[Advanced] Monty Python and the Holy Grail Mafia (Game Over)

[Sedai]

I think I'm hammered.

 

Well anyways, town, please don't lose this game. Look at red more closely. Her unwillingness to answer one question, her post trimming, and her just general leading town everywhere plus anyone who thinks she's scum or thinks differently then her is scum attitude is very scummy

 

That's my piece of advice. Take it for what it's worth.

[Sedai]

Then when I bring a point up that would incriminate Red from her own actions. She doesn't respond. And I'm the scummy one.

[Sedai]

Now that's it I think.

[keyholder21]

We need 13 to lynch and that's only 10.

[trench]

In the intrests of avoiding a random lynch I will Unvote Vote Jack I still think Min is a better option, but we can pursue that on Day 3.

[trench]

I have Jack at L1 by my count, I think were gonna need an official one.

[sVieira151]

  On 6/26/2011 at 3:36 PM, Jack_D said:

  On 6/26/2011 at 3:21 PM, Vieira151 said:

Hmmm. It seems DL is coming up soon. I don't feel like I have enough to go on to lynch anyone, but in the hope of a controlled lynch, I'm going to vote Jack. The only reason being he has appeared the most scummy out of everyone in my eyes. Obviously I hope he is scum, but he may every well not be; which will be unfortunate.

 

How have I been the most scummy?

 

Is it because I asked one question, and gave reasons I thought validated the question?

 

Is it because I had back and forths with people I found scummy and found a person most believed to be scum?

 

Or is it because I called red out on trimming posts to fit into cases. Omitting key facts, that would possibly vet the person she is casing?

 

Maybe it's because red refused to answer my question and I didn't back down.

 

I can see how all that is unfriendly to the town and very scummy. Not.

 

This is a joke, it really is. The last vote has been the only one with an ounce of truth. No one can give me a solid reason for me playing scummy. The only thing they can say is they don't like my play style. I don't fit in their perfect world of how mafia should be played. Well I'm not Gina change so this should be a fun relationship.

 

I'll quote myself from earlier:

 

  Quote

Jack has seemed the most scummy to me as he has been acting erratically and single-mindedly for the majority of day 2.

 

Don't bite back and tell me this is your playstyle, as from what I noticed/read from early Day 2 and Day 1, you did not play this way. It seemed you became agitated that Red did not answer you(yeah, this has her 2nd on my list) and you just kept trying to squeeze the answer from her. And more recently you have been rambling and joking about your (seemingly) inevitable lynch. Most people would act in a similar fashion, but I don't like how you are just shouting out against people(Moon and Red) and basically implying "oh lookie here, these people are WAAAYY more scummy than me, yet you are all voting me? F*** you all"(At least that is the impression I get). You are just restating the same points over and over(they are decent points, but not enough for me to attempt a lynch on either of them now) and it isn't helping you.

Also, I am fairly new on the Mafia/Werewolf scene. I don't have an ideals about the game. I'm still discovering the different play-styles of different people, and I'm still developing my own. It's quite odd, as the two environments I play in have vastly different approaches to games.

 

For example, I'll take a little out of your book(from what you said to Red once):

 

  Quote

I find all of this comical. Bitterly so that is. Carry on with this trumped up train. A train so pathetic that people have stopped using reasons. Just saying, "what they said." which in itself is either a lazy town or a safe playing scum sign at that.

You wouldn't be saying this if it wasn't your own lynch.

 

In-Post EDIT: Seems Jack has went on one of his wee post sprees(that also doesn't help in my mind your case. If anything, it makes you seem agitated and in a rush to post things, rather than taking your time to post)

 

  Quote

Then when I bring a point up that would incriminate Red from her own actions. She doesn't respond. And I'm the scummy one.

 

I see you are mislead. Her not responding makes her more scummy, not you. You are scummy for other reasons such as the ones I stated above. I will gladly look at Red and Moon and Min closely next day in the hope I see what you see, Jack. They are the main ones I've had bad vibes from(besides yourself), but as I stated earlier I was uncomfortable with placing my vote.

Unfortunately, as you had the most votes it appeared easier to achieve a controlled lynch with a vote on you(I would have probably voted whoever had the greatest votes at the time. I am still not sure enough of any scum to pursue a lynch from scratch.)

[Krakalakachkn]

Vote Count

 

 

Red(3): Min, Jack, leelou

Min(1): Kil

Jack(11): Charis, csarmi, bg, red, ama, christine, GF, key, vieira, tiinker, trench

 

 

Day 2 ends in one hour.

 

With 24 alive it takes 13 to lynch.

[Sedai]

I know that. My post was meant to be sarcastic.

 

I would have said the same thing about the train if it wasn't mine. Check Alanna's aiel game. I said the same thing when another player was being lynched. I said "everyone restating others reasons looks scummy. If your going to godlessly bandwagon just say so. Don't over glorify a vote you have no real reason for." so no, I practice what I preach

 

That's just how I post. I thought I was hammered. So I wanted to get everything out before the death scene.

 

For a New player Vie, that was an extremely well articulated post. I think you'll do well in this game. (meaning mafia in general)

[csarmi]

Don't talk about games in progress Jack. That might get you modkilled. Especially when your mod play here as well.

[Sedai]

Sorry for the post being scattered. I hope you can figure out what each paragraph was referencing. I didn't keep it in order. :(

[Sedai]

  On 6/26/2011 at 5:02 PM, csarmi said:

Don't talk about games in progress Jack. That might get you modkilled. Especially when your mod play here as well.

 

What I said had no bearing on the game in reference. It was only relevant to a point made here. Thanks for the advice though. Good looking out

[sVieira151]

  On 6/26/2011 at 4:56 PM, Jack_D said:

I know that. My post was meant to be sarcastic.

 

I would have said the same thing about the train if it wasn't mine. Check Alanna's aiel game. I said the same thing when another player was being lynched. I said "everyone restating others reasons looks scummy. If your going to godlessly bandwagon just say so. Don't over glorify a vote you have no real reason for." so no, I practice what I preach

 

That's just how I post. I thought I was hammered. So I wanted to get everything out before the death scene.

 

For a New player Vie, that was an extremely well articulated post. I think you'll do well in this game. (meaning mafia in general)

 

Yeah, that is what I was pointing out. You are rambling/joking/sarcasm-ing now you feel you are done and dusted.

 

Oh did you? I take my statement back then. This is my first game with you so I suppose that was short sighted of myself.

 

Hmm. But surely you could have written all 3 posts into 1? I don't see how it would have affected your time that much before the death scene anyway. Seems you are still at L-2 though. If you post like that always, then I'm not really a fan, but I wouldn't lynch you for it. At least you're play style isn't as irritating as Mynd's.

 

 

And thanks. I think it is my 3rd game here(I have lasted about 2 days total in the previous 2 games, and one where I was on the end of a random lynch. I don't like random lynches. ) and I'm playing my 2nd game on another forum(In my first, I came in as a replacement on Day 1 and was betrayed and lynched Day 2. )

[Sakaea]

I am uncomfortable with lynching Jack. He may have an abrasive playing style, but he's a good player.

That said, I am still going to VOTE JACK because a controlled lynch is better than a random, and with the DL in less than an hour now, we don't have enough time to switch to someone else. Sorry Jack.

[Sedai]

  On 6/26/2011 at 5:17 PM, Sakaea said:

I am uncomfortable with lynching Jack. He may have an abrasive playing style, but he's a good player.

That said, I am still going to VOTE JACK because a controlled lynch is better than a random, and with the DL in less than an hour now, we don't have enough time to switch to someone else. Sorry Jack.

 

Don't worry about it. I appreciate the honesty and the compliment :)

[csarmi]

so anything you can add Jack?

[Sedai]

If the site is mafiascum don't play there. Just saying.

 

I post in burst as things come to me. I'd of put them all in one post if my ideas would have hit me as such. But as I read one post I realized I missed a point here. Wasn't to clear on something else. Etc.

 

I'm a rambler and very sarcastic person. I'm just all around quirky.

 

  On 6/26/2011 at 5:16 PM, Vieira151 said:

  On 6/26/2011 at 4:56 PM, Jack_D said:

I know that. My post was meant to be sarcastic.

 

I would have said the same thing about the train if it wasn't mine. Check Alanna's aiel game. I said the same thing when another player was being lynched. I said "everyone restating others reasons looks scummy. If your going to godlessly bandwagon just say so. Don't over glorify a vote you have no real reason for." so no, I practice what I preach

 

That's just how I post. I thought I was hammered. So I wanted to get everything out before the death scene.

 

For a New player Vie, that was an extremely well articulated post. I think you'll do well in this game. (meaning mafia in general)

 

Yeah, that is what I was pointing out. You are rambling/joking/sarcasm-ing now you feel you are done and dusted.

 

Oh did you? I take my statement back then. This is my first game with you so I suppose that was short sighted of myself.

 

Hmm. But surely you could have written all 3 posts into 1? I don't see how it would have affected your time that much before the death scene anyway. Seems you are still at L-2 though. If you post like that always, then I'm not really a fan, but I wouldn't lynch you for it. At least you're play style isn't as irritating as Mynd's.

 

 

And thanks. I think it is my 3rd game here(I have lasted about 2 days total in the previous 2 games, and one where I was on the end of a random lynch. I don't like random lynches. ) and I'm playing my 2nd game on another forum(In my first, I came in as a replacement on Day 1 and was betrayed and lynched Day 2. )

[Sedai]

  On 6/26/2011 at 5:51 PM, csarmi said:

so anything you can add Jack?

 

Nothing else. I've broke down why I think Red is scummy, why I think Moon is scummy, my feelings on Charis and the JLM nk. That's about the only major events that has happened this game so far. So those are my opinions. Didn't make them fact but I believe those three are the scummiest 3 ATM. Look carefully at the players on my train. Look for the players just rewriting what other people are saying just so it looks like they've got a reason. Scum tend to hide between the third and 6th spots on a train. Those are key votes to set a train in motion.

[Sedai]

And that's deadline with me at L-1 so it's a modkill

[bgrishinko]

Fair enough.

[csarmi]

BG, have you voted?

[Sedai]

  On 6/26/2011 at 5:59 PM, bgrishinko said:

Fair enough.

 

What is?

[csarmi]

Jack, why didn't you hammer yourself?

[Krakalakachkn]

I'll give ya an hour

[Sedai]

  On 6/26/2011 at 6:06 PM, Krakalakachkn said:

I'll give ya an hour

 

That's not fair