[Advanced] Malazan Mafia - Game On

[Ithillian Turambar]

I'm on a Mason Team that was with Berf. The two of us. He didn't do an action. We were both Vanilla Town Masons. He didn't play and posted once. He got replaced by Kill, who also didn't do an action. I have been mostly chatting to Jack for the whole of this game.

 

That's the truth.

 

Believe it or don't believe it. I can't make you. If she had picked anyone else it would have just been her word against that one person. But me and Kill are together. We both know what she said didn't happen. And I would never lie about anything to do with Friends. People who know me know this.

 

 

Now according to the wiki, I can control a pack of great big nasty hound things. That would have been far more interesting, but Jack neglected to let me have any.

[killuliu]

Lily could have done what she said (use her supposed redirecting ability on me and redirect my supposed NA to Red) and then the mafia could have targeted Red by coincidence, but that isn't very likely.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Yeah but you didn't have a night action. So why would she say you had?

[Krakalakachkn]

Lily could have done what she said (use her supposed redirecting ability on me and redirect my supposed NA to Red) and then the mafia could have targeted Red by coincidence, but that isn't very likely.

 

Then what about Nolder?

[Sedai]

Vote Count - 6 to lynch

 

 

Lily (6) - ithy, Amadine, ed, wombat, kill, Tina

Kil (1) - lily

[Ithillian Turambar]

Kill also voted Lily

[killuliu]

Lily could have done what she said (use her supposed redirecting ability on me and redirect my supposed NA to Red) and then the mafia could have targeted Red by coincidence, but that isn't very likely.

 

Then what about Nolder?

 

How would I know? Maybe we have a SK, another Vig or something (or then the mafia has two killers, for example arsonist and normal killer (the setup of Alanna's Aiel vs Seanchan -mafia))

 

 

 

[bhskeeper11]

I'm on a Mason Team that was with Berf. The two of us. He didn't do an action. We were both Vanilla Town Masons. He didn't play and posted once. He got replaced by Kill, who also didn't do an action. I have been mostly chatting to Jack for the whole of this game.

 

That's the truth.

 

Believe it or don't believe it. I can't make you. If she had picked anyone else it would have just been her word against that one person. But me and Kill are together. We both know what she said didn't happen. And I would never lie about anything to do with Friends. People who know me know this.

 

 

Now according to the wiki, I can control a pack of great big nasty hound things. That would have been far more interesting, but Jack neglected to let me have any.

 

 

Lily could have done what she said (use her supposed redirecting ability on me and redirect my supposed NA to Red) and then the mafia could have targeted Red by coincidence, but that isn't very likely.

 

 

Yeah but you didn't have a night action. So why would she say you had?

 

 

Something about this all just doesn't smell right. First, it's because you didn't do an NA. Then, it's because you don't have one. And, it sounds like Kill is just trying to follow along with what Ithi is saying and parroting what she says back to us.

 

Vote Ithi.

 

If she flips Town Mason, I'll be fine going for Lily. Or, if you all have some thing against lynching Ithi, we can go for Kill instead. There is definitely something going on between the two, so a coroner's report on one can save the other. If we lynch one of the two, the worst case scenario is we lynch a vanilla Town, best case is we get two mafia. If we lynch Lily, we'll be potentially losing a roled Townie vs. lynching just one mafia.

 

Either way, it's a she-said, she-said argument until we get a coroner's report.

[bhskeeper11]

Oops.

 

Unvote. Vote Ithi.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Oh MAN ! Kate you are sooooo on the Mafia team. Lol

 

Hahaha

 

Brilliant.

 

:totallyliedtomyfaceatthestartofthegame:

[Krakalakachkn]

:whatisthis:

 

 

:whyisthishappening:

 

 

 

:whydidkirkcameronmakelefbehind:

[Ithillian Turambar]

Sorry Krak - only the cool kids from the WT know what it is.

 

:andfilthycopyingSGdreadlords:

[bhskeeper11]

Oh MAN ! Kate you are sooooo on the Mafia team. Lol

 

Hahaha

 

Brilliant.

 

:totallyliedtomyfaceatthestartofthegame:

 

If you think so, you are sadly mistaken. I am all Town.

 

However, I'm confident with where my vote sits.

 

:whatisKrakgoingonabout:

[Krakalakachkn]

:howdyouknowiwasadreadlord:

 

 

Also, I like this idea of the Lily vs. Ithillian train. This will tell us a lot.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Oh I always thought you were SS like berf.

 

:wasreferringtoEddietheDreadie:

[Ithillian Turambar]

:howdyouknowiwasadreadlord:

 

 

Also, I like this idea of the Lily vs. Ithillian train. This will tell us a lot.

 

Yeah it will tell you that I am a Townie Mason. Isn't it interesting that Lily's train has been derailed everytime.

 

If I'm lynched you may well be able to identify the Mafia team though. Are there enough of us left for that to work?

[Ithillian Turambar]

Also - semantics@Kate.

 

If you are Town, you are making a big mistake.

[bhskeeper11]

I'm not saying I know 100% that you are mafia, but I think I have a more-than-decent shot at being correct.

 

I just don't like how that all played out. It just felt like you were telling Kill what to say, reminding him that he supposedly has no night action.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Oh right. No - I was saying that it is unlikely to be a co-incidence as there was no action to redirect. So Lily had lied in her initial statement. Little lie, big lie as far as I'm concerned.

[bhskeeper11]

Eh, maybe I just read it wrong or maybe I read it right. However, regardless, I still think that the whole thing doesn't sit right with me.

 

I've said what I think the best course of action is at this point, so I guess we'll see what the rest of the players want to do.

[WWWwombat]

Could be seeing town on town violence.

 

unvote

 

1. Lily - claimed Ganoes Paran, Redirector

2. Tina

3. Ithi - claimed Shadowthrone, Mason

4. Kil - claimed the Rope, Mason

5. Wombat - Blend, 50% chance of avoiding NAs

8. Amadine

11. Kate

12. Ishmael

13. Christine

15. Krak

16. Ed - claimed 2-shot vig?

 

I would like claims from everyone (especially Krak, Kate, and Ishy). Going top to bottom, Tina is next.

[WWWwombat]

Also, let me know if I switched you Ithy and Kill

[Niniel]

I find myself believing Ithi. It would be stupid of her to out herself and a team member if she wasn´t telling the truth. There is a small chance that both Lily and Ithi are telling the truth. Someone said that she could have done what she says she has done and then mafia (or someone else) killed Red. It could be true but seams very unlikely. Vote Lily.

[Ithillian Turambar]

No- you have it right Wwwwwwwwombat.

[bhskeeper11]

I find myself believing Ithi. It would be stupid of her to out herself and a team member if she wasn´t telling the truth. There is a small chance that both Lily and Ithi are telling the truth. Someone said that she could have done what she says she has done and then mafia (or someone else) killed Red. It could be true but seams very unlikely. Vote Lily.

 

I agree with your first point. It would seem a bit silly to do, but I just smell gambit. It was Kill that threw out the idea that maybe if Lily flipped Town, they could all be telling the truth. To me, that seems like setting up a reaction to the coroner's report. All in all, this only furthers my suspicions.