[Basic] Lily's Aladdin Mafia - Game Over

[Christine]

Why? Because I was hoping someone else would post something scummier before the deadline got closer. I just found it odd.

[LilyElizabeth]

*not so gently nudges her sister away from the line she is trying to cross* I'm serious, Sis. Don't push it, okay?

[Minuet]

But.... okay it would hurt the town and I don't want to do that.

 

Well, I have at least voted for someone. How about the rest of you?

[Minuet]

Too bad Player wasn't in this game too. I would try to lynch him here. Sis, you know how I get when I get pissed off. Sorry, metagaming. However, posting.....

[Sedai]

Well, I'm certainly flattered, waking up to two votes on me, but I don't believe it is a smart way to vote, as the scum are going to be mighty pleased when the townies have killed yet another town, and then the mafia are just sitting there laughing at us.

 

 

Christine, why did you wait for a good four hours or so before calling Kat out on being overly defensive in her post, while still being active within that time frame?

 

And Jack, are you saying that you can't find even a hint of scummy behaviour in the game?

 

I find Verbs killing to be the hardest evidence we have to go on. I traced it back and you are where the lines intersect. It's been 8 pages and tbh nothing extremely scummy has caught my eye.

[Christine]

Peoples are far too quiet. We have a possible lynch target and no convo.

 

vote arlow because I am intoxicated and he didn't answer my q even though its afternoon there

[LilyElizabeth]

Vote count:

 

Arlow (3) – Min, Jack, Christine

 

Not voting – Kat, Arlow, Ameg, Ed

 

With 7 alive, you need 4 to lynch.

Deadline Saturday 5 PM MST

[amegakure]

I just got home from work and nothing new has happened im choosing not to vote arlow cause I don't see the point in siding with such weak cases. I might change my mind in the morning though

[murf2011]

What question was that? the "any response to Min's vote"? There's not really any way to respond to a vote cast on a gut feeling... and even though it is afternoon, I was out shopping for more stuff for my house, as it's very sparse and we needed electricals and stuff. I can go into details on what we bought if you want.

 

And how is being intoxicated relevant to any vote?

[ed2funy]

Players

1. Kat

2. Jack

3. Arlow

4. Christine

5. Verbal, Aladdin, roleless townie, night kill night 1

6. Wolfbrother

7. Ed

8. Minuet

9. Thorkin, Sultan, roleless townie, lynched day 1

 

 

Kill Order

Thorkin - D1 Lynch - Town

Verbal - NK 1 - Town

 

 

7 Alive 4 to Lynch.

Big game...either newer kids, or experienced ones looking for nice WIFOMs.

*looking at Jack here*

 

 

Well, I'm certainly flattered, waking up to two votes on me, but I don't believe it is a smart way to vote, as the scum are going to be mighty pleased when the townies have killed yet another town, and then the mafia are just sitting there laughing at us.

 

 

Christine, why did you wait for a good four hours or so before calling Kat out on being overly defensive in her post, while still being active within that time frame?

 

And Jack, are you saying that you can't find even a hint of scummy behaviour in the game?

Ummm, not really a defense. More of a "omg, I'm town, don't do it!" plea.

 

 

What question was that? the "any response to Min's vote"? There's not really any way to respond to a vote cast on a gut feeling... and even though it is afternoon, I was out shopping for more stuff for my house, as it's very sparse and we needed electricals and stuff. I can go into details on what we bought if you want.

 

And how is being intoxicated relevant to any vote?

Noted about not really having a defense here, but still hold by my response to the bolded up thar.

 

 

[Christine]

You aren't really defending yourself, and I don't see anyone else to target. Also, hungovver me concurs with drunk me

[murf2011]

How the hell am I supposed to defend myself over a gut vote, a voter who only wants an easy lynch, and a drunk voter? come on, if i had even tried, you guys would have gone after me for being "over defensive" and the outcome would've been the same as it is now. Christine, I think your vote on me is sus, because I don't see how someone can defend against a "gut" vote... How would you do it, if i voted you and said, i have a feeling?

 

Jack, so you didn't find Kat's post overly defensive or anything? Or did you find that it wasn't, and saw that Christine's vote on her because of the "overly defensive post" might be scummy?

I personally didn't find it overly defensive, as Kat posts like that in most of her games, and so I thought that Christine's vote was a tad scummy, but nothing extreme.

Or what about Christine trying to split votes from Thorkin onto Kat?

 

(Christine, I'm not trying to single you out here, but these are posts that are catching my attention)

 

Also Christine, who did you mean by this?

 

Ok. After flipping through Verbal's basic chit chat, I would say that his death POINTS at Red and Jack. That being said, that is flat out too obvious for them, so FOR NOW, I am considering them not the scum.

 

 

Any response, Arlow, to Min's vote?

 

Red isn't in this game?

 

I see no way I'm not gonna die, coz the deadline's today, and there's nothing else going on coz everyone's focused on lynching me, but I'm trying to provoke some conversation to help town on Day 3. Come on guys, don't let it get down to this again on Day 3, otherwise you're all screwed.

 

Sorry if I sound shitty, but even for a fast game, not much has been going on.

[ed2funy]

Hmmmm, I'm not feeling this vibe any of you are getting from Arlow atm, so

 

Vote Christine

 

I should be up for awhile....not at deadline, but if there is no activity, I may consider hammering. >.<

[Christine]

 

I personally didn't find it overly defensive, as Kat posts like that in most of her games, and so I thought that Christine's vote was a tad scummy, but nothing extreme.

Or what about Christine trying to split votes from Thorkin onto Kat?

 

 

 

Also Christine, who did you mean by this?

 

Ok. After flipping through Verbal's basic chit chat, I would say that his death POINTS at Red and Jack. That being said, that is flat out too obvious for them, so FOR NOW, I am considering them not the scum.

 

 

Any response, Arlow, to Min's vote?

 

Red isn't in this game?

 

 

[Christine]

Woops didn't mean to hit post. Crap. Ok, well here is what I have to say in response.

 

1. I did not mean to type Red. I actually meant Min. Sorry. Thanks for correcting me on that, I actually meant Min.

 

 

2. I have never played with Kat before, but it seemed overly defensive. Perhaps that is how she plays, but I don't know that.

 

 

3. Me trying to "split votes" from Thorkin would be a better point if Thorkin had flipped Mafia. He didn't. I saw an innocent guy getting voted on, so I voted for who I thought was scummy. What about Ed taking away from the Arlow posting? Trying to "split votes"?

 

Yeah.

[ed2funy]

Spliting votes is splitting votes.

lol, And I'm not ready to hammer him, so I'm fine with splitting the vote here.

[amegakure]

.I would say that ed is trying to split votes, he like me dosent see that arlow is scummy. Plus kat didn't seem defensive at all. And really you can't cast a super weak fos on arlow by saying your going with ur instincts and on top of the drunk vote him. So im gonna go with ed and vote christine

[murf2011]

Christine, I didn't expect Ed to vote for you, I was just providing some info for tomorrow's discussion. But because he has, and Amega has, I feel like I still have a chance to live, and I'm not gonna forgo it, because I like to stay alive as long as i can in mafia games, so VOTE Christine.

[ed2funy]

Vote count:

 

Arlow (3) – Min, Jack, Christine

Christine (3) - Ed, Ameg, Arlow

 

Not voting – Kat

 

With 7 alive, you need 4 to lynch.

Deadline Saturday 5 PM MST

 

 

 

>.<

What we have is an old-fashioned Mexican standoff here...

 

 

[murf2011]

And Kat left about 20 minutes ago to go out for the rest of the day :/ won't be home until about an hour or two before deadline...

[murf2011]

Also Christine, you never answered my question. How would you defend yourself against a vote from me if I based it on a feeling?

[Minuet]

Since I am the gut feeling vote I will solve it here. Unvote. I will say that gut votes can be totally off. Arlow you hadn't said much in your defense earlier. However, your longer post up there where you mentioned the votes and how you felt about them was the response I wanted. Yes, you can say something to defend against a gut feeling vote. You can call the person out and let them know they are wrong. I did that with Jack in a game.

 

I see you points about Christine. She would have been my choice for tomorrow if we lynched you today. So, why wait?

 

Vote Christine

 

 

Oh, I think that is the hammer.

[Christine]

You guys messed up.

[Christine]

After this y'all should look at an arlow ed alliance.

[ed2funy]

Hmmm, yea, I'd be more looking at Arlow/Ameg.

Or even Ameg/Me (but we're not).

 

I see why you'd say that, but no. We're not.