Rebel Mafia - GAME OVER - Congratulations Black Ajah and Wombat!!

[ed2funy]

*points up*

Or just makings things seem what they're not?

 

*pulls the chain in the ceiling and watches Limi's lightbulb go off*

So, she *isn't* technically lying. :D

[Amadine]

Official Vote Count: 19 hours to deadline

 

Ed (0) - Wombat

Talm (1) - Talya

Limi (4) - Aemon, Wombat, Ed, Talmanes

Ed (1) - Limi

 

Not Voting: KeyHolder, Tigs, ArlowAlanna, Kat

 

With 10 players, you need 6 to lynch.

[Talya]

I'm not sure what to make of the reveal of Limi's. Theodrin is a minorish character. Probably more then some but not up there with Romanda and Lelaine and she wouldn't be someone who I would choose if selecting ones for the game. Doesn't mean she is lying though! But a fairly safe bet for mafia if they wanted to claim...

[ed2funy]

Had to look her up to make sure...she is minor, but plays a key role in trying to break Nyn's block. And I agree that she is not up with Lelaine and Romanda, but....

Well, I pretty much agree with your last post Talya. lol

 

I'm keeping my vote on her for now.

[Talya]

I just can't make my mind up about it, lol...like you say minot but does play a role of sorts...and she was a spy for Egwene against Romanada

[Little Miss]

Eddie - of course I am going to talk about who I find suspicous. And you and Talya are high up there as well.

 

I am a vanilla townie.

 

I also want to point out the comment I made about "I walk in the light"

 

I gaurentee any members of the town will have gotten that phrase in their pmed roles.

[ed2funy]

Eddie - of course I am going to talk about who I find suspicous.

 

 

Where did I say you couldn't???

 

 

Really Limi, with the theme of the game, its not hard to think of what the role PM said if you didn't get it..

So, good try, but *pinches nose* I think your inner witch shows.

[Little Miss]

I think you are scum :p

 

Watch him people! First Aj and now me.

 

And I am not saying it isn't a role that could go both ways.

 

But like I pointed out. Only townies should recongize that particular phrase from their roles.

 

And no I didn't get it from AJs post.

[ed2funy]

Really, if being the most active makes me scum. *sigh* I miss old DM.

And I think you are scum!

 

Hell, I could probably figure out the mafia's role PM. "you have forsaken the Light" or "You serve the Dark One."

 

 

And no I didn't get it from AJs post.

It's an interesting tactic, I've always thought....to put out the truth while disguising like that. So simple, and common.

 

 

*translates*

Liar.

[Little Miss]

*shrugs* Think what you will.

 

All I ask of the town is that they watch you Eddie.

[ed2funy]

And all I ask is that they vote you.

If you really thought I was scum, you'd ask the same.

*nods slowly while tying the rope for the scummy witch*

[keyholder21]

Well Limi in that particular post merely said she thought it was weird, not really distancing herself that much. Ed, as shown by his 'shrug', just didn't seem to care much, as he was already slightly suspicious. Quite honestly, as I did my post at like three in the morning, I missed Alanna, but I'll be looking at her for the same reason I am you.

 

The reason you stuck out, is because you seemed to be, more so than anyone else, trying to convey not wanting to vote. I know you weren't the only one, you just stuck out more to me. Alanna did do it a bit more later too, though, so she is almost equal with you. You are still pinging me a bit more.

 

Hey Talm, you mention here that you missed Alanna in your reread, but actually, you DID mention Alanna (1.0) in your post (see below), so I'm still confused.

 

 

Well, this sucks. I was really hoping some others would decide to go with me on lynching an inactive. But, I said I would hammer if necessary, so I will. I think there are still a few hours til the deadline, but I really have to go to bed, it's past 1 in the morning here. UNVOTE, VOTE AJ.

 

SOrry, AJ, because I really do think you're telling the truth, but I still think a controlled lynch is better than a randon modkill, and though it would be better to hit scum, it's certainly not the first time a Day 1 lynch ends up hitting town.

 

Says she believes AJ is town, but is voting anyway, though she gives a fairly good explanation.

 

FULL ANALYSIS COMING SOON

 

Just pointing it out.

[Alanna]

I found this little exchange interesting:

 

I'm not sure what to make of the reveal of Limi's. Theodrin is a minorish character. Probably more then some but not up there with Romanda and Lelaine and she wouldn't be someone who I would choose if selecting ones for the game. Doesn't mean she is lying though! But a fairly safe bet for mafia if they wanted to claim...

 

 

Had to look her up to make sure...she is minor, but plays a key role in trying to break Nyn's block. And I agree that she is not up with Lelaine and Romanda, but....

Well, I pretty much agree with your last post Talya. lol

 

I'm keeping my vote on her for now.

 

 

I just can't make my mind up about it, lol...like you say minot but does play a role of sorts...and she was a spy for Egwene against Romanada

 

It smacks of teamwork. I'm sorry, I would say Theodrin is a minor character in the grand scope of the entire WoT series, but when it comes solely to the Rebel AS camp, she most certainly is not a minor character. In fact, I can think of about 7 or 8 AS whom I would be positive are in this game (amongst the townies), and Theodrin is most certainly one of them. She works for Egwene - which by the way, does not make her scum, even if she did spy against Romanda. The scum are obviously Darkfriends in this game, meaning Egwene and her cohorts are probably both townies.

 

My vote goes to ED for now.

[ed2funy]

 

how dare you?!

 

 

*runs off haughtily*

[aemonkristen]

I still think she is lying and my vote stays where it is.

[Little Miss]

Alanna I am glad I am not the only one who saw that :p

 

Aemon :o Scum!

 

I am pretty sure that the mafia are working hard to explain it.

 

I really like the fact that some people are ignoring something that each of them can confirm.

[Alanna]

I actually am not really suspicious of Aemon at the moment; I didn't really get the whole 'team' thing between him and Ed that other people saw. I mean, they were kind of being buddy buddy, but, I mean, it doesn't seem very out of character for Aemon and Ed to act that way.

[Little Miss]

I don't think that was normal for them honestly.

 

Reason I am suspicous at eddie besides the obvious now, is because I can't help but feel he pointed out something small and made a bigger deal out of it than it was. Notice I said biggER not big.

 

This caused people aka tigs and several others to look at her.

 

As to Aemon, he was the second to vote on her when there where several other with just one vote and then Eddie voted.

 

Alanna (and town and maifa) I do understand that lynching me will get a controled lynch, and you aren't loosing any role.

 

All I ask is that you listen to my observations and don't let the mafia pawn this off as "well she was scummy, or her character COULD have been scum" or some other such nonsense.

[ed2funy]

I don't think your character can be scum. Just that you are ebil. And a liar.

 

And if I am on a team with Talya....well, I don't know about it!

 

*gags Limi* Die already, scumbag!

[Talya]

I actually went through the list of AS I would choose from Salidar who I would have had on a team and Thoedrin wasn't one of them. So I thought it could easily be a name Mafia could use, that wasn't too far down the list, but wasn't the 'top' ones... The same i would look at any reveal. I would question it, so I find odd, Alanna that you don't. Any claim should be question and voiced. To out right believe her makes me think that actually she is telling the truth and you are Mafia. Because that is the only way you would know that she is and innocent character, so must be telling the truth!

[WWWwombat]

I agree with Eddie about divining the innocent victory condition being really easy.

[Little Miss]

But to be exactly on?

 

*shrugs*

 

Believe what you will. When I die I just hope you all actually learn something from it.

[Alanna]

Any claim should be question and voiced. To out right believe her makes me think that actually she is telling the truth and you are Mafia. Because that is the only way you would know that she is and innocent character, so must be telling the truth!

 

I'm a little insulted that you think I would be so obvious, if I were mafia I'll be honest, Talya, I did think it through again and realized I completely forgot about the group that was first ruling in Salidar before Egwene becamse Amyrlin...Carlinya, Myrelle, etc. (Although Sheriam would not be part of that, and I'm not sure Beonin would be either). I was only thinking of Siuan and Leane, in addition to Romanda and Lelaine. So I'm not as sure about Theodrin as I was.

 

However, I still find Ed to be scummier and will stick with my vote on him...for now. For some reason, Limi's last few posts have kind of pinged me, so I would feel okay changing my vote over, if I have to.

 

The reason I don't really find Aemon scummy is because the main reason for doing so at the moment seems to be because he was second to vote AJ. Yet really, what is so scummy about this, because we really did need to start consolidating votes. There was all this confusion about Tigs thinking she was the second vote, and Aemon thinking he was the third, and I think I (or rather, the other me, the dead one) was the cause of that. Because I (the dead me) was the first one to suggest voting for AJ. However, I didn't actually vote for her at that time.

[ed2funy]

However, I still find Ed to be scummier and will stick with my vote on him...for now. For some reason, Limi's last few posts have kind of pinged me, so I would feel okay changing my vote over, if I have to.

 

 

Hmmm....sounds like you think she is innocent and distancing yourself if she did flop town (she won't, the dirty scumtron).

Just saying.

[Alanna]

LOL. Something in that statement doesn't quite make sense, Ed, but I can't figure out exactly what it is.