[Basic] Saw Mafia - Day 6

[Red2111]

JLM; Reggie Garfunkle, guilty of Murder and Mafia Team Member has been lynched

Deadline

 

Deadline is sometime Thursday, Sept 29th or when all NA's have been recieved

 

17:52:30

[Louise]

Ed: Sorry I'm having a lot of trouble with quotes lately. So in response to post 523:

 

Lol.

I'm actually kind of sorry, I hadn't intended to hammer it home like that, was sort of just a point of interest. (probably should have left out the FoS)

 

When I posted earlier I was actually going to say this but didn't because I thought it might have looked kind of stange. In a bizarre turn of events, I completely agree with you and my FoS is now pointed at Nolder

[Nolder]

I am FOS Noldy on FOSing you for FOSing me. o_O

Noldy, her concerns about me not posting were legit.

I am not scum, but I see where she is coming from.

I don't agree

I don't think people should be held accountable for their actions on the internet aside from posting in game

maybe this game isn't priority number 1 for some people

maybe they'd rather check their emails, post in other threads, watch some videos on youtube, and THEN come to post in a mafia thread

 

just because of that they should not be voted off as scum

if you lurk consistently maybe but just because you were posting in another thread? no I think that's wrong

 

I actually think that kind of breaks etiquette of what is and is not ok in mafia

but as that's mostly an unwritten thing maybe others don't feel the same as me

 

anyway I feel it's a weak case to fos you for that reason so my fos stands

[Nolder]

also I'm not sure why you guys think it's me

can you explain please?

[ed2funy]

Yes, we can. :D

 

 

May you explain why you want us to explain?

[Nolder]

Yes, we can. :D

 

 

May you explain why you want us to explain?

so I can attempt to convince you otherwise obviously

[Red2111]

Tina the cop and Ed a Vanilla Townie have been killed.

 

it's now day

 

 

 

Deadline

 

Deadline is sometime Sunday, October 2nd. 4 alive, 3 to lynch

 

16:50:13

 

Vote Count

 

No Vote (04): Nol, Sakaea, Louii, Ley

 

[Nolder]

oh god

am I in 4 way lylo with a SK?

 

FML

[Niniel]

I´m so surprised.

 

Go town!!

[Nolder]

based on vote counts alone I'm leaning towards Sak being the mafia

I have to reread more though

[Nolder]

errr sorry I forgot you don't like sak, I keep forgetting

[Nolder]

Red is there a difference between the terms killed and night killed?

you've switched between them in the same posts twice so I'm a little confused

[Red2111]

nah Nol, they mean the same thing

[ed2funy]

Tina the cop and Ed a Vanilla Townie have been killed.

 

 

 

-__________________________________________________-

 

 

 

Great game AGAIN, Red! :D

[Nolder]

what happens if no majority is reached by the deadline?

sorry to ask more questions but uhhh I didn't see mention of it in the rules

[Sakaea]

After you saying that, Nol, I went and looked at all of the vote counts, and here's what jumped out at me:

 

Day 1 lynch, Mawthtex, Leyrann was the second to last vote. Maw flipped town.

 

Day 2 lynch, Amega, Leyrann hammered. Amega flipped town.

 

Day 3 lynch, Verbal, Leyrann didn't vote, and we knew Verbal would flip mafia.

 

Day 4 lynch, JLM, Leyrann hammered, and we knew JLM would flip mafia.

 

To me, that screams of scum going "Oh shit, I should have voted for team mate #1, and I didn't, so I'll hammer team mate #2."

 

There's 4 of us left. I know I'm not scum/SK. I'm pretty sure Nolder isn't either (just gut feeling). So that means Leyrann and Louii are scum and SK. So FOS at Louii, and VOTE LEY

[Sakaea]

And I believe it goes random if there's no majority, btw.

[Red2111]

np Nol on the questions

 

 

if their isn't a majority by the tie the deadline hits, the vote will resort into a random lynch from all players still alive.

[Leyrann]

Day 1 lynch, Mawthtex, Leyrann was the second to last vote. Maw flipped town.

 

Day 2 lynch, Amega, Leyrann hammered. Amega flipped town.

 

Day 3 lynch, Verbal, Leyrann didn't vote, and we knew Verbal would flip mafia.

 

Day 4 lynch, JLM, Leyrann hammered, and we knew JLM would flip mafia.

 

Day 1: Near deadline, we were sure no one else would be lynched. I didn't want random.

 

Day 2: Already hammered before my vote. I made it L+1. It was just a bit for fun I still voted.

 

Day 3: I wanted to vote before going to bed, but then my parents called me for something, that took 10 minutes, when I was back, I had already shut down my computer when I thought of the vote. That was before Verb declared himself mafia. Deadline was while I was sleeping.

 

Day 4: Who would not vote for mafia?

[Nolder]

I'm pretty sure Sakaea is the mafia and Ley is the SK

but I could be wrong

I don't really see a way out of this...

 

if we lynch one scum the other wins so that's no good

if we lynch a townie we autolose either way regardless that's no good either

 

if we nl I think three things can happen

1. scum kill each other, town wins

2. scum kill the same townie and we enter 3 way where the townie gets to pick who wins

3. one scum kills a townie while the other scum kills the other scum resulting in a town lose

 

so uhhh

yeah

unless I'm very much mistaken the only real option here town has is to nl and pray because we more or less already lost

 

Vote: No Lynch

[Sakaea]

I'll go with that. Assuming one scum, one SK, and 2 town, we have like a 50/50 shot of a town win. UNVOTE, VOTE NO LYNCH

 

Ley, I don't know whether to believe you or not atm. Thanks for answering, tho.

[Louise]

Well I can't see any other option now, I doubt we're going to be able to get a consensus on anything else....

 

Vote No Lynch

[Leyrann]

I agree with you (and then I mean both Nol and Louii).

 

Vote No Lynch

[Red2111]

Deadline

 

Deadline is sometime Sunday, October 2nd. 4 alive, 3 to lynch

 

16:30:44

 

Vote Count

 

No Lynch (4): Nol, Sakaea, Louii, Ley

 

 

 

NO LYNCH HAS OCCURED!

 

Deadline

Sat, Oct 1st @ 10pm CST or when all NA's have been revieved.

 

15:41:53

 

[Nolder]

correct me if I'm wrong but I believe we've now entered a form of Prisoner's Dilemma

IIRC the usual mafia form of this is 1SK, 1Maf, 1Village but I think this still counts