are scum, without question. Look at how the D1 trains moved, you'll see it.

 

Vote Ledinna

 

Don't care what order we lynch them in, tbh. Ledinna is playing opportunistically and could be getting some coaching.

 

First a useless vote on Amadine and now this. Why would scum put themselves out there that much just because of 2 votes on a goon? You are def pinging now. I think maybe you are trying to distract from your useless vote and possible bussing votes on Leyrann.

[WWWwombat]

Vote: Amadine

 

She was in good bussing position on Leyrann and her lynch might give us some info on the Ape. Also, FoS Ape and Verbal. Ape for bad arguments and Verbal because I don't feel quite right about his hammering Leyrann. There seemed to be no caution there. Possible bus move.

[Netbattler11]

...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ama was nk'd by leelou, who was nk'd by the mafioso.

[Netbattler11]

Are you playing the same game we are?

[Ithillian Turambar]

Well that's a gem of a prize. Wonder if this is something that will be passed around every night or what. Would be pretty useless for the doc probably.

 

Commenting about the ring and how it might work. Apparently commenting and theorising how it all works is a known mafia tell - or so I've been told in this game ;-)

 

Wom, Amadine and Tink, leave the scum QT and come get involved.....

 

Naming others as Mafia, thus indicating he couldn't possibly be himself.

 

 

Well, that's the second time in three games we got scum on D1. I chalk it up to my outstanding play.

 

'We got scum' = I am Town

 

Seriously, whoever you are, get in your NA....

 

I have no night action, I am not Mafia

 

-------------------------------------

 

I really hope you appreciate me getting that together. Its an absolute arse on a mobile with no multiquote thingy. According to John, making statements like this is a Mafia tell. I mentioned Ishy cos he was making them and yet John said nothing, whereas I made a comment about the NKs and had a Mafia target painted on my back.

 

Another thing. Min, why do you think that the Healer and Cop have to be Pippin and Merry? Surely Aragorn would make the better Healer - it was a talent he had in the book after all. And Gandalf would make a better Finder - cos he's got the Magic Powers. I'd love to know your reasoning.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Ithi is spelt with an 'i' not a 'y' also. A little courtesy please.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Oh and to clarify my Ishy Quotes - the bits underneath are my interpretation of what HE is actually saying in each post.

[WWWwombat]

...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ama was nk'd by leelou, who was nk'd by the mafioso.

 

>.<

 

unvote

[WWWwombat]

Vote: Ape

[Minuet]

Another thing. Min, why do you think that the Healer and Cop have to be Pippin and Merry? Surely Aragorn would make the better Healer - it was a talent he had in the book after all. And Gandalf would make a better Finder - cos he's got the Magic Powers. I'd love to know your reasoning.

 

Actually I was in hobbit mood when I was thinking of them. Maybe with so few players we don't even have Merry and Pippin. I was just speculating too. Trying to stimulate conversation.

[John E. Kelley]

Oh and to clarify my Ishy Quotes - the bits underneath are my interpretation of what HE is actually saying in each post.

 

Don't know why I'm suprised at this....I've been saying stuff my whole life and women have been telling me what I "really" said.....

 

"If a man is alone in the woods, and there's no woman there to hear him, is he still wrong?"

[John McClane]

What I was thinking to be honest. Not to mention he jumped on the lynch wagon at the end. It is the weekend and I know some people don't get on then.

 

This is a possibility.

 

Verbal could have easily bussed by hopping on Leyrann's train. My guess is that one scum might have bussed, and one was on the Leyrann train as I pointed out with my post earlier where I voted Ledinna and then Tinker.

[Ithillian Turambar]

What is this Bussing? Also Ishy - I see your righteous anger has disappeared and been replaced by humour again. Very nice.

 

I've not seen Verb around on any of the Boards to be honest - and he is supposed to be adding people to a special secret board for me. Maybe he is off out and about somewhere.

[John McClane]

Maw is mason. Leyrann was Gollum. She voted Maw first, dumb of me not to catch this the first time through.... Scum needed a competing train with Leyrann and that Maw train was rapid. Ledinna also needed a competing train... Ledinna, Tink, Minuet.

 

At least one of those 3 are scum, without question. Look at how the D1 trains moved, you'll see it.

 

Vote Ledinna

 

Don't care what order we lynch them in, tbh. Ledinna is playing opportunistically and could be getting some coaching.

 

First a useless vote on Amadine and now this. Why would scum put themselves out there that much just because of 2 votes on a goon? You are def pinging now. I think maybe you are trying to distract from your useless vote and possible bussing votes on Leyrann.

 

Vote on Amadine was with reason - I just hadn't been back online to move it to one of the trains that were realistic in time for the deadline. You want to lynch me for not being around for a deadline?

 

Also, I don't think its far fetched at all in a 12 person game to imagine that there's at least 1 scum on the train for an uncountered mason that was the competing train for scum who was eventually lynched. In fact, it seems like common sense to me.

 

Vote: Amadine

 

She was in good bussing position on Leyrann and her lynch might give us some info on the Ape. Also, FoS Ape and Verbal. Ape for bad arguments and Verbal because I don't feel quite right about his hammering Leyrann. There seemed to be no caution there. Possible bus move.

 

Oh wow. You are voting the person you just told me I had a useless vote on.... who happens to be dead. This reeks like a "womby didn't have any NK actions, so womby didn't notice who died" play.

 

Only thing I agree with you about is Verbal's excitement over hammering Leyran, which I stated above.

 

Vote: Ape

 

Pfft... lol.

[John McClane]

What is this Bussing? Also Ishy - I see your righteous anger has disappeared and been replaced by humour again. Very nice.

 

I've not seen Verb around on any of the Boards to be honest - and he is supposed to be adding people to a special secret board for me. Maybe he is off out and about somewhere.

 

Bussing is when scum hops on the train for fellow scum, essentially giving them up to the lynch mob - so as to appear like part of the town that wanted scum dead.

 

Verbal's hammer was kinda scummy looking - since he didn't wait for Leyrann to defend herself at all really.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Gotcha. I thought Leyrann was a guy? How close off of deadline were we when he Hammered?

[John McClane]

Another thing. Min, why do you think that the Healer and Cop have to be Pippin and Merry? Surely Aragorn would make the better Healer - it was a talent he had in the book after all. And Gandalf would make a better Finder - cos he's got the Magic Powers. I'd love to know your reasoning.

 

Actually I was in hobbit mood when I was thinking of them. Maybe with so few players we don't even have Merry and Pippin. I was just speculating too. Trying to stimulate conversation.

 

 

I think both of you talk about setup like this is kinda scummy.

[John McClane]

Gotcha. I thought Leyrann was a guy? How close off of deadline were we when he Hammered?

 

Oh, I've been saying she... I have no idea for half the people in this game what sex they are. Apologies, I'll figure it out. The names many of you choose are very asexual to someone not familiar with these books...

 

As for the deadline, I'm not entirely sure, haven't looked it up yet. I wasn't around for it.