[DPR Mafia] Call-Your-Shot Mafia- Points being posted...

[ed2funy]

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]

[glow=red,2,300]Lia[/glow]

 

there

[DPR]

 

ed, there are no points for saying "dammit"...I'm not sure if you knew that. *snickers*

[Naeann]

Damnit.  Spoil my fun DPR. :P

 

 

I'm thinking [glow=red,2,300]Lia[/glow] as well.  Her confused act bothered me from the get go.  That was her right?  "thou doth protest too much"

[DPR]

Current Vote Count:

 

Lia (4) - Kivam, Lavinya, ed, Nae

Hybrid (1) - Lia

Nae (1) - Talya

 

With 10 players, it takes 6 to lynch.

[Kivam]

Damnit.  Spoil my fun DPR. :P

 

 

I'm thinking [glow=red,2,300]Lia[/glow] as well.  Her confused act bothered me from the get go.  That was her right?  "thou doth protest too much"

 

No, that was Lavinya

[Lavinya]

Pete may or may not be scum, but unless DPR gave the governor crazy killing powers, he's no real threat at night.

 

And yeah, the act that wasn't an act was me :P

[Naeann]

Then nevermind. [glow=red,2,300] Unvote[/glow].  Were you the one Pale claimed he viewed?  And you said your role wasn't as important as barms and therefore not worth risking him?

[Lavinya]

Yep, me again :)

[Naeann]

Ok.. I think I got you two straight now :D.  The second part makes you seem on the innocent side to me.  One of the few im fairly sure of.  I'd also like to believe Kivam.  He was pretty on target with FDM and the role in my opinon.

 

Pete's constantness on either me or Kiv has me highly suspicious of him.  I'll give him the benefit of the doubt for now though because he's on a loa.

 

I'll wait before revoting Lia for now ... I'd like for her to make her case so hopefully she can get back before a majority is reached.  She wasn't the highest on my suspect list.

[ed2funy]

::)

I just saw the name.

 

:P @ DPR

[DPR]

 

Current Vote Count:

 

Lia (2) - Kivam, Lavinya

Hybrid (1) - Lia

Nae (1) - Talya

 

With 10 players, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

***YOU HAVE 48 HOURS TO LYNCH A PLAYER, OR A RANDOM PLAYER WILL BE CHOSEN TO DIE BEFORE NIGHTFALL.

[DPR]

 

If activity increases, I will consider appeals for time extensions.

[Talya]

Well for the moment, i'm sticking by my vote!

[cosmicpanda]

Wes, can you poke Lia?

[Hybrid]

First off, sorry for the recent disappearance.  I was skiing with family this Pres Day weekend.  I'm not usually this inactive, as Kivam pointed out, but that combined with being away in Vegas for an ultimate frisbee tournament the previous weekend, and the need to do school work around that schedule has hurt my contributions to this game. 

 

----

 

Pandy

He claimed Evangelist, but we haven't had a chance to check that claim out.  He's probably not mafia because he didn't just let a teammate slip in with an "I agree," but he could be the serial killer.  I'd like to see him chime in today before I make up my mind about him.

 

Wombat

Falls into the category of "people who post a lot but are content to stay out of the action"

 

Lavinya

Inclined to believe she's innocent because of her interaction with Pale.

 

ed

What I said about Wombat.

 

Pete

For logic inconsistencies and flip-flopping, probably the scummiest of the active people to me so far.  However, he's either the governor or a 1-shot unlynchable scum.  Since we know there are at least 1 mafia left, maybe 2, and a serial killer, I don't think we should try to lynch him just yet.  If we're wrong, we waste a lynch and our numbers decrease even further.

 

Lia

A little more detail because she's one of the major lynch candidates.

- Disagreed with mass reveal plan.  (She did not call him out on numbers not working or asking power roles to lie.)

- Votes Kivam in the interest of ending day after headdesking Rey's reveal.  (Is she headdesking it as a bad reveal or just a bad time to reveal?)

- Unvotes Kivam.  Again does not want to vote Rey because he's revealed.  (Refusing to vote scum teammate?)

- Votes Rey for lying.  (After everyone else already had - she voted 11th)

- Suspicious of Dsworn.  Will role claim if necessary.  (Role "claim"?)

- Calls out Kivam and Pale as liars.  (But doesn't vote on either.  Why?)

- Thinks Dsworn is scum but votes me.  Will role claim if necessary. (Defending scum teammate?)

 

Summary: I'm actually leaning more towards the mafia side on this one.  She's been blending in with the crowd.  She stayed off the Rey vote until people started voting for him, for one thing. For another, she thinks Dsworn is scum but ends up voting for me.  Also, there is all the talk about a role "claim" rather than reveal -- slip up?

 

Nae

Voted for Dae (4th), DS (4th), Kivam (8th)

Was not on the Rey vote - in fact, it was the only real major vote she stayed off of.  Beyond that, she's be very active but hasn't taken a real major role. 

 

Talya

I honestly have no idea with just a reread.  I'll have to case her myself, but I don't have time at the moment.

 

Kivam

Perhaps the most confirmed innocent in my point of view due to his firefighter claim playing out.

 

So, my summary:

 

Probably innocent:

Kivam (firefighter claim pretty much verified)

Lavinya (scum don't sign death warrants like that)

 

Possible SK:

Wombat, Ed, Pandy

 

Possible mafia:

DS, Lia, Nae

(I'm leaning towards DS and Lia.  If DS is innocent, I'd lean towards Lia and Nae, assuming two mafia left)

 

Unknown:

Talya

 

Right, so let's run some numbers.  There are ten players left.  With two NKs in play, we're looking for at least one mafia and one serial killer.  Our best chance of survival is lynching the serial killer and ending that NK.  Lynching a mafioso is good too, obviously, but that still leaves us with two dying per night now that Lily's dead.

 

I'm not going to vote for Kivam or Lavinya.  I'll vote for DS, Lia, and Nae for the sake of a majority, but I'd rather focus on SK suspects.  That leaves Ed, Wombat, Pandy and maybe Talya.

 

I think Ed's been staying out of the spotlight more than the others. [glow=red,2,300]Ed[/glow].

 

I'll be rereading yet again and focusing on Ed, Wombat, Pandy, and Talya in the meantime.

 

[Talya]

hybrid, why are you discounting DS, Lia and Nae as Serial Killers. It could be just as easily be one of those as the last 4...though I know it's not your last one.. ;D

[Kivam]

Wombat was viewed by Barm and cleared of SKdom

[Kivam]

I'll be honest, I'm not getting a SK vibe from Ed - but I do tend to agree with your point on Lia.  That said . . . if Lia and DS are the last two mafioso, we can take out the extra NK that way.  And, since Lia is still a SK candidate . . . lets lynch her, whittle down the SK list, and if she's mafia, we lynch DS tomorrow and give ourselves a real chance of winning this thing.  (especially if our cop has any luck)

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

[glow=red,2,300]Lia[/glow] just going with the bandwagon. I don't really have time to reread this thread.

[Hybrid]

hybrid, why are you discounting DS, Lia and Nae as Serial Killers. It could be just as easily be one of those as the last 4...though I know it's not your last one.. ;D

 

Well, I'm just saying that they're giving me more of a mafia vibe than an SK vibe.

 

Wombat was viewed by Barm and cleared of SKdom

 

Must have missed that.  Scratch that idea, then.

 

I'll be honest, I'm not getting a SK vibe from Ed - but I do tend to agree with your point on Lia.  That said . . . if Lia and DS are the last two mafioso, we can take out the extra NK that way.  And, since Lia is still a SK candidate . . . lets lynch her, whittle down the SK list, and if she's mafia, we lynch DS tomorrow and give ourselves a real chance of winning this thing.  (especially if our cop has any luck)

 

That's a good point.  [glow=red,2,300]Unvote and vote Lia[/glow]

 

I think that puts her at 4 votes (L-2).

[cosmicpanda]

okay, somebody say "I agree with Pandy" and then I'll vote Lia.

[Lavinya]

I wondering if agreeing with you has a different affect than we all think. I wonder if you have a strange restriction where you only gain the power to be a psycho night time killer if you're agreed with. Like a holy vengeance lol. I do wonder. What if we've been giving you the power to kill all along? Why have a role that does nothing at all for the town except keep you alive? In itself I suppose it always adds to the innocent numbers...but I do wonder.

[Kivam]

Nobody should agree with Pandy tonight and the cop should check him.  Sorry, Pandy - but the only way to vet your claim is to make you vulnerable.

[Kivam]

okay, somebody say "I agree with Pandy" and then I'll vote Lia.

 

You'd risk a random death rather than vote Lia without an agreement?

[Naeann]

In light of the impending deadline and having given her plenty of time to pop on and post something.... [glow=red,2,300]Lia[/glow].