[Pete Mafia: Dr. Who Style] End game congrats cult of skaro

[Lavinya]

Hahaha...oops. The delay in this game has made me forget everything.  ::)

 

Well then, I am confused, and can only go on the fact that she was also nicked by the warewolf in the episode. They make some talk about there always being a blood disorder among her descendants, so maybe she was in fact the warewolf. I still can't imagine her having any role.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

Wouldn't it be something if at endgame I didn't give out any information, only Player x, player y, and player z won?

[Verbal32]

[glow=red,2,300]Pete[/glow]

 

What?  No?

 

Fine.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote[/glow]

[Adella]

That WOULD be something Pete.. Something very very lame! But still, something.. :-*

[Lavinya]

That would be so incredibly cruel XD

[LilyElizabeth]

I can do it, even if you can't.

 

[glow=red,2,300]ModGod[/glow]

 

[aemonkristen]

I realiza that a PR like that would make any recruit a rather large target, but what if there is a 75% chance that there won't be a PR and you were unlucky enough to be in the 25% that did get it? Can anyone else think of a reason to give a PR that makes someone sound like a robot? I've been thinking about it and I don't believe the cybermen speak at all (correct me if I'm wrong). This still leaves me with a bad taste in my mouth about the PR. Would one of our roles be to give out PRs? If so, why have we only seen one when we are in day three? Verbal is the one that has me most convinced of being anti-town right now. My vote stays where it is.

[Lavinya]

Yes, cybermen speak. And they are definitely bad guys.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Verbal[/glow]

[dapianoplay3r]

cybermen create more cybermen so I think they are definatly recruiting

[LilyElizabeth]

I think this is right:

 

Verbal (2) – Aemon, Lavinya

Aemon (1) – Red

 

Not voting – Aust, Lia, Boopsy, Player, Adella, Tigraine, Naeann, Crafty/Sarah, Jeran, Aemon, Verbal, Pookie, Anox

 

With 15 alive, you need 8 to lynch

 

[Verbal32]

I realiza that a PR like that would make any recruit a rather large target, but what if there is a 75% chance that there won't be a PR and you were unlucky enough to be in the 25% that did get it? Can anyone else think of a reason to give a PR that makes someone sound like a robot? I've been thinking about it and I don't believe the cybermen speak at all (correct me if I'm wrong). This still leaves me with a bad taste in my mouth about the PR. Would one of our roles be to give out PRs? If so, why have we only seen one when we are in day three? Verbal is the one that has me most convinced of being anti-town right now. My vote stays where it is.

 

A few points for you to think about:

 

1.  The PR was only for a day.  Even if that far-fetched percentage thing you posted was true, wouldn't it make sense to have the PR be permanent?  Pete has been pretty straight with the theme, no?  What sense does it make for a temporary PR like that for a recruit?  It doesn't.

 

2.  Based on my above point, then why the heck would somebody give me that particular PR (which by the way was to post as a robot for 1 day)?  How about.....to frame me?

 

If this works, they won't use it again, as my coroner will reveal I'm NOT a recruit and therefore the PR-giver will use something different next time.  But I do ask that you think logically about it - if I'm a recruit, then why the heck would I have a temporary PR to post like a robot if I've actually become one?  That doesn't make sense.

 

I don't begrudge your votes, as I can see where it would look bad.  Which is why it is both highly unlikely for Pete to make a PR like that, regardless of chances (it would be logical to make it permanent), and a PERFECT opportunity for scum to frame somebody.  Just think on that...

[aemonkristen]

But, I ask again, why is this the only PR we've seen when we are on day 3. If it is a night ability we should see someone with a PR today and, obviously, nothing on day 1. If it is a daytime ability, we should see PR on day 1 and day 3, yet there are none. It makes sense to me that it was from a night action on night 1 and the most logically the result of recruitment as no one else has had a PR and we lynched the dalek recruiter.

[Naeann]

Unless

1. They were blocked

2. They chose not to do one so it would better frame Verbal for his

3. They tried to give it to someone who is immune

4. Someone does have one and has either not posted enough for us to notice or it was a PR we haven't figured out?

5.  It was given to the person who died

[aemonkristen]

If there is a PR giver rather than this being a result of recruitment, it would have to be someone familiar with the show as it started before any of the Daleks were killed. Do you have any suspects? Right now Verbal is the only one I have strong feelings about, though I'm still not sure if Al is cured or not. I think he may be trouble down the line if we can't sort out his situation.

[Naeann]

Didn't Al die?  He was a Dalek.  I do get what you are saying.  I can easily see DPR recruiting Verb.  I agree with Verb however that I don't think Pete would have made that a condition of recruitment.  It would make it entirely too obvious.

[Liathiana]

I have to say I'm more inclined to believe Verbal at the moment, the whole "well what if it was this, this and this!" just to make it sound like a "probably" scenario sounds far-fetched and a little desperate tbh.

[craftyreader]

With Pete being the Mod there are all kinds of reason that only 1 PR has been given.

[Adella]

I have a thought. Who says Al really had a PR? Maybe he was just being a huge distraction to pull attention off of Wes. Just a thought.

[Verbal32]

I have to say I'm more inclined to believe Verbal at the moment, the whole "well what if it was this, this and this!" just to make it sound like a "probably" scenario sounds far-fetched and a little desperate tbh.

 

I don't view it as desperate on Aemon's part, though.  If I was in his shoes, 2 things would happen:

 

1.  I'd probably think along the same lines initially.

 

2.  Aemon would be barefoot.  :P

 

But really, the thing that kills it for me is the limited time thing and the unlikelihood of Pete having an obvious scumtell for a recruit.

 

If I was the PR-giver, and a bad guy, I'd hold off on giving it to anybody else as well, to Nae's point.  Meh.  Not sure what else I can say on the topic...

[Pookie]

I'm also inclined to believe Verbal at the minute.  I agree with Nae's list of possible other reasons we haven't seen a PR today, but I want to add a couple bits...

 

Pete saw the sheer awesome of the frame power in Rey's game if he hadn't seen it already.  The PR could be an action given to the dalek to frame a player more obviously.  I could see this being a one-time or limited-times action to adjust for the more visible aspects of it.  

 

It could be someone with a random power, like in Nae's game.  I picked someone but never knew what item I was giving to them (night freeze item, one-time res item, role swap item, PRs aplenty, an extra vote were the ones I had).  

 

There are a number of evil reasons Verbal might have had the PR as well (side affect of failed night action, recruited, etc) but if memory serves, he was still working to help the town even with his PR.

[Adella]

Hmkay, new rule for me, no posting when I just woke up, please disregard my last post, I had no CLUE what everyone was talking about.

What's the deadline for Day 3?

[Naeann]

You are right it does have merit Adella.  No worries about wakey posts. :P

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

*Looks at pookie*

 

I made the framer thing up. It was in my circus game. But Rey's game was when it reached it's potential.

 

MOD NOTE

 

I know my not giving out anything but SCUM and NOT SCUM upon death is a little limiting, but I leave hints to the killers, and sometimes I leave hints to alignments in my night ending posts. Someone who is familiar with Tennet as the Doctor should pick up on some of them.

[LilyElizabeth]

Bro, I know you made it up, but did you know it's on wiki now?

 

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

Really? I never check the wiki. I just make up roles as I need them or tweak other roles I know. I like bread and butter roles like finder, healer, etc, but I also love to change them up.