[Pete Mafia: Dr. Who Style] End game congrats cult of skaro

[DPR]

 

 

Aemon, you are a ding-dong:

 

 

Look at it this way - we stand to gain the most info by lynching ed now - he has insured that with his claim.

 

* If he is telling the truth, we have learned a lot about what kind of roles are out there.

* If he is lying, we ned to go back and find out who he is covering before, because they very well might have another daykill.

* Lavinya is making sense to me.

 

Trying to pull back from a lynch at this point is not a great idea - look at the deadline.  This is mafia, townies die. Especially when they hammer themselves.  :P

 

The right play is to let the lynch stand, sober everyone up and get the innocents to start playing instead of messing around.

 

[Naeann]

Chosing to say you never lie in a mafia game even if you are scum and using that to try to convince people they shouldn't vote for you is also stupid. :-*  See how that works? ;D

[DPR]

Nae, I am so not the werewolf. Consider your source...

 

I will also point out that the werewolf does not appear to be mafia - so let's not take our eyes completely off of the ball.

 

And through all of this, during my re-read, you know who stuck out like a sore thumb. Wayward fool. Go back and read for yourselves...

[Naeann]

I never said the werewolf was mafia.  I said scum.  You know I like to stalk you. ;)  I watch you when you think no one is looking.

 

So who are you impling is my source?  How bout you just elaborate on Boopsy instead of asking others to reread?

[aemonkristen]

Wow, Wes. Another redirect. Hmmmm...All right. Let's put this in perspective. My question came after your post. The quote you are trying to use was your justification for lynching Ed.

 

 

Look at it this way - we stand to gain the most info by lynching ed now - he has insured that with his claim.

 

* If he is telling the truth, we have learned a lot about what kind of roles are out there.

* If he is lying, we ned to go back and find out who he is covering before, because they very well might have another daykill.

* Lavinya is making sense to me.

 

Trying to pull back from a lynch at this point is not a great idea - look at the deadline.  This is mafia, townies die. Especially when they hammer themselves.  :P

 

The right play is to let the lynch stand, sober everyone up and get the innocents to start playing instead of messing around.

 

Overreaction, Wes? I get the feeling you want to lynch a few more innocents before anyone figures out your playing for the other team. I tend to get annoyed when I make my case and everyone basically ignores everything I have to say and then lynch an innocent. And there you are saying it's an overreaction. We NEED to lynch some innocents to understand the game. I say that's a three-coil steamer. What info did we get from the fact that Ed was innocent? Only the fact that he was innocent. Gee, I'm so glad we went ahead and did that. Why don't we just lynch everybody else who says they're innocent. Would that do it for you, Wes. And yes, this is sarcasm. Just in case you decide to try and use this against me later.  ;) I would like to know what info you believe we have gleaned from the death of Ed.

 

Check the time stamps. Wes, you never, ever answered my questions. But let's take a look at your reasons for voting Ed.

* If he is telling the truth, we have learned a lot about what kind of roles are out there.

So, Wes, what kind of roles are out there? It says right in the OP that roles will not be revealed after death. I told you that immmediately after you posted this. Where is this valuable information we were supposed to get?

* If he is lying, we ned to go back and find out who he is covering before, because they very well might have another daykill.

In other words, lynch anyone who reveals to see if they are telling the truth. Good strategy there, Wes. Let me know how that works out for you.

* Lavinya is making sense to me.

This one is the one that bothers me the most. I say it bothers me the most because we all know how Wes is always telling us to give reasons, not to just go along with everyone else. This goes against his own philosophies of how to vote. Especially when the votes are on him. I can only presume that he was talking about this post when he made that last comment.

I'm thinking Ed's claim of being a townie with two kills was more a desperate bid to get someone to change their vote before Pete comes online. He appears to be the scummiest and was well on the way to a lynch anyway, when Min was killed. There's always the risk of being wrong; I just happen to think he's scum. Why let him live, in that case?

 

And besides, he stupidly voted himself. :P

Not scummy in and of itself, but there are things there that kinda rub me wrong if you know what I mean. And this is one of his listed reasons for wanting to lynch Ed.

 

I just have to say that NOT lynching Wes/DPR today would be a seriously bad move for the town. He is a cunning opponent. A manipulator of people who knows how to twist words and make people believe his version of the truth until he takes them down. We need to get him today.

[Naeann]

Plus he's the werewolf and leaving him alive another day just lets him recruit more people to his cult.

[aemonkristen]

Aemon, I'm just going to sit back and let you two go at this and watch trying to get back into the mentality of this game. However I will metagame and say his callus attitude is identical to yours in our disney mafia game for Players death.  

 

And you believe I am scum for it, correct, Al? Vote DPR.

 

EDIT: I don't know about him being the werewolf, but based only on the facts I can see, he is scum.

[DPR]

 

This is pretty weak - especially coming from Nae - Aemon I understand, he's newer to the games and full of zeal. I'm not even really thinking he's mafia, he's just a dog that has a bone and won't let go.

 

Nae, I asked you to check your source - not to reveal it. You knew that. And, you have laid down a cover story for being in contact with another player. Not good. Not good at all.

[aemonkristen]

We'll see what tune your buddies are singing when you show up scum, Wes. I'm already trying to see who your associates are so we can go after them. I sincerely hope you ARE the werewolf, because I don't see how else we're going to find him without a lock of luck.

[Tigraine]

How does everyone know that the weird thing that happened is being turned into a werewolf? 

 

I'm just curious cause if it said it somewhere then I missed it!  Or was it just an educated guess from having watched the show?

[aemonkristen]

A howl can be heard all around the Torchwood estate. The full moon is hanging loftily in the starlight sky, illuminating the field below. In the distance a werewolf is being tailed by a group of monks. The beast howls as it draws closer and can smell the the humans in the estate. The beast breaks through front doors and sniffs the air. The doctor motions everyone to the tardis which is located in the mistletoe room. One member was to slow and got nicked by the beasts claw. The doctor closes the door, and himself and his companions are safe for the remainder of the day in the room.

 

Weird thing has happened prior to this post, but not necisarily adjacent to it.

 

I put the part that has us thinking werewolf in bold, but you have a point. We really don't know for certain what the wierd thing was. I do, however think it is werewolf. The beginning of a cult.

[Naeann]

I'm not understanding you Wes?  Where did I say I was in contact with another player?  I won't confirm or deny that.  I simply know you weren't sleeping last night.  Like I said before.. I was stalking you. ;)

 

 

Edit:

 

Aemon.. that wasn't the beginning.  Wes recruited someone last night.

[aemonkristen]

I hope you have a name, because after Wes shows up scum, we're gonna have to go after whoever he recruited.

[dapianoplay3r]

In the episode it took years to manafest with only a nick of the claw so I think we have to wait atleast till night 4 to see the werewolf

[Naeann]

No.. that would just be to see who the werewolf infected.  He's already out there.

[Red2111]

pete said something interesting would happen to the person who posts the "nth post"

 

i took this to mean that that person would become the cult leader.  in a norml game, the cult recruits during the night and it has no barring on who has what post.

 

ofcourse taking it into count that this is Pete were talking about ... anything could be possible lmao

 

 

all this back and forth stinks of a WIFOM situation being set up. i don't knwo which of you stinks of scum more but one of your sure does. i say we lynch one of them (Aemon or Wes) if the one we lynch flips innocent then we lynch the remaining person.

 

its an easy way to resolve the bickering and find answers.

 

 

[Red2111]

well not that the person who has the "nth post" would become the cult leader.  but since the werewolf attack happened due to the "nth post" that it activated the cult and the cult leader was born.

 

just for clarification

[DPR]

 

I'm not understanding you Wes?  Where did I say I was in contact with another player?  I won't confirm or deny that.  I simply know you weren't sleeping last night.  Like I said before.. I was stalking you. ;)

 

 

Edit:

 

Aemon.. that wasn't the beginning.  Wes recruited someone last night.

 

Wasn't sleeping equals recruitment? You know who else wasn't sleeping? Anyone with a role...and you know who likes to out people with roles? The mafia.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Nae[/glow] - that last bit sealed it for me. You never play like this, so I'm curioius to see what angle you are working.

 

 

[Pookie]

Hmmm.  One thing to think about... the scene Pete posted may not have been the start of a cult.  Werewolves attacked.  Maybe they just got a semi-random day recruit?  I'm not saying this is a definite answer, just that it's a perspective to consider in addition to the idea that the attack was the start of a cult.

 

That said, at the moment I trust Nae more than DPR or Aemon. [glow=red,2,300]DPR[/glow]

[DPR]

 

Everybody trusts Nae more than me. That's what she's counting on... :P

[Al Jenn Mael]

Chosing to say you never lie in a mafia game even if you are scum and using that to try to convince people they shouldn't vote for you is also stupid. :-*  See how that works? ;D

 

Yup and I got lynched for it, are you suggesting something? ;)

 

Aemon, I'm just going to sit back and let you two go at this and watch trying to get back into the mentality of this game. However I will metagame and say his callus attitude is identical to yours in our disney mafia game for Players death. 

 

And you believe I am scum for it, correct, Al? Vote DPR.

 

EDIT: I don't know about him being the werewolf, but based only on the facts I can see, he is scum.

 

No I don't think you are scum in this game or that. However I don't always agree with your reasoning. According to Nae this scene and weird thing had absolutely nothing to do with him. You have been going after him the entire game. So honestly I'm not to convinced by your reasons.

 

Nae, however I do believe with her finder/tracker/watcher half reveal. I'll wait to vote though, there have been to many quick lynches going around to suit my tastes. I have learned to value the time the mod gives you. I have been lead down to many false trails to think otherwise.

[Lavinya]

Vote NAE

 

You start out claiming he is scum, then suddenly the story changes and he has become the warewolf, and no wait! He was already warewolf scum and has been recruiting! Your story is inconsistent and based on nothing. If you're going to reveal, reveal and be done with it and then I might believe you. I think you're just determined to lynch DPR because he is known to be a clever player and thus a serious threat to your scum plans for world domination. I don't buy his scumminess based on what you've posted, if anything it makes you look far guiltier than he.

 

Oh, and Aemon, you two fighting the same fight but supposedly not working together...yeah, right. You're next. You are either both mafia, or both in some kind of cultish weirdism. I say scum!

[Lavinya]

oops, forgot to glow! [glow=red,2,300]Vote Nae[/glow]!

[Naeann]

 

I'm not understanding you Wes?  Where did I say I was in contact with another player?  I won't confirm or deny that.  I simply know you weren't sleeping last night.  Like I said before.. I was stalking you. ;)

 

 

Edit:

 

Aemon.. that wasn't the beginning.  Wes recruited someone last night.

 

Wasn't sleeping equals recruitment? You know who else wasn't sleeping? Anyone with a role...and you know who likes to out people with roles? The mafia.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Nae[/glow] - that last bit sealed it for me. You never play like this, so I'm curioius to see what angle you are working.

 

 

 

My role showed me what you did last night.  I have said this several different ways since the beginning.  Starting with "I prefer being initiated."  What's another word for initiation?  Recruitment.  I was hinting that I knew you recruted but I hate going against you because you have a away with twisting words quite well.

[Naeann]

Vote NAE

 

You start out claiming he is scum, then suddenly the story changes and he has become the warewolf, and no wait! He was already warewolf scum and has been recruiting! Your story is inconsistent and based on nothing. If you're going to reveal, reveal and be done with it and then I might believe you. I think you're just determined to lynch DPR because he is known to be a clever player and thus a serious threat to your scum plans for world domination. I don't buy his scumminess based on what you've posted, if anything it makes you look far guiltier than he.

 

Oh, and Aemon, you two fighting the same fight but supposedly not working together...yeah, right. You're next. You are either both mafia, or both in some kind of cultish weirdism. I say scum!

 

Lav I have never once changed up my story.  Wes recruited someone last night.  It makes sense that the cult leader would be the werewolf a la the show.  That's why I started suggesting that.  No matter what he is he DID recruit someone last night my dear.  I don't lynch DPR just becuase he's a clever player.  I love having him in the games and hate when people take him out early without checking him.  WHich is exactly why he is who I checked when I found I had a watcher role.  I say you are full of bull crap to try the stupid "they must be working together" line just because we agree.

 

Can I make it any clearer for you?  I GOT INFO LAST NIGHT FROM THE MOD THAT SAID DPR RECRUITED SOMEONE.  To me that screams cult and I have hinted that that is what he has done most of the day and he knows I know he did it and thats why hes trying to throw it back in my face instead of owning up to it and saying yeah.. im a mason group who got a recruit or something along those lines.