[Basic] JLM's Ad Icons Mafia - Game Over!

[Moon Sedai]

The below quote was edited for length:

  On 5/21/2011 at 1:06 PM, trench said:

As for killu, the only evidence against him is him defending Red. But there was someone else who defended Red as well, who was that. oh yhea it was Leelou. What role did she have, was it finder or handing out candy to everyone, well either way it was a good one. I bet that if the Mafia had not killed her last night, it would be her at L-3 now and not Killu. So right now I am not going to vote because this Killu lynch has Mafia speed lynching written all over it.

Trench, you seem to be concerned with a 'speed kill.' since Killu flipped symp, that means it may not have been a mafia speed kill after all.

You ended up not voting at all.

Why, if you thought this was a mafia speed lynch, did you not vote for another person?

And you seemed certain that the Mafia killed Red, instead of a possible Vig or Serial Killer.

 

Gmaster, I agree that CSarmi does seem suspicious in trying to throw us off of killu's trail.

 

a comparison of day 1 votes to day 2:

Day 1 vsChristine, Tina, Trench, CSarmi, Killu, Moon, Leelou, Key, Pruthvish

 

Day 2 vs Mynd, Moon, Tina, Pruthvish, Alanna, Christine, Gmaster.

 

In common voting: Moon, Christine, Tina, Pruthvish.

The four of us voted for both Lily and Kill, this does not clear any of us.

 

Voted to lynch innocent Lily and not to lynch the scummy Killu : Trench, CSarmi, Key.

This makes you look far more guilty than the four of us who voted against both.

 

Key is under threat of Mod kill if she doesn't post. I still suspect her for her defense of Red. I was wrong about Lily. And I admit it.

[JenLenaMom]

Okay warning posted...

 

As you tried to settle in hoping to survive the night you hear a crashing in the forest. You see a group of men dressed in hunter's orange come bursting out of the trees followed closely by Sasquatch. The men stop and turn back toward the beast and one of them holds out a can of soda. "We're sorry! We didn't mean to shoot at you. Here take this soda." The toss the can to him. As it's flying through the air you notice that while it's painted red and white the shape actually resembles a grenade. The Sasquatch catches it eagerly and tears the top off. It instantaneously explodes blowing him to smithereens.

 

Keyholder, the Jack Links Sasquatch, mafia member has been ModKilled for inactivity.

 

[danneric]

WOW! thats surprising havent seen a mafia lynched for inactivity before...

[keyholder21]

Wow, really? I thought I had at least until today to post considering the deadline isn't until tomorrow. Sorry team, had stuff come up and thought I would be able to post before I was MKed. Not meant to sound whiny lol, if it does. Just saying I thought I had more time. Sorry.

[Christine]

*sits on Moon's skirts and waits to be dragged around* Moon keeps getting it right! This either mean that she is very good or.... she is mafia?

 

Hmm. Shall see.

[trench]

  On 5/23/2011 at 9:34 PM, Ahmoondah Sedai said:

The below quote was edited for length:

  On 5/21/2011 at 1:06 PM, trench said:

As for killu, the only evidence against him is him defending Red. But there was someone else who defended Red as well, who was that. oh yhea it was Leelou. What role did she have, was it finder or handing out candy to everyone, well either way it was a good one. I bet that if the Mafia had not killed her last night, it would be her at L-3 now and not Killu. So right now I am not going to vote because this Killu lynch has Mafia speed lynching written all over it.

Trench, you seem to be concerned with a 'speed kill.' since Killu flipped symp, that means it may not have been a mafia speed kill after all.

You ended up not voting at all.

Why, if you thought this was a mafia speed lynch, did you not vote for another person?

And you seemed certain that the Mafia killed Red, instead of a possible Vig or Serial Killer.

 

 

I still think it was a mafia speed kill, it just didnt work out for them. I doubt the Mafia were really upset when the town had a player lynched in just over 48 hours, until he flipped symp. I am sure they had some people in that vote count. I was leary of Kill's defense of Red, but I had no idea he was a symp, I doubt the mafia saw it coming, or anyone else.

 

I notice your preety quick to point out that people in on that lynch are likely innocents, got something to hide? Also thats preety lucky FOS'ing Key right before the Mod Kill went down, thats a bit fishy IMO. Did you know that was coming?

 

The reason I didn't vote anyone was 1) because the day ended to fast and 2) I thought Mynd was leading you all around, I am not saying he is mafia but he is manipulative. but mostly I just was not ready to commit so quickly to a rushed lynch, its to easy for the mafia to control it.

 

As for the bolded, I am 100% certain that Red did not kill herself it was a Vig/SK that did. I should have indicated I was refering to Leelou in that statement about being at L3, I just wasn't clear, Im sorry

[trench]

I don't why I can't ever spell Pretty correctly,

 

*shakes fist at no editing rule*

[Moon Sedai]

I had an FOS on Key before Lily was killed. I said that I thought Lily, Red, Killu and Key were in a group together.

I was only wrong on one.

 

Of the 4 who voted for Lily and not Killu, we're left with Csarmi and Trench.

[Quibby]

I've never seen so much Modly smiting in a game before. It's amusing in a worrying kind of way.

 

Speedy lynches in mafia are worrying to me, even without the possibility of a mafia speed play. It tends to result in people bandwagoning without casing or doing any research. I had actually chosen to pursue a different case because I couldn't find anything more damning than the vote for Lily over Red thing, and that isn't enough for me for now. Of course, somebody pounded the last nail before I could come up with a decent case. Thanks for that, by the way. *

[Quibby]

Oh, and before I forget, I'll be traveling starting tomorrow, and I won't be able to access the game until Thursday.

[csarmi]

What is this nonsense about leading you off killu's trail?

 

1) Yesterday there was hardly any discussion. I brought up the only two players I had found highly suspicious (and still do). What's wrong with that? We've got evidence of two players not doing their best vs a random lynch with like a few hours left only.

 

2) Now it's killu killu killu again. Leading off trail? Bah. For some reason everyone is fixated on killu.

 

3) How on earth would someone like to get information from the lynch of a symp on day two?

[GMaster479]

  On 5/23/2011 at 9:31 PM, csarmi said:

  Quote

The Symp is a role with a pro-Mafia alignment that is not actually in the Mafia family. The Symp knows who is in the Mafia, but the Mafia do not know who the Symp is. The Symp uses through his or her vote to keep the Mafia from getting lynched and wins with the Mafia.

 

Ahhh...I am actually playing that role in another game :lol:

[danneric]

Hmmmmm seems there is quite the dillema going around here. (cant think of anything to post)

[Niniel]

  On 5/23/2011 at 7:11 PM, Myndrunner said:

  On 5/23/2011 at 6:58 PM, Ahmoondah Sedai said:

Mynd: why are you so sure it is a Vig and not a SK?

 

I've been in basic mafia games with a SK and not a vig.

 

Could you be the SK trying to throw off the scent?

 

I am not positive it isn't a SK, but I was highlighting the fact that Kill was so sure it was a SK, that he completely dismissed the possibility that it was a Vig kill at all. That is what clinched it for me that he was scum, or of scum nature.

 

Upon reflection, I have realized that I might have made myself a target with that statement. If the healer hasn't sent in his or her night action yet, I strongly beg that they protect me. SK or Vig, I think the mafia figured out the same thing Kill and Moon did.

 

Can we just order a night protection? Cos then I want one tomorrow night.

 

We are lucky that Key stayed away too long and got mk´d.

 

I´m supriced of all the talking during the night. I think there is a lot of interesting comments that we can learn from but I`ll wait with my own until the morning. That would be late evening or tomorrow for me.

[JenLenaMom]

Just so you guys know, I have all NAs but since Im at work Im not gonna be able to post it unless I can convince my husband at home to let me email it to him to post, highly doubtful, lol. So for now it's still night.

[Myndrunner]

What surprises you, Tina? Sometimes you gotta play a little misdirection at night. Sometimes things are said to influence not the healer's choice, but the mafia's. A little WIFOM is good for the scum as it is for us, and now that JLM says all night actions have been received, we will just have to wait and see.

[JenLenaMom]

The mood was slightly more up-beat as you all turned in for the night. You thought briefly of trying to stay together but slowly everyone wandered off to find their own little haven, you don’t really trust any of them anyway. As dawn breaks you all wander back together and do a head count. Yep, someone is missing. Someone notices a cat under a tree, covering something bloody with dirt, she’s hiding her kill. Moving closer you see the green skin before she notices you and grabs it up to run away. You see a lizard’s tail hanging from her mouth as she bolts away.

 

Csarmi, the Gieco Gecko, innocent psychiatrist has been catnapped and eaten.

 

 

And sorry I found this one and just can’t resist!!

 

 

 

As you stare after the offending cat you hear arguing behind you. “On the phone!” “Online!” “On the phone!” “Online!” “I’ll show you!” “No I’ll show YOU!” You look around to find the Esurance pair arguing once again about who gives better discounts. They rush over to their desks to settle their argument. One plugs in his headset; the other reaches down and turns on the computer. Then something goes wrong. Someone has apparently been tampering with their system because sparks start to fly. Before anyone can think to grab a fire extinguisher they are both electrocuted.

 

GMaster, the Esurance on the phone/online discount pair, inncocent Vig, has been fried.

 

 

 

It’s now Day 3. Which will end Friday at 4:00 pm CST. With 9 alive majority is 5. Happy hunting!!

[GMaster479]

Wow...that was a waste...keep an eye on the MafiaManiac topic

[Myndrunner]

I can't say I disagree with GMaster's choice in Vig killing; however, I do find Gmaster an interesting choice for the mafia kill. Someone who was likely going to get himself lynched was an interesting target. Did he reveal that he was the Vig at any time?

 

And I can't put my finger on it but what are everyone's thoughts on Moon? She's playing differently this game and, while I don't have any proof just a gut instinct, I'm feeling like she would be a good candidate for lynch.

 

Ahmoondah

 

....why SHOULDN'T we lynch you today?

[Moon Sedai]

The strongest defense I have in my favor is only my word that I am a vanilla townie.

Yes, I'll admit, my playstyle has adjusted since last time we played together, Mynd.

I've gotten a little better, I think.

When I am Mafia, I am OVERLY defensive and act EXTREMELY offended at accusations.

 

I'm going to Vote Trench

 

Mostly, this is because of what I said in an earlier post about Trench being one of the 4 who voted FOR lily but not for Killu.

 

[trench]

Ahmoon, I still dont understand your asumption that anyone who voted Kill is exonerated from voting Lily. Thats basically your whole case against me. I voted for the best possible mafia candidate at that time, so did you, for pretty (yes!, I spelled it right)! much the same reason you did. As for Kill's lynch, you keep pushing the assumption that there were no mafia in that lynch, and if you voted Lily and Kill you are an innocent. Honestly from my point of view it seems like you are trying to protect yourself and your teammates who did vote for Kill by mistake.

 

Also with the day just begun I dont see why you are throwing votes around so early. I have always replied semi-promtly anytime I have been questioned, so there is no real need to get my attention. Looking for another speed lynch Ahmoon?

[Christine]

I may have just laughed my ass off at that death for Csarmi. OMG. Even my husband had to look and laugh. Too perfect.

 

Anyways! Wow!

 

So this leaves us with 9 more people and we have gotten 3 Mafia down (if you include the symp) out of 18. I am guessing 1-2 more mafia, given it is about 25%? Or am I totally wrong here? Someone poke me if I am wrong in my guesstimates.

 

So we have 9 people left and 1-2 are Mafia Scum.

 

 

Looks like Moon and Trench will be the two lynch targets this round, both for various reasons. However, I do really agree with Moon pointing out that Trench didn't vote for Kill. Hmm...

 

Looks like Majority is 5 this time around. So, given that the 1-2 Mafia scum won't be voting for themselves, of course, this means we need pretty much everyone on the same side on this one. I think I am going to wait to see where the votes go, as I would of course prefer a controlled lynch to a random lynch, but my vote at this point is really leaning towards Trench.

[JenLenaMom]

Vote count:

 

Moon (1): Mynd

Trench (1): Moon

 

 

Deadline is Friday at 4:00 pm CST. With 9 alive majority is 5.

[PruthvishK]

VOTE MYND

[Christine]

And out of no where we have a third person added to the lynch list....

 

 

Why do I suddenly have a really bad feeling that this might end up in a random lynch? We have 9 total votes this round.

 

Trench - 1

Moon - 1

Mynd - 1

 

Given that Moon and Mynd have already voted, this leaves just Trench to throw on his vote to one of the two, probably Mynd since Mynd is voting for him. This would put us at 1 1 2. I am probably voting Trench, so 2 1 2. So, we are at 5 total votes. We need 5 votes on one person to get a lynch. Best case scenario, three out of the four people left would vote for Trench or Mynd, I guess depending on Trench's vote, but....

 

 

Pruth, this puts my eye on you. Why would you come out of no where with a random vote, unless it was to protect mafia people. I guessed that there was 1-2 more mafia people, but it could be three, Trench, Moon, and Pruth. Or, Pruth is trying to protect Moon or Trench by throwing suspicion onto someone else, but then why wouldn't he just vote for the person that wasn't mafia?

 

 

My eye is still on Trench, but Pruth may be getting a glare from me on the next day.