Rebel Mafia - GAME OVER - Congratulations Black Ajah and Wombat!!

[ed2funy]

You're right. so many options! It could be any of them, but I'm leaning Vig because there wasn't a Night 1 Kill.

 

And I was starting to look askance at Aemon, though not much. I don't like it when I agree with him to much. LOL

 

Wombat

Key

Tigs

Me

Alanna 2.0

Talm

Kat

 

 

These are the 7 alive now.

 

I'm pretty sure I know who to vote, but want to hear what others think.

[Talmanes]

I'm thinking that the two kills most likely stem from either a Vig or SK.

We might be able to glean some info from people who targeted the deceased to see who likely killed them.

[WWWwombat]

7 left. Judging by standard setups probably 3 or 4 scum. If we don't lynch mafia today we will hand them the game imo.

[ed2funy]

Well, we don't wanna do that, so let's get cracking!

 

Vote Alanna

for now, as that is where my main suspicions lie. I'll revisit them soon.

[Alanna]

How come?

[ed2funy]

However, I still find Ed to be scummier and will stick with my vote on him...for now. For some reason, Limi's last few posts have kind of pinged me, so I would feel okay changing my vote over, if I have to.

 

 

Hmmm....sounds like you think she is innocent and distancing yourself if she did flop town (she won't, the dirty scumtron).

Just saying.

 

So, again, found that odd.

 

LOL. Something in that statement doesn't quite make sense, Ed, but I can't figure out exactly what it is.

You never said what, but sounds like you were planning some defense?

 

 

It's gone quiet...is everyone watching the SuperBowl? Cuz I'm so not

 

I have been rereading and rereading the thread (which is bad, because I'm just doing it to put off writing, which is what I'm supposed to be doing right now), and having looked a few things over, I am going to UNVOTE and VOTE LIMI after all.

 

First of all, I hate to say this on Day 2, but at this point I just want info from her lynch. She herself said she has no role and wouldn't be much loss, so...I'm going with it.

 

Secondly, even though Ed's recent posts with Talya seemed scummy to me, I discovered in my rereads that really nothing else of his seemed scummy. In fact, I found Limi's idea that he's scummy for taking the AJ thing out of proportion weak, because he wasn't the only one. I (Alanna 1.0) did the exact same thing, yet I was innocent. It was Day 1, and someone needed to nitpick over something, or we weren't going to get anywhere because there was really nothing else to go on.

You completely turn around, it seemed. I was super scummy, and Limi was an angel (obvious exaggeration), then flipy flop.

 

Well I'm bummed she was town, but this strengthens some of suspicions, so it wasn't a totally wasted lynch.

So, got some stronger vibes....

 

 

My guess would be vig, since there wasn't two nightkills before, though that could've been because one of the mafias failed to turn in a NK or were stopped by a healer.

 

Well, this has thrown me a little; Talya was one of my top suspects. I'll have to think about this some more.

 

Thrown a little, but don't you have more than 1 suspect? You don't care to spill?

 

 

 

 

 

HOW COME, INDEED! pssh

[Alanna]

 

LOL. Something in that statement doesn't quite make sense, Ed, but I can't figure out exactly what it is.

You never said what, but sounds like you were planning some defense?

 

No, not really, I was having a laugh at myself, more than anything else, because I really didn't quite get what you were saying.

 

You completely turn around, it seemed. I was super scummy, and Limi was an angel (obvious exaggeration), then flipy flop.

 

Yes, because as I said, I had done a reread and caught up on what I missed when I wasn't in the game (having died). When I first voted for you, I had a few recent posts, but hadn't read the majority of what happened between my dying Night 1 and then coming back into the game (more than halway through Day 2). Then, I went back and reread and got caught up (I reread some parts a couple times), and realized that Limi did seem pretty scummy.

 

After Limi's lynch, I was pretty sure Talya was scum, and I also thought you might be too (I felt stronger about Talya though).

 

Thrown a little, but don't you have more than 1 suspect? You don't care to spill?

 

Like you, Ed, I wanted to hear what other people had to say. You are actually my next suspect, but Talyda dying made me doubt that a little too, because most of the scummiess I got of you was in intereaction with Talya, which I thought looked like teamwork.

 

I understand your suspicions on me 'flip-flopping' ; I realized, as I changed my vote to Limi, that I was going to look suspicious, whether she flipped town or not. But I had just come back in to the game, so it took me a little while to get all the way caught up and really decide where I wanted to place a vote.

[WWWwombat]

I remember we had two people not voting yesterday. I think they were Kat and Talmanes. I would like to see what they have to say.

[Tigraine]

I decided to go back and check on our remaining players. I had forgotten that keyholder was in the game. So I decided to put all of his/her posts on here so we could all look at them together!

 

Checking in! Hello hello!

Just checking in of course!

 

I'm going to vote MCS, because he's number one and I wanted to be!

Day 1 Random vote!

 

 

I guess if we don't want a random lynch that I need to vote AJ. Don't really feel all that good about it :/.

Bandwagon vote!

 

Oops. Forgot to UNVOTE, VOTE *sigh* AJ.

Re-vote!

 

Oh, and yeah Alanna, she is. Ama said she's waiting to hear from Adella to see if she wants to replace Song.

General chat!

 

Talm, I really don't see how my being unhappy about it is any different from some of the other voters.

 

I still think Ed and Aemons jumping on this was weird.

 

However in interest of a controled lynch :/ unvote vote aj

 

Limi has a :/ face here which means she's not happy about it, she just said in a face instead of what I said.

 

 

 

I guess if we don't want a random lynch that I need to vote AJ. Don't really feel all that good about it :/.

 

I voted for her because I didn't want a random lynch, I don't have to feel good about voting for someone who SAID she was town.

 

I've already explained how I came to my vote....I may not be ecstatic about my vote, but there really is no where else to go.

I'd rather vote for that small oddity.

*shrugs*

 

Ed mentions that he's not happy about it either, so why pointing me out and not him?

 

 

Well, this sucks. I was really hoping some others would decide to go with me on lynching an inactive. But, I said I would hammer if necessary, so I will. I think there are still a few hours til the deadline, but I really have to go to bed, it's past 1 in the morning here. UNVOTE, VOTE AJ.

 

SOrry, AJ, because I really do think you're telling the truth, but I still think a controlled lynch is better than a randon modkill, and though it would be better to hit scum, it's certainly not the first time a Day 1 lynch ends up hitting town.

 

Alanna also mentions that she's sorry and that the vote "sucks." So again, I don't understand how my statement "looks bad."

Just defending herself!

 

 

Well Limi in that particular post merely said she thought it was weird, not really distancing herself that much. Ed, as shown by his 'shrug', just didn't seem to care much, as he was already slightly suspicious. Quite honestly, as I did my post at like three in the morning, I missed Alanna, but I'll be looking at her for the same reason I am you.

 

The reason you stuck out, is because you seemed to be, more so than anyone else, trying to convey not wanting to vote. I know you weren't the only one, you just stuck out more to me. Alanna did do it a bit more later too, though, so she is almost equal with you. You are still pinging me a bit more.

 

Hey Talm, you mention here that you missed Alanna in your reread, but actually, you DID mention Alanna (1.0) in your post (see below), so I'm still confused.

 

 

Well, this sucks. I was really hoping some others would decide to go with me on lynching an inactive. But, I said I would hammer if necessary, so I will. I think there are still a few hours til the deadline, but I really have to go to bed, it's past 1 in the morning here. UNVOTE, VOTE AJ.

 

SOrry, AJ, because I really do think you're telling the truth, but I still think a controlled lynch is better than a randon modkill, and though it would be better to hit scum, it's certainly not the first time a Day 1 lynch ends up hitting town.

 

Says she believes AJ is town, but is voting anyway, though she gives a fairly good explanation.

 

FULL ANALYSIS COMING SOON

 

Just pointing it out.

I'm not real sure what's happening in this one!

 

In the interest of a controlled lynch, Vote Limi.

Bandwagon vote!

 

Seems to me that she is laying pretty low in this game. I don't know her play style but I think it's time to stir some of these people out of the shadows. We are getting very close to end game here and people need to start stepping up. Keyholder

I'm going to continue checking out our remaining players.

[Talmanes]

I voted for Limi yesterday. Not voting was Tigs and Kat.

[keyholder21]

 

Seems to me that she is laying pretty low in this game. I don't know her play style but I think it's time to stir some of these people out of the shadows. We are getting very close to end game here and people need to start stepping up.

 

I'm really new to mafia, so that's how I play - I try to always have something of importance to add to the game, and if I don't then I have a bad habit of not posting. I try not to proclaim that I'm new though, because I don't want to rely on it - I'm trying to learn how to play.

 

Oh, and I'm a her *laughs*.

[keyholder21]

That part at the bottom wasn't sarcasm btw, I saw your "him/her" at the top and was just responding to it. I see that you called me "her" later on, so I guess you figured it out, but I wanted to let you know for certain .

[Amadine]

Official Vote Count: 26.5 hours to deadline

 

Alanna (1) - Ed

 

KeyHolder (1) - Tigs

 

Not Voting: Wombat, KeyHolder, Talmanes, Kat, Alanna

 

With 7 players, you need 4 to lynch.

 

 

[Talmanes]

I'm going to vote Key.

She has been pinging me all game for reasons I've explained.

Most of her points and arguments haven't seemed to be helpful and not very well done to me.

I know it isn't much, but the deadline is getting closer, and it is the best thing I have to go on right now.

[WWWwombat]

I will also

 

vote: keyholder

 

For playing the confused and newbie cards.

[ed2funy]

i don't necessarily agree, but i see where ya guys are coming from, and think you haz a point.

 

unvote

vote key

[Alanna]

Wow, that all happened very fast, you guys didn't even give her a chance to reveal. I really hope she's mafia, or else, I think we've lost this game.

[WWWwombat]

Actually, that was only L - 1 by my count. Also, Ed, why would you vote with us this late in the game if you didn't agree? Sounds to me like you are trying to distance yourself from your vote.

 

unvote

[WWWwombat]

wait nvm ur right alanna. Anyway I think we just lost too. Sucks.

[Talmanes]

Well we haven't necessarily lost unless Key is Town. Hopefully we were right.

[keyholder21]

Wow, really? Thanks guys.

 

So I said I -wasn't- trying to play the 'newbie' card and then I get voted for it because I said that? Awesome. Tigs asked about my play style so that's the only reason I even said it.

 

 

 

Btw, I'm Leane and I walk in the Light.

[Tigraine]

I wasn't trying to get her lynched....only to talk more

[ed2funy]

Oi....I was hammer? I thought I was L-1, yo

 

 

Well, If you're not lying (Leane seems pretty legit), then sorry.

[WWWwombat]

You can cut the act, Ed.

[ed2funy]

???

*stands up more firm and straightens his dress*

Pretty ol' lil me? What act might you be talking abou, darling Womby?