[Basic] Warhammer 40'000 Mafia GAME OVER!

[Ithillian Turambar]

Excellent. Thanks JLM

[Locke]

Yeah, things like that were much easier to determine in the old format. Not necessarily bad, it just applies the codes automatically.

 

Moon and Mav seemed to overreact a bit to Ithillian earlier, in my opinion.

[Moon Sedai]

Bah, Vote Tiinker because I'm not mafia and Tiink's rant sounded like a zealous scum

[Moon Sedai]

Grr. I meant vote tiinker

[Vambram]

I am checking in for the day. I don't know who to vote for, yet. So, I am not voting now. But I do reserve the right to vote later on Day 1 once I get a better sense of who is scummy, and who is not.

[paladin22]

It only stands to reason to Vote Mav.

He tried too quickly to shift blame, likely showing his guilt.

[sVieira151]

checking in folks. I'm going to random vote Vambram for the now :)

[Mav]

Yeah, things like that were much easier to determine in the old format. Not necessarily bad, it just applies the codes automatically.

 

Moon and Mav seemed to overreact a bit to Ithillian earlier, in my opinion.

 

I don't think I'm overreacting, just trying to get the game running, poking here and there. And it works!

 

 

It only stands to reason to Vote Mav.

He tried too quickly to shift blame, likely showing his guilt.

 

Eh what o.O, I never shifted the blame, I just pointed out the flaws in his own logic and posts afterwards. Let us overview what he wrote.

 

vote Mav because he is posting far too much, perhaps in a classic 'appear strong when you are weak' double bluff kind of scummy way.

 

I gain that reason while the post count stood equal between 2 others and me. Perhaps I'm seeing ghosts here but that is just the most hypocritical reason to give, what do you have to say about this statement Northwind?

 

 

Ha, a scummier statement I never heard. Surely a desperate attempt to deflect attention from herself - a person who has not even written in red for her vote. Vote disallowed I say and if I were some kind of vindictive scum I would definitely change my vote to you. However I am not scum and will keep my vote with my initial feeling for now.

 

Seriously though I am so glad I am not scum because I suddenly realised I might not be able to access the secret chat room place using my phone and that would have stuffed up the whole game :-)

 

And then we get this reason in reply to Moon her post/fail vote.

 

Well excuse me if I'm not allowed to start being suspicious of someone who denies 3 times in one post, in a post of 5 sentences, on the first day ! That he is not scum.

 

 

But! Northwind, I never shifted the blame, I just pointed out flaws in his logic, nobody likes to be voted, I also stated that it could be plain ignorance, hence me not further going into it. But now that you made that post I believe I should look further into it.

My gut is telling me that your backing up your friend, presumed in a pinch, needless to say it wasn't needed, since I would have left it alone by the end of this page. And I'll think I'll trust my gut this game, it seems its trustworthy after last game.

 

Unvote Locke, Vote Northwind

[paladin22]

Ah, but you have misinterpreted me. I myself have suspicions about Ithillian, and I'm not trying to back her up. She actually seems to be fulfilling her own statement. Also, I don't agree with the idea that the number of posts can accurately determine innocence or guilt.

In fact, I don't think that Ithillian's behavior seems to point out innocence but rather the opposite, as she seems to be grasping at any type of handhold.

Hmmm...

Unvote Mav, Vote Ithillian.

[killuliu]

By the way, is it so that we will have a random lynch, if we won't have majority lynch? :D Well I refuse to vote just yet, but if it seems that we are going to have a random lynch, I might vote..

[Ithillian Turambar]

Northwind is very easily swayed to change his vote. Perhaps he thinks Mav will unvote him and then vote me instead (I am a girl by the way Mav). Anyhoo at the time I made my original vote it was a choice between Mav and Locke because we had no player list and I thought you had to vote for someone and they were having a good old chit chat. I've never played Mafia before but I do play Poker and often the person making the biggest noise is bluffing.

 

I am a prolific poster its true. Check my post count. I have more posts than someone who has been on DM for ages. I don't see the point in just sitting quietly though. I decided to have a go at Mafia so I could join in and have fun.

 

Nice one Northwind - my 1st vote. I really feel part of it all now. Mav seems to be quite reasonable actually, and is joining in an making an effort. Northwind has changed his vote just to try and stop Mav from thinking he is scum. Therefore I unvote mav and vote Northwind and that's your lot for the day as its Bank Holiday Friday and I'm having a nice day with my family.

[Tiinker]

Baaaaaaand..-wait for it!-..WAAGON!

[Locke]

Northwind is very easily swayed to change his vote. Perhaps he thinks Mav will unvote him and then vote me instead (I am a girl by the way Mav). Anyhoo at the time I made my original vote it was a choice between Mav and Locke because we had no player list and I thought you had to vote for someone and they were having a good old chit chat. I've never played Mafia before but I do play Poker and often the person making the biggest noise is bluffing.

 

I am a prolific poster its true. Check my post count. I have more posts than someone who has been on DM for ages. I don't see the point in just sitting quietly though. I decided to have a go at Mafia so I could join in and have fun.

 

Nice one Northwind - my 1st vote. I really feel part of it all now. Mav seems to be quite reasonable actually, and is joining in an making an effort. Northwind has changed his vote just to try and stop Mav from thinking he is scum. Therefore I unvote mav and vote Northwind and that's your lot for the day as its Bank Holiday Friday and I'm having a nice day with my family.

Your explanation makes sense. I'll say that activity in mafia games is generally more of a play style. Some players are more of lurkers while others tend to post more often. I don't think one way or another is very often a tell. (unless they're behaving contrary to normal or something)

 

But I do agree about Northwind, though. That was a strange transition from Mav to Ithillian, contradictory even. Unvote. Vote Northwind

 

Bah, Vote Tiinker because I'm not mafia and Tiink's rant sounded like a zealous scum

This too. Tink's 'rant' sounded to me like a Day One joke vote.

[Locke]

That's 3 votes. The start of a bandwagon, yes. But with no deadline, there is no rush, so I wouldn't suggest moving much further. No need to lynch yet.

 

Suspicions list:

Northwind

Moon

Mav

[paladin22]

Northwind is very easily swayed to change his vote. Perhaps he thinks Mav will unvote him and then vote me instead (I am a girl by the way Mav). Anyhoo at the time I made my original vote it was a choice between Mav and Locke because we had no player list and I thought you had to vote for someone and they were having a good old chit chat. I've never played Mafia before but I do play Poker and often the person making the biggest noise is bluffing.

 

I am a prolific poster its true. Check my post count. I have more posts than someone who has been on DM for ages. I don't see the point in just sitting quietly though. I decided to have a go at Mafia so I could join in and have fun.

 

Nice one Northwind - my 1st vote. I really feel part of it all now. Mav seems to be quite reasonable actually, and is joining in an making an effort. Northwind has changed his vote just to try and stop Mav from thinking he is scum. Therefore I unvote mav and vote Northwind and that's your lot for the day as its Bank Holiday Friday and I'm having a nice day with my family.

Your explanation makes sense. I'll say that activity in mafia games is generally more of a play style. Some players are more of lurkers while others tend to post more often. I don't think one way or another is very often a tell. (unless they're behaving contrary to normal or something)

 

But I do agree about Northwind, though. That was a strange transition from Mav to Ithillian, contradictory even. Unvote. Vote Northwind

I'll admit that I did hope Mav would change his vote, but the switch from him to Ithillian was a result of a combination of extra thinking and indecision in the first place. Since there aren't many clues, I really can't tell for sure if anyone who posted is mafia. For all we know, it is theoretically possible that none have posted at all, however doubtful.

Regardless, my own statements seem to have gotten me in big trouble.

This reminds me a lot of Daes Dae'mar, and by that standard, Cairhien would kill me.

[Tiinker]

A small thing to jump on someone but it does seem likely. Your top of my list though and I will vote for you if we need a controlled lynch.

 

 

Is there anyway we can get a list and a Mod post? A notice about Day/Night times would be nice.

[Blackhoof]

and the moment you've all been waiting for!

 

Day 1 vote count

Song- MCS

Ahmoondai- tinker

Tinker- ahmoon

vambram- vieira

northwind- mav, ithllian, Locke

ithillian- northwind

 

not voting: MCS, Song, killulie, vambram

 

with 12 alive it takes seven to lynch.

 

ok, you win, a nice player list for you all!

 

song- check

Locke- check

tinker- check

mav- check

killuliu- check

vieira- check

ahmoondai- check

ithillian- check

vambram- check

MCS- not checked in

JLM- check

Northwind- check

 

deadline so far is, lets say,

 

9PM MONDAY, APRIL 25 EST

 

or until you lynch someone, whichever is first.

 

IF NO LYNCH IS ACHIEVED, A RANDOM WILL DIE

 

night will then commence and last for at least two days or until all NA's are submitted, whichever is first. talking durng night is allowed.

 

also, to elaborate in case of confusion, your character names and bios are just little fluff pieces i wrote for details sake. your alignment and role should be braketed and instructions on your power will be in the last few lines, should you have one.

[mcs0083]

Sorry about the late check-in everyone. I am here though. I need to read up until now however.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Lazybones@mcs

 

Right so I've just worked out that is 1.00am on the 26th for me

[Locke]

That was a + post by Northwind. Still suspicious, but a little reduced.

 

Other than that....more activity?

[mcs0083]

I agree with a player list. I'll go with my normal vote MCS *winks*

 

OMG WIFOM! VOTE SONG <3

[Ithillian Turambar]

Oh that's probably my fault - or everyone is out having a nice Easter weekend. Anyway, just in case it is anything to do with me I promise that I shall never ever vote for anyone purely based uppon the amount they post. In fact the more posty you are the better.

 

*might not have made much sense as has just woke up from having a nice aftermoon nap*

[sVieira151]

Man, totally not used to these short days yet A game I'm playing on another forum had a 21 day first day(day=number of players alive). It's too fast paced for my slow thoughts

 

But I'll hopefully be fairly active guys :)

 

Anyways:

 

I agree with a player list. I'll go with my normal vote MCS *winks*

 

OMG WIFOM! VOTE SONG <3

This a joke vote? :P

 

 

I've had a wee read through and it's honestly difficult for me to gather any concrete thoughts about anyone.

[Locke]

And if you don't make cents, you'll die! =(

 

Hey, you missed your chance for joke vote, MCS!

 

>.>

 

=p

[sVieira151]

It's hard when you have thoughts going through your head at the snail pace of my thoughts

 

And yeah, he was a bit late lol